> then realizing what was going on then positively jovial at how they'd played the scammers along for almost a full day.
...because once they realize they're talking to an old lady, they may realize the "kidnapping" story may not work, but a call verifying something for a Stimulus check might (for example).
Just hang up. You won't outwit them.
Has that ever happened?
Does a fake recording like that make it easier to scam you in any meaningful way?
I'd like to think that if enough people did this they wouldn't make any money.
There was a video that he kept the scammer on the phone for 6+ hrs then at the end when he was giving them the apple cards was "confused" and redeemed $20000 dollars onto "her" "own" account to send them a computer all on a vm where they could watch her putting in the cards codes and go through the checkout but the control software "was broken" so they couldn't interfere.
edit: Youtuber/twitch streamer is mentioned below, Kitboga
Then there is Jim Browning on YouTube.... I’ll just leave this here: https://youtu.be/le71yVPh4uk
The population density and average income disparity between the US and India works strongly in their favor, however.
I established this system because it is possible I will be involved in an accident or something and I do want my relatives to be able to trust someone calling if I am unable to do so. Many scams start with news of an accident so this usually stops them before they get to the asking for money part. I also make it explicitly clear that an emergency call would never be a request for money. I have savings and insurance and there is no occasion where I would need money from relatives, ever.
The countdown timer to when this can be convincingly deepfaked is ticking, but while a pre-recorded video is within realm of possibility (if the scammer can get access to video of the person, which is already hard), being able to fake a live conversation is still a ways off.
Also, I'd tell you to leave a backup card in a separate place from the rest of your belongings, but you've probably learned that the hard way already!
I've also built up a network over the years so I have friends in virtually every major city on the planet. You could literally spin a roulette wheel of cities and drop me into one anywhere on the planet with nothing in my pockets and I'd be fine. People are far more helpful than you realize and of course knowing people helps.
I was completely broke once in one of the most dangerous cities on the planet (San Pedro Sula, Honduras) due to poor planning and a city wide internet outage that took out all ATMs. I also didn't speak any Spanish at the time. This was before I had multiple banks too.
In the end it wasn't really an issue at all, bus driver let me ride for free to the next town and personally escorted me to a safe ATM. Once you've been through things like that a few times you realize most situations just aren't as big a problem as you might think.
A better approach would be to establish a set of preshared keywords that convey information about what's going on.
Or can you have that person bring the form and show ID?
However, you can list as many people as you like and change it at any time by visiting the school. So we have four or five neighbors listed and my sisters who live in other states.
Perhaps a pre-established code phrase is a good way to address this. "If I ever need help, I will mention that [memorable vacation] we spent together. If that vacation isn't mentioned explicitly, it's not me."
There might be better protocols - make sure all their cash is in the bank, set a per store per week limit of £200 on their cards, require your/siblings authorisation to make larger purchases?
But then there are things like their pensions, who they move their phone/internet account or other utilities to, so much opportunity for malicious people to commit fraud and deception; companies aren't motivated to help as it often reduces the companies income.
Seemed kind of silly at the time but it truly is a low cost way to mitigate this issue.
And people think Pascal's wager is a good argument and you lose nothing believing in hell.
edit: apparently trolling is fine here:
Yet it still happened that, during the exact week my family was on a Caribbean cruise that included a stop in Mexico[0], scammers targeted both of my parents' mobile phone numbers insisting that they were alternatively Mexican authorities demanding bail money for me or that they were my spouse sobbing over the phone that I'd been in a tragic boating accident and needed money for the hospital.
This was before international roaming was included with my mobile phone plan so when I got back to port a few days later I turned on my phone that morning to several voicemails from my parents, starting out panicky then realizing what was going on then positively jovial at how they'd played the scammers along for almost a full day.
They didn't send any money but both of them said it was incredibly difficult to keep what I'd told them in mind because "what if it really was you needing help?"
0 - We think the scammers got the information off of the Facebook pages of one of our related family members who posted publicly about "being envious of [my name tagged] going to Cozumel" next week and then trolling linked family members for people who appeared older.