It’s particularly when we ‘re-import’ something that English actually imported from Latin or Latinate languages. For example, import itself: we have importare in Italian which actually means “to care about”. But of course we re-import it as meaning “to bring in” (either in economics, or in the Python sense), so it acquires a meaning that it doesn’t actually have in Italian, and we pronounce it differently by moving the stress from early in the word for our native meaning to late in the word (on the -are) for the ‘foreign’ meaning.
Esportare means “to export”. But of course we bring in “exportare” from English, which is a corruption of our “esportare”.
Since I’m half English too, out of courtesy I make a point of using the most Italian words possible, because slinging around English terms is snooty and a sign that one is showing off, and of course as a native English speaker I could do it better than most. So for most people it’s a computer, which gets pronounced something like com-pù-tèr”, whereas I make it a point of referring to it as a calcolatore (a “male calculator”, which is the native term for an arithmetic machine that can execute arbitrary streams of commands, whereas a calcolatrice is a “female calculator” that cannot be programmed, i.e. a calculator in English).
Many terms we need daily seem to have no real native analogue; at least not one that wouldn’t sound as if you’re deliberately trying to engage in some form of Dadaist absurdity: file, record, monitor, mouse, record. Others have perfectly serviceable local alternatives: algoritmo, tastiera for keyboard, processore for processor, puntatore & cursore, memoria, archivio for storage (aside: by God does it annoy me when people who should know better speak of hard drives or SSDs having a certain amount of ‘memory’: it’s storage goddamnit!), sistema operativo, finestra for window...
It’s kind of a mixed bag.
مثالی از سیستم عامل های مبتنی بر Linux
In Persian (Farsi), we usually take the English term and add a form of "kardan" (meaning "to do") to make a new Persian verb. For example, "commit kardan" (to commit), "commit kon" ([you must] commit), etc.However, due to publishing rules, people have to use literal translations instead of the foreign ones in formal situations. Sometimes, those actually convey the same meaning as the English terms, but other times, they're just more confusing.
We study CS in French. Which itself, uses lots of English words in CS. I'm not sure if there is any country that studies it in Modern Standard Arabic and I can't think of a standard translation for the words above.
When I was in highschool, I got a gift of this Pascal programming book "الخوارزميات والبرمجة الانشائية بلغة باسكال" reading it felt very weird, but I still keep it for the novelty.
To inline is to include (incluir) or insert (insertar), in a fashion that's compatible with the compiler optimization concept.
Debug, depurar.
Both have been in use in Spanish since at least the 80s.
Pullear, deployar are ridiculous and lazy.
For instance, deploy has its roots in the military term: to place and equip troops in a battlefield. The Spanish words desplegar (v.) and despliegue (n.) have existed for ages with identical meaning, and in common use in the 90s in IT.
You are aware that importing words is a thing, right? Even if equivalent words already exist. It's perfectly normal and even healthy for a language to do so.
To me, pullear and deployar are just a lot more clear and there's no ambiguity. "Desplegar" would not be very meaningful to me in the context of my work.
It's all about clarity in my mind and condescension really has nothing to do with it.
“America deployed her armies” => “América desplegó sus ejércitos”.
It's fascinating, over here we incorporate thousands of English words into the Spanish IT lingo, but while they can could roughly communicate in English, most people I know wouldn't be able to have a discussion entirely in English. As others have said, there's several literal translations for some concepts, but it feels a bit condescending/academic to use those instead of the English words in casual environments.
A fun quirk of this is that we turn many English verbs into Spanish versions of them (where verbs must end in -ar -er -or). Some examples: - to commit -> committear - to pull -> pullear - to deploy -> deployar
That last one is particularly fun because it turns the 'y' at the end into a consonant (sort of like if you said 'deployate'). And we do all this instinctively, for some reason it's what feels most natural!
A sad quirk is that we've also adopted the frustrating English tendency to turn _everything_ into acronyms, which always irks me.
Amazing thread!