Local big-city paper ran several days with virtually no ads. Sport and Entertainment sections still carry none, though a few are appearing in the news and. business pages. And of course, obituaries -- or as they're called in the biz, "former subscriber appreciations".
Even the Sunday edition inserts were reduced to a single druggist's circular.
Even with increased eyeballs, ad buys are likely down and both business and people are avoiding all possible expenditure.
Lately I've been seeing a lot of (allegedly) dropshipping advertisements for "home gym" equipment, from "brands"/"stores" with no recognition.
Sure I'll buy this from you. Especially something that's heavy and from an ad teaming with jpeg artifacts and a non-local currency. I'm sure I won't pay an arm and a leg for shipping and I'll have no issues with a brand that has 3 posts on instagram.
There really isn't a limit to profits such as, 'we can only make $500 off of this policy anything over that we would have to refund'
That doesn't however stop you from acquiring more customers and increasing absolute profit.
The other comment in response about loss ratio is correct
States have pretty broad powers and I could see them forcing a disgorgement if they felt so inclined.
Source: I was a state insurance regulator for the Alaska Division of Insurance for a few years
This model seems to be doing a fairly good job keeping auto insurance costs under control. Is this regulatory model also being applied to health insurance ?
If yes, why isn't it controlling healthcare costs ?
If no, why not ?
While I haven't done a deep dive recently, I doubt health insurance administrative expenses and profit are the main driving factor in health insurance costs. Losses (utilization multiplied by price) are the main driving force. You can look up rate reviews at https://ratereview.healthcare.gov/ and probably view the entire filings on the state DOI website, altho these filings are usually not really as accessible as they should be.
https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/0...
Also in France one big insurer started paying people back, with government asking the other companies to do the same.
https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2020/04/02/coronavir...
I live a block away from a shopping complex; the "anchor store" is a chain grocery but there are other businesses ranging from restaurants, drycleaners, a smoke shop, an alcohol store, and so forth.
There is a local movie theater in this complex. It is obviously shuttered due to COVID19; no audience means no movies means no popcorn, &c. So their marquee "should" be blank or say "Closed". Instead, they are using their road-side marquee to advertise who in the complex is opened for take-out.
I don't know if this is out of "solidarity" or if they're getting a trickle of money for an otherwise unused resource, but I'm fine about it either way.
In terms of ad spend reduction, How would this compare to regular media advertising spend (TV etc.) ?
> ...channel traffic, increasing by 15%
> ...one in four media buyers and brands have paused all advertising for the first half of 2020, and a further 46% have adjusted their spending downwards
> Digital ad spending is down by a third, according to the IAB — a slightly less painful drop than the traditional media’s 39% cut
Traffic is up but ad spending is down more than the traffic increase.
You’re right that some smart execs will run into the fire as everyone is fleeing, buying up cheap adverts for a long term investment. There are some signs of this with a few companies seemingly increasing spend to take advantage of the cheap prices. Purely anecdotally I noticed a lot more adverts from Scott’s on lawn care products. Their pitch is basically “hey so the lawn care guy is on lockdown... go to our site and we’ll ship you fertilizer and tell you how to apply it.”
The execs running into the fire with ad spend to take advantage aren’t any smarter than the rest, just better positioned for the pandemic. I doubt virtually any of them prepared or planned for this scenario.
Though from my experience there’ll be lot of companies out there cutting short cycle high ROAS campaigns, throwing the baby out with the bath water.
To all the folks saying "4 guys in a truck is low-risk" that's only true if they're the same 4 guys every time and they're not all living with other people... for instance if one lives with a nurse and another with a nursing-home health aide, then, well, not so great, huh.
TV as deals are often worked out O(months) in advance. I expect they've seen drops in bookings, but you won't see as agile of a reaction to the pandemic in Television.
There is an opportunity now to invest and come out ahead in the long run. Most companies are conserving and cutting back right now, given the uncertainty.
Also I noticed a number of the youtube channels I use to watch because they have useful information and I was learning from them have now reached the end of their knowledge. Thy are now posting fluff to try and get me to keep coming back, but I don't want to waste my time watching a 30 minute video to get 5 minutes of useful information.
One channel I watch use to only post about 1 hour long videos, now they have cut back and often only post a 5-7 minute video so I keep coming back. One the other hand another channel used to and still posts 1-2 hour long video, I don't bother going there anymore. The host is smart, but he takes too long to get to the point of the video, I have other uses of my time.
That will depend on whether people will have that money to spend economy bounces back. I am not optimistic, restaurants or hospitality industry are going to suffer for a long time.
And Youtube ads are sold upon delivery, I don't think they will be retrospective revenue share, which is impossible (the conversion is intractable).
Not when you're paying per impression? The way to think of this is good old supply and demand. There is a lot more supply of ad slots, and a general decrease in demand. Both of these directly mean lower ad rates.
That would lead to lower ROI as operating costs are increased to serve those extra users. Sure, with more users they'll serve more ads, but as total spend by advertisers is shrinking those ads will go off at bargain prices, it's simple math.
Anything is possible. It might be another Great Depression that takes years to recover from. Or maybe once this external force (quarantine) is removed, things will mostly bounce back.
So those advertising dollars might have a good ROI or they might not. At a time when revenue is down (even if just temporarily) and some companies are laying off employees, it doesn't make a lot of sense to spend money on something that might or might not be worthwhile.
France has just announced extending the lockdown one full month. UK has just announced they won't end the lockdown in the coming weeks, with no dates formally given (it was expiring today).
I'm saying that "when" isn't a given; instead, it's an "if". Companies (whose cash flow just tried up) don't want to spend on "if".
You couldn't have said it better
It kind of makes sense. There are ads for products you can't buy at stores that are closed, for cars you won't need to commute with, insurance you're already not using, other goods that won't ship for a month, and small gadgets that are totally out of stock; and that's assuming the person viewing the ad isn't avoiding spending due to financial risks.
If ads aren't converting viewers into customers, it doesn't matter if there are 2x or 20x more viewers than there were before, the ad placements are just worth less.