Looks like that's already happening: https://www.buzzfeed.com/alexwickham/coronavirus-uk-strategy...
> "We were expecting herd immunity to build. We now realise it’s not possible to cope with that," professor Azra Ghani, chair of infectious diseases epidemiology at Imperial, told journalists at a briefing on Monday night.
i can multiply numbers fifteen times in a row and come to that conclusion. alternatively, i can watch italian tv. did these people never looked up from their models to confront them with actual reality?
> Looks like that's already happening
Is UK ICU capacity overwhelmed and are young people dying in the streets?
No.
Don’t spread rumours in this situation.
is completely false. It was hyped by some out of context quotes by some media outlets and spread like a literal virus and people didn't bother to find out the reality, and so we see the same mis information being shared here.
We need to flatten the curve of these misinformation viruses
- schools/nurseries open
- theatres/bars/restaurants open
- stadiums open
- large gatherings allowed
The Mayor of London was still organising mass events a few days ago ( https://www.facebook.com/sadiqforlondon/posts/30260791107781... )
But they're crammed as usual.
And businesses can't claim insurance money if they close, as they're not required to close by law.
If you run their model for UK with weak mitigation, Moderate/North epidemiology, you get 390,000 total deaths.
From https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-51917562 social distancing is now in place.
The original announcements said that it would always be in place, but that they wanted to wait because it is hard for people over prolonged periods.
They (we) have already shifted towards a lockdown (voluntary for now, but people have been told to avoid office, pubs and travelling[0]) due to the model used being updated with the data from Italy.
Waiting until the problem obviously seems like a real problem is exactly what crushed cultures under epidemics in the past.
And yes South Korea and China seem to have stopped the pandemic in their countries, and have done an impressive job at it, but its early days and not at all clear how sustainable their approach is, or whether that approach would work everywhere.
It is too late for stopping it and you can barely delay it either.
You delay a few days or maybe 1-2 weeks if stringent but it won't be as effective when you desperately need it to be. Likely more will die if you start too early.
Think about something akin to some sort of nuclear reactor with control rods up you've just started to insert.
Thank god.
Especially where our knowledge is imperfect and subject to a lot of latency, we have to accept that we have very little actual control over how quickly the curve speeds or slows. Thus the bell-shaped curves.
Of course, all it takes is a UK to screw everyone over by not playing along and providing a population pool for the virus to mutate. And then a ton of poor countries who probably can't do anything even if they wanted, where it's just starting.
Honestly, I think the UK, Sweden et al. will be "voted out" here. Commerce can't continue between countries that follow the China/South Korea model of keeping R0 < 1, because frequent large outbreaks are bound to follow. Britain can't economically dominate its neighbors like that today. Sweden, forget about it.
This is a spectacular high-stakes experiment. But if Boris Johnson isn't persuaded by public opinion and a high death toll, his trading partners will.
Both approaches put strong selection pressure on the virus to mutate to a milder form, so even in the absence of a vaccine, we'll win in the long term.
That's not what is being said. What is being said is that specifically to avoid people dying, you need to stop ICUs being overwhelmed, but that in their judgement and modelling an immediate hard clamp down is not the best way.
Trump just announced advice not to gather for 2 weeks. A 2 week restriction is a drop in the sea.
China is celebrating lifting of many restrictions. But the virus will come back in those areas and the restrictions will come back too.
Related, if we take the numbers out of China at face value: A tiny tiny fraction of the population has been infected (acquired immunity). So what now? Lock everything down until a vaccine is discovered?
Basically, masks in public, no-contact thermometers everywhere, and QR codes that you scan to enter a subway or a building. There's more, but that's the core.
If you have a fever, then they send you to a specialized fever clinic: https://mobile.twitter.com/MikeIsaac/status/1238604080571772...
There, they determine if you've been infected. If you have been, they send you to a group isolation ward, where you spend a few weeks chilling out and doing group dance exercises. If can't stand up and dance, you get treatment.
It's clearly a society at war, and I'm sure some ugly details are hidden. But it looks better than hiding indoors while our medical system burns and our elderly relatives die (and at least some of us younger folk wind up with scarred lungs).
My sense is that the UK will probably fold and institute a lockdown once their ICU capacity gets overwhelmed and healthy young people start dying in the streets. Either that or they'll face a revolution and then have a lot more problems. Of course, by the time it gets to either of those points it'll be too late to effectively change course.
But it's interesting to see at least one country take the position that "Hey, we're going to let this run its course, take our lumps now, and try to get back to business as usual ASAP." I could be wrong, and maybe this is a genius application of heartless logic. Time will tell.
RemindMe!2months ;-)