Another possibility is that Italy doesn't have a handle on who is or isn't infected so what they report are the obvious infections, who tend to be older.
This is very likely the case, as can be seen in the positive test outcome rates.
16.7% in Italy vs. 3.6% in South Korea
Italy has run around 60k tests.
South Korea are testing around 15k people/day and have tested 234k people in total. They've even setup drive-through testing centers where anyone can drive through, get tested, and get results via SMS in under a day.
The result of this is likely a much larger number of asymptomatic or mild cases in the South Korean numbers, which based on the China data, tend to be a lot younger.
https://www.cdc.go.kr/board/board.es?mid=&bid=0030
https://github.com/pcm-dpc/COVID-19/blob/master/schede-riepi...
https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-act-today-or-peop...
North Italy has a population of 27 people btw so the 10K that are registered as positive as a drop in the bucket.
"Why must I always explain" Bob Dylan
FAFAIK, we've never had a policy to pre-emptively test every returning tourist, and even now we don't test everybody. The current policy is to test new cases only if they have no relation to an already-established case. For example, people living in the same house as a known Corona case will not get tested. If they start showing symptoms, they're automatically assumed to have contracted it.
It's not that old people aren't worthy of protection, but when you're 85 in the US you have a 10% chance of dying in the next year for any and all reasons.
So saying this disease kills 15% (for example) of 80+ year olds without context sounds horrific, but contextualized in the actual risks of just being very old to begin with, sounds much less scary.
If Italy, for example, were to report on the number of fatal infections in people younger than the natural life expectancy, the fatality rate would drop in half.
Best not to suggest anything that might down play the seriousness considering how infectious this virus is. (Otherwise it may encourage risky behavior.)
https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/artic...
Mind you that isn't covid 19 putting them over-capacity. In the worst hit region in Italy (Lombardy) confirmed covid 19 cases represent enough cases to take up less than 10% of their hospital beds. So it seems incredibly unlikely anything but panic is to blame for such absurdly high over capacity.
Do you have a source for this comment? This WaPo story from 6 hours ago says differently:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/italy-coronaviru...
> Giulio Gallera, Lombardy’s health chief, said Thursday that the region would reach its capacity in “five, six or seven days,” even if it tried to add more beds in hospital “cellars.” In an interview with Italy’s La7 channel, Gallera described the possibility of adding 500 intensive-care beds at Milan’s expo center, the kind of rapidly assembled zone that China created in the hard-hit Wuhan area.
the math for that adds up to 31,800 hospital beds 7280 confirmed cases is 22% - so my sources were off or wiki is wrong as originally I recall reading lombardy has a 16MM population.
I will say that your article claims they haven't run out of ICU beds yet but that number is surprisingly high for ICU needs to cover covid 19. The article implies 600 ICU cases from covid 19 - that's over 12% ICU from confirmed covid 19 cases, which is more than twice what china reported.
It's also very surprising how few ICU beds they have allocated towards ICU....
The USA has something like 14% of hospital beds as ICU beds [3] but Italy appears to only have have less than 3% of their beds available for covid 19 ICU
[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1099375/coronavirus-case... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_OECD_countries_by_hosp... [3] https://www.sccm.org/Communications/Critical-Care-Statistics
What's not plausible is ICU beds being taken up by people who don't have the disease (maybe miild-to-moderate flus or bad colds) and are just panicking. Emergency room lines, sure. Test shortages, absolutely. But hospitals will not put someone who's just scared and doesn't even need to be admitted at all into the ICU.
Remember that there's a difference between hospital beds and ICU beds.
In the UK, we maintain 80% utilisation of our ICU beds all year round[0], with very little change in the number of beds available in real number terms. We have ~4100 total ICU beds, which can be expanded to ~5000 if all operating theatres, etc are shut down and used as ICU equivalent instead.
While getting past flu season will help the total number of beds, it does nothing for the ICU.
This is the other reason why it's increasingly important to https://www.FlattenThesCurve.com and employ social distancing techniques. The rate of patients being admitted into ICUs needs to be slowed as much as possible. Once we're out of capacity, every additional patient has a much higher probability of dying than the overall fatality statistics indicate.
[0] https://www.england.nhs.uk/statistics/wp-content/uploads/sit...
2. Other things still happen to people and those people need to have their hospital beds.
3. I'm not a hospital planner but I think there may be other things that determine capacity than just hospital beds. I worry that the hospital bed metric is actually a bad metric. Obviously adding hospital beds implies adding people to staff those beds, but also adding people probably also means adding all sorts of other infrastructure to support those people.
As a developer it reminds me of a project that goes way off schedule, you don't bring the project back on track just by adding developers because of the overhead more developers add to your system. Probably most hospital administrators have never actually experienced operating at capacity, so estimations of what would happen could be off and are being corrected now.
https://www.statista.com/chart/21105/number-of-critical-care...
You can see that in the death rate, it's happening because they can't care for the volume of older intensive care patients properly. They don't have the medical infrastructure capacity to do it. That's why Italy and other European nations such as France have an extreme variance in mortality rates, despite France and Italy both having similarly old populations. Germany is even older than Italy and I'm skeptical we're going to see anywhere near a 6% mortality rate there (their rate is very low so far). Italy's mortality rate has been abnormally high from the first few thousand cases in, when it quickly began overloading their healthcare system in Lombardy.
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2002032
edit to address your edit: The mortality rate is often wildly inflated with new diseases. That's because most people don't seem to understand real mortality rate vs confirmed cases mortality rate. Obviously when a disease is new the confirmed cases will be confirmed against the people showing serious symptoms. Then when you pretend deaths/confirmed cases == mortality rate you end up with a wildly inflated mortality rate. Until we understand how many people are asymptomatic we won't have a real mortality rate that is reliable.
There is plenty of evidence that in Italy COVID-19 has overwhelmed ICU beds. They are trying to transport people to ventilators via helicopter. We do have at least twice the ICU bed capacity in the US (compare info from [4], [5]). But many other people need these ICU beds -- it's not like other illnesses will just stop for our convenience.
[1] https://minnesota.cbslocal.com/2020/03/08/talking-points-pre... [2] https://www.ahd.com/states/hospital_MN.html [3] https://www.mnhospitals.org/mn-hospitals/quick-facts [4] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4351597/ [5] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00134-012-2627-8
Edited to add: remember, included in most totals of ICU beds are neonatal and pediatric ICU beds, which won't help much with COVID-19.
Toolz, I just don't understand your math. You seem to assume that a neonatal ICU bed is just as good for a 55-year-old man as an adult one, and that no one is going to have any other ICU-needing illnesses for the duration of this epidemic. That's quite puzzling. Can you support these ideas?
737 ICU beds available isn't the same as the total number of ICU beds. Normal health problems that need hospital treatment (strokes, heart attacks, car accidents, etc.) are still happening during this outbreak (well, car accidents are probably reduced now with Italy's lockdown protocols).
This probably won’t kill millions (though it could worst case) but hospitals being overwhelmed would lead to an exponential rise in deaths, and many deaths from other causes as other treatments are abandoned. The situation is serious and will require significant measures to bring it under control, it is not yet being taken seriously enough in the US.
Evidence [0] (partly based on COVID-19, parly on MERS) also says that NIV has a significantly worse outcome than ventilation. People are already getting NIV in some hospitals because they ran out of tubed ventilators.
[0] https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/clinica...
And they live in Italy
Still the heat wave in 2003 killed 18 thousands people in a month and 15k in France in only half a month.
Old people are vulnerable to many things, unfortunately
80+ age category has a 21.9% death rate in confirmed cases.
Some of the people that die from this would have died anyway, but for the most part this is on top of that 10% chance. Same for young people, there's something like a 0.2 chance of death every year and this is basically doubling that.
Italy: Above 80: 1,532 (18.4)% vs age 20-29: 296 (0.0)%
South Korea: Above 80: 243 (3.1)% age 20-29: 2,261 (28.7)%
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_S...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_I...
Of note, neither country has had anyone under 30 die. Deaths in the 80+ age range are 8.23% in South Korea and 13.2% in Italy.
PS: South Korea saw 2 deaths under age 50 where Italy has seen 1. So this age is by far the largest factor.