News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by ArtWomb on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:21PM (#22228538)
I believe this was released as part of Tesla's Autopilot hiring announcement. More details here:

https://www.tesla.com/autopilotAI

Definitely someone's dream job ;) I particularly like the applicant query: "Tell us, what extraordinary work you have done?"

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by WrtCdEvrydy on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:51PM (#22228911)
"Tell us, what extraordinary work you have done?"

I wrote code that worked....

I like boring things.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by daniel2x on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:17PM (#22229211)
You may be trying to sound snarky, but that is truly extraordinary in todays world!
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by 72deluxe on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @05:26AM (#22234089)
Too right! I seem to be encoutering garbage software all the time, either in use, or by expanding an existing project (including widely available, popular OS projects).

Sometimes it's my own code.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by agumonkey on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:24PM (#22229304)
I like to check for ranges and limits
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jacquesm on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:47PM (#22229549)
Big fan of treating all inputs and outputs to and from functions as hostile. So parameters and return values as well. Always interesting how fast the bugs turn up once you start enforcing that.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by eru on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:27PM (#22232080)
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by agumonkey on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:49PM (#22229561)
partial evaluation much
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by _jal on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:36PM (#22231814)
This is starting to sound like the worst dating site ever.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by m463 on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:57PM (#22231195)
would that more languages let you do this proactively.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by Shivetya on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:34PM (#22229417)
while an interesting video I really want to see the entire front arc stitched together. How is it judging it is safe to go through the stop sign? Situations like that fascinate me the most.

One issue not discussed enough is all this push for automation really needs road marking guidelines pushed down from the Federal level. While the feds can hold domain over the interstate system or roads it can be maddening the differences on right of way rules to simple markings at state level

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by phkahler on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:44PM (#22229519)
>> One issue not discussed enough is all this push for automation really needs road marking guidelines pushed down from the Federal level.

That would be a mistake. You don't take a safety critical system and rely on a nationwide beauracracy getting all the details right to make it safe, or even effective. We've had the discussion here before, and the only way for full level 5 autonomy is a general AI capable of most everything a human is. Until people realize that it will be an endless stream of "we just need to fix these corner cases" or put more constraints on the physical world because the cars aren't smart enough.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by toufka on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:50PM (#22229573)
Isn't that exactly what the federal government has done to extrodinary success with the interstate system?

The interstates follow very strict and powerful standards that make us all so much safer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Association_of_State_...

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by grecy on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:25PM (#22231394)
I drove across the US 5 times in the summer of 2019, almost excursively on interstates (the 40, 70, 80 end to end).

I can assure you, there are hundreds of times that "strange" things happened to the road. Odd or incorrect lane markings, no lane markings, lanes beginning from the right and left, lanes ending suddenly on the right and the left, lanes marked as merge that were not, lanes not marked as merge that were, etc. etc. etc.

Every time I thought I could just stay in my lane with cruise set I found I was severely mistaken.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by hermitdev on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:58PM (#22231595)
The vast majority of the US interstate system involves two lanes each way with a wide median separating opposite traffic flow. There is always ample signage around exits, interchanges and whatnot. There is also a stretch that is straight and level enough to be used as a runway in wartime. I think most inclines are restricted to a max 6%-6.5% gradient (for reference, I grew up on the side of a mountain and the first climb was around 14%. You could stand on that in icy conditions and would slide down if you attempted to stand on it. Most mountains passes on the interstate also have "runaway truck" pulloutss in case a semi's brakes fail.

Most of the weirdness on the interstate system is usually caused by cities; having to adapt to preexisting conditions. As an example, I offer up Chicago. i290 is a mess. The Austion and Harlem exits are both left-handed exits. Worse yet, oncoming traffic are both given protected turns from the ramps. A lot of people dont follow the law and turn into the nearest lane. A lot of people drift, and a situation like this just breeds accidents. This is in oak park, a near west suburb. The Edens expressway (I90) also had expresslanes, which causes confusion, too. Not always open at the same time or direction.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by gowld on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:46PM (#22231120)
If it worked so well, why isn't it good enough for self driving cars?
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by komali2 on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:54PM (#22231174)
Or people, for that matter, who break the speed limits like 99% of the time and regularly smash their cars into eachother?
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by HeWhoLurksLate on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:38PM (#22231490)
Five over is still an acceptable rate, right?

Okay, good.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by hermitdev on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:01PM (#22231616)
I drive I88 outside of Chicago. The typical speed is in the 80-85 mph range, while the limit is 60 (I drive opposite prevailing traffic). Prevailing traffic is a parking lot for my entire 15 mile commute.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jodrellblank on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:40PM (#22230133)
Isn't that what we do with building codes, fire safety codes, airline industry regulation, electrical safety regulation, gas regulation, food hygiene, product labelling, site safety symbols, and many more?

Collectively decide what needs to be done for something to be considered safe enough, then regulate that it must be done that way for it to be allowed. Maybe this could be "self-driving car approved roads" and self-driving cars must check their navigation systems and only travel down approved roads. Drivers then get to lobby their local or state councils to make more roads follow the self-driving car markings and signage, and when they have, cars become permitted to drive down them next time they update.

Until people realize that it will be an endless stream of "we just need to fix these corner cases" or put more constraints on the physical world because the cars aren't smart enough.

That is one way of considering trains and trams, and they're good enough to be useful with extreme constraints on what they can do.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by spookthesunset on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:41PM (#22229492)
> One issue not discussed enough is all this push for automation really needs road marking guidelines pushed down from the Federal level

Who will fund that in a way that ensures a timely rollout (as in "sometime this century")? Who will pay to maintain it?

Unfortunately, self driving cars are just gonna have to deal with infrastructure as-built.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by iamaelephant on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @12:45AM (#22232782)
> One issue not discussed enough is all this push for automation really needs road marking guidelines pushed down from the Federal level

Yup especially because every country is USA.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by Traster on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:30PM (#22228654)
Two issues, first: I thought fully autonomous driving was meant to be done by now? Second, don't Tesla & SpaceX have a reputation for being a terrible place to work, with Musk expecting everyone to be working as hard (or harder) than him, and firing people in weird and capricious ways.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by axguscbklp on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:30PM (#22229367)
>I thought fully autonomous driving was meant to be done by now?

Musk was bullshitting when he made that prediction. Maybe he did it because he had bought his own bullshit. Personally I think what's more likely is that he was cynically conning people.

In reality, I think no-one is anywhere close to fully self driving cars. I would be surprised if we saw fully self driving cars any time in the next 50 years.

The whole field of fully self driving cars has been astonishingly full of empty hype, for some reason often believed by otherwise quite smart people.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by spookthesunset on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:54PM (#22229622)
> for some reason often believed by otherwise quite smart people

I don't understand why so many smart "tech people" fall for the hype.

Maybe it is because "machine learning" is just abstract enough that even the most jaded developer thinks they can treat it like a black box where if you pour enough videos, photos and LIDAR readings for training into the top it will somehow spit out a fully autonomous self driving car at the bottom.

I do find it funny though. On the one hand Alexa only manages to turn on the lights successfully 50% of the time yet somehow we will magically have self driving cars capable of safely navigating the roads any day now. I mean for fsck sake, we don't even have a thing that can wash and fold clothes automatically but somehow self driving cars will be on the market any day.

Like, if we cannot even get voice recognition to work right, how on earth will you tell this magical car which street parking spot to take in a busy city? How will you tell it to pull over to pick up a friend? Hell, how will you tell it to go through a drive-through at McDonalds? A touchscreen?

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by tim333 on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:51PM (#22232213)
As to "tech people" falling for the hype, it all depends which particular hype but:

"surprised if we saw fully self driving cars any time in the next 50 years."

a couple of years after there have been self driving cars driving around Arizona https://youtu.be/aaOB-ErYq6Y?t=93 reminds me of quotes like

"The aeroplane will never fly." — Lord Haldane, 1907

a while after the Wright brothers had done many flights. You could argue both the Wright brothers planes and the Arizona Waymos were a bit rubbish but these things tend to improve rapidly.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by toast0 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:19AM (#22232925)
Rather expensive self-driving cars, with safety drivers have been driving around a very small part of Arizona, right?

That's not really that close to an affordable self-driving car that I can take overnight door to door from the bay area to the Los Angeles area while I sleep.

That may not be 50 years away, but it sure doesn't seem any nearer than 20 years. Progress towards something usable has been pretty slow, and the edge cases are going to be tricky.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by tigershark on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:21AM (#22233470)
A percentage of the trips have been without security driver for several months. As for affordable they are comparable to Uber and lyft and you can actually get a Waymo trip using the lyft app, so that seems pretty affordable to me.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by tim333 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @04:43AM (#22233862)
If you click the video link it's one driving without a safety driver.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by mr_toad on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:17AM (#22233447)
> How will you tell it to pull over to pick up a friend?

You can’t imagine a way to do this, therefore it’s impossible?

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jodrellblank on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:54PM (#22230277)
The way you suggest the future of automotive transport rests on a fast food chain drive through suggests a kind of astroturfing social media advert. If burgers were that important, the burger company would partner with the self driving car company and find a way.

None of those things are physically complex - the car will be able to see or lidar if a space is big enough for it to park in, pulling over to pick up a friend is no different to pulling over to let you out at your destination, and a drive-through is moving forwards slowly and steering a bit like all low speed driving is. None of them require the dexterity of folding soft wet fabric, and the market for $30,000+ vehicles is much larger than the market for $30,000+ washing machines.

One simple answer is: you don't. Self-driving car owned by <car company. takes you from A to B and you get out. You don't choose the parking spot anymore than you chose the lane or the highway exit, you don't pick up a friend they take their own separate ride, and you don't use the drive through, you use <car company>'s food delivery service.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by spookthesunset on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:31PM (#22231014)
> None of those things are physically complex

I don't care about how physically complex something is. You didn't tell me how I'd tell the self driving car which spot to park in or which person on the corner is my friend. If you think this detail is minor, trivial or doesn't matter.... you are sadly mistaken.

> If burgers were that important, the burger company would partner with the self driving car company and find a way.

So you are telling me your $70,000 self driving car can't take me through one of the hundreds of thousands of drive thru's out there? That sounds pretty shitty.

> You don't choose the parking spot anymore than you chose the lane or the highway exit

You are telling me that this self-driving taxi will just stop at whatever place it feels like? How will I tell it precisely where to let me out? Remember it is pouring down rain / I am physically disabled and cannot walk very far / I am not entirely sure where I need to be dropped off until I get there.

So seriously, how will I command this self-driving car? Nobody seems to be able to answer this or even thought about it in any amount of detail at all. Probably because we are so far away from an actual self driving car that a realistic answer doesn't really matter at all.

And that is the problem with self-driving hype. Every time you ask about a specific detail it gets hand waved away as not important or some kind of edge case that doesn't matter. Guess what... edge cases matter. Your edge case is my important case. You add up all these edge cases that "don't matter" and you've excluded almost your entire market.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by Slartie on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:03PM (#22231246)
> I don't understand why so many smart "tech people" fall for the hype.

Maybe it's just that some of these "tech people" are not that smart at all?

> And that is the problem with self-driving hype. Every time you ask about a specific detail it gets hand waved away as not important or some kind of edge case that doesn't matter.

I think you are you spot-on with that analysis. Way too much hand-waving going on.

But that is a constant problem in tech, the entire area is susceptible to hypes and fads, with hands waving and waving at record speed. Like I said, maybe it's just not all geniuses and such...

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by RaceWon on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:50PM (#22231560)
> > I don't understand why so many smart "tech people" fall for the hype. Maybe it's just that some of these "tech people" are not that smart at all?

The crux of the problem is you have people who although may well be cabable of driving to work--they are by no means cabable of understanding driving at its essence. They will never, not ever; be able to create a car that can also interact with human drivers because they don't understand driving. Period... end of story.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jodrellblank on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @06:17PM (#22242221)
A comment which is nothing but posturing. Why would you expect everybody discussing self-driving cars, in every situation to, be a genius, and to be using their maximum effort even on trivia questions about what UI you would use to tell a car that doesn't exist yet how to drive to McDonalds, under the questionable assumptions that a) it must work exactly the same way as a traditional car and you won't accept otherwise, and b) there will be only one self-driving car full stop, so there will be one answer and it must be perfect for every possible use case first time?
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by brokenmachine on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:48PM (#22232206)
That's the easiest problem to solve... if the car is capable of driving itself then you have both hands free to operate your phone or a touchscreen.

You can enter the location to stop at, and in this imaginary world where the car is capable of driving safely, then it should also be able to find the nearest safe location to stop at.

The actual part where the car is able to drive itself is clearly nothing but unfounded hype though.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by HeWhoLurksLate on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:01PM (#22231612)
Honestly, I think I'm fine piloting a Tesla through a drive-through if it means I can eat on the road. I'll take 80% of possible performance / [aptitude?] now (heck, even 50-60%, as long as it's safe enough) versus 100% of possible scenarios being covered at some far-off point, especia)y if my enjoying 50-60% of capability actively gets the remaining % closer.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by spookthesunset on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:04PM (#22231636)
Too bad you are judgment impaired cause you are drunk. Always remember, you have to assume people in these self driving cars are drunk / high.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jodrellblank on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @07:27PM (#22242747)
Always remember, you have to shift the goalposts every time someone answers, so you can claim they didn't answer.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jodrellblank on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @05:33PM (#22241817)
I did answer. Quite possibly you won't have control. Your entire complaint is a "you can't precisely manage memory in a garbage collected language? Then nobody will use them." style complaint. And that's demonstrated wrong by history over and over - take people's choice away and do it for them, people like it.

Self-driving car, is the hard bit. "Who will design the smartphone app which lets me tap "go to the nearest mcdonalds drive thru"?" is the easy bit. Almost anyone on any $5/hour microconsulting web developer site could do that bit.

"Oh but who would buy an iPhone if it can't let me control the filesystem? You can't answer, nobody can tell me, it's impossible, the tech can't exist, everybody is stupid" - nope, it sold by the hundreds of millions.

Where will it stop? It will stop wherever there is a space. Maybe you can mash your finger on your app for "closest space right now" or maybe you'll get bored of doing that because it already does "closest available space to the chosen destination" because that makes sense.

"One disabled person will get wet in the rain so the tech can't exist" - most tech ignores disabled people completely, and sells in large numbers.

"I can't voice control tell it to go through a drive through so nobody will use it" - if it matters that much to people in general, mctakeout will partner with car company, let you drive up in your fancy car, and they will walk the food out to you. I'm more worried that the cars will come with a "take me to the nearest McDonalds" physical dashboard button, than that no cars have any way to instruct them to go anywhere off-route ever.

"your $70,000 self driving car" - I don't think most self-driving cars will be owned by individuals, but what does price have to do with it? People buy supercars which can't drive through narrow, bumpy, steep, city areas, there is a market for them. Why do you think there will be only a single self-driving car design which has a binary appeal to everybody or nobody, and therefore must be a single answer to how you will control it, and that there's no room for iteration so it must be conclusively decided and locked in several years before any such car even exists or its capabilities are understood and settled?

"So seriously, how will I command this self-driving car?" - so, seriously, driving two tons of machine around a busy unpredictable space is something you're fine with, but having some buttons is what you think the impossibly dealbreaker is? Touchscreens are an appalling human interface, and having almost every control in a touchscreen hasn't stopped Tesla customers.

"Nobody seems to be able to answer this or even thought about it in any amount of detail at all. Probably because we are so far away from an actual self driving car that a realistic answer doesn't really matter at all." - Yes, good point. Nobody has settled on the trivia, because the trivia is not a dealbreaker compared to whether the car can exist at all. It's like you're obsessing over what font the Dragon space capsule will use on its readout displays, and saying that human spaceflight is all hype because "nobody has thought about it in detail".

But no, surely everyone involved is just stupid for not prioritising shovelling burgers into your face over getting you from A to B without killing you or anyone around you.

"Every time you ask about a specific detail it gets hand waved away as not important" - you asked about details, I gave plausible answers (you won't have the level of control you demand) - you completely ignored my answers because you don't want that (you can't answer! ya boo sucks you can't answer!) and then whine that nobody will give you answers.

"You add up all these edge cases that "don't matter" and you've excluded almost your entire market." - I am still boggled that you are putting "can drive through a drive thru" as if that was a thing people actually do enough to influence their choice of car purchase. Can commute to work? Is affordable? Is safe? Is reliable? Has reasonable maintenance and insurance costs? Is big enough for all the people? Can carry enough luggage? Looks OK? All way more important after the dominating "can actually self drive".

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by tenpies on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:52PM (#22230726)
This has been my take too. The whole hackathon and hiring effort screams to me of "we have finally concluded that a LIDAR-less implementation is impossible within our lifetimes. We hope one of you has at least a Hail Mary that we can burn money on so we can at least pretend that it may still be done. Anything to keep us from having to refund millions, dealing with a huge class action, seeing the stock halve, and Elon having to admit that he's something of a charlatan."

And that's just on the decision to not use LIDAR because "it's dumb", not the whole concept of self-driving as it has been marketed being decades away.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by gowld on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:51PM (#22231148)
Tesla lawyers are good as their engineers. They know how to make you think they are selling self driving cars without actually saying it.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by brokenmachine on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:54PM (#22232233)
Another commenter here said that Tesla has been selling "fully self driving" as an option since years ago.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by kickopotomus on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:03PM (#22229735)
I think 50 years is being overly pessimistic. Self-driving in temperate climates is probably pretty close (<10 years). Waymo has pilot programs currently underway in California and Arizona[1][2].

[1]: https://techcrunch.com/2019/09/16/waymos-robotaxi-pilot-surp...

[2]: https://www.theverge.com/2019/10/10/20907901/waymo-driverles...

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by axguscbklp on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:13PM (#22229862)
The thing is, I see no way to have full self driving without AGI. And I don't think humanity is anywhere close to developing AGI. Without AGI you can have level 4++ self driving, maybe, but not level 5.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by rifung on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:52PM (#22231572)
> The thing is, I see no way to have full self driving without AGI.

Why? AGI seems like a significantly harder problem than self driving cars (itself a hard problem admittedly).

What I personally think will happen is we'll meet somewhere in the middle: we can redesign roads/cars to make solving the problem of self driving easier.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by axguscbklp on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:36PM (#22232137)
Because of all the edge cases that humans can handle a good amount of the time because we have a lot of intelligence compared to any computer.

But I agree with you that if we meet in the middle, that could actually work well.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:19PM (#22230468)
How much difference does 4++ vs 5 make for the predicted consequences of self-driving cars though? That's the important thing.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by axguscbklp on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:31PM (#22232105)
I would say that I would feel comfortable falling asleep in a 5 while it is driving nontrivial distance and/or road conditions, but I would not feel comfortable doing so in a 4++.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by Dylan16807 on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:49PM (#22232519)
Why? Plain old 4 is supposed to be the "safe to sleep" level.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:02PM (#22240281)
How often do you have drives when you need to fall asleep though?
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by mlindner on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:21PM (#22231746)
No Elon constantly buys his own bullshit. This has been true for years and years and years long before he became famous from Tesla. His bullshit does eventually become true though, unless it's canceled entirely. It just never happens when he says it will happen.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by hermitdev on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:04PM (#22231635)
Publicly bullshitting (without explicitly stating as such) about your companies capabilities while CEO of a publicly traded company is a potentially huge issue with the SEC.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkemp on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:08PM (#22231274)
I don't understand why "otherwise smart people" feel the need to diminish the potential and successes of ML. When chess was basically solved, it was dismissed brute force, with a sarcastic challenge to do Go, and we now the fate of that challenge.

There used to be, on slashdot and I believe in the early days of HN, this running complaint of the new-at-the-time CSI-style shows, specifically the "enhance" trope: "you can't reconstruct a license plate from a bad frame in a video. That information is just lost. It's not there anymore", they would say, usually with all the aura of letting you in on a secret only a very smart mind could gleam, although there were five others in the same thread making this point.

Today we have superresolution algorithms that can reconstruct license plates from low-res images. Turns out the information wasn't really lost, at least not in the sense applicable to the situation (i. e. you are allowed to train on other data).

Many tech people dismiss such progress as "just statistics", but I haven't seen much of an attempt to find a definition of intelligence that is meaningful different from "just statistics". In fact I doubt it's possible within the realm of science, i. e. without resorting to mind-body dualism.

As to driverless cars: they exist, right now. Google does thousands of miles without any need of human intervention. Yes, maybe it doesn't yet work well enough in a hailstorm. But predicting that these problems will endure for 50 years plus, against a combination of restricting these cars to certain situations, improving the models, and/or improving maps, seems at least as overconfident in your ability to make predictions as those made by self-driving optimists.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by Dylan16807 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @12:04AM (#22232587)
> When chess was basically solved, it was dismissed brute force

Deep blue was brute force. There are different ways to solve a problem, and only some of them are impressive in certain ways, even if they're impressive in other ways.

> Today we have superresolution algorithms that can reconstruct license plates from low-res images.

You need to take another look at CSI. You can reconstruct a little bit, usually with the help of multiple frames or exact font data. You can't do this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I_8ZH1Ggjk0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3uoM5kfZIQ0

> Many tech people dismiss such progress as "just statistics", but I haven't seen much of an attempt to find a definition of intelligence that is meaningful different from "just statistics". In fact I doubt it's possible within the realm of science, i. e. without resorting to mind-body dualism.

That's about as useful as saying everything is 'just chemistry'. It's true but not helpful. And the same way that your brain and a science fair volcano are both just chemistry, demonstrating a simple reaction isn't impressive.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by spookthesunset on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:37PM (#22231480)
They exist now as what amounts to fancy amusement park rides. Wake me up when I can get sloppy drunk and catch one home. Only I was drunk and didn’t provide the exactly correct drop off address and need to somehow communicate to the robo-Uber where exactly it should drop me off... (how will I do that, by the way? talk to it? What if it doesn’t understand my accent?)

Also, I’m at a wedding and the pickup is in a grass field in front of the venue. Can’t pick me up on pavement... it’s a two lane road 50mph road with no shoulder to pull over in. Also the entrance to the venue is a poorly marked dirt road. Also, the “pin” I told the robo-Uber to pick me up at has it at the street ‘cause that is the address.

I’ll wait for the robo-Uber to call me on how the hell it should pull into the lot. I did mention cell sucks here, so hope you’ve got that all offline, right?

And I fully expect my use case to be waved away as “edge case” and “doesn’t matter”. Except it does. Every trip that isn’t a pre-planned, set route amusement park ride is an edge case. Until you can meet my use case, a common one for an Uber driver, self driving cars are empty hype.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by HeWhoLurksLate on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:59PM (#22231927)
> Until you can meet my use case, a common one for an Uber driver, self driving cars are empty hype.

For you. The semi-autonomy we have now- not "this vehicle will get me from point A to point B without need for intervention- but "this vehicle can take out some amount of the area between points A and B" is incredibly useful. I don't know how hard it is for you to keep going straight while fumbling about with a hamburger- I'm not that great at it- but if I can get a bot to help me steer in a relatively straight path and keep me in my lane while I take my jacket off because I'm beginning to sweat, send a message or place a call (having something make that easier is also useful), fire at an armed robber, or let me give more attention to a child who needs it, I will be safer.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by spookthesunset on Monday February 03, 2020 @10:46PM (#22232192)
Nice for you until the “self driving” car gets into an accident and kills the other driver. You don’t get 50% attention with driving. It’s either 100% or 0%. Anything other than that will put everybody else on the road at risk.

If you are driving around in your Tesla using its adaptive cruise control and not paying attention to your driving... I can only hope the accident you will eventually cause hurts nobody but yourself.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jaxn on Monday February 03, 2020 @11:55PM (#22232545)
I have easily driven 12,000 miles under autopilot and regularly do the kind of tasks the parent described.

Maybe I will have an accident and comments like this one will age poorly. Or maybe we will find that the scary technology wasn't as scary as first thought.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by Dylan16807 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @12:11AM (#22232615)
Your phone knows where your home is.

What if the human doesn't understand your accent!

> Every trip that isn’t a pre-planned, set route amusement park ride is an edge case.

That is not even remotely true.

And you could have a fleet that's 80% or 90% robot. It's not hard. $5 discount if your end points aren't all wonky and robot-confusing.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xiphias2 on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:01PM (#22229034)
- I thought fully autonomous driving was meant to be done by now?

One thing that Elon did is gathering lots of video data instead of perfecting LIDAR, and at this point it seems that he was right: until detecting objects in 3D from video data is completely solved, self driving can't work. After it's solved, LIDAR is not needed.

- Tesla & SpaceX have a reputation for being a terrible place to work

When I'm looking for jobs, my main criteria is market cap / number of employees, and Tesla (as most startups/small companies) was very bad before the stock price went up. Now with high stock prices Tesla can afford to pay market rates (even if it's in stock).

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by justapassenger on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:19PM (#22229227)
> When I'm looking for jobs, my main criteria is market cap / number of employees, and Tesla (as most startups/small companies) was very bad before the stock price went up. Now with high stock prices Tesla can afford to pay market rates (even if it's in stock).

All big companies grant stock based on monetary value at the time of the grant. If you join company X when their stock went up 2x, stock grant will be smaller 2x.

You can get market rate, from historically underperforming company, only if you got grants that appreciated, don't expect grants to improve pay rate.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:01PM (#22229717)
> When I'm looking for jobs, my main criteria is market cap / number of employees, and Tesla (as most startups/small companies) was very bad before the stock price went up. Now with high stock prices Tesla can afford to pay market rates (even if it's in stock).

You don't care about the work culture at all?

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xiphias2 on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:52PM (#22230248)
Of course I care, it's just in my experience it's much easier for a company to provide any kind of benefits when the company has money for employees.

Before 2008 when I was working at Google, we were just getting more and more fun stuff all the time, and it seemed like it's never ending. I was together with about 200 people in the Zurich office.

After the stock price went down, although we just had a hiring stop, the food got worse, the bonuses got smaller, and later every new year more and more people came, the stock went up, but the benefits got worse every year until the point where you have to stand in a queue to go to toilet if you are a male.

I think Google is still a great place to work at, but very far from what it was 13 years ago.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:04PM (#22230365)
Sure, but having worked in a number of different environments and having a family, a work culture that is willing to support me is very important. Tesla and SpaceX don't seem to have that at all.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xiphias2 on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:09PM (#22230405)
Sure, I'm also too old to go to Tesla, but if I would want a great carreer, really change the world (not just talk about it) and not care about having a private life, I would seriously consider going there.

At the same time Zurich is small, and many more men go to work there than women, so dating was so hard that I didn't have a real private life anyways.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by solidasparagus on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:26AM (#22232950)
> One thing that Elon did is gathering lots of video data instead of perfecting LIDAR

I really don't understand this thought. Every self-driving car company has more raw data than they can realistically use. I don't see how Tesla has some advantage

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by Reedx on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:54PM (#22228959)
It's pretty clear at this point what you're signing up for at Tesla and SpaceX. They're intentionally trying to filter for people who will dedicate much of their life to the mission of electrifying transport and becoming interplanetary. If you want to do that, there are few better options. If you don't, avoid.

As for firing, well, who knows... The story about Elon's assistant was apparently rife with misinformation, as these things often are.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by zaroth on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:10PM (#22229834)
> I thought fully autonomous driving was meant to be done by now?

That is not what Elon predicted at Autonomy Day last April. He thought they would be feature-complete by the end of 2019, which is to say, that all the basic code paths necessary for best case city driving would be functional.

If you've done software development, you understand that getting to "feature-complete" is different from "code-complete", which is also different from "Beta", which is different from "GA". Those are each progressively later stages in the software development / release cycle.

Feature complete is merely the day that you can say that there is some functional code in place for all of the code paths that you expect to write. You would expect to be able to do an internal demo showing all the functionality working in the "happy case" at that point. Usually QA has not really even begun in earnest at this point. It is by no means the point where development is "done", which is for FSD in fact, approximately, never.

Code complete isn't always distinguished from feature complete, but in my experience, code complete would contemplate negative testing, error handling, and alternative processing modes which might not have been implemented at the point of "feature complete". Code complete typically signifies that from that point forward only bug fixes will be added into the next release.

Some projects can reasonable be expected to remain in testing, validation, and certification for several years after the point of "code complete".

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by karpodiem on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:15PM (#22229884)
He said a million self driving vehicles would be on the streets a year from FSD day.

To try to say the hardware for FSD is now present in 1M vehicles (which I doubt) is disingenuous to the insinuation Elon made that FSD is right around the corner. They're not meaningfully closer to FSD today than they were three years ago. Somewhat closer? Sure. A few feet on a journey that's a few miles though.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by zaroth on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:48PM (#22231133)
> They're not meaningfully closer to FSD today than they were three years ago.

Actually driving a Tesla for 15,000 miles, of which perhaps 5,000 of those miles have been AP over the last 18 months, I can state this is totally false.

There has been extremely significant incremental progress with AP which is totally evident in everyday usage.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by bdamm on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:13PM (#22230427)
Looking at how much has happened over the last two months though it seems that they are on the verge of something big. I'm on pins just waiting for stop light and stop sign detection to be integrated into lane keeping. They're already seeing them, they just need to put that data into action. In terms of my personal driving that'll be pretty big, road trips get a lot shorter when my attention isn't forced.

Turns through intersections is another area where Tesla's current implementation needs a lot of help (read: can barely do it at all) but should be within range soon given where they are at. And lane splits in city streets is definitely something the Tesla implementation is going to need to get better at before really making it door-to-door.

It's a very exciting, even historic time for self driving.

But yeah, taxi fleets are a ways out. There's a turn in the road just a 1/2 mile from my house where my Model 3 gives up every time.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:20PM (#22230479)
Given that in many countries GPS barely works enough to order an Uber with a human driver, I'm highly skeptical of self-driving taxis.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by sib on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:05PM (#22231637)
I'd like to understand this better. Intentional interference with satellites? Too mountainous or too heavy tree cover?

I can imagine navigation services not working, but I've not been in places outside of the high Arctic (~82'N) where GPS itself wasn't very reliable.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by bdamm on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:08PM (#22238835)
Deep in large cities (New York, San Francisco, etc) with all the RF reflections can actually be quite challenging for GPS. Challenging == actually terrible and everyone knows it. Off by blocks, and definitely no help at all for vertical location.

And inaccuracy at start-up is also surprisingly challenging; think a person requesting a car within 5 seconds of opening the app, before the location service of the device has really resolved the location, thus ending up with a pick-up pin that is a hundred feet wrong or more. And maybe on the wrong side of a street, fence, etc.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:00PM (#22240265)
There's also issues like Australia, which because of plate tectonics the maps corresponding to GPS coordinates had to recently be moved close to a meter.

We think of GPS as just the positioning part, but its just as important to remember that there is a large amount of work to translate that position into a meaningful data point within each given country. Just knowing someones exact GPS coordinates isn't helpful.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @02:55PM (#22240209)
Have you ever used Google Maps in a country like Costa Rica? Because the country isn't mapped to nearly the same degree (also, they have a habit of not even naming their roads), it becomes barely useful. I'm not talking about the technology of global positioning, I'm referring to all of what we take for granted with it for.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jsight on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:50PM (#22228894)
I've gotten the impression that the "firing people in weird and capricious ways" bit has been greatly exaggerated.

I do think anyone taking this has to expect grueling and challenging work. The job description practically demands that.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by scrumbledober on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:54PM (#22229629)
Anecdotal evidence here, but I have a friend who worked in their palo alto office for several years. One day as Elon was walking through the Fremont factory he saw a large empty floor space and asked someone why there were no workers occupying that space. It was then decided that her job would be moved from Palo Alto to Fremont. She was not fired in a weird and capricious way, but she was managed out of the company in a weird and capricious way, and that was less than a year ago.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jsight on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @11:34AM (#22237546)
I do not doubt your story at all and have heard a few similar stories. My comment was specifically about the Business Insider story that someone else linked, as I feel like that one was exaggerated.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by kwhitefoot on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:51PM (#22230246)
That happens in pretty much all big companies.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:04PM (#22230368)
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by arexxbifs on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:12PM (#22229854)
I don't doubt for a second that people like Musk (and before him for example Steve Jobs and Jack Tramiel) can be very demanding and sometimes difficult to work for. I also don't doubt for a second that a lot of the stories told have a sour grapes quality to them: If you're good at the kind of job they're offering, you can easily find employment somewhere else and you're also probably smart enough to move on of your own volition, before being capriciously fired.

I worked for an erratic, sociopathic boss once. I quit after about six months. Unless you're a masochist or truly have no other options, you'll soon realize it's not worth whatever extra money or prestige the company name might possibly come with.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by hermitdev on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:55PM (#22231909)
I worked for a hedge fund that fired the bottom 10% every year. I lasted 9 years and my first boss was fired after I was ready to quit 6 months in (figured iwas about 2 weeks away from quitting). Not all firms that employ such tactics are terrible. Sometimes, you need to get rid of the people that just arent cutting their weight. 10% isnt a hard rule, just a guideline.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:22PM (#22230492)
> I worked for an erratic, sociopathic boss once. I quit after about six months. Unless you're a masochist or truly have no other options, you'll soon realize it's not worth whatever extra money or prestige the company name might possibly come with.

Many people move their families, buy houses, and make large commitments taking new jobs (plus are normally granted large stock vesting at a given schedule). There's a lot of reasons people might put up with abuse for awhile.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by arexxbifs on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:32PM (#22230572)
Some of that fall under "having no other options", which is of course a very unpleasant situation to be in.

I'm not, however, desperate enough for wealth to sell my sanity for stock options. :-)

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by anchpop on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:48PM (#22228863)
> I thought fully autonomous driving was meant to be done by now?

It was, but software often goes over-schedule, especially in a brand new field.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by FireBeyond on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:14PM (#22229184)
The prudent thing to do there, would be to exercise prudence. Not announce to investors and the public ever more grandiose targets after each miss.

As it is we're on about Autonomous Driving Promise Mk IV from Musk, "fully autonomous, coast to coast, by the end of 2020". (That's after 2018 was missed. Which was after 2016 was missed.)

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:05PM (#22230376)
Especially not when they are literally accepting money for the feature, which they have consistently estimated wrong timelines on.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by optimiz3 on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:52PM (#22229597)
> Not announce to investors and the public ever more grandiose targets after each miss.

Those poor investors are really taking it on the chin today because of those overly optimistic software projections!

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by mrich on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:23PM (#22229963)
A massive short-squeeze/bitcoin-like retail bubble is certainly not indicative of the strength of the company. Look at the last earnings report, it wasn't impressive for a growth company.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by optimiz3 on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:35PM (#22230086)
More capital volume happened on TSLA today than SPY. Do you think that's a retail bubble? Only the top 1% of global asset controllers have the ability to do that.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by mrich on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:08AM (#22232870)
Why do you think it's appreciating? Do you believe that volume comes from large asset controllers going long at that price level?
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by optimiz3 on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @02:15AM (#22233182)
Couldn't find the source but supposedly today was long buying as opposed to short covering. One theory is funds buying ahead of S&P 500 inclusion.

E: https://twitter.com/ihors3/status/1224362065906872322

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by mrich on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @03:05AM (#22233390)
That sounds plausible, thanks!
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by nickik on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:33PM (#22229405)
Tesla and SpaceX, specially SpaceX has been rated very highly in some rating I have seen. But there is a reputation that it is a lot of work specially in crunch time.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by Seenso on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:46PM (#22229535)
>> Tesla & SpaceX have a reputation for being a terrible place to work, with Musk expecting everyone to be working as hard (or harder) than him, and firing people in weird and capricious ways.

> specially SpaceX has been rated very highly in some rating I have seen.

IIRC, SpaceX has a COO who handles much of the day-to-day management, so the employees there are shielded from much of Musk's management style.

Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by Rebelgecko on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:02PM (#22231236)
I may have a biased sample because I know more former SpaceX employees than current ones (and I'm sure it varies from team to team), but being overworked is the #1 complaint I've heard. Like, to the point where someone working 60 hour weeks is considered a slacker because they take Sundays off.
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:23PM (#22230503)
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by jdc on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:30PM (#22231423)
Re:Tesla's self driving algorithm's overlay [video] by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:18PM (#22230459)
Honestly, I don't know how often that question ever warrants good responses. From my experience, most hiring comes from interviewing people who resumes show they're pretty obviously qualified, rather than questions like this from the beginning.