News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pantone 448 C by reaperducer on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:10PM (#22133890)
It is commonly used as a transparency placeholder for a reason - nobody wants to actually see it.

My memory from my days in television was that magenta was used to represent transparency because it was the opposite of chroma green, and was easy to generate electronically. That's why it ended up being in one of the palettes for the primitive-by-today's-standards CGA adapter in the early IBM PC's.

Chroma green, magenta, and superblack were three "magic colors" that made TV production work in the pre-digital age. Sadly, there is no wikipedia entry for superblack even though everyone saw it all the time, and few understood its utility.

Re:Pantone 448 C by hug on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:30PM (#22134057)
I'd love if you were able provide some reading on "superblack", or even just explain it yourself.

I tried looking it up myself, because it sounds interesting, but of course search results are polluted with articles on vantablack. "Super black TV" and related search terms just bring up garbage about OLED TVs and such.

Re:Pantone 448 C by derefr on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:32PM (#22134507)
Analogue TV encoders took a signal with a dynamic range of "black to white" (e.g. 0V to 5V) and, before modulating it onto a carrier frequency, first compressed the signal upwards, making it into a smaller range of e.g. 1V to 5V, making it into a signal that's actually more like "dark grey to white." Analogue TV decoders did the opposite, treating 1V as the "black level", stretching the 4V "dynamic range" back into the full black-to-white intensity range.

Doing this allowed "true 0V" (i.e. gaps cut out of the modulated signal by electronic post-processing, below the "minimum" intensity of 1V, where you're just getting carrier) to act as a form of in-band signalling. 0V was used "outside" the image to both synchronize the TV's raster electronics, and inform said electronics of the period of time they should be off altogether, rather than firing even a weak electron beam. (This most noticably prevents your CRT from drawing a subtle diagonal swoosh when it starts each new frame.)

See also: the terms "front porch" and "back porch" (in e.g. https://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/201011/what-...), referring to the parts of each scanline that are 0V.

Re:Pantone 448 C by smogcutter on Friday January 24, 2020 @01:42AM (#22135915)
As long as we’re talking about analog video, I can’t stop myself from throwing Dan Sandin’s analog image processor in there. Think the principles of a moog synth, applied to video signal. Here’s a totally amazing video of him demonstrating the machine, circa mid 70s:

https://youtu.be/8qh6jRzjmcY

Sandin also had a distribution philosophy that was a precursor (early contemporary?) to FOSS: he called it “copy-it-right”. He’d send anyone a copy of the schematics, but you were expected to build it as designed and not get creative until you at least had it working properly. The process of building the machine was also supposed to teach you how it worked.

Many moons ago I emailed Sandin and got a copy of the plans. They’re a hell of a document. Unfortunately some critical components are no longer in production, and updating the schematics was beyond my skill (setting aside that the scale and expense of the project was also beyond me, but hey).

Re:Pantone 448 C by miek on Friday January 24, 2020 @04:38AM (#22136706)
Awesome video, thanks for posting that. I'll add a more recent interview with Sandin that is pretty interesting: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Izx2CqxM71s
Re:Pantone 448 C by 0xcde4c3db on Thursday January 23, 2020 @11:03PM (#22135305)
One consequence of this setup that people might remember: the Nintendo Entertainment System can produce a "color" below the standard black level because of the primitive (albeit clever) scheme used to generate the video signal. It's been alleged that this was forbidden for licensed games, but a few games (and the Game Genie) did use it [1], causing an unstable image on some TVs.

[1] http://wiki.nesdev.com/w/index.php/Color_$0D_games

Re:Pantone 448 C by hyperdimension on Thursday January 23, 2020 @09:22PM (#22134804)
Interesting to see 'superblack'. I always remember reading the terms 'blacker than black' and 'whiter than white' in old TV repair/theory books.
Re:Pantone 448 C by taneq on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:06PM (#22135040)
So given that many TVs displayed a flat blue screen on no signal, does that mean that blue is blacker than black?
Re:Pantone 448 C by smogcutter on Friday January 24, 2020 @01:19AM (#22135831)
That’s a later development in CRT TVs, where if there’s no signal you get a flat blue generated by the TV instead of noise. Hence the often quoted tidbit that Gibson’s line “The sky was the color of a television tuned to a dead channel” (close enough) doesn’t scan as a grey sky for younger readers.
Re:Pantone 448 C by wruza on Friday January 24, 2020 @02:37AM (#22136151)
Hmm, I do remember both. It was not even grey, static is high-contrast flickering of b/w dots or short lines with an amount of random grey between them (maybe soviet static was staticker, idk). For me and sky, blue makes sense, static just doesn’t. If I read it before blue screens appeared, maybe it could.

https://www.canstockphoto.com/real-tv-static-10531607.html

Re:Pantone 448 C by taneq on Friday January 24, 2020 @03:22AM (#22136371)
> static is high-contrast flickering of b/w dots or short lines with an amount of random grey between them

Like snow, even. Hence 'Snow Crash'. :)

I imagine the sky in a predominantly cold, snowy or rainy place could look a bit like static. Dry sunny climates are tend to be more "A/V 1" blue. :)

Re:Pantone 448 C by jameshart on Friday January 24, 2020 @07:44AM (#22137592)
Static also has the quality of lacking scale, and containing spurious signal that your visual cortex tries to lock onto but never can. I always read the neuromancer sky as having that same kind of depthless gray and false motion that I associate with tv snow. A color you can see but can’t rest your eyes on.
Re:Pantone 448 C by taneq on Saturday January 25, 2020 @08:53AM (#22146234)
Exactly! It’s white noise in visual form.

shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Re:Pantone 448 C by jacobush on Friday January 24, 2020 @03:21AM (#22136367)
I think you are supposed to view the CRT from a bit afar, then you'd get that gray feeling. Also these "bands" were either jumping too much up and down to be noticable or not appearing at all on the old purely analog sets. As I remember them, the static was truly chaotic, no lines.
Re:Pantone 448 C by wruza on Friday January 24, 2020 @03:51AM (#22136514)
I guess it may depend on a signal saturation. Some empty channels were relatively dim and sparse, and some screamed white morse at you. That picture is not exactly what we should have seen, for one I cannot count 500+ lines in there. It must be only a part of a screen or a non-standard resolution (or a very short expo that captured half-frame?). Couldn’t find a good one quickly.
Re:Pantone 448 C by woobar on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:21AM (#22139585)
HBO still uses this "static analogue flickering" in their logo.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P_Oh7HizY5I

Re:Pantone 448 C by SECProto on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:21PM (#22135112)
I can't recall ever seeing an analogue TV display a flat blue screen - with no signal, they generally display black&white noise
Re:Pantone 448 C by Animats on Friday January 24, 2020 @03:33AM (#22136423)
Not colored noise, amusingly. NTSC color TV is backwards compatible with NTSC black and white TV. Color comes in on a subcarrier of the TV signal, relative to the black and white signal, and is low bandwidth compared to the intensity signal.

Because the color signal is optional, TV receivers had to have a detector for it to enable color. Noise didn't contain the "color burst" that identified the color signal, so noise showed as black and white noise, not colored confetti. At least until TV receivers acquired enough signal processing that no-signal produced a "No Signal" message, a blue screen, or a channel guide.

Gibson has written that he has mixed feelings about that line. Great line, but dates the work.

Re:Pantone 448 C by DrStalker on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:59PM (#22135283)
I can remember it, I think in setups where the TV signal was passed through a VCR (so it could be recorded) and then into the TV. If the VCR detected there was no useful signal it would output a blue image instead of static.

Just showing raw static was much more common though.

Re:Pantone 448 C by tenebrisalietum on Friday January 24, 2020 @03:16PM (#22142014)
In the early 90's, TV's started including low-resolution "Teletype" type chips (the kind you see overlay information on security cameras) that would generate menu text for volume control, etc.

Frequently these TV's would have a "muting" mechanism - if you selected a channel without a signal, it would mute the audio and display a blue background instead of the underlying signal.

When LCD TV's and HDTV started gaining traction the "No Signal" screen was often some text bouncing around in some manner.

Re:Pantone 448 C by gwbas1c on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:41PM (#22135210)
The newer ones made in the late 1990s did.
Re:Pantone 448 C by namdnay on Friday January 24, 2020 @01:55AM (#22135972)
This reminds me of the fact that younger generations have a completely different understanding of the first sentence of Neuromancer
Re:Pantone 448 C by Cerium on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:48PM (#22134199)
I found a short snippet: https://www.alanpedia.com/television_production_glossary/sup...

Superblack: A value on the wave form monitor of 0 or less luminance units. 7.5 units is standard TV black. Graphics and logos placed on superblack are much easier to work with.

Re:Pantone 448 C by hug on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:30PM (#22134496)
That's a pretty good dictionary definition, I suppose, but I have no idea what that might actually look like in practice, which is a shame.
Re:Pantone 448 C by floatingatoll on Thursday January 23, 2020 @09:43PM (#22134908)
On an HDTV with "local contrast dimming", freeze frame at some point in a video where there's only a logo showing in the corner of the screen and the rest of the frame is black. (A screenshot of certain video game loading screens works, too.)

You will see that the area around the logo is glowing slightly, and that the area opposite the logo is completely lights out.

That is, essentially, the difference between "black" and "superblack". Both areas are displaying black, but one area is backlit and the other is not. Lit black is clearly different from Unlit black, because LCD pixels aren't perfectly opaque.

If you have an OLED TV (or an OLED phone, like a top-end iPhones), then every black pixel is superblack, which is why it looks so high contrast and gorgeous. If you have an LCD phone, you can see the "lit black" thing — but probably only if you set it next to an OLED phone.

Folks who know what "235" has to do with this, yes, I know, but I'm only addressing "what that might actually look like", not "deep dive into the RGB low/high problem". Feel free :)

Re:Pantone 448 C by reaperducer on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:39PM (#22134551)
I'd love if you were able provide some reading on "superblack", or even just explain it yourself.

I'm not a TV engineer, I was a journalist, so here's what I remember:

Superblack was a special kind of black. When you watched analog TV and the video faded to black, the screen was black. But that was a transmission black. It wasn't as black as was electrically possible. There was always still some signal there generating not-quite-black.

The not-quite-black was largely an artifact of video tape, and all the dozens of machines a video signal had to go through from playback to broadcast. If you were watching black recorded on tape, it was never quite black. An ordinary person would never notice that it wasn't perfectly black, but you could see it if you were in a TV station with oscilloscopes monitoring the signal at various points in the video chain. IIRC, it was like -1db, or something like that.

You could see it at home, if you tried. If you knew what to look for. The easiest way to do it was to turn the brightness up on your TV and look for the dark dark dark grey at the beginning and the end of commercial breaks. That wasn't superblack, that was regular black. But superblack would be next.

In a videotape room or an editing suite, you could see superblack quite easily. Watching a tape with black on it on an analog monitor showed regular black. When you ejected the tape, the monitor would go a shade darker: superblack. The blackest the monitor could electrically be without actually being off.

Superblack could be used for all kinds of things. I only remember three off the top of my head.

First, primitive chroma-key effects in the days before digital video. It wasn't great, and you'd need extra equipment down the line to boost the signal because it would get dark, and then boosting the signal made it look bad, so it was rarely used.

Second, the equivalent of today's alpha channel compositing. This was more common, but still resulted in some signal degradation. But it was how you could put chyron or an OTS over video or a live signal.

Third, was the TV station equivalent of a "silence sense." When I worked in radio, each station had a gadget called a "silence sense" that would be hooked up to an ordinary radio tuned to the station. If there was silence for longer than x number of seconds, it tripped a relay that flipped on red blinking light bulbs in the DJ booth, in the newsroom, in the PD's office, in the MD's office, and if you were unlucky, the GM's office. In non-studio locations it was often accompanied by a beeping noise. The idea was to let everybody in the building know that something had gone horribly wrong and there was nothing on the air. Some stations I worked at it was set for 10 seconds. Some as few as 3. Really, it depended on the type of music the station played.

A similar gadget could be made (most of these things were home-made by the station engineer) to look for superblack in a TV signal. Too much superblack, and alarms go off everywhere.

Fourth, Panasonic is the only company I know of that used superblack in the consumer arena. It made a VCR that, after a show was recorded, would automatically rewind and re-watch the show for you. When it sensed superblack, it would mark the location on the tape. Then when a person went to watch what was recorded later, the VCR could sense the marks it made previously and use them to fast forward through the commercials in the program. This worked because there would always be superblack inadvertently broadcast at the start and at the end of each commercial set where there was a break in the video chain from the switch between the show playback machine and the commercial break's playback machines. I had one of these machines. It worked really well, except that it made all kinds of chugging and whirring noises in the night while it marked the tape.

Again, I'm not an engineer, so I'm just working from memory. But I'm typing what I know here because so much information about these sorts of things has disappeared, and the people who know more about these things are mostly dead.

Re:Pantone 448 C by hug on Thursday January 23, 2020 @09:44PM (#22134912)
Thank you -- I genuinely appreciate the explanation. Even if it's not as thoroughly technical as it could have been, it's still enlightening. (and the fact that it's not dryly technical makes it more interesting in its own ways!)
Re:Pantone 448 C by p1necone on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:35PM (#22134100)
My assumption would be that it's whatever the darkest shade of black representable is - so 0x000000 in rgb. However that can't really be read as a distinct value in an analogue signal, maybe it's some kind of "sufficiently out of range" value so as to be distinguished from legitimate colors?
Re:Pantone 448 C by kaetemi on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:48PM (#22134200)
I remember there was some particular shade of off-black in Windows 95 that was always transparently showing any video that was playing. Don't think it's related though.
Re:Pantone 448 C by zamalek on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:05PM (#22134318)
That happened because 3D cards used something called "overlay". Recall that your 3D card (Voodoo or some other 3dfx) was an additional card beyond your 2D card. The card would overlay its signal on the 2D card according to 2 parameters: a rectangle and a color.

I assume that videos used the same machinery, possibly in software, so that you couldn't take screenshots for copyright reasons. Or maybe it was faster for some reason, who knows (Raymond Chen might).

Either way, it's probably unrelated.

Re:Pantone 448 C by cycloptic on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:40PM (#22134557)
The video acceleration was done the same way with overlays because of the same hardware limitations. I remember the difference was that they used chroma keying to try and fake that it knew how to work with the windowing system -- the hardware would mask the video using the chroma key color while rendering the plane. Of course if you had another window that happened to have the chroma key color for text or something, you could drag it over the video and the text would appear oddly transparent. This happened with certain drivers on Windows up to XP, and on Unix/X11 when using the old "XVideo" extension.

But this is indeed tangential and not relevant to the original comment, because the chroma key color could be anything. On one particular driver I had, I remember the chroma key color was a very ugly shade of brown :)

Re:Pantone 448 C by wizzard on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:46PM (#22134189)
I believe OLED technology is what OP is referring to. The pixels can turn off individually in order to create true blacks.
Re:Pantone 448 C by function_seven on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:52PM (#22134234)
OP mentioned 3 magic colors in pre-digital TV production. The 3rd, "superblack" is what we're all curious about. OLED hadn't been invented yet.
Re:Pantone 448 C by kiwidrew on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:26PM (#22135136)
> That's why it ended up being in one of the palettes for the primitive-by-today's-standards CGA adapter in the early IBM PC's.

Interesting... do you have a source for that?

The hideous CGA palette is legendary, but I thought the reason for its ugly palette is a consequence of: (1) only having 16KB of video RAM, and (2) only having ~10 bits of mode-setting and colour control registers. The CGA card was built entirely from off-the-shelf discrete logic chips (plus a 6845 CRTC) and there simply wasn't room to add any extra registers.

At 320x200 resolution the colour depth was limited to 2bpp, and these two bits are wired up directly to the red and green bits of the display output. The blue and intensity bits are (in graphics modes) wired up to the mode control register. Thus the four hideous palettes: the B and I bits have to be set to a fixed value for the entire screen, and only the R and G bits can vary on a pixel-by-pixel basis.

(There's a bonus palette of red, cyan, and white that can be enabled by yet another mode control bit; and the background colour -- which is usually black -- can actually be set to any one of the 16 available colours.)

Re:Pantone 448 C by toast0 on Friday January 24, 2020 @01:27AM (#22135855)
I think you both agree. Magenta is easy to generate, and the CGA electronics were designed around easy to generate colors, not pretty or good looking colors.
Re:Pantone 448 C by dylan604 on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:22PM (#22134430)
I was only familiar with the term blacker-than-black in analog broadcast. Legal black was 7.5IRE, but any value below 7.5 was referred to as blacker-than-black. Older CRT TVs were very susceptible to bad(cool/interesting) things when the video signal was out of spec.
Re:Pantone 448 C by bonzini on Friday January 24, 2020 @02:48AM (#22136204)
The 2-bit palettes of CGA were simply colors 2/4/6 and 3/5/7 of the text mode palette, where bit 2 is red, bit 1 is green and bit 0 is blue. The fourth color (encoded as 00) was the background and could be chosen from any of the 16 text colors.

(In addition there was an "undocumented" palette consisting of colors 3/4/7 plus the background color).

Re:Pantone 448 C by ineedasername on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:14PM (#22133930)
What is it about magenta that makes it easy to generate electronically?
Re:Pantone 448 C by dylan604 on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:18PM (#22133967)
In TV, the 3 primary colors are Red, Green, Blue. Magenta is a secondary color made from combining Red and Blue. That's what makes it easy. Just turn on 2 of the 3 colors you have to make it. It's not a fraction of them, it's just full on of 2 out of 3.
Re:Pantone 448 C by aaronblohowiak on Thursday January 23, 2020 @08:47PM (#22134604)
Fun fact: there is no such thing as magenta as a frequency of light, it is a fun trick your mind does to explain both the low energy and high energy receptors activating without the middle energy receptors also activating. In terms of pigment, magenta is one of the primary colors.
Re:Pantone 448 C by lubujackson on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:25PM (#22135133)
Yes, was going to say this. Magenta isn't on a rainbow and isn't really a normal color in that sense. By the weirdness of how our eyes detect colors amd how our brain processes them, magenta is something like an error response catch-all for colors outside our eye's capabilities and from that standpoint it is quite interesting.
Re:Pantone 448 C by mcv on Friday January 24, 2020 @04:30AM (#22136679)
Our heads are good at mixing colors, and we register those as colors too. Brown isn't on the rainbow either.

The most interesting color on the rainbow is violet. It registers in our heads as a kind of purple when objectively it's super blue. But the cones that register red in our eyes are also slightly activated with this super blue light, which makes it register as purple in our brain.

I'd love to see an experiment where people are shown both true violet and purple mixed from red and blue in proportions that make it register as the exact same purple as violet does. And then check how many people see a difference between the two colors. That might finally answer the question of whether red in your head looks the same as in my head.

Re:Pantone 448 C by SamBam on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:51AM (#22139980)
I've always wondered by violet looks purple. Thanks for that.

So, to be clear, it's just a hardware detail with our red cones? They fire in the presence of photons in the red band, but also happen to fire in the super-blue band? It's just an artifact of how they're constructed, either by chance or evolution?

> I'd love to see an experiment where people are shown both true violet and purple mixed from red and blue in proportions that make it register as the exact same purple as violet does.

Isn't this basically exactly what the computer color violet does? E.g. there are photographs of violet at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violet_(color), which presumably look close to reality, but the hex color is #7F00FF, which has a lot of red in it.

Is that red not there to simulate our perception of violet, if I've understood you right?

Re:Pantone 448 C by mcv on Friday January 24, 2020 @05:39PM (#22143086)
Yeah, the computer merely simulates violet by mixing a kind of purple that looks just like violet.

As far as I understand (I'm no expert, I just read this somewhere), red cones also fire for extremely blue (violet) photons. No idea why. Maybe it's blue light of exactly double the frequency of red light?

My guess would be it's accidental, but I truly don't know. It might be interesting to test if animals with different kinds of cones (like butterflies) also have a similar effect for some of their cones. Though of course we'll never be able to imagine the colors they see. We're colorblind compared to them.

Re:Pantone 448 C by aaronblohowiak on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:36PM (#22144062)
You do not have blue cones, you have violet cones. Well, your “blue” cones are activated starting around 380 nm wavelength, which is violet.
Re:Pantone 448 C by aaronblohowiak on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:20PM (#22143999)
Brown is dark orange, which is on the rainbow.
Re:Pantone 448 C by SamBam on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:49AM (#22139932)
> Magenta isn't on a rainbow

Unsure of the relevance of this. Surely there are many colors not in the rainbow: black, white, gray, brown, pink, yellow, periwinkle...

Re:Pantone 448 C by gugagore on Friday January 24, 2020 @12:27PM (#22140398)
Here is some visual support for that explanation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_spaces_with_RGB_primarie...

It's fortunate that we mostly have 3 categories of cones and also 3 spatial dimensions. Notice that magenta is a vertex (of 8 vertices) in the cube, along with Yellow and Cyan too.

How the particular space (of activation to the 3 categories of cones) is carved out by that cube is something we engineered, and in fact is different across different printing and display technologies.

Re:Pantone 448 C by ineedasername on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:51PM (#22134228)
Ah, of course! One of those things that's obvious once I know the answer.
Re:Pantone 448 C by jayd16 on Friday January 24, 2020 @02:51AM (#22136221)
With RGB floats magenta is #FF00FF and that's pretty easy to remember.
Re:Pantone 448 C by jameshart on Friday January 24, 2020 @08:01AM (#22137738)
Interested in what field you get the term ‘rgb float’? Not a term I’ve heard before (and not an accurate one) so I’d be interested if it’s a term of art in some industry...
Re:Pantone 448 C by jayd16 on Friday January 24, 2020 @11:59AM (#22140064)
Computer graphics use floats for color values very often. It was indeed misleading of me to mention floats and then use a hex value to explain it, though. Just a brain fart from seeing it earlier in the thread. With floats it would simply be (1,0,1).
Re:Pantone 448 C by pickpuck on Thursday January 23, 2020 @10:41PM (#22135211)
I was thinking because it is one of the inks in CMYK for printing.
Re:Pantone 448 C by praptak on Friday January 24, 2020 @03:02AM (#22136277)
You are probably thinking of rich black, which in CMYK is black plus some of the other three ink colours. Converted to RGB it would still be black, but in actual printing it has its uses.
Re:Pantone 448 C by jameshart on Friday January 24, 2020 @07:58AM (#22137709)
I definitely recall hearing the term super black as distinct from rich black to refer to just a mixture of black and cyan, but I can’t find a cite for that. May have been local to a specific printer? This was in a context where avoiding using four inks was an important cost saving, so maybe it was just a two color equivalent of rich black.

Of course, those two colors were also immortalized by John Cougar Mellencamp in his “little ditty ‘bout black and cyan...”

Re:Pantone 448 C by zamadatix on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:33PM (#22134083)
Is this not what you are talking about? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_black
Re:Pantone 448 C by tesseract on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:46PM (#22134191)
In this context, it's not a physical color. It refers to an analog video signal with a lower brightness level than the level which was defined as corresponding to pure black.
Re:Pantone 448 C by wizzard on Thursday January 23, 2020 @07:48PM (#22134206)
That article is about a “surface treatment” for solid objects, like Vantablack. OP is talking about screens — I believe they are referring to OLED true black.