Because "France" is not going after anyone, nor our watchdog, it's UFC Que Choisir (a pro consumer association, similar to eg EFF in their status/legal form) that sued Valve in court.
UFC is a regular of first trying mediation and getting companies to change nicely, and if nothing occurs then they do court cases like this, and then use the verdict as a basis for more mediation with other actors in the field.
(The cases against closed platforms would be stronger, since on those platforms it's far easier for the secondary seller to prove that they no longer have access to the game.)
Instead make the ruling clear in a case where this specificity doesn't apply, then go deeper in the rabbit hole if needed.
Again I'm only guessing here but it makes sense; similar to how, if you were to go against phone os app stores, you would go after Google first because Apple has the "my market for my product" and "not legaly a monopoly [depending on how you define the market]" card.
You can't really export the game outside of Steam, or use it with Steam disabled for any significant amount of time.
While on the other hand, an gamer or game-maker on iPhone or Android or Nintendo or Playstation or XBox has no choice in digital distribution channels.
(And of course the latter have other flaws too - like their famously capricious acceptance processes)
One could even go on to argue that PC gaming allows you to launch your own game store that allows resale if you think it's so important. Personally I don't find that a very convincing argument, though.
Further, many games purchased on Steam provide keys that work without using the steam account.
For library management, GOG 2 (Alpha) is the best solution I've personally seen (have the various storefronts installed, import the connector for GOG 2, all the games from that storefront are imported into GOG 2, can install/play/etc. on a whim).
- because games are software, it is hard to enforce that people “selling” them don’t keep a copy for themselves as well
- apparently, this may have allowed an exemption from the “must allow reselling” rule
- because iOS is a walled garden, it is easier to implement DRM to prevent this
- therefore, the courts would have been more likely to force the App Store to allow resale
That isn't true for all games. There is this [0] list, but I have no idea about its quality. Essentially there are games that don't use the steamworks DRM parts, so while you do not get a steam-independent installer, those games still work after uninstalling steam (and you could probably watch the installer to make your own for a completely steam free PC).
It's easier to beat Valve's lawyers than Sony's. Sony has a long history of paying out the nose for lawyers who could convince a judge that a law saying "Kill no one" meant "Genocide is legal for Sony Corporation!" (See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Computer_Entertainment_Am...)
Apple and Microsoft are the two most valuable companies on the planet right now, and they, too, can get some great lawyers (though they haven't demonstrated the same courtroom magic that Sony has).
I can't remember who originally was responsible for this quote, but "Nintendo is a pile of cash disguised as a video game company" is something that has been proven anything but incorrect over the past decades. Wouldn't want to pick a fight in any court with them, either. (Relevant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Nintendo)
Valve, though? Valve is worth little in comparison, and hasn't had a great history in court. Easy pickings. Then, after you win against Valve, you go up, using the precedent set to help you with the next target.
Is this supposed to be hyperbole? The case itself was never tried, so it that doesn't show anything about how effective sony's lawyers are.
There are plenty of other Sony cases that demonstrate the rule.
If it meant hackers stole everything you own and worked for in your life so far you would think twice how legal this is.
Further, the idea that software piracy is stealing is also absurd, for an entirely different reason: copying is not stealing. Sony still had the original copies.
Beyond that: I already do release all of my source code under libre licenses. Copying isn't stealing, and I've lived my life as a testament to that.
They aren't valuable by the metric he was measuring.
Obviously everyone knows what Apple and the various zero-day companies pay for them; no one here is stupid or unaware.
Now you can use the stupid libertarian argument that you're just "moving bits around" or "moving numbers around" (and math is not illegal). But do that do much and you'll find that society's answer is to move particles of lead in your general direction, at high velocity.
Stealing is taking someone else's property without permission, as you said. However, copying doesn't take it away from them, and jailbreaking literally doesn't do anything but apply a patch to your existing bits. That's the farthest thing from stealing you could imagine, and your argument falls apart with just the tiniest bit of poking.
Not much happened before the settlement, the parties settled very quickly after Hotz's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction failed. The TRO sucked, but wasn't particularly unreasonable.
>incredibly unfair things (like the list of people who had legally downloaded the legally-created software of Hotz).
Jurisdictional discovery is not incredibly unfair, and was only a natural consequence of Hotz's motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction.
>The reason it was settled out of court was seemingly just so Hotz could avoid a felony.
The fuck? This was a civil case.
Computer fraud is a felony, and around that time the DoJ was getting very trigger-happy in turning civil cases criminal. Google the CFAA, which they were trying to pin Hotz under.
Do you happen to have a single example of this?
And in any case I don't think this is a great example of the DOJ being trigger-happy, what Swartz did was obviously criminal and they were still willing to let him off with only a slap on the wrist.
Sarcam aside ufc que choisir have foughr a lot of high profile guys before.
This is the origin of their refund policy today, which is no questions asked within usage limits. Australia is only like 5% of Steam users so they unfortunately got away with the vast majority of their fraud, perhaps several hundred thousand other instances.
https://www.engadget.com/2016/12/23/valve-steam-fined-2-mill...
One year and nine months later, Steam implemented the refund policy. I asked again for a refund. Steam declined it because the purchase was made too long ago.
I did go to the ACCC a couple years ago when I wanted a refund on GOG - they're more dishonest than Steam as they market a money back guarantee but the only circumstance they will refund is if you prove to their satisfaction that the game cannot open on your computer. It's a "no refund" policy just like Steam used to have.
https://support.gog.com/hc/en-us/articles/115000487189-GOG-C...
These "This is the same company that..." type of comments are very low value. Companies operate across dozens of jurisdictions and have to comply with hundreds of laws. I goes without saying that eventually they'll bump up against a law and/or group of people that disagree with their decisions. That's a normal part of doing business and doesn't have any relevance to some other controversy.
I don't get why games and books are treated differently here.
Personally I understand the economic and technical problems a resale would present, but nevertheless I think putting restrictions of the abilities to resell is an idiotic policy approach.
Got a Ryanair flight, but outside EU? Can’t download the app and need to print your boarding pass (or pay half the ticket price to do it in the airport).
Got family abroad? Yeah no family sharing for you (even for storage).
Edit: did I say most? App reviews are downright fraud.
Even knowing some Googlers working in that area, it took me 6 months in order to migrate my google account to another country.
I don't remember the details that clearly but some features were not working well with a 'foreign' google account.
It has been 2 years and I am still trying to close my original paypal account and get back the money that is on it.
Dealing with Paypal support in particular has proven kafkaesque. The original account wants a recent proof of residence in my origin country, which is of course not possible. After multiple calls with support, the solution they provided was for me to create a new account in my country and ask them to transfer my old account to that one. I did so but the customer service for that other country claims that they can't access my original account and that I need to call their colleagues in my origin country.
[1] https://tinkrmind.files.wordpress.com/2017/09/bcbp-implement...
I think the whole "you must print the PDF boarding pass" thing is just about saving time. Imagine an older person in a hurry trying to zoom the PDF just right and also max the brightness. My wife (30-ish) struggles to do this without slowing down the queue.
Most of those restrictions don't hold up under nations with significant Consumer Protection laws, like the EU and Australia.
Also, in those same jurisdictions, if a part of a contract is trying to enforce something illegal, like taking away a right, then the entire contract can often be considered void.
So if a Consumer Right is the transfer or reselling of the license, like it is here, then the contract is worth less than toilet paper.
Which would mean that nothing was transferred to the purchaser. What you seem to actually mean from the rest of your comment is that the illegal term can be excised leaving the rest of the contract in places rather than the contract being void (which may also be an option, but not one, in this situation, that would benefit the purchaser against whom the illegal term would apply were it not illegal.)
No. The contract is void. Which means the seller has no recourse, and no ability to rescind the product, etc, etc.
Which means that the transfer has happened without any obligations on the purchaser. The seller has transferred it to them, without a valid agreement in place.
If only the term itself was all that was made invalid, then the seller could hold the purchaser to account for other parts of the contract - but the contract itself is considered void.
In practice, this usually means that the purchaser has received the equivalent of an unlimited license grant. They can copy, disassemble, and so on, without limitation.
That's not what a void contract would mean; a void contract would mean the seller and buyer have no obligations to each other, particularly, if the product required some interaction with the seller's servers to function (as much software does these days), the seller would have no obligation to continue such service to the buyer, as that obligation is rooted in the contract.
While use the language of a void contract, you seem to be suggesting that the contract would be valid in all respects against the seller but the buyer’s obligations would be voided. I'm not going to argue that there aren't legal systems that take that remedy for an unconscionable contract term, but it is not the same as voiding the contract. (It would be indistinguishable from voiding the contract in the exceptional case where the only obligations not already fully executed ran from the buyer to the seller.)
> In practice, this usually means that the purchaser has received the equivalent of an unlimited license grant. They can copy, disassemble, and so on, without limitation.
A substantial grant of rights that would not exist without the contract and which also weren't present in the contract is a radically different remedy than simply voiding the contract.
Ah. That's where you're getting stuck. No, that obligation is rooted in the Consumer Protection laws that supersede all contracts, not the contract itself.
are toilet paper in EU. Thanks to UsedSoft v Oracle I can go to the recycling center and pick up $5 copy of Windows 10 and Microsoft cant deny activation.
From a developer’s perspective, Steam actually handles many more pain points of building games (voip, playing with friends, build processes, DRM, anti-cheat etc.) so arguably, the user is a subscriber of _steam_, since the developer is a subscriber of those services.
I’m curious to know why you find this defense “obviously bullshit”?
It's why the NZ's consumer guarantee's act has terms like what is "reasonable" and The Disputes Tribunal (somewhat equivalent to small claims court) will often consider things from an average consumer perspective.
HN is full of technical power users so it's common for the comment sections of these stories to devolve into a "well actually" nitpick of language use but most sane countries consumer protection laws are intentionally not designed this way.
Otherwise you can probably extrapolate anything into a "subscription" service. Your bank and most credit cards are structured in a way that looks like a subscription, but an average consumer doesn't consider their plastic cards a financial "subscription".
I do, but I have to pay my bank X EUR a month to use it; therefore a paid subscription service. I don't have to pay Steam X EUR a month to use it. If I don't pay for Steam for a year, my account is still going to work exactly as it did before (sans a few DRM games, maybe, heh). Therefore, Steam is at the very least not a paid subscription service.
Whether it is a subscription service or not, well that is a different matter. I'd say a subscription service is only a subscription service if you regularly pay for the subscription (ie. monthly, quarterly, yearly). If the service stays running and working for you without you paying, then it isn't a subscription service. No, the reason Steam stays working is because of the <= 30% tax on all the sales. Which isn't a subscription service but more akin to a communal tax to keep the infrastructure working.
Apart from that, I never signed up for a Steam subscription. I did sign up for a World of Warcraft subscription. And that means there's no first sale doctrine, sadly, as this goes against the collector mindset the game stands on.
Steam is a DRM too, so if they don't want to keep the games in their servers offer a DRM free versions of all the games.
I’ve lost a case recently by super partial judge and dyslexic seller just blasting nationalistic insults.
NZ is nice but it’s not all daisies and roses.
You'll get no argument from me. Didn't mean to imply our processes are perfect. I do my fair share of complaining about the NZ political and legal landscape elsewhere. :)
no idea how this lines up with the legal definition, though.
And then separate from that, the core of the 2012 court decision was the 2009 "legal protection of computer programs" directive. But in 2014 (in the Nintendo vs. PC Box case) the CJEU basically ended up ruling that games did not fall under that directive due to how heavy they are on non-software (audio-visual) content[1].
I'd be really curious why Valve's lawyers ignored these avenues and went for the ridiculous subscription option. (And equally, I'm curious about why France was going after Valve when PSN, Xbox Live, Apple App Store and Nintendo eShop appear to be softer targets).
[0] https://gameslaw.org/the-end-of-the-usedsoft-case-and-its-im...
[1] http://curia.europa.eu/juris/document/document.jsf?docid=146...