News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by kick on Sunday December 29, 2019 @06:59PM (#21909561)
Steam is a closed platform, but:

It's easier to beat Valve's lawyers than Sony's. Sony has a long history of paying out the nose for lawyers who could convince a judge that a law saying "Kill no one" meant "Genocide is legal for Sony Corporation!" (See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Computer_Entertainment_Am...)

Apple and Microsoft are the two most valuable companies on the planet right now, and they, too, can get some great lawyers (though they haven't demonstrated the same courtroom magic that Sony has).

I can't remember who originally was responsible for this quote, but "Nintendo is a pile of cash disguised as a video game company" is something that has been proven anything but incorrect over the past decades. Wouldn't want to pick a fight in any court with them, either. (Relevant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Nintendo)

Valve, though? Valve is worth little in comparison, and hasn't had a great history in court. Easy pickings. Then, after you win against Valve, you go up, using the precedent set to help you with the next target.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by gruez on Sunday December 29, 2019 @08:28PM (#21910004)
>It's easier to beat Valve's lawyers than Sony's. Sony has a long history of paying out the nose for lawyers who could convince a judge that a law saying "Kill no one" meant "Genocide is legal for Sony Corporation!" (See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Computer_Entertainment_Am...)

Is this supposed to be hyperbole? The case itself was never tried, so it that doesn't show anything about how effective sony's lawyers are.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by kick on Sunday December 29, 2019 @11:29PM (#21910816)
That was just one example of a case (I just picked it because it's close enough to Hacker News that most people here probably remember it), and notice that Sony got everything they asked for before the case was settled, including some incredibly unfair things (like the list of people who had legally downloaded the legally-created software of Hotz). The reason it was settled out of court was seemingly just so Hotz could avoid a felony.

There are plenty of other Sony cases that demonstrate the rule.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by twobat on Monday December 30, 2019 @01:09AM (#21911196)
People go on telling everybody about "legal" cracks because their lives are not affected.

If it meant hackers stole everything you own and worked for in your life so far you would think twice how legal this is.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by kick on Monday December 30, 2019 @04:41AM (#21912162)
A jailbreak isn't a crack, and the idea that it's a crack is ludicrous. iOS has had hundreds of jailbreaks. There's no financial incentive: it's just freeing a system.

Further, the idea that software piracy is stealing is also absurd, for an entirely different reason: copying is not stealing. Sony still had the original copies.

Beyond that: I already do release all of my source code under libre licenses. Copying isn't stealing, and I've lived my life as a testament to that.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by thatfrenchguy on Monday December 30, 2019 @05:09AM (#21912298)
iOS Jailbreaks are immensely valuable because they let you access the user’s data, hence why they’re literally sold for millions these days.
Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by kick on Monday December 30, 2019 @05:27AM (#21912374)
Hotz initially gave his for free to everyone, and I was referring to the ones that have been released for free, again to everyone. There were like five this year alone!

They aren't valuable by the metric he was measuring.

Obviously everyone knows what Apple and the various zero-day companies pay for them; no one here is stupid or unaware.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by pnako on Monday December 30, 2019 @05:33AM (#21912405)
Stealing is taking someone else's property without due permission. That applies to intellectual property, it doesn't have to be physical.

Now you can use the stupid libertarian argument that you're just "moving bits around" or "moving numbers around" (and math is not illegal). But do that do much and you'll find that society's answer is to move particles of lead in your general direction, at high velocity.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by kick on Monday December 30, 2019 @02:32PM (#21915978)
I'm not a libertarian at all, actually. Intellectual property is a reasonable idea, but it only makes sense when forced upon producers instead of consumers, and a lot of what people deem as intellectual property is in reality something that should have patents on it. Patents expire, copyright doesn't meaningfully.

Stealing is taking someone else's property without permission, as you said. However, copying doesn't take it away from them, and jailbreaking literally doesn't do anything but apply a patch to your existing bits. That's the farthest thing from stealing you could imagine, and your argument falls apart with just the tiniest bit of poking.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by FDSGSG on Sunday December 29, 2019 @11:58PM (#21910920)
>Sony got everything they asked for before the case was settled

Not much happened before the settlement, the parties settled very quickly after Hotz's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction failed. The TRO sucked, but wasn't particularly unreasonable.

>incredibly unfair things (like the list of people who had legally downloaded the legally-created software of Hotz).

Jurisdictional discovery is not incredibly unfair, and was only a natural consequence of Hotz's motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction.

>The reason it was settled out of court was seemingly just so Hotz could avoid a felony.

The fuck? This was a civil case.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by kick on Monday December 30, 2019 @12:13AM (#21910966)
The fuck? This was a civil case.

Computer fraud is a felony, and around that time the DoJ was getting very trigger-happy in turning civil cases criminal. Google the CFAA, which they were trying to pin Hotz under.

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by FDSGSG on Monday December 30, 2019 @08:28AM (#21913181)
> DoJ was getting very trigger-happy in turning civil cases criminal

Do you happen to have a single example of this?

Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by kick on Monday December 30, 2019 @02:32PM (#21915981)
Re:French court rules Steam games must be able to be resold by FDSGSG on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @03:20AM (#21919675)
I don't think there was ever a civil suit filed against Swartz. As far as I remember and according to the timeline on wikipedia this seems to have been a criminal case from the very beginning.

And in any case I don't think this is a great example of the DOJ being trigger-happy, what Swartz did was obviously criminal and they were still willing to let him off with only a slap on the wrist.