News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by kevindong on Sunday December 15, 2019 @01:49PM (#21798033)
I'm a big fan of the way JetBrains sells their licenses. Like a lot of software companies nowadays, they only sell licenses on a subscription basis. But with a very customer-friendly clause of where if you pay for a subscription for 12 months you get a perpetual license for the latest version of the product when you initially subscribed. And then after paying for any particular version of a product for 12 months, you also get a perpetual license for that particular version and so on and so forth.

Their FAQ page explains it a lot better than I can: https://sales.jetbrains.com/hc/en-gb/articles/207240845-What...

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by thijsvandien on Sunday December 15, 2019 @01:57PM (#21798100)
True; that's the only subscription model I find acceptable for software that hardly changes in meaningful ways. For example, I refuse to upgrade Git Tower to version 3 as a protest against fournova's new licensing. Up to that point, I was a loyal customer and product advocate, basically buying every upgrade anyway, but by my own choice. Instead, I'll be on version 2 "forever", despite all its flaws. It was even worse for Windows users, who bought licenses (on my advice, sometimes...) for a thing that realistically speaking never came out of beta. To have a usable product to begin with, they suddenly needed to pay for a subscription. There was zero response to my email explaining this, so there's that. Now I'm keeping my eyes open for alternatives.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by jakobegger on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:16PM (#21800153)
I also switched from Tower when they introduced subscription pricing.

My current git setup:

- Git Fork for committing, pushing

- P4 Merge for resolving conflicts (it's not a pretty app, but the fantastic feature set more than makes up for the non-native look)

- GitUp for reordering, editing and splitting commits

- Command line for the rare things the GUIs can't do

None of those cost money and I don't understand how these awesome apps are all free. I would pay for all of them, they are much better than Tower.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by aldanor on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:33AM (#21802562)
Emacs is free and in my opinion Magit is far, far superior to Tower / Fork / SourceTree (used them all on mac extensively at some point; out of those, fork is pretty nice and lightweight).

I'm not an emacs user but always install it (via spacemacs) everywhere solely to host Magit.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by jtms on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:09AM (#21802741)
The terminal is the best and only git client you need and it will always be free. You are doing yourself a disservice as a developer by not learning how to use your terminal
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by hderms on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:50AM (#21803899)
I'm not sure about that in the case of git. I used the terminal UI exclusively for a long time but it's so bizarrely designed that I've been interested in using a GUI for a while. There are a lot of reasons a dev should learn to use a terminal but making git more pleasant to use isn't necessarily one of them.

GUIs aren't super flexible but they are good at taking a common flow users go through and making it stupid simple to exercise. A lot of the usage of git should be stupid simple, with only infrequent need for complex interaction. Obviously there are some people out there for which a GUI will never be sufficient for their needs, but I'd argue it isn't the common case.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mkopinsky on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:00PM (#21809431)
I'm typically a heavy terminal user. Git is my exception. a) the UI of git cli is just so terrible that I'd rather fill my brain with more important things, and b) for viewing what's changed, `git diff` just doesn't cut it relative to a GUI.

Sourcetree is my go to git client, but if I couldn't use sourcetree I'd be OK with pretty much any git GUI. But git CLI is reserved for particularly tricky things that GUIs just can't handle well. (And I need to look up the specific flags or commands every single time.)

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by je42 on Monday December 16, 2019 @02:10AM (#21801303)
Cool ! Git fork looks quite like GitX (which is unfortunately not indevelopment anymore) !
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by eftokay83 on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:00AM (#21801990)
I'm a big Fork advocat and use it on a daily basis, but I fear they will charge for a new version at some point in the future.

I think that because it seems they founded a company "Fork" which inevitable will need to make money eventually.

edit: I'm of course willing to pay some bucks for great software if it's a fair pricing model.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by adar on Monday December 16, 2019 @01:46PM (#21805782)
Just yesterday I noticed a "Fork Activation" option in the Fork menu with fields for an email and a license key. I think you might be right, it won't be free for much longer.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by kossae on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @04:50PM (#21819303)
Yep, and the 'Buy Now' link leads to https://fork.dev/buy

Not subscription based!

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by eftokay83 on Friday December 20, 2019 @04:13AM (#21842710)
Seems like a fair price to me. Will propably buy it if the time comes.

Somehow I hesitate to pay subscription based models, although I understand why this model exists.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by csmiller on Sunday December 15, 2019 @10:22PM (#21800584)
I found P4 Merge to be totally inscrutable, could you elaborate on what makes it so good?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by jakobegger on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:51AM (#21801062)
It's a 3 way merge tool that works well with Fork. To be honest I can't say how it compares with other merge tools, I tried a few merge tools some time back and liked P4 best.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by acemarke on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:15AM (#21800957)
I suggest using SourceGear DiffMerge for resolving conflicts. Best 3-way merge conflict handling tool I've tried:

https://sourcegear.com/diffmerge/

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by luladjiev on Monday December 16, 2019 @07:41AM (#21802590)
Another suggestion is Beyond Compare, the 3 way merge is a pro feature though:

https://www.scootersoftware.com/

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by tenken on Monday December 16, 2019 @01:08AM (#21801110)
Better than Meld?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by akie on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:41PM (#21798440)
I am just replying to say that I have the exact same experience. I love Git Tower and recommended it to many people, but I haven't upgraded to version 3 and likely never will - for the exact reasons that you have lined out. I think FourNova (the company behind it) is probably missing out on quite some cash here...
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by kawsper on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:58PM (#21799572)
I'm in the same boat, and I would rather search and find an alternative when my version 2 no longer works, than to support them again.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by uptown on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:07AM (#21803485)
Tower became unusably slow for me. I switched to GitKraken and have been very pleased.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by Nextgrid on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:38PM (#21798430)
Check out Sublime Merge, from the creators of Sublime Text: https://www.sublimemerge.com
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by spectramax on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:05PM (#21799603)
I switched to Sublime Merge from using Git Tower (their licensing was awful after v3).

Never looking back, SM is amazing.

Git Tower folks: Stop pissing off your paying loyal users. Get a hint, I want my money back because you guys never made v2 properly stable and jumped on v3 for an awful cash grab. Fuck you, kindly.

Sublime HQ is an amazing company. I would pay for their products even if they charged double. Honesty and integrity matters. You’re not selling to normal sheep, programmers are a smart bunch.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by manigandham on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:23PM (#21799093)
There's also Fork: https://git-fork.com/
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by echelon on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:11PM (#21799335)
I'm really curious - why do people want a graphical git client? The command line exposes everything, and the model is simple and intuitive.

I work in a very large monorepo, so it's not like I'm working in a git tree that isn't complicated.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by andybak on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:40PM (#21799996)
> the model is simple and intuitive

I nearly spat out my drink. Git is many things but those aren't the first two words that would leap into my head.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by gdxhyrd on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:46PM (#21800243)
Git model is simple.

What is complex is the hundred features and commands it provides on top of that model.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by andybak on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:35PM (#21808765)
> Git model is simple.

I strongly disagree.

Let's list just basic git concepts that you're likely to encounter fairly early on: the working tree, staged commits, branches, remotes, stashes, detached heads, tags, submodules, merge conflicts, squashed commits, fast-forwards, rebasing, cherry-picking.

Some of these you could choose to ignore - rebasing and submodules - but on the whole you need at least a cursory understanding of everything on that list to get by without a git angel to get you out of trouble. I still have a person I phone when anything out of the ordinary happens and I've taught git to other people!

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by gdxhyrd on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:03PM (#21810123)
You are confusing the model with the features built on top of that model.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by deepaksurti on Sunday December 15, 2019 @10:01PM (#21800513)
Git is a great example of worse is better philosophy.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by okusername on Monday December 16, 2019 @03:47AM (#21801692)
Thats exactly wHat GUIs are good for. Make infrequenlty used features and options accessible.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by anticodon on Monday December 16, 2019 @04:25AM (#21801853)
But GUIs for git usually do not provide access to all the features. They implement a very small subset that is just as easy to use from cmdline.

I'm also genuinely surprised that people use GUI for git. For merge I understand, but for all other tasks cmdline is easier and faster.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by fwip on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:08PM (#21800124)
The model is relatively simple, but the UI is a disaster.

Which is exactly why people want better clients than the official git cli client.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by erklik on Sunday December 15, 2019 @09:11PM (#21800341)
I find that it has too many magic commands built-in so no-one really gets to learn the under-side of what's actually occuring so when it eventually breaks like everything does, you have no idea what you did wrong. An example would be how the git pull command is basically a bunch of different git fetch and merge commands.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by OJFord on Monday December 16, 2019 @03:45AM (#21801684)
Yes, but if it didn't exist people would say git's bad because everyone copies the same alias from StackOverflow, and it should just be built-in.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mehrdadn on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:19PM (#21800158)
Say you want to find a commit that occurred around June three years ago, and look at what the repo looked like after that commit -- without checking out any files. How do you currently do it?

For me, I just Right click -> TortoiseGit -> Show Log -> scroll -> Right-click -> Browse Repository.

How long does it take you? For me it takes < 10 seconds (I just timed myself).

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by tannakartikey on Sunday December 15, 2019 @09:29PM (#21800400)
Not against GUI or anything but just curious about doing it from CLI: git log | grep 'June 2017' (and remember the first 5 characters of hash) And then `got checkout <hash>`
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mehrdadn on Sunday December 15, 2019 @09:33PM (#21800407)
I think you missed the part that said "without checking out any files"?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by debaserab2 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @11:47PM (#21800872)
Why would checking out files matter? What exactly do you think the GUI is doing underneath the hood?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mehrdadn on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:01AM (#21800917)
Because it messes with your work tree. See here for a longer response: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21800524
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by gumby on Sunday December 15, 2019 @09:15PM (#21800350)
git log | grep -- find the hash of the one I want. or git log > file and look at it in an editor. no need to change the tools just for this unusual action.

I understand that YMMV -- de gustibus non disputandum est -- but I have ever understood the appeal of GUI tools especially for something like git. I do use magit, but even then I do most manipulation with the command line interface

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mehrdadn on Sunday December 15, 2019 @10:04PM (#21800524)
> git log | grep -- find the hash of the one I want.

This misses the point of the problem -- the point is you don't know precisely what string to grep for.

> or git log > file and look at it in an editor. no need to change the tools just for this unusual action.

I mean, nobody said this 1 reason should be enough to make you switch tools? I was just giving an example.

And no, it's not "unusual" just because you say so to try to dismiss the problem. I know I use Browse Repository as well as the GUI logs pretty frequently, and they're godsends compared to your solution.

And lastly: this is what your solution actually looks like:

1. Dump the entire log output into a temporary file

2. Open that temp file in your editor

3. Look through the commit messages/dates/names

4. Realize that's not quite enough to narrow down your search to a single commit (maybe you want to see the diffs or file paths or something else?)

5. Try to figure out which flags you should to pass to git log to dump all the info you need

6. Call git log again, hopefully now it dumps all the info you need

7. Open the temp file again in your editor

8. Scroll through your file containing diffs/names/whatever extra info you dumped

9. Type 'git checkout COMMIT -- file/path' once you find something

10. (Hopefully,) before you press Enter, realize you're about to trash your current copy of the file, which had some other changes

11a. Run git stash, and now suddenly messing up your staging area that you'd carefully staged changes in, and also messing up the file metadata (e.g. Make will now rebuild everything...), OR

11b. Figure out how to run git checkout-index -a -f --prefix=/destination/path/ so that you check the file out into a different directory.

12. Once you have a copy of that file, look through it, maybe examine/pull out the code you wanted (or whatever)

13. Remove the temporary file you checked out.

14. Remove the temporary file in your editor.

15. git stash pop.

And somehow you always do all the above without making a mistake, otherwise have fun reverting or recovering lost data.

With a GUI log TortoiseGit's log, you literally:

1. Click on a commit with the date you're interested in

2. Select Browse Repository

3. Double-click each file you want to examine to see the diff

4. If it's not the file you want, press Escape and click again.

Not only is the number of steps smaller, each one is also significantly faster, and less risky too. No need to mess with a single temporary file, fire up your editor manually, or risk losing anything.

Anyway, again: this was just 1 example meant to get the idea across, hopefully with the aid of your imagination to extrapolate to other scenarios. But if you're going to trash this all with "this never comes up" I don't really have the energy or interest to keep bringing up examples or try to convince anyone; you should just keep using the CLI.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by debaserab2 on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:14AM (#21800951)
I don't think a lot of the steps listed in your first example are as painful as you make them about to be. Most of those steps are just as elementary as clicking a button in a GUI to someone with fluency on the CLI. I also doubt the claims that it's that much faster for someone with a lot of experience doing it.

Perhaps you could be faster with the GUI than on the CLI, but learning a GUI doesn't come with zero overhead: you have to understand it's terminology, how it's configuration works, what its icons and symbols mean. Particularly when it comes to VCS management, GUI's like to simplify sometimes complicated or nuanced VCS behavior and you can't really be sure what is being done to your repo until you've pressed the button and done it. Not to mention you are now investing time learning a program that can be abandoned at any time and leave you without the basic knowledge necessary to manage your repo (not saying this would affect you this way, but it could certainly be a reason to not learn it in the first place).

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mehrdadn on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:49AM (#21801058)
> I don't think a lot of the steps listed in your first example are as painful as you make them about to be. Most of those steps are just as elementary as clicking a button in a GUI to someone with fluency on the CLI. I also doubt the claims that it's that much faster for someone with a lot of experience doing it.

I mean, it's not like you can ever convince me that >10 keystrokes are as fast as 1 click, but regardless, this is easy enough to settle -- just time yourself and let me know how long the steps take you on the CLI.

> Perhaps you could be faster with the GUI than on the CLI

Hence the point!

> but learning a GUI doesn't come with zero overhead:

I don't think anybody claimed this either, so it's fine.

> you have to understand it's terminology, how it's configuration works, what its icons and symbols mean.

It sounds like you haven't used TortoiseGit... at all? How often have you had to look at its manual? How many times have you had to look at the manual of git itself? Honestly, your own reply is warranted here so many times more than it was to me -- "I don't think a lot of the steps are as painful as you make them about to be."

In fact so many of the commands are so obviously self-explanatory (both in text and in icons) that you literally never need to look them up. Stuff that you would never just guess how to do in git itself. Like when you right-click a file in a commit and click "Save revision to...", which also has a floppy next to it. Is it really such a mystery what it does? Is it even remotely comparable to figuring out checkout-index (or whatever the right command is)?

And honestly: it's such a poor attempt at an argument to suggest that the minor ramp-up time of TortoiseGit is somehow not worth the perpetual git pains it saves you from that I don't even know what to say.

> Particularly when it comes to VCS management, GUI's like to simplify sometimes complicated or nuanced VCS behavior and you can't really be sure what is being done to your repo until you've pressed the button and done it.

First, this is such an unnecessary strawman. If you're so worried what some GUI command does, then just use the CLI for it instead.

Second, this is completely irrelevant for read-only operations (like log, Browse Repository, etc.) which were the ones concerned here.

And third... again, it sounds like you're only saying this because you haven't used TortoiseGit, because (shockingly enough, to someone coming from the git CLI) it's not a minefield; in fact it has a number of safeguards. "Commit" creates a commit, "Revert" reverts your changes, "Checkout" checks out a commit, etc... and in fact fails if your tree is dirty, so you don't lose data. Heck, sometimes the git commands it prints end up being more correct than what you'd type on the command line. I know I've learned a fair number of random git features from TortoiseGit.

> Not to mention you are now investing time learning a program that can be abandoned at any time and leave you without the basic knowledge necessary to manage your repo

Again, nobody said you shouldn't learn the CLI. In fact, I'll say it right here: you should definitely learn the CLI, especially for git, before moving to the GUI, or you will be confused (though even then, you'd probably be less confused than you would be if you started with the CLI itself).

> (not saying this would affect you this way, but it could certainly be a reason to not learn it in the first place).

No, it's most definitely not a reason not to learn it.The discussion was never about what you learn in the first place, but what you use. You should learn the command-line regardless. And even regarding usage, it's again a strawman: nobody even suggested you should never use the CLI. The question was "why do people want a graphical git client?" and the answer was "because it makes {tasks} easier", for some tasks. If you find any tasks that don't fall in that category, just use the CLI. It's just a tool after all, not a religion.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by gumby on Monday December 16, 2019 @04:06PM (#21807190)
> I mean, it's not like you can ever convince me that >10 keystrokes are as fast as 1 click,

I know your reply was to debasarab2 and my upstream comment did say YMMV, but in fact it is a lot faster for me (and likely debasarab2) to type 10 characters than click an icon. My working mode is simply different. We’re not saying you’re wrong, what we’re saying is it’s not universal.

If I Haase to click a button I have to move a hand off the keyboard, shift my gaze, find the mouse pointer, move it, then BT my hand back to the keyboard.

Whereas on a command line I always know where my keystrokes go, I never have to move my hands or look away from the screen, and I have >40 years of typing at computers wired into my basal ganglia. (This is despite the fact that the first computer I used, a CADR lisp machine, had a mouse and bitmap display). GUI interfaces are simply much slower for me, except in very unusual applications. I am not claiming it to be universal but it is clear the affordances of the command line are significantly lower-friction for people accustomed to them.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mehrdadn on Monday December 16, 2019 @04:12PM (#21807247)
My hands are on the keyboard most of the time too, I'm not a particularly slow typer, and there's no way I could write a proper git checkout-index command at the speed of just a click or two.

But again: I will believe you if you measure it and report back. So far the only person who's measured anything has been me, and I have to wonder why others are so averse to it.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by debaserab2 on Monday December 16, 2019 @01:42AM (#21801215)
Yeah, if you consider my arguments to be strawmen, then using a VCS GUI for the narrow use case of tracking down diffs might save you a solid few minutes. That just feels like a drop in the bucket compared to the overall time spent developing. YMMV I guess, depending on what organization/codebase you are working on.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by lllr_finger on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:15AM (#21803568)
Probably just GitHub (the browser UI). If you want to do it offline or from the command line, I understand why you might hesitate want to check out files, but stashing in git is extremely easy.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by gdxhyrd on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:47PM (#21800249)
git log, copy paste hash, git checkout

If you have a dirty wd, stash.

But, to be honest, I almost never perform that action, and when I do I use the web browser.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mehrdadn on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:50PM (#21800260)
> git log, copy paste hash, git checkout

You remember the hash of your June commit 3 years ago??

> But, to be honest, I almost never perform that action, and when I do I use the web browser.

Web browser... for a local repo? Or do you mean you don't have a solution if your repo isn't on GitHub or you don't have an internet connection handy?

(You should also time yourself on your web interface by the way.)

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by gdxhyrd on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:01PM (#21810117)
> You remember the hash of your June commit 3 years ago??

...which is what the git log above is there for.

> Web browser... for a local repo? Or do you mean you don't have a solution if your repo isn't on GitHub or you don't have an internet connection handy?

Yeah, local repo. You know, git is not GitHub. :)

> (You should also time yourself on your web interface by the way.)

Just paste the hash commit in the HEAD selector or even in the URL.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by manigandham on Sunday December 15, 2019 @09:18PM (#21800367)
> "when I do I use the web browser"

So a graphical interface then? I'm sure you can see why using a GUI for other functions is just as useful.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by cwojno on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:12PM (#21799637)
Try doing a merge with IntelliJ's 3-way merge UI. It's flippin' fantastic compared to roaming through the files and removing sections between >>>> and <<<<.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by philwelch on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:17PM (#21799907)
Command-line git allows you to specify a mergetool, many of which are capable of three way merges.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by cwojno on Monday December 16, 2019 @02:24AM (#21801337)
The point was convenience. I don't have to leave the IDE.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by chiefsucker on Monday December 16, 2019 @01:45PM (#21805773)
For some people Unix is the IDE.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by manigandham on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:27PM (#21799406)
Many people are visual. It's a lot easier to see changes, compare diffs, and generally follow the development branches through a GUI instead of through a command line.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by danielbarla on Monday December 16, 2019 @02:23AM (#21801333)
I think the main advantage of GUIs in general is a contextual, curated explorability that is often lacking in CLI tools. The GUI is stateful, allows the user to click on things and prod it, and hopefully shows the most frequently used features for that context. This allows even complete newbies to be productive almost immediately.

For something like git, the slightly more visual representation is a benefit to many, too.

I'm not here to knock CLIs, there are a set of tradeoffs to be made, and CLIs win in many cases (flexibility, scriptability, being able to copy snippets you frequently use, etc). The above does tend to hold true, however.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by dabeeeenster on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:53PM (#21799544)
Git is famous for being unintuitive?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by OJFord on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:29PM (#21799704)
Infamous, and a more accurate description might be that discussions about git are well-known for quickly descending into discussions about whether or not it's intuitive and whether or not that matters since you use it every day you'll soon get it and no longer care that much how intuitive it is anyway.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by aclsid on Sunday December 15, 2019 @09:16PM (#21800359)
Just give thanks that you did not have to work with the likes of CVS and such.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by muzani on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:06PM (#21799855)
One of the advantages is you can easily explore what changes were made and merge conflicts through the tool.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by chrisseaton on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:34PM (#21799975)
I like to drag and drop commits into an order I want when doing an interactive rebase.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by gdxhyrd on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:51PM (#21800261)
That's easy with the TUI
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by chrisseaton on Monday December 16, 2019 @04:54AM (#21801968)
Dragging and dropping? Or do I have to rearrange the lines using a text editor?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by gdxhyrd on Thursday December 19, 2019 @04:52AM (#21833444)
Rearranging a line is 3 keystrokes in vim, which I use for that particular action, since it is perfect for that, rather than my normal GUI IDE.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by hota_mazi on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:34AM (#21801014)
I wonder the opposite thing: why do people try to use git in a terminal?

Its output is so rich and complex that it's impossible to make it legible outside of a real GUI, with graphics and colors.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mandeepj on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:25PM (#21799399)
for a new person, it's almost impossible to get anything done with git command line
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by OJFord on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:32PM (#21799716)
You could say that about any tool, of course you have to spend some time to understand how to use it safely and effectively.

'for a new person, it's almost impossible to get anything done with a table saw'

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by jstrong on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:00PM (#21800083)
do people say, "a table saw is simple and intuitive"?
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by OJFord on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @09:43AM (#21813868)
Well on the face of it, it's a simple tool isn't it? It's a spinning saw blade, and surface(s) against which to rest the wood being cut.

And I've never used one, but I'm sure it takes some learning, skill, and practice to get good cuts the way you need them, e.g. bang on 45deg all the way across for a 'mitred' corner joint. And it certainly needs learning, care, and attention to operate safely.

I don't mean it to be an insensitive analogy - accidents involving table saws are obviously horrendously worse than those involving git.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by throwawaymath on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:45PM (#21800239)
I haven't heard anyone say that, but after thinking about it for a second I sure as hell would. A table saw is a lot easier to use than git.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by amerine on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:09PM (#21799867)
I think most folks like a graphical merge tool, such as opendiff, or at least that's what I've been able to glean.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by kelsolaar on Monday December 16, 2019 @03:57AM (#21801734)
I work on a lot of repositories, having a GUI makes it really easy to change context and getting up-to-speed quickly.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by randomidiot666 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:50PM (#21799799)
As someone else mentioned here, the graphical merge tool in IDEA is extremely powerful. Plus keyboard shortcuts to all the main Git actions. It's overall more efficient. However I always use Git IDEA + Git CLI side by side.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by snypox on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:36PM (#21799731)
Switched to Fork from SourceTree, never looked back.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by tobidobi on Monday December 16, 2019 @04:15AM (#21801805)
Thanks for your thoughts on this, Thijs! Here's Tobias, the CEO of Tower.

We want to make sure that Tower can stay a high-quality application in the long run. This means we want to constantly improve the application, add new features, fix bugs, and help users with great customer support. To be able to do that, we need a steady and reliable source of income. The thruth is: for us - a small, self-funded business - a recurring revenue model from a subscription is the only sustainable way to survive.

A model where the user gets to keep the last version after she stops paying for the product does not work for a small business. If you have a team of 1,000 employees like JetBrains, you might be be able to afford this. But not a 7-person team like ours. For two reasons:

(1) First, it doesn't provide the steady and reliable source of income that we depend on. It's the old one-time payment model of the past - which we tried and which did not pay the bills for us in the long term.

(2) Second, and maybe more importantly: very quickly, there are lots of different old versions of the product out there. People want bugfixes, documentation and support for their version, no matter if they're currently paying or if they don't anymore. With a 7-person team, we simply cannot do this. We need to focus all of our painfully limited time on _one_ version and make sure to improve that one.

Most of our users make a simple calculation: "Can Tower help me or my team save some time or prevent some mistakes?" Over the course of the next 12 (!) months, even 1 or 2 hours or a mere handful of mistakes would make this worthwhile. If so, Tower has _easily_ paid itself off.

We offer a free and fully-featured 30-day trial that will help you answer this question for yourself - without any risks or commitments.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by HelloNurse on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:29AM (#21802109)
For the customer, automatically converting long subscriptions to perpetual licenses for an old version is a major safety net (the software will not stop working if I stop paying) and it proves that the vendor is committed to improving the product enough to make upgrades compelling.

On the other hand, reasonable customers do not expect support beyond the latest version and whatever they are currently paying for: "we have fixed that in the latest version, which you should buy" is a valid and honest answer to support issues.

For a tool that can be changed with very little friction like a revision control client, the typical "calculation" about spending money is likely to be waiting for an actual troublesome situation and then get out of it with a short subscription or a 30-day trial.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by krageon on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:39AM (#21802358)
To summarise, you say you're not offering perpetual licenses for old paid-for versions because you don't feel you can make clear to your customers they don't come with support.

For some reason you do expect you can sell them on this new payment model that benefits mostly you, so it's really not your communicative skills or your customers' capacity to learn that are the problem here. That really only leaves us with the financial advantage to you.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by emmanuel_1234 on Monday December 16, 2019 @06:23AM (#21802294)
There are many comments complaining about exactly that product, you probably ought to spend a bit more time on that thread.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by Stratoscope on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:25PM (#21798335)
Try SmartGit. I don't know how it compares with Tower, but it is very powerful and easy to use. I like the way it integrates Git features into a consistent view. For example, stashes and reflog commits can be viewed and manipulated in the same log view as any other commits.

They offer both purchase and subscription models, and a free license for open source work. Runs on Mac, Windows and Linux. I've been using it for years and have always been very pleased.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by bjornjaja on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:45PM (#21799773)
Also take a look at Git Extensions. I like this product a lot. It’s open source
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by keithnz on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:54AM (#21801074)
I switched from smartgit to fork. Fork is really nice to use and very keyboard driven. Also free.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by brianpan on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:25PM (#21799935)
FYI, Git Tower is made by JetBrains is made by 7 people. JetBrains is a company of 1000. Not all software scales to allow that kind of model.

Also, JetBrains can afford that model because the JDK and other software languages are changing and it's not very feasible for their users to stay on an old version for very long.

https://www.fournova.com/company

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JetBrains

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by optimiz3 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:15PM (#21798249)
Same here for Adobe Creative Suite; still on version 6 (perpetual license), which I run in a Virtual Machine due to support end-of-life.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by prox on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:16PM (#21799654)
Switched to Affinity, Photo, Designer and Publisher are pretty awesome and a true replacement for Photoshop, Illustrator and InDesign. Switched 1.5 years ago, never looked back and saved a lot of money in the process. There are a few things it doesn’t have, but its impressive nonetheless. The devs are very committed to speed and anti bloat.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by dangoor on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:50PM (#21798505)
FWIW, I think Adobe actually adds quite a bit to Creative Cloud every year, plus they offer fonts and connections with their mobile apps and such as part of the same price. Creative Cloud today is a very different beast from CS6.

(obdisclaimer: I worked for Adobe several years ago, but have no current stake other than being on the CC photography plan)

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by wlesieutre on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:00PM (#21799269)
Same boat here. I’ll concede that they do add things, but as a pretty small scale hobbyist they don’t add anything I want or need. But they expect me to pay the same full price as a pro user.

I used to buy it every couple of versions or when it went on sale, and that was good enough for my needs. No such luck anymore.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by dangoor on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:02PM (#21799285)
Depending on what you do use, Mac users actually have lots of great choices now. The Affinity apps, for example, are terrific.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by wlesieutre on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:08PM (#21799319)
I’ve got them!

Did a stint on Sketch as well. It’s now gone subscription, but it think it’s the more acceptable “still works but you stops getting updates” type subscription like jetbrains.

What I really want is an Affinity photo library manager like Lightroom. I’ve looked at some currently available options and not been impressed, but there were tweets to the effect that Affinity was thinking about it.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by prox on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:18PM (#21799661)
I believe its the current objective to produce a lightroom alternative.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by wlesieutre on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:57PM (#21800277)
Best I’ve found is “considering it,” but fingers crossed! Seems like the next obvious step after vector illustration, photo editing, and desktop publishing
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by matwood on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:00PM (#21798571)
And I think all the plans come with cloud storage which syncs across devices.

I fought the subscription plan for LR, but realized I usually updated yearly and had this complicated file management system for my photos. For $120/year I have the latest LR versions on all my devices and only have to worry about true backup.

I do keep an eye out for a LR replacement, but I haven't found anything that comes close to LRs file management.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by dd36 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:18PM (#21798272)
Intuit Quickooks is same way. Hasn’t substantively changed in 20 years but they stop you from importing new data if you don’t update to latest every 3 years. They need some real competition.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by takeda on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:45PM (#21800020)
Switched to GnuCash and didn't look back. The UI is uglier, but at least it works correctly with double entry bookkeeping.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by projektfu on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:00PM (#21799576)
There’s Sage 50 if you want desktop, but even desktop QB is on life support and everyone’s going online.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by toasterlovin on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:42PM (#21798848)
> They need some real competition.

Have you tried Xero? I haven’t, but if you have, I’d be curious to hear your take on it.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by keithnz on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:56AM (#21801079)
We run our company on Xero, it's pretty good!
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by redgc on Sunday December 15, 2019 @11:37PM (#21800837)
I upgraded to version 3 but feel like they haven't made a product improvement since, despite the new subscription model. Staging of chunks still remains the killer feature to keep me with it but I'd be happy to switch (pay) if anything else came along.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by kalev on Monday December 16, 2019 @01:52AM (#21801248)
It’s interesting to see quite a few others in here had the same struggle with upgrading to tower 3 as I had a year (or 2?) ago. Then I moved to vscode with it’s git integration and that works just as good.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by hota_mazi on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:32AM (#21801008)
I switched from SourceTree to Fork, which is awesome for me. Check it out.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by lol768 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @01:50PM (#21798040)
>But with a very customer-friendly clause of where if you pay for a subscription for 12 months you get a perpetual license for the latest version of the product when you initially subscribed. And then after paying for any particular version of a product for 12 months, you also get a perpetual license for that particular version and so on and so forth

This came about due to a decent amount of consumer backlash, if I recall correctly. They used to sell standalone perpetual licenses which included a period of updates.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by Lazare on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:16PM (#21799900)
When you say it like that, it doesn't sound amazing, but you can also phrase it as:

"JetBrains listened to their customers, took feedback on board, and made meaningful changes that addressed the concerns."

In a perfect world, that would the minimum expected behaviour, but in the world we live in, it's kind of surprising when it happens.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by Nullabillity on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:39PM (#21800218)
Or.. JetBrains went ahead with a disliked move, then took a half-step back. There's still a half-step in the wrong direction remaining, on top of showing that they would have been willing to go the whole way if they could have gotten away with it.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by gmiller123456 on Monday December 16, 2019 @02:38PM (#21806337)
"JetBrains listened to their customers..."

Yes, you can make something sound positive when you leave out material facts. They knew an expiring license would be much less popular than a non-expiring one before they did it. So, just saying they listened to their customers leaves out the very important detail that they ignored their customers the first time around.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by antpol on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:49AM (#21801056)
You can frame it whatever you want. Fact is, if not the pushback JetBrains would be worse than Adobe
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by monksy on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:47AM (#21801051)
It wasn't amazing. There was a lot of unneccessary effort to change their mind.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by georgemcbay on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:18PM (#21798275)
Still commendable given how common it is these days for companies to get consumer backlash and just continue to do the same thing while comically trying to publicly convince the customer base that the new model is somehow better for them when any rational person can see it isn't.

Also useful as a guide to show the customer they should go ahead and voice their displeasure when these situations arise, preferably before the product is so entrenched in the given market that they can "pull an Adobe" in this situation ("Don't like the new terms? Fuck you, pay us").

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by lol768 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:44PM (#21800016)
Oh, absolutely. I think they handled this particular change quite gracefully. It's a compromise.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by sireat on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:34PM (#21799147)
A huge part of the backslash actually happened here on HN when they originally proposed the pure (like Adobe and 90% of other companies) SaaS model.

  So Jetbrains model is an improvement over most other companies but it is not as consumer friendly as the old licensing model.

  I would love to have the old model back(buy now with 12 months of updates) but that ship has sailed.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by snuxoll on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:51PM (#21799804)
Sure, it came about due to backlash - but they still listened to their customer base and made changes, quite publicly admitting they had pushed the subscription model too far.

Honestly I’m quite happy with it as a compromise, especially with the All Products Pack - I save money every year than when I used to buy upgrades for IntelliJ and ReSharper stand-alone, and JetBrains has incentive to keep pumping out new features to keep me from deciding to utilize my fallback license.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by srcmap on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:19PM (#21798290)
Google must play InteliJ for the Android Studio License use, right?

I wonder how big is that part of the revenue.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by enitihas on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:59PM (#21798559)
I think android studio uses the community (open source) version of IntelliJ Idea, so it should not be a big part of Jetbrains revenue.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mongol on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:58PM (#21798557)
Given that Kotlin now also is first class development language for Android, I think Jetbrains gets plenty of revenue from Android
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by enitihas on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:09PM (#21798645)
I don't think Jetbrains gets any money directly by the usage of Kotlin on Android, as Kotlin too is open source, and works very well in IntelliJ Community (also open-source). In fact, I don't think IntelliJ ultimate has any extra Kotlin features.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by snuxoll on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:55PM (#21799820)
No, but IntelliJ ultimate has more features than Android Studio given there are JetBrains developed plugins that aren’t available in the CE platform.

Guice support, for example. You can live without it, but if you are working on a larger Android codebase and utilize it then it may be useful.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by enitihas on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:14PM (#21799890)
IntelliJ Ultimate has a lot of extra features, yes, but I don't recall any of them being related to Kotlin, or Android, so I don't think the parent comment claiming kotlin usage will result in extra revenue is relevant.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by dcow on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:20PM (#21799074)
Regardless, I’m sure they are getting money.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by ScottBurson on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:22PM (#21798720)
> They used to sell standalone perpetual licenses which included a period of updates.

I'm missing something. What's the difference between that and what they're doing now? You pay $X, you get a perpetual licence and updates for a limited period.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mthoms on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:08PM (#21799324)
Your perpetual license is for the oldest version available during your subscription period, not the newest.

Old model: Pay $X.XX and get one year of updates.

New model: Pay $X.XX (spread over 12 months) and you can use all new versions UNTIL the subscription ends. At which point, unless you renew, you have to DOWNGRADE to the one year old version.

Let's face it, downgrading such an import tool is not something developers will be comfortable with (especially since JB products occasionally have show-stopping bugs).

Having said that, I'll admit to liking their products (and support). But the model is not as generous as everyone seems to think.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by innocenat on Monday December 16, 2019 @03:22AM (#21801565)
IIRC, the price of 2 year subscription is still cheaper than the 1-year update of the old model. They even offered subscription discount when they were transitioning, so the out-of-pocket is still cheaper than the old model.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by rtpg on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:54PM (#21800057)
So that was the original plan but I believe they changed to the “more reasonable” one after the backlash (so you get the current version + 1 year of updates)
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by Nullabillity on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:41PM (#21800224)
The original plan was that you'd lose access completely. The "more reasonable" one was the 1yr downgrade.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by lol768 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:12PM (#21799020)
In addition to what michaf mentioned, what we have now is not what they originally proposed.

https://blog.jetbrains.com/blog/2015/09/18/final-update-on-t... - the perpetual license fallback did not exist under the original proposals and only happened due to backlash.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mynameisvlad on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:02PM (#21799841)
Why does this matter? Yes, their original plan was pure SaaS. But they listened to criticism and changed it once they realized that there was backlash from the community. If anything, that should be admired not criticized.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by lol768 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:43PM (#21800011)
> Why does this matter? Yes, their original plan was pure SaaS. But they listened to criticism and changed it once they realized that there was backlash from the community. If anything, that should be admired not criticized.

It's useful context. Yes, it's good that they listened to their customer base - and I've not criticised the current subscription model.

But I still think it's relevant and on-topic to point out that the previous model was more generous and they tried to do full-SaaS when reading the parent comment in isolation sort of suggests they did this out of the goodness of their hearts (and entirely unprompted).

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by antpol on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:53AM (#21801069)
It's matter, because even in this thread you have people prizing jetbrains for beign better than Adobe SaaS, but in reality jetbrains would go even futher than any big predatory corporation out there to vendor lock you into their set of tools.

If you have an option, stick with open tools with strong community support. Just observation: with commercial tools you don't have full control of your own work, nuff said

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by michaf on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:37PM (#21798813)
Now the perpetual licensed version always lags 12 months behind in updates, i.e. you do not have a perpetual license for the past 12 months worth of updates at the time your subscription runs out.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mthoms on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:57PM (#21799258)
This is incorrect. Lots of people believe this but it just isn't true.

When your one-year subscription expires you actually have a perpetual license for the first version that was available when you signed up. NOT for the last one available when the contract ended.

In other words, when your one year subscription is up, you have to downgrade to a one year-old (possibly buggy) version.

For more mature toolchains like C or Java, this seems reasonable. For ones that undergo massive updates each version (WebStorm, AppCode) it's a non-starter.

EDIT: on second read, this may have been what the parent poster was trying to say. I'm leaving this comment as-is though because there seems to be a TON of confusion about this point.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by RussianCow on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:14PM (#21799350)
The OP said:

> you get a perpetual license for the latest version of the product when you initially subscribed

Which is correct, and is the same thing you described.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mthoms on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:31PM (#21799426)
On second read, you might be right so I amended my comment... In my defense, OP's comment is ambiguously worded. What you actually get is a permanent license to the oldest release available during your subscription. OP also says:

>... after paying for any particular version of a product for 12 months, you also get a perpetual license for that particular version and so on and so forth."

Also kind of unclear. And judging by the comments here, many many people misunderstand this. I think it's a general expectation that you'd get access to most up-to-date version of the product when your subscription ends. Not the version from the day your subscription started.

Think about it. If there's a bad bug or regression in the old "perpetual" version you aren't entitled to the subsequent bug fixes. Bug fixes which you've been "using" for the past year. It's kind of a hard thing to swallow.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by prox on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:20PM (#21799670)
You get the latest version you subbed to. So if you subbed last in 2018, you get that version. If resubbing j. 2019, the 2019 version. Also every year the price goes down, so you pay less and less.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mthoms on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:08PM (#21799862)
That's misleading. Each year has multiple point releases. You don't get the latest point release.

My PHPStorm subscription expires in less than a week. In order to continue using it (without re-subbing), I have to downgrade from 2019.3 (current release) to 2018.3 (the release available on the date I subbed). Software that is one year old.

Similarly, the JetBrains site says my WebStorm subscription expires in around 10 months. At which point I have to downgrade to 2019.2 if I don't re-sub. Today's current version is 2019.3.

>Also every year the price goes down, so you pay less and less

That part is true and it's certainly commendable that they do that.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by osmianski on Monday December 16, 2019 @05:10AM (#21802019)
I recently renewed my PHPStorm subscription (again). Not because there are hot features released in the past year which I'd miss.

Rather, I thing it is right thing to do - to pay some recurring cost for the software we use and to let the developers of that software to make their buck.

We are too accustomed to get everything for free at the expense of someone else.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by jakobegger on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:20PM (#21800161)
> For ones that undergo massive updates each version (WebStorm, AppCode) it's a non-starter

At least you should still be able to open up old projects.

If you use Adobe Creative Cloud, and you stop paying, do you lose access to all your data?

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by aclsid on Sunday December 15, 2019 @09:50PM (#21800455)
Plus in all honesty, lots of Adobe software behaves like a virus by installing these always running updaters. I haven't had Flash in my laptop for sometime and the web has evolved to a point that it was never an issue, but the CC updater ended up saying I needed to install the latest update to Flash.

I have already tried Pixelmator and the Affinity suite, but after that shady behavior plus the monthly fee, I ended up uninstalling anything Adobe based and just switched completely to Affinity Design and Photo. The only thing I'm missing is when somebody sends me an .ai file in a certain format, but if they export with SVG or with PDF support, zero issues there.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by NeedMoreTea on Sunday December 15, 2019 @10:02PM (#21800515)
I'm amazed you think that way. It's a huge step down, and incredibly customer hostile. I stopped giving JetBrains money when they switched. If there's no perpetual licence, I'm not buying.

In the old world, you bought the latest version, got upgrades for a year - sometimes more, then got a discount on upgrading come a newer version. At any time you stopped paying you kept the latest software, in sync with everyone else. You'd slowly move out of step.

In JetBrain's fabulous con you pay a sub for the latest, and if you decide to stop paying - almost certainly having paid markedly more during the duration of your sub than under the old model - you get shunted to an older version, instantly putting you at least a year out of step with everyone else.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by sytelus on Monday December 16, 2019 @03:08AM (#21801503)
This is a terrible terrible business model despite good intentions. Let me explain... Vast majority of developers who can pay are living in corporate world where you need to approve expenses each time charge is made. Subscription model is especially bad in that world because PO approvals for subscriptions are usually very hard, at least requiring additional justifications + process barriers. Most folks would just rather not do it or find alternatives. I've seen this first hand even when folks are very fond of product.

A far better licencing model is to have one time charge and free upgrades for a year followed by nagging that can be turned off. This would have exact same effect but much easier to have purchase orders pass throughs in big company rule books.

JetBrains have far more potential than $270M. One of the easiest thing they can do is to allow users in same companies to form user groups on their website. They can then approach those companies to buy site licenses with list of all these supportive users at those companies. They can then evangelize to users within same companies who are not yet using their products. This would make sure their subscription churn is lowered due to individual developers.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by kevingadd on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:08PM (#21798640)
I understand the business reason for the licensing model so I don't really hold it against them, but after a couple years of 'Oh, you want fixes for these bugs we introduced recently? You'll have to buy another 12 months' where they constantly kept breaking new things when landing important fixes, I got fed up with the treadmill and just stopped using their products (in my case, ReSharper and dotTrace). I'd get problems like "having ReSharper for C# installed breaks VC++ compiles" (yes, really) and very often they'd just close the bugs outright or tell me the fix was only in the upcoming paid version with its own new bugs.

I feel like this is the downside to the subscription license model - if you want to use the product at all you have to keep paying unless the version you've currently got is somehow perfect. And in the case of JetBrains products I've used, it is not. I wish companies like this offered something like an LTS branch where I could pay (subscription even!) for a version that just actually works instead of constantly having to put up with new features/bugs just to get fixes for workflow issues.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mthoms on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:13PM (#21799343)
That's my experience also. It's like their model almost incentivizes them to introduce regressions.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by ghaff on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:42PM (#21798845)
Honestly, I don't really have a problem with subscriptions generally if it's a product that I use regularly. (Modulo "reasonable" pricing of course.) Where I have an issue is when I need a product I rarely use any longer to open an existing file or do some once in a blue moon task.

At some point, software stops working with OS upgrades etc. anyway and I can deal with that. But I don't want to pay a subscription for something I use a couple times of year and don't need the latest version of.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by modernerd on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:38PM (#21798820)
You also get loyalty discounts on your subscription!

After year three even their "everything" licence feels affordable for a working dev. (€649 for the first year, €389 by year three: https://www.jetbrains.com/store/#commercial?billing=yearly )

I wish more companies did this.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by Macha on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:09PM (#21799628)
Their "everything" commercial license is €249 for y1, €199 for y2 and €149 for y3+ as an individual: https://www.jetbrains.com/store/#personal?billing=yearly

The organizational license is only needed if your employer is paying for you or compensating you for the license cost: https://sales.jetbrains.com/hc/en-gb/articles/207241075-What...

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by Aeolun on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:17PM (#21799905)
Considering the hassle involved in switching employers, then licenses, I’d much rather just use my personal license anyway.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by SOLAR_FIELDS on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:38PM (#21799165)
If I remember correctly when they first announced they were moving to a subscription based model a few years ago years ago there was a backlash from customers and they listened to customer complaints and modified the model to be what it is today. Another plus to them in my book for doing that.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by meraku on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:35PM (#21798801)
Same here. I wish everyone company with a subscription based licensing model did it this way. It should be noted though, when Jetbrains initially decided to move to this type of licensing, it was a bit different and they got a lot of backlash from existing users (including myself), but credit to them for listening and amending it to something better for customers.

I've been a happy customer and Resharper user for many years and it makes my life much better, so it's great to see the company doing well.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by ljm on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:09PM (#21800128)
Totally agree. I thought Adobe's offer would be just as good until I cancelled early and got bit in the arse. I basically paid more money to cancel than what I would have paid if I left the sub open, and of course I lost access once I did cancel. Total asshole design there.

I go back to JetBrains and now I basically have to use their IDE because my company does, and it's not very easy to get the same kind of experience with Java with Vim or Emacs.

I'm using CLion to help me learn C++ because it knows C++ better than I do (and on a Mac I'm not using Xcode for writing C++, only building it). For £10-£20 a month, that is discounted every 12 months, with full ownership of the last version you had... it's great. They seem to handle it a lot better than Sketch as well, who will force you to find the download page for old versions. IntelliJ just seems to give you what your license allows.

I'd still go back to emacs in a pinch but I'm not proficient enough with C++ or Java and those ecosystems to know how to set my environment up.

JetBrains seem to have a pretty fair and solid strategy and it must be doing well enough for them to expand their IDE-base so far.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by albertshin on Monday December 16, 2019 @01:59AM (#21801268)
I'm curious about the counterfactual here. If they had a VC on their board, they may have been "gently guided" towards a pure subscription model since SaaS valuations are much higher.

But, it sounds like a pure switch to SaaS would have alienated customers and perhaps would have forced more users to seek alternatives, and we might not have seen the business as this scale today.

Wonder if this was the optimal move at the time.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by mroche on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:54PM (#21800266)
As others have mentioned, the fallback license is for the point releases you have paid 12 months for, not the most recent release during your subscription (which is what your comment suggests).

It’s also worth noting that the requirement is 12 consecutive months. You can’t have any breaks so you need to be actively subscribed to take advantage of this.

It’s not the best solution (I am a fan of pay for a year (prepaid or monthly) and you get 12 months of updates where you keep all of them), but it’s a good compromise in the era of SaaS. And a compromise I’m willing to make for their IDEs.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by monksy on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:42AM (#21801036)
That didn't happen by what they tried to push. This happened because there was lots of developers threatening to walk over a pure subscription model.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by sudhirj on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:45AM (#21801047)
That's still the good thing. Can change the narrative to "developer tools company listens to its customers and gives them a fair deal". The effect is amoral, even if the cause is moral.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by antpol on Monday December 16, 2019 @12:47AM (#21801050)
Oh, I remember that pushback. Glorious days of outrage culture when it wasn't abused yet and the consumer power was strong
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by teddyuk on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:16PM (#21799048)
The thing I like is that their stuff makes it easier to develop and is reasonably priced.

If your company won’t pay for it you can buy a personal subscription cheaply.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by bad_user on Monday December 16, 2019 @02:24AM (#21801334)
Also the core of their main product, IntelliJ IDEA, is open source. And it's actually pretty usable for Java and Scala development for example, which is my interest in it.

The Ultimate version comes with bells and whistles, but truth be told I'm only paying for it because of how happy I am with it.

Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by memn0nis on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:11PM (#21800137)
Interesting... the problem with this model is that investors / the market value SaaS revenue way higher than revenue from perpetual licenses, for a variety of reasons. Although I guess that doesn't matter when you're not raising or public :)
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by baroffoos on Sunday December 15, 2019 @09:25PM (#21800392)
I was using their RubyMine editor for a few years and really liked it but then I switched jobs and ended up using vscodium and found it did basically everything I needed but was free.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by jariel on Sunday December 15, 2019 @04:20PM (#21799075)
I think Sketch does this and I agree, it's the way it should be.
Re:JetBrains: $270M revenue, 405K paying users, $0 raised by lordleft on Sunday December 15, 2019 @08:00PM (#21800084)
That's an absolutely brilliant pricing model. I love it.