News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by twic on Saturday November 30, 2019 @07:05AM (#21669618)
The Golgi case seems dubious. Golgi was wrong about the nervous system being continuous, but he did masses of other pioneering work in neurobiology and cell biology. He discovered the Golgi apparatus, which continues to baffle undergraduates to this day. He developed the staining technique which Ramón y Cajal eventually used to prove him wrong! I don't think the Nobel was given specifically for the idea that he nervous system is continuous, so it seems justified even today.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by masklinn on Saturday November 30, 2019 @09:11AM (#21670018)
The joint nobel was awarded

> "in recognition of their work on the structure of the nervous system"

Not cell biology, not lab techniques, but work on specifically the structure of the structure of the nervous system.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by ketzu on Saturday November 30, 2019 @09:36AM (#21670112)
But they also awarded it to two researchers proposing opposite interpretations, so they obviously did not endorse his interpretation of a continuous nervous system.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by mannykannot on Saturday November 30, 2019 @09:47AM (#21670178)
Insofar as the committee endorses specific discoveries (Nobel's criterion was for conferring the greatest benefit on mankind), it notably did not endorse relativity in awarding the 1921 prize to Einstein, either. It has been argued that this was due to the indirect influence of Henri Bergson's philosophical- and intuition-based objections.

http://nautil.us/issue/35/boundaries/this-philosopher-helped...

The committe went so far as delaying the award until 1922, saying, in 1921, that none of the candidates that year had met their standards.

https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1921/summary/

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by twic on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:27PM (#21672237)
Yes, and he did loads of work on the structure of the nervous system, including developing techniques, which is an inseperable part of scientific research, which was entirely valid.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by wyxuan on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:25AM (#21668868)
I'm surprised they didn't include lobotomies in this list. That was a huge blunder. Otherwise, the Nobel committee has a pretty good track record.

This is of course because they wait for the dust to settle on these discoveries and for the scientific community to validate and build on those conclusions.

This is why there is such a large lag time between the discovery and the granting of the prize.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by Ice_cream_suit on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:17AM (#21669102)
Functional stereotactic neurosurgery for psychiatric and neurodegenerative disorders is actively practiced.

The popular media is not a good place to get your information from...

"Functional neurosurgeons at UVa are currently treating: Neuropsychiatric conditions, including obsessive-compulsive disorder and depression" https://med.virginia.edu/neurosurgery/services/functional-ne...

"We read with great interest the publication of Liu et al. [1 ]reporting results from the largest published series of schizophrenia patients treated with MRI-guided bilateral anterior capsulotomy with 2 years of follow-up. Let us specify that a series of 87 schizophrenic patients operated, notably, by capsulotomy - but associated with a cingulotomy, amygdalectomy or thermocoagulation of the nucleus accumbens"

https://www.karger.com/Article/Fulltext/366005

http://med.stanford.edu/neurosurgery/divisions/functional.ht...

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by masklinn on Saturday November 30, 2019 @05:14AM (#21669369)
> Functional stereotactic neurosurgery for psychiatric and neurodegenerative disorders is actively practiced.

Lobotomy is the removal of most or all of the prefrontal cortex. That its descendant is now called "functional neurosurgery" does tell you how disparaged and discredited lobotomy is.

It's not unlike nuclear medicine though, there was an early hype phase where it was applied too often[0], too much and without enough precision. The underpinnings remain in active use but at a very different level of activity, and with much more precise targeting.

[0] the US performed 20000 lobotomies during the 40s, mostly on women.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by frozenport on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:38AM (#21669011)
Many doctors, patients and family members of the period believed that despite potentially catastrophic consequences, the results of lobotomy were seemingly positive in many instances or, at least they were deemed as such when measured next to the apparent alternative of long-term institutionalisation.[1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lobotomy#Prevalence

Lobotomies do something, unlike the other cases in the article.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by masklinn on Saturday November 30, 2019 @07:03AM (#21669610)
It's hard to disagree with these early criticisms though:

> it makes the custodial care of many patients easier. Let me remark in passing that killing them makes their custodial care still easier

and

> through lobotomy an insane person is changed into an idiot

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by svara on Saturday November 30, 2019 @10:26AM (#21670340)
Odd to see Moniz' 1949 lobotomy prize omitted here.

See https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1949/moniz/articl...

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by BeetleB on Saturday November 30, 2019 @11:59AM (#21670861)
Because it is disputed whether it was "wrong" (in terms of effectiveness, not in terms of morality). It did achieve what it claimed. It just happened to be a rather blunt method of doing it.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by svara on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:10PM (#21670929)
The point of any medical intervention is to make the patient better. By that standard, a lobotomy is ineffective. Lobotomies "worked" by making patients deeply disabled, in a way that made them more manageable.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by lovehashbrowns on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:38PM (#21671455)
They performed one on JFK's sister: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosemary_Kennedy

It's a very sad story, although that's pretty common for lobotomy cases.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by tzs on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:58PM (#21671226)
Speaking of lobotomies, most people think of it is a fairly major operation that requires hospitalization, but there were actually people doing them on an out patient basis. You could get your lobotomy and be on your way home an hour later, thanks to the development of the "transorbital lobotomy".

Here's part of a letter written in the mid-40s by Walter Freeman [1], a well-known lobotomist, describing this:

> I have also been trying out a sort of half-way stage between electroshock and prefrontal lobotomy [to treat mental patients]. … This consists of knocking them out with a shock and while they are under the ‘anesthetic’ thrusting an ice pick up between the eyeball and the eyelid through the roof of the orbit [the bony cavity that contains the eye] actually into the frontal lobe of the brain and making the lateral cut by swinging the thing from side to side. I have done two patients on both sides and another on one side without running into any complications, except a very black eye in one case. There may be trouble later on but it seemed fairly easy, although definitely a disagreeable thing to watch. It remains to be seen how these cases hold up, but so far they have shown considerable relief of their symptoms, and only some of the minor behavior difficulties that follow lobotomy. [That is, prefrontal lobotomy, which typically involved boring holes through the front of the skull. The ice pick operation is called a “transorbital lobotomy.”] They can even get up and go home within an hour or so. If this works out it will be a great advance for people who are too bad for shock but not bad enough for surgery.

That quote is mentioned in this classic The Straight Dope [2] column, which includes more info and cites if you want more on this disturbing topic.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Jackson_Freeman_II

[2] https://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/607/in-medicine-wh...

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by ekianjo on Saturday November 30, 2019 @10:45AM (#21670403)
This makes me very sad:

> However, I see no reason for indignation at what was done in the 1940s as at that time there were no other alternatives!

So, destroying someone prefrontal functions (which is basically akin to destroying their whole personality) was an acceptable remedy for schizophrenia treatment, because, err, we didn't have anything else? How can anyone even write anything like that?

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by gamblor956 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:40PM (#21672031)
When you meet people with severe enough schizoaffective disorders, you will start to feel differently.

Imagine being able to get someone off the streets and back on course with their life, without risk of relapse, with a simple outpatient surgery?

And the crazy thing is that we actually have the medical capability to do so. We just don't have the legal capability.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by ncmncm on Saturday November 30, 2019 @06:31AM (#21669528)
It is kind of looking like the prize for Dark Energy was awarded for a nonexistent phenomenon. The dust hasn't settled, but it will or should be very embarrassing if it turns out so.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by ldarby on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:35PM (#21671071)
The whole point of the article is that it shouldn't be embarrassing. The current dark energy theory is just currently the best explanation for observed phenomena (or was, I'm not sure what you're referring to). Even if it's wrong, the Nobel is still deserved even just for making that observation, because it encourages others to pursue science.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by hpcjoe on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:33PM (#21671422)
Not a practicing physicist anymore, so I may be hopelessly out of date.

This noted, I've been under the impression for a while that dark energy/dark matter is more likely a detailed accounting error. That is, it's likely that it is not a "new" thing, but old physics that we have an incomplete understanding of.

Science is funny that way. Early results considered groundbreaking are refined and extended over time. And sometimes, as we gain more information and comprehension, the effect we think we observed is subsumed into "boring" physics (this is how it was described to me by a friend).

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by baddox on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:36PM (#21671757)
I don’t know if there’s a huge difference between “a brand new thing” and “an old thing that is not interacting at all the way we understand it to.”
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by scarmig on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:25AM (#21668986)
Nobel Prizes in the sciences do seem to withstand the test of time better than economics, literature, and (laughs) peace.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by paggle on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:43AM (#21669020)
With actual war criminals winning peace prizes I do wonder what is the point of it. The value of an award is in the company it puts you in, now it looks like the peace Nobel is just worth its dollar value and its value on the TED circuit.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by Tomte on Saturday November 30, 2019 @07:13AM (#21669637)
The value in awarding the Nobel Peace Prize to warmongers is — and the awarding committee is very conscious of it — that it has enough cachet to actually motivate warmongers to stop warmonging and go for the prize (and a relatively well-off, safe and calm retirement).

It may not be fair, but the people who don't die because of that effect won't complain.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by bathtub365 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @10:42AM (#21670394)
Do you have any examples of this happening?
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by Tomte on Saturday November 30, 2019 @10:49AM (#21670422)
There are multiple instances of violent people who stopped being violent and got the prize. Arafat is one example.

Whether the prize played a role in their decision is something only they can say (and then you might not believe them).

So I find this question useless, because it cannot be answered. The mechanism I sketched is generally plausible, though.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by dnautics on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:56PM (#21671209)
There are also instances of relatively peaceful people who got the prize and became warmongers, e.g. a certain president of the us, who sent 500 drone strikes into Libya in a single year after winning the prize (among other military adventures)
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by Tomte on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:05PM (#21671275)
How does that relate to the question in this sub thread?

Do you actually propose that they did violent things because they got the prize?

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by jtolmar on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:18PM (#21671672)
If there are as many examples of people receiving the peace prize then going on to be warmongers as there are the reverse, it suggests that the peace prize isn't really doing anything here and we're just looking at the base rate of leaders switching between peaceful and warlike actions.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by Tomte on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:31PM (#21671729)
No, that's a fallacy, unless you can credibly argue for a causal link, i.e. because of the prize people feel they can get away with violence.

I find that not impossible to argue, but incredible, and would want to see supporting evidence.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by baddox on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:33PM (#21671737)
Yes, but that cuts both ways.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by Tomte on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:36PM (#21671753)
I only argue that there is a plausible mechanism, you argued in quantitative terms.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by benjohnson on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:13PM (#21671644)
The prize may have given them political cover that let their violence go on longer
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by Tomte on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:33PM (#21671738)
They only get the prize after stopping, so you're arguing for something more complicated: violence, then non-violence, then violence.

Possible, but not terribly plausible, IMO. And the examples proffered so far (Obama or Kissinger) certainly don't fit that pattern.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by _Microft on Saturday November 30, 2019 @05:18AM (#21669378)
Do you talk about war criminals being awarded the Nobel peace prize or about Nobel peace prize laureates turning into war criminals? This is an important difference in my opinion. Since you seem to follow this more closely than I do, would you mind giving an example?
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by stenl on Saturday November 30, 2019 @08:03AM (#21669778)
Obama pursued policies that arguably (https://www.amnestyusa.org/the-obama-bush-doctrine/) amount to war crimes, and refused to allow the obvious war crimes of the preceding administration to be investigated. He got a Nobel peace prize essentially for being less terrible on that front than his predecessor, George W Bush.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by moneybadger on Saturday November 30, 2019 @11:03AM (#21670495)
> But does the drone program amount to a war crime as Marc Thiessen suggests? That is a complicated question to answer. Unlike the use of torture, there are circumstances in international law and under the laws of war in which the use of lethal force can be lawful. Much depends on where, how and with what intent such force is used. We do not, as yet, have sufficient evidence to make a determination regarding the legality of the US drones program. It has been conducted in secret and in places where it is very difficult to mount an effective investigation.

Also there was a 1,200+ page Senate investigation into the use of torture by the previous administration.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by JackFr on Saturday November 30, 2019 @11:33AM (#21670633)
It’s not more complicated. The same flawed intelligence apparatus which provided the lists of people to capture and interrogate during the Bush administration also compiled Obama’s kill list.

Neither method really provides any useful intelligence. The difference is victims of torture can go on ‘60 Minutes’, victims of targeted drone strikes can’t.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by dragonwriter on Saturday November 30, 2019 @05:30AM (#21669401)
> Do you talk about war criminals being awarded the Nobel peace prize or about Nobel peace prize laureates turning into war criminals?

For the former, Henry Kissinger.

There are examples of the latter, as well.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by thundergolfer on Saturday November 30, 2019 @06:13AM (#21669487)
Holy hell, Kissinger won the Nobel Peace Prize?! I'm was familiar enough with him to know he's disgustingly immoral, and never imagined people back then would have been stupid enough to give him that award.

With 2 members of the committee resigning in protest, it seems not everyone with power to award it was so morally corrupt.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by croisillon on Saturday November 30, 2019 @07:52AM (#21669746)
Gorbatschow sent tanks on civilians in Vilnius just one month after being awarded the Peace Nobel
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by pram on Saturday November 30, 2019 @05:27AM (#21669395)
Aung San Suu Kyi is probably the most recent example with a very dubious legacy.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by ekianjo on Saturday November 30, 2019 @10:48AM (#21670421)
Obama certainly did not deserve his Peace prize by the time he was elected and continued violence in the Middle East, started new wars (such as Libya) and expanded the (secret) drone strikes.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by dnautics on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:57PM (#21671216)
Well to be fair he did most of those things after winning the Nobel.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by ekianjo on Sunday December 01, 2019 @08:07AM (#21675290)
Which makes it even worse.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by hos234 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:13AM (#21669216)
Well humans are human. Mistakes happen and as long as they aren't increasing over time, it's all cool.

Awards don't just exist to award the individual.

In polarizing times, where the instinct is to create more conflict as a path to resolving conflict, what many of the Peace Prize winners have done, is to remind everyone that alternate non-obvious paths exist.

[dead]
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by dang on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:22AM (#21674534)
Would you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and/or flamebait to HN? You've been doing it a lot, unfortunately, and it is not what this site is for.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by dm3730 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @06:57AM (#21675061)
They are not unsubstantiated comments. They are well based in fact. https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/ezj3km/gandhi-was-a-racis...
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by dang on Sunday December 01, 2019 @01:32PM (#21676975)
I'm not arguing about Gandhi facts. Your comment was flamebait. By unsubstantive I mean comments that add more noise than signal to a thread.

It's also against HN's rules to use it primarily for political or ideological battle. Would you mind taking the spirit of this site more to heart, as described at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html? We're here for curious conversation, not to smite enemies, and those two things can't coexist. For example, if you jump from a topic like "Disproved discoveries that won Nobel Prizes" to "Gandhi was a horrific racist", you're taking the thread in the sort of hellish direction from which the internet never returns.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by ekianjo on Saturday November 30, 2019 @10:51AM (#21670432)
If you are looking for any figure that is pure like snow and more saint than Saints, then nobody can reasonably win any kind of Award ever - you can find faults with absolutely every single one person in the Universe.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by dm3730 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:43AM (#21674385)
well, people do portray Gandhi and Mother Teresa as saints whereas the reality turned out that both of them were horrible individuals.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by yesenadam on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:04AM (#21674468)
What basis do you have for saying that Gandhi was a 'horrible individual'? And I take it from the way you said that, that you see yourself as a far finer human being, is that right? (Maybe that second question is an improper one, but it does seem raised by how and what you wrote.)
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by dm3730 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @06:56AM (#21675059)
> What basis do you have for saying that Gandhi was a 'horrible individual'

I'm surprised this is not more well known.

https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/ezj3km/gandhi-was-a-racis...

> you see yourself as a far finer human being, is that right

Yes. I do as I believe most people are better than Gandhi, simply by virtue of not abusing children the way Gandhi did, and numerous other crimes that he committed.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by spodek on Saturday November 30, 2019 @08:34AM (#21669890)
There is no Nobel prize in economics.

> The five real Nobel Prizes—physics, chemistry, literature, peace, and medicine/physiology—were set up in the will left by the dynamite magnate when he died in 1895. The economics prize is a bit different. It was created by Sweden’s Central Bank in 1969, nearly 75 years later. The award’s real name is the “Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel.” It was not established by Nobel, but supposedly in memory of Nobel. It’s a ruse and a PR trick, and I mean that literally. And it was done completely against the wishes of the Nobel family.

> “The Economics Prize has nestled itself in and is awarded as if it were a Nobel Prize. But it’s a PR coup by economists to improve their reputation,” Nobel’s great great nephew Peter Nobel told AFP in 2005, adding that “It’s most often awarded to stock market speculators …. There is nothing to indicate that [Alfred Nobel] would have wanted such a prize.”

https://www.alternet.org/2012/10/there-no-nobel-prize-econom...

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by tzs on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:47PM (#21671151)
> There is no Nobel prize in economics

The Nobel Foundation [1] disagrees. That bank donated the money to establish the prize, but it is awarded by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, the same organization that awards the physics and chemistry prizes, using the the same procedures.

[1] https://www.nobelprize.org/

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by ekianjo on Saturday November 30, 2019 @10:46AM (#21670409)
> It was created by Sweden’s Central Bank in 1969,

Well that will probably rule out any economist opposed to central banking systems.

Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by MagnumOpus on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:22PM (#21671361)
Except it won't - for the same reason why Nobel donating the prizes for the other subjects doesn't rule out opponents of dynamite or high-explosives for the Peace prize. (I.e. the Royal Academy in Sweden gives out both prizes, the Nobel family and the Rijksbank are not involved.)
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by baddox on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:32PM (#21671732)
Huh? Wasn’t Nobel opposed to (many uses of) high explosives? Wasn’t that the point?
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by ivnubinas on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:02AM (#21674270)
Milton Friedman won a Nobel prize. He didn't like central banks at all.
Re:Disproved Discoveries That Won Nobel Prizes (2015) by FussyZeus on Saturday November 30, 2019 @08:57AM (#21669966)
Of course the Nobel prize for economics is a ruse and at least semi-fraudulent. That's the least surprising thing I think I've ever learned.