News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by coldcode on Thursday October 31, 2019 @01:51PM (#21411629)
From your perspective you died. From the copies perspective you are continuous.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by neals on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:05PM (#21411788)
I honestly think this is only "scary" the first time.

After that, you will have the experience of "dying and being resurrected" and since everything went fine that last time, the next time is less of a concern.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by zepto on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:08PM (#21411823)
After that the copies will be deluded into thinking they survived death while in fact they died.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by Symmetry on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:28PM (#21412032)
Hah, maybe. And maybe we die every night when we go to sleep and are only deluding ourselves into thinking we're the same person who went to sleep. But ultimately "dead" is a matter for us living beings to define, the universe itself has no notion of elan vital that discriminates between the living and the dead.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by zepto on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:41PM (#21412195)
A useful thought experiment is to consider a machine that first duplicates a person and then drops the original into a meat grinder.

The duplicate that steps out would be identical to the original and have no memory of having been ground.

Would you step into such a machine, safe in the knowledge that from the point of view of the universe and all other living beings, you would emerge unharmed?

Re:Is Death Reversible? by Symmetry on Thursday October 31, 2019 @03:13PM (#21412498)
Well, there'd be two consciousnesses produced both of which I'd think of as me, pre-duplication. And one would die in horrible pain. I'd really rather not die in horrible pain even if there was still a me around afterward, though you could probably offer a large enough inducement that I'd take it. Of course, there exist inducements that would get me to consent to the meat grinder without duplication
Re:Is Death Reversible? by zepto on Thursday October 31, 2019 @05:22PM (#21413826)
I’m curious what kind of inducements would get you to consent to the meat grinder without duplication?
Re:Is Death Reversible? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday November 01, 2019 @01:09AM (#21416423)
You must not be very creative if you can't think of any. Off the top of my head:

1. Credible threat of ceaseless torture as an alternative.

2. Credible threat death to your offspring.

3. Credible threat of death and injury to many other people.

All of these are reasons people are frequently documented to willfully cause their own demise.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by zepto on Friday November 01, 2019 @08:05PM (#21424967)
I’m sorry you misunderstood ;-)

I wasn’t looking for a generic list - I was curious about Symmetry’s examples for themselves.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by Symmetry on Saturday November 02, 2019 @11:16PM (#21431891)
AnIdiotOnTheNet basically got the things I was thinking of so well I didn't feel the need to reply.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by zepto on Monday November 04, 2019 @12:19AM (#21439223)
Is it really ‘consent’ if you are being threatened with those kinds of things?
Re:Is Death Reversible? by Razengan on Friday November 01, 2019 @05:12AM (#21417209)
4. A reward in the afterlife.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by jodrellblank on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:32PM (#21414474)
Hugh Jackman does, in the film "The Prestige" - https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0482571/ - with the inducement being "to perform the greatest magic trick" and one-up Christian Bale.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by neals on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:43PM (#21412210)
Netflix: "Living with yourself"
Re:Is Death Reversible? by garmaine on Friday November 01, 2019 @12:00AM (#21416179)
Your brain doesn’t shut down when you sleep. You just stop forming memories.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by Loughla on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:03PM (#21411756)
This will devolve into a 'what is consciousness' debate, but honestly does it matter?

To your consciousness, there is no gap, just the novel experience of watching someone who looks an awful lot like you die. If the consciousness is copied perfectly from a to b, is there a difference in it at that point?

Re:Is Death Reversible? by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:25PM (#21411994)
Future you (or "you") won't give a shit. Present you may or may not have cause to worry.

A simple thought experiment: We somehow copy me, but leave the original alive after reviving the copy. Then we kill the original. As the original, I'm gonna be unhappy about that. The exact time you kill me doesn't change that, so killing me then copying me then reviving the copy at the very least isn't a trivially unobjectionable process. As to whether it's actually unobjectionable, that's probably way above our paygrades philosophically.

There's a great star trek episode where Riker gets duplicated in the transporter, leading to years of jokes (and philosophical debates) that the transporter doesn't send you anywhere, it just copies you and kills the original. Real fun to think about.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday October 31, 2019 @03:37PM (#21412750)
Except they went out of their way in that episode to explain that transporters absolutely do not work that way and this was a very strange occurrence that they could only guess at the cause of.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by vermilingua on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:28PM (#21415521)
Well they would say that, otherwise, who would transport? ;)
Re:Is Death Reversible? by Loughla on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:31PM (#21412063)
Vaguely connected to this conversation now, the Daystrom Institute subreddit is one of my most favorite things that exists.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by J5892 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:27PM (#21412019)
This is only true if you're looking at it from an external point of view.

From the individual's point of view, which is the only one that matters from their perspective, they are dead. Their consciousness no longer exists.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by Loughla on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:30PM (#21412047)
That's the thing. If you exist as one consciousness, then they copy the other while the first dies, the second is, essentially, the same consciousness. Therefore, you are still alive.

I feel like this has been discussed somewhere already in history.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by J5892 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @03:41PM (#21412803)
This is a weird roadblock I've run into before when discussing this topic.

No matter how many times I say that I'm speaking from the individual's point of view, some readers seem incapable of looking at it from an individual perspective.

In the case of your statement, it would solely depend on how the copy was made. If it's copied by somehow reading the consciousness, storing it as data, and perfectly restoring it in a new brain, then no, it is not the same consciousness, and from your perspective you are dead.

If it's copied through some kind of direct transfer, where the electrical impulses move, through some kind of biological link, to a new brain, then it is possible that the same continuous consciousness could now exist in the new brain.

(to be clear, I don't mean any of what I said to be insulting. I'm just observing that there are perspectives on this issue that I don't quite understand)

Re:Is Death Reversible? by wrcwill on Thursday October 31, 2019 @08:50PM (#21415307)
We feel like there is a difference between those 2 cases because we experience a continuity in our experience of the universe (ie. consciousness).

Under this premise (as you stated), copying your entire state and spawning it elsewhere (then killing the original) means your original version experiences a stopping of their continuity.

But if you analyze that premise, you realize that the only reason we believe we existed a second ago is because of our memory (the same reason the clone believes it was always alive).

How can you know that you aren't being cloned, in-place, right now? ie. Copied, killed, and spawned in place almost instantaneously. At every instant you carry all your memories and thus "feel" continuity, but it's a new you.

In this view, being killed and spawned elsewhere is no different. It isn't taking anything away from you because you never had it.

Obviously this is just a thought experiment, but just the fact that right now, while you were questioning if being cloned and killed was bad for the original you, this process could have been happening to you without your knowledge, might mean it is irrelevant.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by kharak on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:49PM (#21414580)
I know what you mean. Guess a helpful analogy for some might be to consider two objects of one class. Those objects can be instantiated with identical values, but they are, in fact, two different objects. They occupy a different, physical space and can be differentiated by that. Same with two identical copies of a person. Not the same space, not the same consciousness. I'm not sure why some overlook the space part in all of this.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by alrehn on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:07PM (#21414253)
Well I consider what makes "the individual" that is me the composition that makes up the brain and body I have. If you can recreate that composition I consider both people to equally have my individual point of view.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by imtringued on Thursday October 31, 2019 @07:55PM (#21415026)
The problem with that is that it means that consciousness is not bound to your body. Two people can share the same consciousness and from that point on it is very easy to imagine that you are sharing the consciousness of your parents and their grandparents and so on until every organism on earth shares the same consciousness. This means consciousness has to be a property of the universe. Making a clone doesn't grant you immortality because you already are immortal.

The opposite scenario is that there are now two consciousnesses. If the original dies so does its consciousness and you failed to achieve immortality. Your clone is just your offspring with an identical body and set of memories.

So which is it? I personally picked it based on what I want to believe in, because even if it is a lie it helps me shape the world into one in which I want to life in, rather than one that I do not like and would prefer to get rid of.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by jodrellblank on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:16PM (#21414340)
I feel like this has been discussed somewhere already in history.

Ship of Theseus paradox, if you replace the planks and beams of a ship over and over until they are all replaced, is it still the original ship?

Difference is, humans have a perspective on the world which ships and brooms do not have. If you watched a team busying about with a machine for a few hours, and then a human stepped out of it, and then one of the team members turned to you and said "OK we've got a clone of you, now we're going to shoot you in the head" would you say "yes I see that new person out there across the room looks exactly like me, so it IS me, so go on, shoot me?"

Re:Is Death Reversible? by AstralStorm on Saturday November 02, 2019 @09:04AM (#21427435)
Humans change all the time, ask your teenage self that.

Some things stay rather permanent though, as they're dynamically reinforced, short of serious trauma. Those parts are likely to survive stepped replacement, or rather both the replacement and original adjust to get to the original state. It's like trying to replace a component of a feedback system while it's live, it will be out of whack for a while but if control is good enough will return to baseline.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by michaelmrose on Thursday October 31, 2019 @08:27PM (#21415186)
The universe doesn't have ships it has something that is aproximated somewhat by waves or particles or strings. The ship is a convenient pointer to discuss a collection of particles that whose state depend on each other in some fashion.

It's a handle of convenience. If it points to something useful it's useful if not then not there never was or will be a ship of theseus so whether it's the same ship means nothing.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by Falling3 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:46PM (#21412238)
It's definitely been discussed for a while. Recent takes on it include a really interesting Outer Limits episode and the recent Netflix show Living with Yourself.

This is easy to say if you're not the one dying. If you know a perfect clone of your current self is going to live from this point forward, are you still comfortable with being killed?

Re:Is Death Reversible? by XorNot on Thursday October 31, 2019 @09:09PM (#21415412)
Most of it depends on the idea as to whether you think you experience death.

For example: general anesthesia is something I think most people having these conversations should experience (which is to say, generally a lot of people don't). Because it's very different to sleep. Waking up from GA, it's as though no time has passed at all - you were one place, suddenly you're another.

In the case where a person is duplicated exactly, sometime during that period of GA - what's the difference?

It takes a special pleading that somehow, someone would know the difference. While under general anesthesia it's worth considering that people can and do actually die. And unless something metaphysical happens at that point, then the reality is they never know. They went under, expected to wake up, and just don't.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by Jordrok on Thursday October 31, 2019 @10:42PM (#21415848)
> Because it's very different to sleep. Waking up from GA, it's as though no time has passed at all - you were one place, suddenly you're another.

Personally, most nights of normal sleep are like that for me as well. Dreams (or at least the remembrance thereof) are a rare occurrence rather than the norm.

(For reference, yes, I have been under GA. I didn't really find it to be all that different, other than the onset being somewhat more sudden and waking up in a different place.)

Re:Is Death Reversible? by UnFleshedOne on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:44PM (#21414543)
Presumably you knew that before you stepped into the teleporter, so decision to partially die is in both copies of you.

This all assumes a destructive copy process -- if a non-destructive teleporter is possible, you don't need to destroy remaining copy, but all kinds of legal issues arise. Maybe you'd want to have one copy destroyed to avoid paying double for lunch.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday October 31, 2019 @03:34PM (#21412724)
If they aren't alive to experience it, in what sense does said perspective exist?
Re:Is Death Reversible? by J5892 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @04:04PM (#21413113)
In the sense that the perspective has ceased to exist, and is not present within the copy.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by sidewndr46 on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:08PM (#21411818)
If you watch the show "Altered Carbon", I kind of felt like there was an unspoken idea that all of the characters are in fact deceased many times over. The capability of replicating the exact consciousness of any of them exists of course.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by Razengan on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:14PM (#21411865)
This is also a core theme of the awesome game SOMA:

https://www.gog.com/game/soma

Re:Is Death Reversible? by mellosouls on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:14PM (#21411862)
It matters particularly depending on whether you are a or b after the transition point.

To your consciousness, there is no gap, just the novel experience of watching someone who looks an awful lot like you die.

This could be rephrased as:

To your consciousness, there is no gap, just the novel experience of dying as someone who looks an awful lot like you watches.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by Loughla on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:22PM (#21411957)
That's the thing, there is NO transition point. There's just two of you. SO, if there are two of your consciousness with the same thoughts, experiences, and the whole shabang up until the second one is made and the first dies, does it even matter that it's not the original?

I would argue no. Because for you, your consciousness, it's as if you are still the same person. The first doesn't matter, because it's just turned off. But you still exist.

Unless you're arguing for a 'soul', there is no difference between the two consciousnesses. Therefore, you are still alive.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by kaibee on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:45PM (#21412229)
> That's the thing, there is NO transition point. There's just two of you. SO, if there are two of your consciousness with the same thoughts, experiences, and the whole shabang up until the second one is made and the first dies, does it even matter that it's not the original?

Externally, no. But it matters to me, the original.

> I would argue no. Because for you, your consciousness, it's as if you are still the same person.

Yes, for the copy, it is as if they are the original.

> The first doesn't matter, because it's just turned off.

What if the copy is made non-destructively?

> But you still exist.

A version of you still exists.

> Unless you're arguing for a 'soul', there is no difference between the two consciousnesses. Therefore, you are still alive.

The causal chain of events matters. If a copy of your consciousness is made, it can be done without you ever knowing about it.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by jodrellblank on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:08PM (#21414266)
So let's assume that the universe is infinite in extent, and everything which can happen, does happen, infinite times. That means you are not the only "you" in the Universe.

You may now commit suicide, safe in the knowledge that it doesn't matter, because there's no difference between the current you and the distant you.

Unless you're now going to change tack and say it only counts if you're in each other's Light cone, and have seen each other, and understand the cloning machine's workings, and trust it was built correctly, and an endless amount of other procrastinating which proves that it does matter to you which one dies, and no matter what words you type, your behavior will show that you recognize a stark difference between "you" and "someone else".

Clearly a condition "I know they exist" doesn't change whether you two are the same person or not, so that can't be an important part of it.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by AgentME on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:39PM (#21414511)
>You may now commit suicide, safe in the knowledge that it doesn't matter, because there's no difference between the current you and the distant you.

If you decide to commit suicide, then any identical copies of yourself will also have the same thought process and decide to commit suicide too, so you'll have killed all identical copies of yourself. That's very different than deciding to do something (like use a scan-clone-destroy teleporter) that will create a copy of yourself and then destroy one copy of yourself.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by jodrellblank on Friday November 01, 2019 @07:56PM (#21424931)
Then make it Russian Roulette; most of you will survive, and any one of you is enough to count as all of you.

Now is it any different to stepping into the teleporter?

Re:Is Death Reversible? by AgentME on Saturday November 02, 2019 @08:12PM (#21431051)
Playing russian roulette would leave many worlds without an instance of me, in a way that the teleporter wouldn't. I care about my responsibilities and loved ones left without me in those worlds.

If there were truly infinite worlds and infinite of each variation, and you could somehow play russian roulette instead with an entire world, so that each one has a risk of just entirely blinking out of existence ... it feels superficially wrong, but I find it hard to argue against. I'd worry that there's a risk of if it was done infinitely, then by some logic the infinite sum could eventually lead to all worlds not existing eventually, but if that was definitely known not to be a risk then I would find it hard to care about whether the world played russian roulette or not.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by scarejunba on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:46PM (#21412234)
There is no “your consciousness” as an identity across the two copies. So you fork a process and you kill one of the processes. That process experiences death. Likewise one copy experiences death. Does it matter? Depending on your objectives. If it’s to achieve some sort of world domination through pseudo-immortality, probably not, since your copy will execute faithfully as you. But your perception, the body unit you’re in, will most definitely see an end. It won’t ‘jump’ into the other medium. This you will die. That you will live.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by UnFleshedOne on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:49PM (#21414582)
This assumes a non-destructive copying process _and_ a mandatory destruction of original. Those two things might not be easy to reconcile.

A destructive copy is strictly more feasible (as far as such things are feasible at all). But it comes with a possibility to print copies once the reading is done. Then you can get multiple clones made and they will be you, but will start diverge from each other right away due to slightly different experiences.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by mellosouls on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:48PM (#21412262)
crossposted / post-posted with several others :)

There is a transition point - at least for b.

a gets to the transition point and dies. b "awakes" with a's memories.

So: you are a ... > [transition] ... you are ?

How do you know you (formerly a) become b at that point? Certainly from b's perspective that is the case - but from former a's perspective? Which do you "switch to"? Death or b?

You need to consider 3 perspectives:

a then after the transition:

b (live a)

c (dead a)

If you don't want to consider dead a, then consider this: what if the experiment went wrong?

a isn't killed in the process, but a copy of their consciousness is loaded into b.

Same situation as before, but both a and b think they are former a.

Which are you (formerly a) in that circumstance? Why?

I would argue a has a strong case to be considered the correct version - which means you die in the first case.

Re:Is Death Reversible? by skissane on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:30PM (#21414448)
The answers to this question depend on what positions one takes in the philosophy of mind. Find the correct philosophy of mind, and you will find the correct answer to this question (well, unless something like Derek Parfit's position is correct, in which case the correct answer is that there is no correct answer.)
Re:Is Death Reversible? by JoshTriplett on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:22PM (#21411954)
Which consciousness? Once copied, you have two, one of them still dying.
Re:Is Death Reversible? by wonderwonder on Thursday October 31, 2019 @06:29PM (#21414441)
What if one of you does not die? If there are now 2 perfect copies, are both of them you? Or as there are now 2, is neither of them you?
Re:Is Death Reversible? by lonelappde on Thursday October 31, 2019 @04:06PM (#21413128)
There is no perspective from which you die. That's what dying means. You can't experience being dead.