Re:Is Death Reversible?
by mellosouls on Thursday October 31, 2019 @02:48PM
(#21412262)
crossposted / post-posted with several others :)
There is a transition point - at least for b.
a gets to the transition point and dies. b "awakes" with a's memories.
So: you are a ... > [transition] ... you are ?
How do you know you (formerly a) become b at that point? Certainly from b's perspective that is the case - but from former a's perspective? Which do you "switch to"? Death or b?
You need to consider 3 perspectives:
a
then after the transition:
b (live a)
c (dead a)
If you don't want to consider dead a, then consider this: what if the experiment went wrong?
a isn't killed in the process, but a copy of their consciousness is loaded into b.
Same situation as before, but both a and b think they are former a.
Which are you (formerly a) in that circumstance? Why?
I would argue a has a strong case to be considered the correct version - which means you die in the first case.
There is a transition point - at least for b.
a gets to the transition point and dies. b "awakes" with a's memories.
So: you are a ... > [transition] ... you are ?
How do you know you (formerly a) become b at that point? Certainly from b's perspective that is the case - but from former a's perspective? Which do you "switch to"? Death or b?
You need to consider 3 perspectives:
a then after the transition:
b (live a)
c (dead a)
If you don't want to consider dead a, then consider this: what if the experiment went wrong?
a isn't killed in the process, but a copy of their consciousness is loaded into b.
Same situation as before, but both a and b think they are former a.
Which are you (formerly a) in that circumstance? Why?
I would argue a has a strong case to be considered the correct version - which means you die in the first case.