Huh? You just described maybe 1 in 10 Americans. We genuinely do not care about "manifest destiny" and many of us don't put much value in being American either. I'm not even sure what you mean by "skin in the game"
> Let's say one day some stupid little state that you don't care about and vaguely resent decides it wants to secede, wants all these rights others don't have, wants to be able to marry its cousins or make nukes at home or whatever. Alabama, go with them. Alabama wants to secede and they have some demonstrations. You think: "hahahaha no"
But Hong Kong doesn't want to secede. They want to keep the freedoms they've had for decades and prevent an oppressive government from restricting those freedoms. Your example is entirely different and opposite sides of the spectrum.
A more apt example would be the Occupy protests that happened throughout the western world close to a decade ago. Those were about returning the status quo to what it was before greed took it too far from the middle class. Looking back, it was highly ineffective. But those were months-long protests that hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of people took part in and for the most part, every day citizens who were not taking part in the protests supported them (or were at least indifferent). Tools were built to help these protesters find where to go and where to avoid (as with all large scale protests) and they were never an issue.
Heck, one of the most widely used apps in the US is Waze and one of the primary appeals of it is the crowd sourced police location data. Law enforcement has complained about it, but no actions have been taken against it and no one seems to have any real issue with it.
Didn’t Americans freak out when Black Lives Matter protesters blocked the highway? A tactic the Hong Kong protestors are using?
Didn’t Americans make fun of Occupy Wall Street?
I expect old Chinese people to be jingoistic but if educated young people are that’s just a sad testament to how little creative/critical thinking is encouraged in China
Looks like you fell exactly for the Trump propaganda. Saying "Americans" "freaked out" over the kneeling thing is so ridiculous I don't even know where to start. Trump tried to make it a big deal, and probably 0.0001% of his stupid supporters like /r/the_donald try to make it a big deal so that someone like you thinks it's a big deal.
Trump has been extremely effective at some things, I'll give him that.....
This is exactly how the United States is setup. Notice how pot is legal in some states and not others? I don't see the National Guard marching on Colorado.
Show me the state where you can show full penetrative sex on public TV at 9pm, like you can in europe, and I'll agree they're independent.
EDIT: OK, that was a dumb example. Substitute banning guns, or lowering the drinking age, or lowering income tax. Country-level things.
> like you can in europe
Europe is not an homogeneous place. Some parts of Europe are just as if not more conservative than the most conservative parts of the US. Europe in fact proves my point if we think of Europe (the EU) as a collection of nation states each with their own local laws. BTW, where in Europe is full penetration shown on a public TV at 9pm?
Not really. It's frigging pot. It's been de-facto legal for decades.
Show me a state doing something serious, like banning guns, reversing roe v wade, changing the state language, change the voting age. Difference-between-country stuff. I should have thought of something like that for my initial post; would have reduced this silly nitpicking.
And thanks, I'm not from the USA but I'm from a federation too so yeah, I have some idea. As for the China knowledge - looking forward to your cogent, evidenced retort. 请说普通话。
You realize gun and abortion laws already vary greatly from state to state?
What does it matter what the average Chinese citizen thinks about this? By pulling the app, Apple is taking the side of an oppressive regime against Hong Kong. Whether or not 90% of Chinese citizens agree with Hong Kong is utterly irrelevant to the conversation. They're not the people being oppressed.
I don't care if the average Chinese citizen likes Hong Kong, any more than I care about whether the average Chinese citizen likes Muslims, or any more than I care about whether the average US citizen likes immigrants or LGBQT+ citizens.
The opinions of the oppressed matter, the opinions of unaffected third-party observers do not, in except that their opinions spur them to action to help the oppressed.
If 90% of the Chinese population thinks that HK is just a misbehaving tiny city that needs to be brought into line, then 90% of the Chinese population is wrong, and Apple is wrong to side with them. Human rights are not a cultural artifact, they're not decided by majority. They're recognized, not granted.
Even if you ignore the particular "special right" Hong Kong was arguing for (like, the right not to be extradited and disappeared for disagreeing with the government), it's still part of an existing system and series of agreements that are now being violated.
It's closer to if the UK tried to disband the Scottish parliament, because those damn Scots get special privileges and still protest and whine all day about secession, and then started moving troops in and brutalizing student protesters.
And, yes, everyone here would side with Scotland over the UK.
The PRC needs to get better propaganda.
If you want to talk about precedent - how about polygamy in Utah? There was a long precedent of that. Substitute that if you like. I was trying to convey a feeling.
User 'sho' wants to present Hong Kong's efforts to preserve their rights in a way that the USA would understand.
When Utah wanted to become a state, they obviously would have liked to preserve their polygamy practice. It took a long time before things settled down and Utah became a state.
In a sense, that's where Hong Kong is right now. "One country, two systems." They aren't a fully-integrated part of the country, though I don't want to delegitimize them by calling them a "territory," maybe the comparison isn't so bad.
There's pressure from the mainland to conform. Just like there was lots of pressure put on Utah to conform.
It seems like a decent comparison.
Yes, it does (assuming you mean precedent). Alabama was one of the initial members of the Confederacy, which it created/joined on March 13, 1861.
Now, this might sound like I'm disagreeing, but I would say, consider the outcome of the next several years. It is true that the United States fought this out to the n'th degree, and self-governance lost.
One relevant difference is that there is a fairly solid case that Alabama joined the United States of its own free will. (Whether they realized it was inherently a one-way trip, well, that's another discussion.) I'm not sure if I agree that Hong Kong was quite so free. But it was certainly legal.
"Well, what's the point of having individual states if they can't control their own destiny. But marrying cousins? A federal issue? Let me chew on that."
Some alabamans post an app on the app store so they can avoid the national guard.
"An app? Cool, plods have mass surveillance, the protestors have it now, too. Oh, you thought the 2nd Amendment was just about guns?" you say.
I see what you're saying, but I will still disagree with the "90%+ of Chinese", and with the CCP's handling of the issue. Your hypothetical had me cheering for the Alabaman's, because frankly, I don't think we protest enough around here.
I guess it depends.
I hate to be pedantic, but wasn't that in Philadelphia
You haven't even provided a single shred of evidence to support the beliefs you are attributing to the vast number of Chinese people. Hacker news is a site of logic and evidence based reasoning, not for propagating senseless propaganda.
I don't know what you imagine I might have to gain from "spreading propaganda". I'm simply trying to explain, from my understanding, how "the other side" often feels. I don't know where you think "bias" enters into it. I've even explicitly said I totally disagree. I don't know what else to say?
What's your evidence that the app is being used to attack the police? And how are you drawing the parallel with the national guard? The things you are posting here are false and dishonest. You haven't provided any evidence to suggest otherwise.
My fucking post started with "Imagine you are...."
> clearly biased against Hong Kong and trying to sway the opinion in China's favor
An explanation of something is NOT the same thing as an endorsement of it. I literally said I totally disagree with them:
>> I'd like to note that I do not support the Chinese Govt in any way and think the world would be a better place with an independent, democratic HK - a city I genuinely love.
If you still don't understand I'm sorry but I'll have to leave it there.
That's probably where you lose most of the US audience. One of the biggest differences between American and Chinese culture is that manifest destiny is mostly dead in America, but it isn't in China. Of course America has multinationals jockeying for global power, but that doesn't reflect how the voters think.
I can say as one data point if Alabama wanted to secede, I would probably be indifferent. I would likely be of the mind: "If that's what they want, fine."
Edit: Also, a bit of a distinction that undercuts the premise of Hong Kong being similar to a US state secession: We've not onboarded any new states as recently as Hong Kong being reunified (to a limited degree) with China. We have used Alabama in this thread, but perhaps a better metaphor is Guam wanting to be free of American entanglements. Again, I would be indifferent.
Sorry, you're probably right. I confess I'm not really aware of the exact difference. I meant the general feeling of "America is the best", which I think is pretty undeniable, at least as the rest of the world experiences it. My point was to contrast it with the Chinese, who have the exact same feeling.
Maaaaybe if you look at the Project for the New American Century with the right lens.
Maybe not colonial in a ~legal sense, but some of the deals they're doing with weaker countries seem designed to grant them significant power.
For the record, I believe in American exceptionalism (to me it's fairly self-evident) but not in a modern "manifest destiny".
>Manifest destiny was a widely held belief in the 19th century United States that its settlers were destined to expand across North America.
The average American does not think that America should expand any further throughout the world, nor do they think that America has an irresistible duty to remake the world in its image. The theme of "the special virtues of the American people and their institutions" is only one part of the definition of manifest destiny.
Also, if you've ever read an HN thread on public mass transit, I think there is evidence against the claim that Americans think that all of their institutions are the best in the world.
You are trying to paint a portrait of Americans in general that is flagrantly false.
Much evidence points to the sentiment that the US behaves like a modern-day Rome and has attempted (or is attempting) to achieve “Pax Americana” globally. Again, not necessarily a bad concept as the world could always use more stability.
Many people explicitly hate this and want to see money diverted from that to stuff like education, etc.
Americans aren't one singular unit that agree on issues, especially things like foreign policy.
I'm not even saying the US overseas forces are bad. They've been misused, yes, but I don't want to argue about that - it's complicated. To disclaim America's outsize global ambitions, however - for whatever purpose - is just laughable.
In fact I hear more about Cascadia or Texas seceding than I do about the USA adding new states or territories.
(at least that's the feeling I get from reading the comments here, I could be wrong, just hoping to clarify)
At least in North American high schools we are taught pretty thoroughly that Nationalism was the root cause of both WW1 and WW2.
I’m Canadian and while we are proud to be Canadian, Nationalism is looked at very skeptically and Nationalism for its own sake would make me think the person preaching it is uneducated.
The biggest different in metaphor is: -> state/city want something vs -> State/city doesn't want something removed.
The origin of the manifest is due to HK losing some of its autonomy, it was a condition unique to it, it's not someone wanting to be special, it's someone special not wanting to be normal. There is a very huge difference in mental state.
No, I'm definitely not. Manifest destiny is just colonialism fueled by racism
>Some alabamans post an app on the app store so they can avoid the national guard. It's linked to secessionist alabamans avoiding and even attacking the guard. Apple takes it down, then puts it back up, then takes it back down
>"Good" you say.
No, I certainly wouldn't
There is no analogy within the US for Hongkong because the US have always been sucking in territory since they were founded, and never had any territory taken away.
A similar situation would be if the Japanese Navy had forced the US to sign the Cape Cod area, or parts of Long Island over to Japan, and then imagine what Americans would think of that.
Public opinion surveys in Hong Kong show the overwhelming majority of respondents aren't asking for independence. The five demands that are the crux of the current protests don't involve independence. They center on China holding up its end of the "One Country, Two Systems" arrangement by allowing genuine democratic elections in Hong Kong, as guaranteed to them under the Basic Law.
The fact that Chinese authorities are lying to their own people about the nature of the protests in Hong Kong is significant. They are terrified of 'contagion'. But since we're discussing this on an American site, we can state the plain facts of the matter, too.
This is the problem though, that the CCP can strongarm corporations into these decisions. China poses a huge risk to any company that does a lot of business or does production there. Today it's just pulling an App, but what is it tomorrow?
In the states this risk is predictable: The FBI can demand what it wants, and Apple refuses when they can, because they know they can weather a legal challenge. The risk is NOT predictable in the case of China: the government can demand what they want, and Apple's only choices are to play along or run home and tank the company. If things sour between nations, who knows what ultimatum is next.
Moreover this unpredictable risk spills over into a chilling effect: to avoid even receiving an ultimatum, Apple and any other company will bend over backwards to always be in the good graces of the government.
Everyone here seems to be up in arms about an NBA exec having to retract a tweet, but the US is throwing its weight around in much more damaging ways at the moment. The entire country of Iran is being economically strangled at the moment, based on the sole, arbitrary decision of the US President, but nobody seems to care too much.
There is a very real risk to me, an American, that the products or services sold to me by an American corporation will be degraded or changed at the request of the CCP in exchange for that corporations continued access to the Chinese market
Does that clear things up?
Millions of Europeans are now affected by the American Huawei ban, which risks degrading the phones that they bought. This is far more serious than any impact China's actions with regards to the NBA, Apple, etc. have had. How anyone can say that an NBA exec having to retract a tweet is more serious than Huawei's CFO being imprisoned and the company cut off from virtually all their international suppliers is beyond me.
> nobody seems to care too much
I explained this is because Americans doing business with American companies are not affected by the things you describe. you're the only one ascribing values like "is more serious than Huaweis CEO being imprisoned", I never said that and I didn't see anybody else in this thread even mention Huawei
So while these threads on China regularly draw huge numbers of comments all but calling for war with China, the much more serious, arbitrary actions by the sitting US President are met mostly with approval in these forums.
I don't really know how that's related at all to my original post, but sure the trade war has massively affected the worldwide economy, and business leaders are well aware (watch the stock market jump and dive every time big T reaches for his phone)
My original post is just adding that business leaders need to also be aware that China is more than willing to put companies between a rock and a hard place - stick with your morals and risk your China business, or give up your values and risk a PR disaster (see Blizzard). Business leaders need to price in this risk, much as they already price in the risk of tariffs, sanctions, etc. If US customers start to care about HK or Taiwan or Tibet or Xinjiang, that's an immediate and new risk to companies that feel pressured to censor themselves
To put it another way - when gay marriage became popular in the states, companies began to proudly advertise rainbow branded products. What happens if support for HK protests reaches that level of popularity? Companies with mainland presence get dabbed on
That dichotomy is not borne out by the facts. So far in this trade war, capricious actions by the US government have done far more damage to businesses than such actions by the Chinese government. China has yet to pull anything of the magnitude of the Huawei ban. That's not to say they definitely won't in the future, but so far, they've held back, so as not to scare off foreign businesses.
If you want to make an American analogy, it's more like if Puerto Rico wanted independence from the US. Because the US kept violating it's citizens human rights.
That said Hong Kong is a fairly unique situation that doesn't accurately compare to any others in recent history.
Puerto Rico is not a better analogy. It's never been America proper and it's not even connected to the mainland.
HK was China, it was occupied by force for a hundred years and now China has got it back. As far as China is concerned HK is China and that's the end of it.
My analogy was flawed, yes, but nitpicking it doesn't really change the basic facts. I note that no-one is arguing that the Chinese don't think like I said.
(HN doesnt' apparently allow me to "delete" it, so I apologize for the edit.)
america is not a unified bloc, internally. nor does it aspire to be. the differences between a city in massachusetts and a city in louisiana are greater than the differences between a city in massachusetts and a city in ontario -- and ontario's in a different country altogether. in other words, social and cultural distance between two regions in the US can be significantly higher than the cultural distance from one region in the US to another country. i do not think the same principle applies to china. for china, its neighbors are decidedly alien, so the cultural distance between regions within china seems very small in comparison, even if in reality it is substantial.
to return to the OP's example: if alabama tried to secede, i'd be fine with letting them go. heck, i'd be glad they even tried to leave, because it would make a credible threat to the federal government that other states would follow along and also secede if things didn't improve promptly.
i wouldn't wish them success though, because knowing that it's alabama, i would assume that their reasons for secession were incompatible with my vision for the country. in other words, if a state liek alabama really tried to secede, my position would be that they probably weren't going to be compatible with the best iteration of america anyway -- perhaps because they'd come off as a neo-confederate or something similarly regrettable.
but in principle, i don't think i would support efforts to stop them leaving or claiming more rights. i'd prefer apple to not handicap them to appease the federal government, even if i don't like the alabamans or their values very much. why?
because i understand that a restriction targeting them today will be used against me tomorrow. and i resent the idea that a private company can dictate what my hardware runs, especially retroactively.
The confusion is why the party is so insecure about their position that they need to lash out in seemingly childish ways like this. I think the difference is cultural here.
>Let me explain how Chinese people think about HK
Do you mean all Chinese people?
Of course I can't know the inner secrets of a billion minds, but it's my genuine belief that what I wrote is at least mostly in the right direction.
Does the majority have complete information on the matter?
I'm just some guy who has, or think I have, a little more access to "chinese thought" than I commonly see around here. I thought it would be useful or at least interesting to bring up a perspective I don't see commonly shared, not endorsing it, just tabling it for consideration. Answering questions such as yours is above my pay grade.
No, it isn't. Hence why Peter Thiel's statement regarding freedom and democracy being incompatible is not as controversial as some people pretend.
Go Alabama.
It's pretty simple: China claims territories that were part of the Qing dynasty until 1911, and internationally recognized as such (except outer Mongolia). Tibet was never internationally recognized as an independent country, and both the PRC and ROC have consistently maintained that it is part of China. That was also the internationally accepted legal view. The PRC and ROC agree that Taiwan is part of China - they just disagree about what "China" is. The PRC and ROC both resented British control over Hong Kong, which is understandable, given that it was taken in the Opium Wars.
I wish people discussing the issues here knew the basic background. The idea that China is trying to gobble up territory, and will next try to annex Vietnam or Laos is just not supported by the historical facts. China's position on territory is pretty clear and has been consistent over time.
Why not let Hong Kong be independent? What moral claim does mainland China have to the territory over the people who live there? If China is so superior and resents Hong Kong then they are better off without it.
None of which changes the facts that China owns and shares a land border with HK, China is 200x bigger than HK, and might makes right.
Let me explain how Chinese people think about HK, since none of them ever seem to explain it on a site like this.
Imagine you are a middle class American. Maybe you are but if not, just imagine, tech city on the east or west coast. You're pretty invested in being an American, skin in the game, manifest destiny etc. Very good. They call this tianxia by the way, basically Chinese manifest destiny.
Let's say one day some stupid little state that you don't care about and vaguely resent decides it wants to secede, wants all these rights others don't have, wants to be able to marry its cousins or make nukes at home or whatever. Alabama, say. Alabama wants to secede and they have some demonstrations. You think: "hahahaha no"
They keep demonstrating. The larger country talks about sending in the national guard or something. "Good, who do they think they are" you say.
Some alabamans post an app on the app store so they can avoid the national guard. It's linked to secessionist alabamans avoiding and even attacking the guard. Apple takes it down, then puts it back up, then takes it back down
"Good" you say.
This is how, conservatively, 90%+ of Chinese think. For them, HK is a tiny little past-glory city who thinks it's better than everyone else and is just causing trouble. They will eventually be brought into line, hopefully without too much bloodshed, just like Alabama. It's not really malicious. It's a province of China - it's misbehaving, and it will be brought into line in due course. Nothing more, nothing less.
I expect someone explained these truths to Apple, they saw the futility of taking some hopeless, simplistic, you-don't-even-live-here side, decided this was not the hill they wanted to die on, and pulled the app. I don't blame them.
I'd like to note that I do not support the Chinese Govt in any way and think the world would be a better place with an independent, democratic HK - a city I genuinely love. The Chinese have about as much chance agreeing with that as Americans would about an independent Alabama. Not going to happen.