News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store by helen___keller on Thursday October 10, 2019 @10:28AM (#21214886)
> they saw the futility of taking some hopeless, simplistic, you-don't-even-live-here side, decided this was not the hill they wanted to die on, and pulled the app

This is the problem though, that the CCP can strongarm corporations into these decisions. China poses a huge risk to any company that does a lot of business or does production there. Today it's just pulling an App, but what is it tomorrow?

In the states this risk is predictable: The FBI can demand what it wants, and Apple refuses when they can, because they know they can weather a legal challenge. The risk is NOT predictable in the case of China: the government can demand what they want, and Apple's only choices are to play along or run home and tank the company. If things sour between nations, who knows what ultimatum is next.

Moreover this unpredictable risk spills over into a chilling effect: to avoid even receiving an ultimatum, Apple and any other company will bend over backwards to always be in the good graces of the government.

Re:Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store by DiogenesKynikos on Thursday October 10, 2019 @01:05PM (#21216860)
There's also the risk that the US President might unilaterally ban American corporations from doing any business with you. Through secondary sanctions, that ban will extend to corporations around the world. The US has arbitrarily cut off entire countries from the world market, including Iran and Venezuela, and it has cut off individual corporations as well, including Huawei and ZTE.

Everyone here seems to be up in arms about an NBA exec having to retract a tweet, but the US is throwing its weight around in much more damaging ways at the moment. The entire country of Iran is being economically strangled at the moment, based on the sole, arbitrary decision of the US President, but nobody seems to care too much.

Re:Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store by helen___keller on Thursday October 10, 2019 @01:59PM (#21217417)
No, I don't think there's any risk to Americans or American corporations that the president will unilaterally ban American corporations from doing business with me, an American

There is a very real risk to me, an American, that the products or services sold to me by an American corporation will be degraded or changed at the request of the CCP in exchange for that corporations continued access to the Chinese market

Does that clear things up?

Re:Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store by DiogenesKynikos on Thursday October 10, 2019 @05:41PM (#21219471)
But they may very well ban you from doing business with a foreign company, for completely arbitrary and opaque reasons. You may be suddenly told that you have to break off relations with your largest customer, or a product you own may suddenly lose important functionality.

Millions of Europeans are now affected by the American Huawei ban, which risks degrading the phones that they bought. This is far more serious than any impact China's actions with regards to the NBA, Apple, etc. have had. How anyone can say that an NBA exec having to retract a tweet is more serious than Huawei's CFO being imprisoned and the company cut off from virtually all their international suppliers is beyond me.

Re:Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store by helen___keller on Friday October 11, 2019 @09:20AM (#21224044)
In your earlier post you said

> nobody seems to care too much

I explained this is because Americans doing business with American companies are not affected by the things you describe. you're the only one ascribing values like "is more serious than Huaweis CEO being imprisoned", I never said that and I didn't see anybody else in this thread even mention Huawei

Re:Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store by DiogenesKynikos on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:08AM (#21225090)
Chinese people doing business with Chinese companies aren't affected by these sorts of things either. By restricting the discussion in that way, you're evading what you must know is the main point of what I'm saying: people doing business have been much more heavily affected, so far in this trade war, by arbitrary actions of the US President than of the Chinese government. This applies equally to American businesspeople. The ban on doing business with Huawei, for example, has wiped out billions of dollars in revenue from the balance sheets of American companies.

So while these threads on China regularly draw huge numbers of comments all but calling for war with China, the much more serious, arbitrary actions by the sitting US President are met mostly with approval in these forums.

Re:Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store by helen___keller on Friday October 11, 2019 @11:28AM (#21225300)
> people doing business have been much more heavily affected, so far in this trade war, by arbitrary actions of the US President than of the Chinese government.

I don't really know how that's related at all to my original post, but sure the trade war has massively affected the worldwide economy, and business leaders are well aware (watch the stock market jump and dive every time big T reaches for his phone)

My original post is just adding that business leaders need to also be aware that China is more than willing to put companies between a rock and a hard place - stick with your morals and risk your China business, or give up your values and risk a PR disaster (see Blizzard). Business leaders need to price in this risk, much as they already price in the risk of tariffs, sanctions, etc. If US customers start to care about HK or Taiwan or Tibet or Xinjiang, that's an immediate and new risk to companies that feel pressured to censor themselves

To put it another way - when gay marriage became popular in the states, companies began to proudly advertise rainbow branded products. What happens if support for HK protests reaches that level of popularity? Companies with mainland presence get dabbed on

Re:Apple Removes HKmap.live from the App Store by DiogenesKynikos on Friday October 11, 2019 @02:31PM (#21227064)
Your original comment set up a dichotomy between China and the US: businesses have to be wary of arbitrary Chinese government actions, but can count on predictable, fair treatment in the US.

That dichotomy is not borne out by the facts. So far in this trade war, capricious actions by the US government have done far more damage to businesses than such actions by the Chinese government. China has yet to pull anything of the magnitude of the Huawei ban. That's not to say they definitely won't in the future, but so far, they've held back, so as not to scare off foreign businesses.