News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by latchkey on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:09AM (#21143597)
Samsung already makes most of their phones in Vietnam. Not a huge difference, other than the lack of tariffs.

https://www.economist.com/asia/2018/04/12/why-samsung-of-sou...

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by hardwaresofton on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:23AM (#21143681)
I wonder why more producers haven't made this move? If Vietnam is there as far as infrastructure goes and they have the skilled/unskilled labor why is this not a more popular move.

Also when we say "make" I assume we mean "assembles".

Somewhat anecdotally I recently purchased a laptop and tried to find one that wasn't made in China and it was nigh on impossible.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by latchkey on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:37AM (#21143764)
I'm a tech expat living in Vietnam (from Bay Area) for the last 4 years. This is a really loaded question. You have to look into the politics of the VN govt, especially related to the fact that it is on the northern end of VN, closer to Hanoi... which has different politics than in the south.

I've been to Hai Phong, which is the city in the north near the China border where most of this commerce happens. It is fascinating to see how big the houses are there. If you drive along the road to the airport it is literally filled with old men riding their nice shiny new bicycles and exercising by the side of the road.

The tariffs definitely have people looking into Vietnam a lot more. I've driven (motorbike) the dirt backroads near the Chinese border where there is nothing but trees and mountains. There are literally trucks brining goods into and out of Vietnam (illegally) on hastily constructed dirt roads. You can see it in google maps even. I've seen how people have strung cables over rivers between China and Vietnam to ferry goods back and forth. So yea... it is happening, it just isn't hitting the news much. It is also happening in Cambodia and Laos. Look into the roads China is building and how Sihanouk is a literal Chinese eco disaster.

Fascinating times...

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by dageshi on Thursday October 03, 2019 @11:41AM (#21148274)
I visited Sihanoukville 11 years ago and 2 years ago. It's like a bomb of chinese money went off, that place is going to be the next las vegas/macau.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by tootie on Thursday October 03, 2019 @08:56AM (#21146415)
I don't doubt it, but there must be a very limited throughput. They can't be shipping even 1% of China's output over dirt roads.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by selimthegrim on Thursday October 03, 2019 @09:32AM (#21146718)
Sihanoukville you mean
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by AFascistWorld on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:58AM (#21144142)
You can pay something like 50 RMB for them to motorbike you through the jungles into Cambodia or Loas (illegally) without any questions asked.

There are also illegal but protected casinos near the Vietnam-China border entry, that only allow in Chinese nationals.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by latchkey on Thursday October 03, 2019 @02:50AM (#21144388)
I did it myself. Even stood on the literal border of Vietnam and China. ;-) That is China in the distance and VN is building a wall of some sort. The road that you see is filled with trucks carrying stuff. Last picture is one of the dirt border backroads I was driving on... pretty epic trip.

I also drove into Laos near the north side and all through it as well. The amount of Chinese influence in Laos is overwhelming.

https://imgur.com/a/WGWv9kr

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by tooltalk on Thursday October 03, 2019 @03:59AM (#21144697)
> Also when we say "make" I assume we mean "assembles".

Well, it's a bit more than that. While Samsung imports many parts and "assembles" all final products in Vietnam, there are also 200 suppliers and contractors who relocated and "make" their parts in Vietnam.

Vietnam in pre-Samsung era was largely known for low-tech textile export. There wasn't a lot of infrastructure to support Samsung's smartphone operation in Vietnam. Samsung not only had to work with the Vietnamese gov't to create the industrial infrastructure that didn't exist, but the company also had to convince suppliers/contractors to set up shops in Vietnam.

Samsung's products now accounts for about 1/3 of Vietnam's overall export.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by shp0ngle on Thursday October 03, 2019 @07:31AM (#21145781)
One problem in Vietnam is that it really does NOT have the infrastructure that China has. (Just look at the state of public transport in China vs Vietnam.)

It's better than Laos/Cambodia, but the streets are now flooded with cars far more than even 1 year ago, and the traffic is becoming a huge issue.

And right now, with all the new factories, Vietnam is suddenly almost as polluted as China. (Just recently we have record AQI numbers here.) But of course rich countries don't care about that, as long as the phones are cheap...

All in all, people are happy, since it helps their bottom line. But the infrastructure is not there yet to beat China.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by krageon on Thursday October 03, 2019 @07:48AM (#21145889)
I am not sure why it is up to "rich countries" to fix Vietnam's pollution problem. Do not allow the building of factories that pollute a lot and it will get better. This is something Vietnam can do on it's own. Absolutely zero foreign interference required.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by netsharc on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:37PM (#21148897)
That's a bit simplistic... "Mr. Tim Apple, we have 2 options to build the next iPhone factory, Vietnam and Laos. They're almost identical, except Vietnam will cost 5% more because of their anti-pollution laws.". What would you do in Tim Apple's position?

Nike stopped using child labour because of (Western) public outcry, without it they'd go for the factory offering the cheapest price. Next you'll say, then it's up to the Vietnamese to have a public outcry about pollution. But corrupt governments seem to have a way to get away with anything, just look at the Dakota pipeline, or arctic drilling...

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by oblio on Thursday October 03, 2019 @10:56AM (#21147752)
Easy for you to say. Not so easy for really poor people.

Rich countries can help: for example Western companies can mandate that all their suppliers, for their entire chains, down to natural resources, have low levels of pollution.

Vietnam and other countries like it will have to comply, in order to sell their products.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by whoevercares on Thursday October 03, 2019 @10:11AM (#21147129)
Wait aren’t we talking about an popular initiative to move all factories to Vietnam??
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by zwayhowder on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:49AM (#21144110)
Go to Japan. A number of Panasonic, Fujitsu & Sony laptops are made there that are only ever sold in the domestic market because of the high costs. Though for the build quality they are still not too bad in terms of value.

Of course their displays and RAM are probably made in Korea or China as are the SSDs and I've never pulled one apart to check the motherboard and battery providence...

However they are definitely assembled in Japan.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by SmellyGeekBoy on Thursday October 03, 2019 @06:13AM (#21145344)
Japan's economy fascinates me. The vast majority of the cars you see on the roads, computers in offices, TVs in hotel rooms, cameras in people's hands etc are Japanese. Amazing self-sufficiency in a world where globalisation is becoming the norm. Japanese-made products are also pretty universally considered to be very well designed and built, too.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by tooltalk on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:54PM (#21149086)

  It would have been fascinating to study Japan in the 80's, but now really sure they are still "self-sufficient." 

  Japan's auto industry is still strong, but their future largely depends on impending trade deal with Trump. Their tech/semiconductor industry has been in decline the past 30 years and what little remains today are being sold to Chinese/Taiwanese companies bit by bit. Japanese brands like SONY or Panasonic now accounts for less than 10% of the US market now, replaced by mostly Koreans like Samsung and LG in high-end, and by Chinese by TCL in low-end markets. The consumer camera business is still dominated by Japanese companies, but the business itself is in a crisis as the market, which peaked in 2013, continues to dive by 30% - 60% annually last several years.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by CDSlice on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:19PM (#21149391)
To make this comment readable on mobile:

It would have been fascinating to study Japan in the 80's, but now really sure they are still "self-sufficient."

Japan's auto industry is still strong, but their future largely depends on impending trade deal with Trump. Their tech/semiconductor industry has been in decline the past 30 years and what little remains today are being sold to Chinese/Taiwanese companies bit by bit. Japanese brands like SONY or Panasonic now accounts for less than 10% of the US market now, replaced by mostly Koreans like Samsung and LG in high-end, and by Chinese by TCL in low-end markets. The consumer camera business is still dominated by Japanese companies, but the business itself is in a crisis as the market, which peaked in 2013, continues to dive by 30% - 60% annually last several years.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by esailija on Thursday October 03, 2019 @08:10AM (#21146046)
Yeah raw materials and parts just fall magically out of the sky, as long as you do the final assembly (and sometimes not even that, sometimes only packaging a product is needed for "made in x") yourself then you are self-reliant.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by FillardMillmore on Thursday October 03, 2019 @09:53AM (#21146930)
No need for the heavy sarcasm - why not just point out the nebulousness of what 'Made in [Country]' means or provide some sources that give a more detailed look at Japan's manufacturing base so we all don't need to make assumptions?
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by nrp on Thursday October 03, 2019 @03:30AM (#21144568)
The RAM is fabbed in either South Korea (SK Hynix or Samsung) or the US (Micron), but Sharp, JDI, and to a lesser extent Panasonic still fab LCDs in Japan (though like the DRAM packaging, the display module assembly process may be in China).
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by simonh on Thursday October 03, 2019 @04:12AM (#21144760)
Assembling in China gets you credit with the Chinese government, which is useful to gain political protection and freer access to the Chinese market. But Samsung is getting squeezed out of the Chinese market, so that's not a big plus for them anymore.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by ksec on Friday October 04, 2019 @07:42AM (#21156633)
I am somewhat surprised I am 24 hours and 175 comments late and yet no one has mentioned what I thought was the answer.

Samsung is an extreme vertically integrated company. As far as I am aware there isn't any other company on the planet that is remotely close to this level of integration. Not even Cargrill.

Samsung doesn't just make Display, NAND/ DRAM / Battery, Assembly, Controllers, MEMS, SoC, Foundry but also down to the Chemicals and Materials as well as actual assembly. Think of it as 80% of the whole Shenzhen Ecosystem.

So while other companies have difficulties moving off that Shenzhen Ecosystem, the reality is Samsung was never part of it. Samsung Mobile is the front line to drive all volumes for each of its subsidiary to a sustainable level, before these subsidiary graduate to start selling to third parties. For Samsung, it is only a matter of government signing an agreement to tariffs, clean water, electricity and all these basic infrastructure. And if the government have trouble getting those up, not to worry, you could paid Samsung and Samsung will built those for you ( Samsung is also a construction company ) and promise to hire enough local workers.

This is in deep contrast to Apple which doesn't actually own any part of the supply chain.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by tanilama on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:57AM (#21143869)
Because most major manufacturers are mainly Chinese now(Huawei/Xiaomi/Oppo), and China is the NO1 market, why leave China?

Samsung had been irrelevant in China for some years now, like below 1% market share. It just can't compete

US is by far the only market that Chinese phones haven't dominated, but that is for a reason. Buying an Android in US there has surprising limited choices, Samsung/OnePlus/Pixel in that Order, and that is it. It is Duoploy either Samsung or iPhone, and others don't play.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by creddit on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:15AM (#21143945)
Right. The US only. Well, also Japan. Also, Korea. I guess also much of Europe too. Or Canada. But, yeah other than that. Which I guess is really just India and China. So I guess the reason is median/mean income??
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by Illniyar on Thursday October 03, 2019 @03:58AM (#21144688)
To be fair India and China makes up almost 40% of the world population.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by tanilama on Thursday October 03, 2019 @04:08AM (#21144740)
https://www.counterpointresearch.com/global-smartphone-share...

Adding Huawei+Xiaomi+Oppo+Vivo alone counts 45% of the world smart share already, by units, and the others consisting ZTE/Lenovo and other Chinese brands as well. Safe to say the Chinese phones are already 50% of all phones shipped.

Yes, it is pretty dominating. Had not for the Trump ban, Huawei would probably dethrone Samsung in EU as well, according to analysis in Feb

https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/14/18224614/huawei-chinese-p...

As a gadget enthusiasts, though overall the phone innovation is slowing down, but at least Chinese brands are the fewer left there to churn out marketable features, like those monstrous cameras and tricks to hide it. Apple and Samsung are just being lazy there, with incremental upgrade which command a premium

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by creddit on Thursday October 03, 2019 @07:17AM (#21145708)
You said "US is by far the only market that Chinese phones haven't dominated"

So Chinese phone manufacturers making up 1/3 of the European market, as per your link, is them dominating it??? Chinese phones don't dominate worldwide in the sense of geography. They dominate worldwide in the sense of units because they are the low margin, budget phone manufacturers supplying lower income parts of the world. Not a bad place to be, but doesn't remotely support your assertion above that the US is the only market they don't dominate. That's obviously wrong just from your own sources.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by oblio on Thursday October 03, 2019 @11:02AM (#21147836)
While you're partially right, I wouldn't look at the smartphone sales trends if I were you... Chinese phones were at something like 1% 5 years ago and now they're at 45%. There's also not much sign of them slowing down.

Samsung was basically saved from being overtaken by Huawei as #1 by Trump's ban.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by tracker1 on Thursday October 03, 2019 @04:16PM (#21151647)
The higher end Huawei devices were nearly as good, but significantly lower priced, or better for similar pricing. Was actually considering a Matebook as a future laptop purchase in a year or so.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by coldtea on Thursday October 03, 2019 @08:39AM (#21146256)
>So Chinese phone manufacturers making up 1/3 of the European market, as per your link, is them dominating it???

Considering that a lot or most of the iPhones and Samsung phones sold (well, before the moving out) were also made in China, yes. The 1/3 you mention are just the Chinese brands....

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by tooltalk on Thursday October 03, 2019 @09:17PM (#21153987)
Apple iPhone, yes, they are made in China; most Samsung phones were made in Vietnam by 2017 and on. So no.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by roneythomas6 on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:27AM (#21144001)
I assume this has to do with carriers. Most people buy their phones from carriers in Canadia, US and Japan. What carriers subsidize dictates the market. In other markets like India where most customers use prepaid plans they get their phones directly from phone manufacturer.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by duxup on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:43AM (#21143789)
I think Samsung and their partners have the funds to make a full shift far more capably compared to companies who operate in China, or their manufacturer is in China... and don't have the resources / have their own concerns about leaving China.

Also who knows how long Samsung has been working on such things.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by avocado4 on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:28AM (#21143711)
It takes time to move supply chains.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by hardwaresofton on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:31AM (#21143724)
Right but Samsung didn't start yesterday either -- I'm surprised news of Samsung starting to move their production (whenever that started) didn't spur other companies to move.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by fauigerzigerk on Thursday October 03, 2019 @03:43AM (#21144630)
And crucially, it takes more time than imposing new tariffs.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by fortran77 on Thursday October 03, 2019 @10:41AM (#21147540)
It is a big difference if you care about fairer trade partners.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by desdiv on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:11AM (#21143933)
There should be more push back against goods made in non-democratic countries like Vietnam, and not just against Made-in-China.

My previous phone was a Samsung Galaxy S5 and I was surprised to find out that it was made in Korea. Manufacturing in Korea certainly didn't seem to harm Samsung's financial prospects back then, and the phone wasn't any more expensive than its Made-in-China competitors. I have zero reservations about South Korea's workers' rights protections, workplace health and safety, and environmental regulations.

Too often the discussion becomes:

1. We shouldn't manufacture in China

2. We can't afford to manufacture in US/EU

3. Let's just manufacture in Vietnam/Cambodia/Myanmar instead

When it should be:

a. We shouldn't manufacture in non-democratic countries

b. Let's manufacture in democratic countries instead

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by spats1990 on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:30AM (#21144014)
>I have zero reservations about South Korea's workers' rights protections, workplace health and safety, and environmental regulations.

Well, Samsung only just apologised last year to workers for some unusually high rates of cancer among workers at its (local) semiconductor and display factories[1]. It took ten years or more to go through the Korean courts. In general, Korea's industrial death/injury rates are very high compared to Western countries.[2] Workplace health for workers in Korea's electronics industry in general does not appear great, to say the least.[3] Finally, Samsung's treatment of workers in its Vietnam factories is, by most accounts, subpar at best.[4]

I live in Korea and I've been here for about four years. (Note that if we were to cover something outside tech/electronics, like construction, the workplace health and safety situation in Korea would appear even more dismal). I think I've dumped enough links already, but without adding more I will agree that legal protections for workers are quite strong in Korea at the base level, but they are often blatantly disregarded or skirted around by employers.

[1] https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/11/samsung-electronics-a...

[2]https://www.ft.com/content/57c76820-d3f0-11e7-8c9a-d9c0a5c8d...

[3]https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25938673

[4]https://ipen.org/news/samsung-workers-line%c2%a0unique-repor...

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by slimsag on Thursday October 03, 2019 @03:30AM (#21144567)
Interesting! It sounds like South Korean worker rights are a little below US/EU ones, but still far superior to the completely lacking ones in China/Vietnam/Cambodia/Myanmar? Or is that wrong?
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by spats1990 on Thursday October 03, 2019 @04:02AM (#21144711)
Sounds about right, but I can't properly speak to US/EU ones, and definitely can't speak properly about worker rights in those other Asian/SE Asian countries. I think we'd probably all agree that EU ones are some of the best. I would guess that generally Korean worker rights are better than the ones in those Asian countries. (The growing foreign labour force in Korea, mostly for manual labour and factories, and mostly from SE Asia and China, might disagree, as they often fall into the same migrant labour trap that exists in other developed countries.)

Some things that I think are good about Korean labour law/rights:

-No at-will employment: employers must have a solid reason for firing somebody (misconduct, financial loss, crippling lack of company funds). In practice, this is often skirted through social pressure, i.e. employees encouraged openly to quit, or having their working lives turned into quiet hells until they quit to get away. If a person is fired they must be given either 30 days' notice or 30 days' salary.

-"Pension"/severance pay: all full-time workers accumulate a month's salary for each year worked at a company. Legally this must be paid out within 14 days after leaving a position. My own (Western) country has nothing like this, and I think it's especially good for the Korean context where a person might work for LG, Samsung, or Hyundai for twenty years, then be eased out right when their kids are starting university. Often, they can't find other whitecollar jobs. Every second or third cabbie I talk to in Seoul used to work for one of the big Korean firms. So the severance gives people a bit of a buffer if they randomly get fired or have to quit.

-Strong state-funded healthcare and social safety net.

Two less-good things:

-Koreans famously work some of the longest hours in the OECD, and it's usually overtime that people find it impossible, culturally, to say no to. The government legislated against it this year (all work beyond 8 hours per day and 40 hours per week to be defined as overtime, with time and a half paid for overtime and a maximum of 12 extra hours per week allowed) so hopefully things are going to slowly change there. In practice, people still seem to be working tons of overtime (for which they should be paid extra) without reporting it, but the law is still new.

-Minimum number of leave days per year is around 11-12 for the first year of employment and could be higher. In practice, corporate culture often limits peoples' freedoms around when they can take leave. Lack of separate sick days is common: people have to either use a leave day, or work sick.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by puranjay on Thursday October 03, 2019 @03:27AM (#21144550)
If it helps, most large brands do take efforts to ensure that their factories and manufacturing partners adopt safety and worker rights measures. Ikea, for instance, forced one of its Indian manufacturing partners to start an on-premise school for its workers' children. It also delayed production by a nearly year to ensure that the supplier could meet all its safety regulations.

I've seen this first hand in Ludhiana, India. I know the narrative from the Nike sweat shop days still holds, but large brands are very aware of the backlash they could face and make efforts to improve working conditions wherever they can. If you're a worker in say, India, you're better off working at a factory affiliated with Ikea than one selling to local brands.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by pjmlp on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:55AM (#21144128)
That doesn't work out because:

1. Every country is susceptible to change government at any time

2. Corporations are in the game for profit, everything else is a kind of nice to have

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by shp0ngle on Thursday October 03, 2019 @07:33AM (#21145792)
Democratic countries cost too much money, since they value environment and worker rights too much.

People say they support human rights and environment, but then they still go for the price.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by tomatotomato37 on Thursday October 03, 2019 @09:14AM (#21146538)
We really need to get rid of the concept of optimal human capital in globalism; focusing the world's battery production in a country with a ton of lithium or whatever is fine, but playing the musical chairs of shit labor & environmental laws so companies can gain more money they aren't going to spend in your country anyway is not
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by notimetorelax on Thursday October 03, 2019 @02:50AM (#21144382)
In my mind this thinking is no better than isolationist thinking of those countries. Bringing business to those countries is the best way to improve living conditions of the workers and expose them to the better world.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by ahartmetz on Thursday October 03, 2019 @05:44AM (#21145194)
It's even better to bring business and good treatment of workers. Your argument is not wrong, but it's sometimes used to defend sweatshop practices.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by meruru on Thursday October 03, 2019 @02:37AM (#21144334)
China is particularly problematic because they are huge and powerful. I agree it would be better to use democratic countries instead, but since that's not gonna happen, I'm glad companies are at least moving to smaller countries.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by aritmo on Thursday October 03, 2019 @05:52AM (#21145231)
As long as the Electoral College is there, the US is not democratic either.
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by taneq on Thursday October 03, 2019 @01:24AM (#21143988)
> My previous phone was a Samsung Galaxy S5 and I was surprised to find out that it was made in Korea.

Samsung is a Korean company so it's not that weird that they should manufacture things there.

Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by ralusek on Thursday October 03, 2019 @02:45AM (#21144367)
They meant that they were surprised it wasn't outsourced manufacturing. They know it's a Korean company...
Re:Samsung ends mobile phone production in China by ganfortran on Thursday October 03, 2019 @02:24AM (#21144273)
Nah, company only manufacture in cheap countries.