AGI is a scientific problem of the hardest kind, not an engineering problem where you just use existing knowledge to build better and better things.
Marving Minsky once said that in mathematics just five axioms is enough to provide the amount of complexity that overwhelms the best minds for centuries. AGI could be messy practical problem that depends on 10 or 25 fundamental 'axioms' that work together to produce general intelligence. "I bet the human brain is a kludge." - Marvin Minsky
The idea that if many people think this problem very hard, the problem is solved in our lifetime is prevalent. It's not true in math and physics, so why would AI be any different? Progress is made but you can't know if there is breakthrough tomorrow or if it happens 100 years from now. Just adding more computational capability is not going to solve AI.
Currently it's the engineering applications and the use of the science what is exploding and getting funded. In fact, I think some of the best brains are lured from the fundamental research into applied science with high pay and resources. What the current state of the art can do now has not been utilized fully in the economy and this brings in the investments and momentum.
Much of the take-aways from this year's North American International Auto Show was that the manufacturer's are reluctantly realizing the real scope of the problem and trying to temper expectations. [0]
And self-driving cars is still a problem orders of magnitude simpler than AGI.
[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/17/business/self-driving-aut...
If the self-driving car has no limits on versatility, then, given an oracle for solving the self-driving car problem, you could use that to build an agent that answers arbitrary YES-NO questions. Namely: feed the car fake input so it thinks it has driven to a fork in the road and there's a road-sign saying "If the answer to the following question is YES then the left road is closed, otherwise the right road is closed."
Compare with e.g. proofs that the C++ compiler is Turing complete. These proofs involve feeding the C++ compiler extremely unusual programs that would never actually come up organically. But that doesn't invalidate the proof that the C++ compiler is Turing complete.
"It has to be able to handle any possible conceivable scenario without human assistance" so people ask things like "will a self-driving car be able to change its own tyre in case of a flat" and "will a self-driving car be able to defend the Earth from an extraterrestrial invasion in order to get to its destination".
They need to update the official definition of level 5 to "must be able to handle any situation that an average human driver could reasonably handle without getting out of the vehicle."
(Although the "level 1" - "level 5" scale is a terrible way to describe autonomous vehicles in any case and needs to be replaced with a measure of how long it's safe for the vehicle to operate without human supervision.)
Self driving cars would realistically have to keep functioning in situations where arbitrary communication with humans is required (which happens daily), which tends to turn into an AI-hard problem quite quickly.
I was thinking in terms of "minimum viable product" for self-driving cars, which I have a hunch will be of limited versatility compared to what you describe. To have a truly self-driving car as capable as humans in most situations, you may be right.
Many cities choose to forego trains for busses in large part due to the lower upfront costs and the ability to change routes as the needs of the populace change.
You sure? It might very well be a single order of magnitude harder, or not any harder. Given that solving all the problems of self driving even delves into questions of ethics at times (who do I endanger in this lose lose situation, etc)
I actually don't think the ethics part is all that hard if (and that's a big if) there can be an agreement on a standard approach. An example would be a utilitarian model, but this often is not compatible with egalitarian ethics. This approach reeks of technocracy but it's certainly a solvable problem.
Neuroscience is full of problems of the hardest kind.
Also, seeing computers perform tasks they haven't done before can convince people that the model behind the scenes is closer to AGI than it really is. The fact that deep neural networks are very hard to decifer only furthers the mystical nature of the "intelligence" of the model.
Also, tasks like playing starcraft are very impressive, but are not very close to true AGI in my opinion. Perhaps theres a more formal definition that I'm not aware of, but in my mind, AGI is not being good at playing starcraft, AGI is deciding to learn to play starcraft in the first place.
That's my 2 cents, anyways.
The Greeks observed these limitations thousands of years ago. Below is an excerpt from Plato's "Theaetetus":
Socrates: That is certainly a frank and indeed a generous answer, my dear lad. I asked you for one thing [a definition of "knowledge"] and you have given me many; I wanted something simple, and I have got a variety.
Theaetetus: And what does that mean, Socrates?
Socrates: Nothing, I dare say. But I'll tell you what I think. When you talk about cobbling, you mean just knowledge of the making of shoes?
Theaetetus: Yes, that's all I mean by it.
Socrates: And when you talk about carpentering, you mean simply the knowledge of the making of wooden furniture?
Theaetetus: Yes, that's all I mean, again.
Socrates: And in both cases you are putting into your definition what the knowledge is of?
Theaetetus: Yes.
Socrates: But that is not what you were asked, Theaetetus. You were not asked to say what one may have knowledge of, or how many branches of knowledge there are. It was not with any idea of counting these up that the question was asked; we wanted to know what knowledge itself is.--Or am I talking nonsense?
The other one (also perhaps relevant to the general topic of this thread): WYSIATI (What You See Is All There Is).
When you read them, you will probably update in the direction of “AGI soon”. It’s possible that you won’t see what the big deal is, I suppose. I personally see what Carmack and others see, a feasible path to generality, and even some specific promising precursors to generality.
It also helps to be familiar with the most current cognitive neuroscience papers, but that’s asking a lot.
I'm going to be pessimistic and say that AGI is probably decades away (if not centuries away for a human-like AGI). There are clearly many biological aspects of the brain that we do not understand today, and likely will not be able to replicate without far more advanced medical imaging techniques.
Every action my brain takes is made of two components: (1) the desired outcome of the thought, and (2) the computation required to achieve that outcome. No matter how well computers can solve for 2, I have no idea how they'd manage solving for 1. This is because in order to think at all, I have to have a desire to think that thought, and that is a function of me being an organism that wants to live, eat, sleep, etc.
So for me, I just wonder how we're going to replicate volition itself. That's a vastly different, and vastly more complicated, problem.
Worrying about some apocalypse seems counterproductive to me.
But speaking of de novo, I'm not at all sure that a desire to think a thought it required in order to think. The opposite seems closer: the less one tries to think, the more one ends up thinking.
I'm pivoting from your point here, but I see that bit as the hurdle we're not close to overcoming. We are likely missing huge pieces of the puzzle when it comes to understanding human "intelligence" (and intelligence itself is not the full picture). With such a limited understanding, a replication or full superseding in the near future seems unlikely. Perhaps the blind spot of the experts, as /u/leftyted alluded to, is that their modest success so far has generated a reality-distorting hubris.
That means 0.01% of the timeline was all it took for us to differentiate ourselves from regular animals who aren't a threat to the planet.
0.01% of 100 years is 3 days.
DNA sequencing went from $3b per genome to $600, in about 30 years, much, much faster than Moore's "law".
Is that not what a computer is? We have continuously tried and failed to create machines that think, react, and learn like the brains of living things, and instead managed to create machines that manage to simulate or even surpass the capabilities of brains in some contexts, while still completely failing in others.
I'm kind of coming up with these numbers out of thin air, but as much of a legend as he is, I agree Carmack's estimate seems way too optimistic to me. It's possible, but unlikely to me.
That said:
>The emphasis on computational power also makes no sense to me. If we had infinite compute today, what steps would you take to build AGI? Does anyone have any good ideas about that?
In this interview with Lex Fridman and Greg Brockman, a co-founder of OpenAI, he says it's possible increasing the computational scale exponentially might really be enough to achieve AGIc: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bIrEM2FbOLU. (Can't remember where he said it exactly, but I think somewhere near the middle.) He's also making a lot of estimates I find overly optimistic, with about the same time horizon as Carmack's estimate.
As you say, it can be a little confusing, because both John Carmack and Greg Brockman are undoubtedly way more intelligent and experienced and knowledgeable than I am. But I think you're right and that it is a blindspot.
By contrast, this JRE podcast with someone else I consider intelligent, Naval Ravikant, essentially suggests AGI is over 100 years away: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3qHkcs3kG44. I think he said something along the lines of "well past the lifetimes of anyone watching this and not something we should be thinking about". I think that's possible as well, but too pessimistic. I probably lean a little closer to his view than to Carmack's, though.
My bet is that humans will go the route of enhancing themselves via hardware extensions and this symbiosis will create the next iteration(s) in our evolution. Once we get humans that are in a league of their own with regards to intelligence they will continue the cycle and create even more intelligent creatures. We may at some point decide to discard our biological bodies but it's going to be a long transition instead of a jump and the intelligent creatures that we create will have humans as a base layer.
Also, although I believe consciousness transfer is probably theoretically achievable - while truly preserving the original sense of self (and not just the perception of it, as a theoretical perfect clone would) - I feel like that's ~600 or more years away. Maybe a lot more. It seems a little odd to be pessimistic of AGI and then talk about stuff like being able to leave our bodies. This seems like a much more difficult problem than creating an AGI, and creating an AGI is probably the hardest thing humans have tried so far.
I'd be quite surprised if AGI takes longer than 150 years. Not necessarily some crazy exponential singularity explosion thing, but just something that can truly reason in a similar way a human can (either with or without sentience and sapience). Though I'll have no way to actually register my shock, obviously. Unless biological near-immortality miraculously comes well before AGI... And I'd be extremely surprised if it happens in like a decade, as Carmack and some others think.
Maybe if you had some isolated human brain in a vat that you could somehow easily manipulate through some kind of future technology, then the line between human and machine gets a little bit fuzzy. In that respect, maybe you're right that superintelligence will first come through human-machine interfacing rather than through AGI. But that still wouldn't count as AGI even if it counts as superintelligence. (Superintelligence by itself, artificial or otherwise, would obviously be very nice to have, though.)
Maybe you and I are just defining AGI differently. To me, AGI involves no biological tissue and is something that can be built purely with transistors or other such resources. That could potentially let us eventually scale it to trillions of instances. If it's a matter of messing around with a single human brain, it could be very beneficial, but I don't see how it would scale. You can't just make a copy of a brain - or if you could, you're in some future era where AGI would likely already have been solved long ago. Even if every human on Earth had such an augmented brain, they would still eventually be dwarfed by the raw power of a large number of fungible AGI reasoning-processors, all acting in sync, or independently, or both.
also, augmenting a human brain for what I’m describing does not mean that each human would get their brain augmented. It’s very possible that only a subset of humans would “evolve” this way and we would create a different subspecies. I’m not going to go into the ethics of the approach or the possibility that current humans will not like/allow this, although I think that the technology part would not be enough to make it happen.
Machine learning at this point seems closer to a tool designed analytically (feeding it well-formed data relevant to the task, hand-designing the network) than to AGI.
One might extrapolate that there is a chance that in 10 years, when the computational horsepower is available to more researchers to play with, and we get another step-change advance, that we will get there.
My own feeling is that it is possible AGI could happen soon, but I don't expect it will.
In general I don't think our current approach to AI is all that clever. It brute forces algorithms which no human has any comprehension of or ability to modify. All a human can do is modify the input data set and hope a better algorithm (which they also don't understand) arises from the neural network.
It's like a very permissive compiler which produces a binary full of runtime errors. You have to find bugs at runtime and fiddle with the input until the runtime error goes away. Was it a bug in your input? Or a bug in the compiler? Who knows. Change whichever you think of first. It's barely science and it's barely a debug workflow.
What pushed me all the way over the edge was when adversarial techniques started to be applied to self-driving cars. That white paper made them look like death machines. This entire development process I am criticising assumes we get to live in the happy path, and we're not. The same dark forces infosec can barely keep at bay on the internet, and have completely failed to stop on IoT, will now be able to target your car as well.
Worst thing is all our otherwise brilliant humans like Carmack are gonna be the guinea pigs in the cars as they head off toward their next runtime crash.
Additionally you can't replicate people exactly, so even when Einstein comes along we only have him for a short while. When he passes away we regress.
Computers are completely different. We can ring them in power plants, replicate them perfectly, add new banks of CPUs, of GPUs, wire internet connections directly into them, etc.
This didn't used to matter because the old "computers can only do exactly what you tell them to do, just really fast" limitation. Now that computers are drawing, making art, modifying videos, playing Chess and Go preternaturally, playing real time strategy games well, etc we can see that that limitation doesn't really hold anymore.
At this point the economics start to really kick in. More machine learning breakthroughs + much, MUCH bigger computers over the next decades are going to be interesting.
If you give Deepmind "x" times the compute power (storage, whatever) it just plays Starcraft better. It's not going to arrange tanks into an equation that solves AGI.
That breakthrough will be assisted by computers I'm sure, but the human mind will solve it.
So these napkin estimates comparing brainpower what server farms can do doesn't inform us at all about how that gets us closer to AGI.
The ML community is generally extremely open, and people know what the other top people are working on. If an AGI was developed in secret, it would have to be without the involvement of the top researchers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cerebral_organoid
I know of at least two people that are eager to make "Daleks" and given the sample size there must be many more.
You're not the first person to express this idea, but it's pure speculation. There is obviously a possibility that it will be proved correct at some point in the future. But historically, very smart people have been ridiculed like clockwork for expressing ideas that were beyond their time but philosophically (and physically, eventually technologically) possible.
I'd be wary of adding to such sentiment. It also feels suspiciously like an ad hominem criticism, although in your case it's expressed more like a question. I think there is clearly something to the idea of very smart people having an intellectual disconnect with the reasoning of their closer-to-average peers (and hence expressing things that seem ludicrous, without considering how they will be received), but not one that negatively affects the quality of their deductions.
IMHO, the ideas of AGI and a "technological singularity" (let's call it economic growth that's extremely more powerful than anything seen up until now) aren't so different from earlier, profound developments in human history. The criticism of "smart people developing a blind spot" could have been applied equally to e.g. the ideas of agriculture and the following power shift, industry, modern medicine, powered flight and spaceflight, nuclear weapons or computers, networking and robotics.
All these ideas put the world into an almost unimaginally different state, when seen with the eyes of an earlier status quo. Maybe AGI is relatively different, it's hard to say without having lived in ancient Egypt. It's certainly qualitatively different, since it involves changes to intelligent life, but I'm not sure the idea feels much more alien than things we've already experienced.
I think the linchpin of my belief is recursive self improvement. I think machine intelligences are a different kind of substance with different dynamics than the ones we typically encounter.
I don't think someone will compile the first AGI and presto there is it. I think a long running system of processes will interact and rewrite its own code to produce something, which eventually a reasonable boundary could be drawn to distinguish the system and anyone interacting with the system would say: "this thing is intelligent, the most intelligent thing on the planet". It would have instant access to all written knowledge, essentially unbounded power to compute new facts and information and model the world to as accurate of an approximation as needed to produce high confidence utterances.
I just don't see how a system like that couldn't come into existence one day. Issues around timelines are completely unknowable to me. But I would put a distribution of something like I would be surprised if it happened in the next 50 years and shocked if it didn't happen within the next 1000. Very fuzzy, but it "feels" inevitable.
If a collection of unthinking cells can coordinate and produce the feeling of conscious experience then I can't see what would stop silicon from producing similar behavior without many bounds inherent in biological systems.
Artificial systems should be able to climb given a suitable gradient. I think the hard part of AGI is going to be designing the environment and gradient to produce "intention", I don't think the hard part is studying the human mind to find out the "secret of intelligence"
The goal of AGI isn't silicon minds isomorphic to human minds at each level of interpretation. Just the existence of an intelligent system.
* Neural nets play Chess or Go better than us. They will soon play Mathematics better than us.
* They turn keywords in photo-realistic images in seconds, and will soon do the same for text. Literature and Arts down this path.
* They learn to play video games better than us, from Starcraft to Dota. Engineering down this path.
There is no hidden information. You just need to look at the width of the field. There is a credible challenge for all our intelligent capabilities.
Anyone with more training want to chime in?
The question is how you get from that to AGI.
Between rounds at an amateur chess tournament you will often find players passing the time playing a game commonly called Bughouse or Siamese chess. It's played by two teams of two players, using two chess sets and two clock. Let's call them team A, consisting of players Aw and Ab, and team B, consisting of player Bw and Bb.
The boards are set up so that Aw and Bb play on one board, and Ab and Bw on the other. They play a normal clocked game (with one major modification described below) on each board, and as soon as any player is checkmated, runs out of time on their clock, or resigns, the Bughouse game ends and that player's team loses.
The one major modification to the rules is that when a player captures something, that captured piece or pawn becomes available to their partner, who can later elect on any move to drop that on their board instead of making a move on the board.
E.g., if Aw captures a queen, Ab then has a black queen in reserve. Later, instead of making a move, Ab can place that black queen on Ab's board. The capture pieces must be kept where the other team can easily see them.
You can talk to your teammate during the game. This communication is very important because the state of your teammates game can greatly affect the value of your options. For example, I might be in a position to capture a queen for a knight, and just looking at my board that might be a great move. But it will result in my partner having a queen available to drop, and my partner's opponent having a knight to drop. Once on the board a queen is usually worth a lot more than a knight--but when in reserve it is the knight that is often the more deadly piece. So, I'll ask my teammate if queen for knight is OK. My teammate might say yes, or no, or something more complicated, like wait until his opponent moves, so that he can prepare for that incoming enemy knight. In the later case, if I've got less time on my clock than my teammate's opponent has, the latter might delay his move, trying to force me to either do the trade while it is sill his turn, or do something else which will let his teammate save his queen. This can get quite complicated.
OK, now imagine some kid, maybe 12 years old or so, who is at his first tournament, and is pretty good for his age, and had never played Bughouse. He's played a ton of regular chess at his school club and with friends, and with the computer.
A friend asks him to team up, quickly explains the rules, and they start playing Bughouse.
First few games, that kid is going to cause his team to lose a lot. He'll be making that queen for knight capture without checking the other board, shortly followed by his partner yelling "WHERE DID THAT KNIGHT COME FROM!? AAAAAARRRRRGGGHHHHH!!!".
The thing is, though, by the end of the day, after playing a few games of Bughouse between each round of the tournament, that kid will have figured out a fair amount of which parts of his knowledge of normal chess openings, endgames, tactics, general principles, etc., transfers as is to Bughouse, which parts need modification (and how to make those modifications), and which parts have to be thrown out.
To get his Bughouse proficiency up to about the same level as his regular chess proficiency will take orders of magnitude less games than it took for regular chess.
I don't think that is currently true for artificial neural nets. Training one for Bughouse would be as much work as training one for regular chess, even if you started with one that had been already trained for regular chess.
Until we define 'cake', we cannot create cake.
I wonder if all the really smart people who think AGI is around the corner know something I don't. Well, clearly they know a lot of things that I don't, but I wonder if there's some decisive piece of information I'm missing. I'm a "strict materialist" too, but that doesn't mean I think we can build a brain or a sun or a planet or etc within X years, it just means that I think it's technically possible to build those things.
I don't see how we get from "neural net that's really good at identifying objects" to "general intelligence". The emphasis on computational power also makes no sense to me. If we had infinite compute today, what steps would you take to build AGI? Does anyone have any good ideas about that?
Sometimes I wonder if AGI (and the concept of a "technological singularity") isn't just "intelligent design for people with north of 140 IQ". Maybe really smart people tend to develop a blindspot for really hard problems (because they've solved so many of them so effectively).