For example, there's no mention of competition or its belief that healthy, fair competition brings about these things. In fact, it's distinctly anti-competitive in the fact that the leadership of all of these companies are behind closed doors coordinating a message like this.
Instead of going to a fancy conference and chumming it up with each other, then patting yourselves on the back about what great people you are, lead by example and hold the others to task. Make the living conditions of your employees better and then attack your competitor for not keeping up. Quit using the latest cultural cause as a marketing stunt and focus on making a better world for your customers and employees. The fact that you wrapped your corporate logo in a pride flag for a month doesn't do a thing to help your employee whose sanity is tested every day by their crappy manager, whether they're gay or not.
And figure out how to still make all this profitable in the long run.
I tend to get harshly downvoted when I bring up Google on Hacker News (since it employs a disproportionate amount of Bay Area engineers that hang out here and then get defensive about it), but no other company did I see quite the disconnect between what they SAY they aspire to and how they ACT.
Google has built an incredibly strong PR brand on being the "good guys", a "not a conventional corporation", "don't be evil", etc. But in a way it's far more dangerous. At least we know what Goldman Sachs is about, making money, the employees there largely know it, the world around them knows it, people know to be on guard when dealing with Goldman because you know what their motives are.
With Google, having worked in NYC with finance companies and spent many years at Google, people are Google are as obsessed with money, success, and prestige as any finance employee. But they SAY they are about making the world a better place, responsibility etc. Where this leads is not, Google doesn't do bad things, but the much scarier, they do wrong things but saying they can't be wrong because Google is the one doing it, and Google is supposedly good! Taking a page from Nixon, "when the president does it, it's not illegal."
This came to a head during the Maven debate over using Tensorflow to build auto-aim killbots. The most common ethical defense amongst employees was "well, if we don't do it, Amazon will do it, and that would be worse! Because we're Google, and we're the good guys." Now if a crack dealer said, it's alright for me to sell dangerous narcotics to these children and addicts, because if I don't do it, someone else will. And that person could be even worse! Would ANYONE accept that argument as ethically coherent? Of course not, yet these otherwise very intelligent Google employees seemingly swallowed up Google's absurd logic without thinking. You become the good guy by NOT doing the bad things, not by doing the bad things while claiming it's alright because you SAID you're the good guys.
Now, to pre-empt people accusing me of derailing, I'm not because this is extremely relevant to the original article being discussed here. This is banks leaders like Jamie Dimon following Google's lead. You don't have to actually take any REAL moral stand, you don't have to make any real ethical decisions, all you have to do is TALK about it a lot. Control the message. It's dishonest and it's hypocritical but it's worked out very well for Google. Compare Google to Uber. If you just look at the facts, between the Kelly Ellis accusations, the Andy Rubin thing, many more examples, Google's sexual harassment FACTS are actually WAY worse than what Uber was accused of. Yet Uber now has this awful reputation for being terrible to women while Google gets way less flak in both the tech community and the broader world - why? All because Larry and Sergey played the PR game way better than TK, they were the cool hip burners who cared about progressive stuff, while really they run their companies with the exact same corporate malfeasance, profit at any cost strategy of any NYC financial institution.
Bottom line, we need to hold companies accountable with ACTIONS, and if they give us WORDS instead of ACTIONS we should be MORE critical, not drop our guard and be LESS critical.
In other words, execs said "here are our values", employees came back and said that maven didn't live up to those values and begrudgingly, kicking and screaming even, execs agreed, or at least capitulated.
It would certainly be better if employees didn't have to remind executives of the values they committed to, but having them has still been a net positive.
Do you think Richard Feynman was a bad person because he helped build the atom bomb?
The person I responded to appears to disagree with maven. But they used googles actions as a negative thing, when in the end those actions aligned with his values.
They may be useful for virtue signalling. But none of the virtues signaled are particularly controversial.
They may be useful for developing more enlightened self-interest among investors and the intermediaries that vote their shares. But they change nothing about the governance structure of the firms. Stockholders elect directors appoint officers who run the companies.
Many of us have seen corporate "mission statements" or "core values" or "company principles" changed with great fanfare and no discernible effect on substantive corporate behavior. This is even fuzzier than that. This release announces a change to a kind of generalization of many corporate mission statements. Fuzzy in, fuzzier out.
In the end, I have to be suspicious. The only meaningful signal I read here is an open, united affront to the principle of simple shareholder primacy. In the balance of power, that behooves executives, who experience simple shareholder primacy as an accountable constraint on their discretion.
Business Roundtable is an interest group for executives. It is not an interest group for customers, workers, suppliers, communities, shareholders, or their representatives. It may choose to try and leverage customers, workers, suppliers, communities, and their representatives against shareholders. That has to be a far more delicate process when you're not the owner of a special class of stock that assures you stay in power.
So 51% of corporate profits are reserved for the employee bonus pool? And all employees are eligible for said bonuses?
It's not hard to come up with examples of where this fails. Don't give me aspirational pie in the sky. Give me operational policy.
See, there are three layers of decision making: vision, strategy, and tactics. You set large aspirational goals first (eg Microsoft "empower every person and organization on the planet to achieve more"), then smaller component strategies ("build the a cloud provider that integrates business intelligence into everything you do"), then the concrete actions to make those srrategies happen ("integrate Active Directory authentication into kubernetes RBAC"). One "vision" level statement spawns many, many "tactics".
When you're dealing on the level of "181 CEOs" from huge companies as diverse as JP Morgan Chase, Johnson & Johnson, and Ford, it is impossible to talk about tactics and strategy. What Ford can do to better serve long term interests of all stakeholders is too different from what Vanguard should do. You are only able to agree on the big vision, and let the units (or whatever smaller more homogeneous group makes sense) work out the strategy level and below.
This is leadership 101 stuff. There are several models of decision-making, but they are all hierarchical in this way. You won't find many media outlets pushing a collective of 181 companies to issue a single press release about the exact on the ground tactics they will all implement, because in this field that's a nonsensical request on par with "but how many packets can apache serve?"
― Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations
Note that most public companies have institutional investors as the largest component of their ownership; such investors tend to own all the major competitors.
GM: top 5 are Capital World Investors, Vanguard, BlackRock, Berkshire Hathaway, and Harris Associates.
Ford: top five are Vanguard, BlackRock, Newport, State Street, Franklin.
Fiat-Chrysler: top five are Tiger, Harris, Baillie Gifford, Vanguard, Deutsche Bank, FMR.
Looks like Vanguard is certainly in a position to encourage the big-three car manufacturers to work together.
Intel: Tiger, Harris, Baillie Gifford, Vanguard, Deutsche Bank.
AMD: Vanguard, BlackRock, Wellington, FMR, Invesco.
Your CPU choices will make money for Vanguard.
HPE: Dodge&Cox, Vanguard, BlackRock, Primecap, State Street.
Dell: Temasek Holdings, Dodge&Cox, Elliott, BlackRock, Vanguard.
Apple: Vanguard, BlackRock, Berkshire Hathaway, State Street, FMR.
When you buy computers, you make money for Vanguard.
In summary, Tim Buckley at Vanguard can set up a meeting with any group of CEOs at minimal notice. He doesn't actually own much of anything, but the right of ownership for a large percentage of the USA's economy is a thing that he directs.
Or maybe it's Robert Kapito at BlackRock; same deal.
Umm, no. Unless you have a very different idea of what "large percentage" means.
He does direct investment.
Free market !== unregulated market.
In order for an unregulated market to be a free market, perfect competition is required[0], otherwise you get market failure.
In the real world, we use laws to discourage behavior that leads to market failure.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_market#Perfect_competitio...
It's not as if corporations don't do a lot of that already when it's in their interests.
See also: "Actions speak louder than words."
It is easy to be skeptical here (and I am), but I think it would be folly to disregard the attempt as mere public relations fodder and instead see this as a starting point and continue to follow-up to ensure they're meeting their stated goals. If it's clear they're not, then happily disregard :)
Health Insurance 401k (even non-match) PTO
How many billionaires are homeless after their ventures implode?
Has this happened in recent memory, at all? Because when I was growing up and getting the pro-capitalist America view of things on the regular, I vividly recall that capitalism is all about your success individually, that you risk it all and if you lose, you lose.
Even Elizabeth Holmes, an entrepreneur* who's business not only failed, massively, not only caused a man's suicide, not only lost fortunes both public and private, all without ever producing a SINGLE FUNCTIONING OR USABLE PRODUCT, she left a rich woman if I'm not mistaken.
*I was gonna quote that word here but no, I'm not going to because the mythical status of these people in American society is a joke. Anybody can be an entrepreneur. There are no qualifications and no requirements and you cannot break someone's faith in the "mythical rich 1%" than having them work for one, directly for a year, and see how maladjusted, how emotionally vulnerable, and how utterly dependent they are on subordinates for even trivial tasks.
Enforcement.
My wife wrote a law journal article on this but it isn't digitized unfortunately.
The whole premise of the article is wrong. The premise is that the problem with corporations is that they only consider the interests of their shareholders. That's wrong. The actual problem with corporations is that corporate governance has broken down, so that corporations no longer consider the interests of all their shareholders, and the shareholders themselves are no longer involved in determining the corporation's goals. Most shareholders now, in terms of percentage of voting stock ownership, are not individuals but mutual funds, who don't care what the corporation's goals are as long as its stock price and dividends meet targets; and CEOs, even if their share holdings are small as a percentage of the total, can easily get themselves special compensation packages and golden parachutes regardless of whether they improve the corporation's situation or not.
You stopped just short of what I think is the real issue here. Corporations these days are simply “financial paperclip maximizers”: amoral entities that do whatever is profitable, consequences beyond the bottom line be damned. There’s literally an episode of Black Mirror about this.
They “privatize profits and socialize costs,” as the saying goes, and they don’t blink at doing things that may be illegal, because the profit reward is so strong.
This is the kind of thinking that had oil companies suppressing climate change research in the 80s and tobacco companies suppressing lung cancer research in the 40s and 50s. A feel good statement by a couple hundred CEOs isn’t going to do anything about that.
I don't think "whatever is profitable" pins it down enough. They do what is profitable on a short time scale. They don't do what is profitable over long time scales like 30 or 50 or 100 years. If they did, they would not be able to get away with, for example, privatizing profits and socializing costs, because what enables them to do that is that the profits show up in the short term but the costs only show up in the long term.
Back when corporate governance worked, shareholders were mostly individuals and they typically held shares on a long time horizon. That created obvious incentives to judge corporations by profits on a long time horizon. But now, most shareholders are mutual funds who judge individual corporations on a short time horizon--if the corporations don't make their numbers, the mutual fund trades their stock away. That means corporations have no incentive now to look at profits on a long time horizon--even though their shareholders do.
When most shareholders were individuals instead of mutual funds and other financial institutions, and held shares on fairly long time horizons. Things gradually evolved away from that during the post-WWII boom.
No, we're not. We have lots of ways to adapt, just as humans have adapted to climate change in the past.
Then consider what adapting to climate change could mean.
But climate change alarmists aren't telling us to do that; they're telling us to take all the resources we could be spending on those good things, and instead squander them on draconian efforts to curb CO2 emissions based on models that have been falsified by the data.
No, the kind of short sighted thinking that might cause civilization to collapse is trumpeting gloom and doom based on inadequate knowledge and failed predictions. The climate models on which the alarmist hype is based have been falsified by the data. And nobody even has predictive models for economics on that time scale.
I don't know where you're getting that from. The models have been significantly overpredicting warming for quite some time now.
Every CEO who signed this was nodding, thinking, "we do that already."
> The concentration of wealth and enhancement of corporate power translate automatically to decline of democracy. Research in academic political science has revealed that a large majority of voters are literally disenfranchised, in that their own representatives pay no attention to their wishes but listen to the voices of the donor class. It is furthermore well established that elections are pretty much bought: electability, hence policy, is predictable with remarkable precision from the single variable of campaign spending, both for the executive and Congress.
https://truthout.org/articles/noam-chomsky-moral-depravity-d...
Most Americans are politically disenfranchised and political decisions are often made counter to what the majority want and vote for, in favour of elite and corporate interests.
It's pretty amazing to claim corporations are signalling some kind of unity and/or support of the general public based on this PR piece, while their money, lobbying, and power are doing the exact opposite.
This should also mean cutting down on abusive or low-paid contractors, if they exist, and converting them to employees.
It may be that we can't, and therefore stock price is a bad metric focus on.
1. over what timescale? 2. at what level of risk?
As soon as they are incorporated, it's obvious that firms have both more leeway and more responsibility to take care of a wider range of stakeholders.
A purpose is not the same as something in its interest or that a "nice" corporation might do.
For example, investing in its employees might be in the corporation's interest in order to fulfill its purpose. But a corporation is not created in order to invest in its employees...
This is a PR exercise, as already commented by someone else.
Quite possibly, but the fact that it is necessary, suggest that businesses are recognizing that there is a problem.
Words is a first step.
Words without action don't mean shit.
For example, take "This starts with compensating [our employees] fairly". What criteria will they use to determine if this if being achieved? Without any additional revenues/profit, the only option you have is to change the distribution of revenues/profit. You could reward investors less and employees more, but investors will defect to those investments that pay them more. You could pay individual contributors more and management less, but management will defect to employers willing to pay them more.
I just don't see how any of these goals are achievable since they are so subjective. Depending on who you ask, someone people will say American corporations are a long way from achieving these and some will say American corporations already do these things.
Statements about planned obsolescence, disposable plastic packaging, repairability or specific forms of rent seeking are examples of the kinds of statements that would be serious.
I hope this isn't the case, but that's what kept repeating in my head while I was reading it. If this is an honest sentiment and the start of a change in the way business runs then we'll see that in short order. But, in the end, it all comes down to making money and not "the greater good".
Lots of businesses operate on razor thin margins, but still serve if a purpose.
What should be their course of action?
Great point! But, if this document is a starting point in Ernest, then as long as this is followed then it's a good start. The next iteration should, then, include a strong commitment to objective fairness in the supplier selection process. Whether or not that actually happens will depend on the commitment to remove corruption in the process.
Here are the words I saw:
value, customers, expectations, investing, employees, compensating, fairly, providing, important, benefits, supporting, training, education, skills, changing, diversity, inclusion, dignity, respect, dealing, ethically, suppliers, good, partners, companies, missions, communities, respect, protect, environment, embracing, sustainable, businesses, generating, long-term, shareholders, capital, innovate, transparent, effective, engagement
Why?
1. Look at how the gig economy pushes contractors further and further towards being employees in all but name, but so much in the way of benefits is tied up in whether or not the name or classification applies.
2. The statements talk about benefits that corporations bring and the support they provide but neglect to mention the costs they incur and the side-effects they place upon others. Corporations are organisms of a kind, and most if not all organisms consume some inputs to produce some outputs. Some of the those outputs are waste. That waste must to be accounted for and processed. Where would the BP oil spill and the PG&E wildfires be accounted for in those statements.
3. The statements avoid the mention of the term consumers, which is how many companies perceive and treat their customers driving the interactions between them to be increasingly banal and scripted. Consider how often in this forum we hear of "selling eyeballs" in advertising.
4. Similar to 3 but more generally, the statements make no mention of accountability in the cases of the spectrum of harm caused by ignorance, negligence, and further along that spectrum all the way to outright malice. The statements try to separate the positive things that human beings are capable of producing from the negative without mentioning the negative at all never mind the ever present probabilities. Failing to mention and own the harm that a corporation can cause makes me think of "rainbows and unicorns", and results in the corporation failing to truly possess genuine humility.
5. I think all the four points I listed above are actually a direct result of this point that I'm about to expand upon: for whatever reasons, corporations try to remove humanness from within and without. By removing the humanness from within, the corporation becomes less sensitive when it does manage to do harm. By removing the humanness outside, they reduce the other human beings they work with into a number of nouns: customers, employees, suppliers, communities, shareholders.
As a point of interest, consider the US Constitution and how it both defines the frame of the US government and the other entities it interacts, but also sets constraints on its behavior.
This is legally incorrect. It's a meme that should die. This idea is based on the assumption that not acting to maximize shareholder value is defrauding investors. But this isn't at all true. Corporations are free to do whatever they want, as long as they're transparent about doing so.
Or to make the same point in the opposite direction: companies must act ethically, because not doing so ends up being securities fraud[0]. Since stock price is in a large part based on perception, things that negatively affect perception that aren't disclosed could be (and are) construed as defrauding investors.
[0]: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-26/everyt...
Right, and acting unethically can be securities fraud. Hence illegal. Even if the unethical thing is on its own not illegal, and in pursuit of higher short term profits.
>A corporation cannot do what it wants, but it can do what shareholders want.
Yes it can, as long as it makes sure to inform shareholders of what it intends to do. As long as shareholders have information with which to make an informed decision, it doesn't matter what that information is.
As for information, management of the corporation works for the shareholders. If the shareholders don’t like management decisions,they can replace management. So, ultimately the corporation is an entity designed to advance the interests of shareholders.
Not exactly no, I made the claim that a lot of unethical, but not directly illegal, behavior has been successfully called securities fraud.
> So, ultimately the corporation is an entity designed to advance the interests of shareholders.
Which is not the same as "generating returns for shareholders". Of course this also gets even more confusing with voting/non-voting shares, where for the majority of shareholders, your interests don't matter at all.
No, they can't. If management took an action that is within their power to take it cannot be reversed at shareholder whim. They can certainly throw out the current management and install new management who will attempt to reverse what the old management did, but what is done is done.
"The purpose of the Corporation is to engage in any lawful act or activity for which corporations may be organized under the Delaware General Corporation Law. "
And the same agreement vests in the officers the ability to do whatever is necessary to further that purpose. You obviously can't go against the results of a direct shareholder vote but officers have enormous leeway. If they decide to forgo profits in order to make customers happy, whether or not that is meant to drive long term growth, that is completely legal as long as there are no conflicts of interest.
But why? This line of thinking typically assumes that people start companies strictly to make money--an assumption that I see as patently false. There are plenty of for-profit social enterprises (which is to say nothing of non-profits).
For example, Patagonia recently changed their mission statement "We’re in business to save our home planet" [1]. To think that they continue to exist just because Yvon Chouinard doesn't have enough cash in the bank is laughable.
I am uncertain how this letter changes the established case law regarding C Corps.
No corporation is required to "maximize shareholder value". In fact, they cannot be because there is no possible legal standard for what constitutes "maximizing value".
B Corporations have no special legal standing. It's just a certification created by a group that tries to push corporations towards responsibility (or, more cynically, provides virtue-signalling-as-a-service). Any corporation can adopt any or all of the principles set out for B Corporations, if the changes to their charter and by-laws are approved. It is the existence of such requirements in the corporate governance documents that provides the legal requirement, not a private certification.
You're correct that B Lab's certification has no special legal standing. A "benefit corporation", however, is a recognized legal entity in many US states [1]. Patagonia is both a certified B Lab B Corp and a private benefit corporation. I should have made this point clearer.
> No corporation is required to "maximize shareholder value"
The rise in benefit corporation legislation was in part caused by the 2010 eBay v. Newmark decision in Delaware, which included the statement, "Promoting, protecting, or pursuing nonstockholder considerations must lead at some point to value for stockholders." [2] Note that this is still a vague statement, not using "profit" or any specific timeframe. I know that this case is still hotly debated, and I don't know enough to comment on all its implications.
Outside of a legal framework, it can be argued that all corporate directors that are non-majority owners of their public companies do have a requirement to "maximize shareholder value", or, to radically oversimplify the process, they will be replaced by shareholder vote.
So I should drop the "legal" modifier to my comments, and just refer to "obligations" to the shareholders and "action" by the shareholders.
Again, I do not know what significance the recent letter has on any of this.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefit_corporation [2] https://www.delawarelitigation.com/uploads/file/int51%281%29...
That said, it would be interesting (healthy?) to discuss/debate the merits of the actual statements:
* Delivering value to our customers. We will further the tradition of American companies leading the way in meeting or exceeding customer expectations.
* Investing in our employees. This starts with compensating them fairly and providing important benefits. It also includes supporting them through training and education that help develop new skills for a rapidly changing world. We foster diversity and inclusion, dignity and respect.
* Dealing fairly and ethically with our suppliers. We are dedicated to serving as good partners to the other companies, large and small, that help us meet our missions.
* Supporting the communities in which we work. We respect the people in our communities and protect the environment by embracing sustainable practices across our businesses.
* Generating long-term value for shareholders, who provide the capital that allows companies to invest, grow and innovate. We are committed to transparency and effective engagement with shareholders.
Curious where people thing they are wrong or incomplete.