News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:25PM (#20739163)
Soviet Union had show trials and U.S. has show letters. The legal purpose of a corporation is to generate returns for shareholders. If training employees and helping customers advances that goal, then corporations should do it. Otherwise - no. Goes without saying that corporations should maximize shareholder value using legal means only.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by joshuamorton on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:50PM (#20739982)
> The legal purpose of a corporation is to generate returns for shareholders.

This is legally incorrect. It's a meme that should die. This idea is based on the assumption that not acting to maximize shareholder value is defrauding investors. But this isn't at all true. Corporations are free to do whatever they want, as long as they're transparent about doing so.

Or to make the same point in the opposite direction: companies must act ethically, because not doing so ends up being securities fraud[0]. Since stock price is in a large part based on perception, things that negatively affect perception that aren't disclosed could be (and are) construed as defrauding investors.

[0]: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-26/everyt...

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:37PM (#20741566)
No, if it’s secutities fraud it’s illegal. Unethical and illegal are not the same thing. A corporation cannot do what it wants, but it can do what shareholders want.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by joshuamorton on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:42PM (#20741604)
> No, if it’s secutities fraud it’s illegal.

Right, and acting unethically can be securities fraud. Hence illegal. Even if the unethical thing is on its own not illegal, and in pursuit of higher short term profits.

>A corporation cannot do what it wants, but it can do what shareholders want.

Yes it can, as long as it makes sure to inform shareholders of what it intends to do. As long as shareholders have information with which to make an informed decision, it doesn't matter what that information is.

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:48PM (#20741672)
You made the claim that corporations must act ethically or its securities fraud. That claim is not correct. Some unethical behavior can indeed be illegal but unethical in itself doesn’t automatically break the law.

As for information, management of the corporation works for the shareholders. If the shareholders don’t like management decisions,they can replace management. So, ultimately the corporation is an entity designed to advance the interests of shareholders.

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by joshuamorton on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:57PM (#20741755)
> You made the claim that corporations must act ethically or its securities fraud. That claim is not correct. Some unethical behavior can indeed be illegal but unethical in itself doesn’t automatically break the law.

Not exactly no, I made the claim that a lot of unethical, but not directly illegal, behavior has been successfully called securities fraud.

> So, ultimately the corporation is an entity designed to advance the interests of shareholders.

Which is not the same as "generating returns for shareholders". Of course this also gets even more confusing with voting/non-voting shares, where for the majority of shareholders, your interests don't matter at all.

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:11PM (#20741865)
We can dance around semantics, the point is corporations cannot do things that shareholders collectively find as bad for them. For example, corporations cannot benefit employees at the expense of shareholders. If management decided to write a big fat check to employees and shareholders didn’t agree, they can call an emergency meeting cancel the check, fire management and appoint new management.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vonmoltke on Monday August 19, 2019 @08:28PM (#20742901)
> they can call an emergency meeting cancel the check

No, they can't. If management took an action that is within their power to take it cannot be reversed at shareholder whim. They can certainly throw out the current management and install new management who will attempt to reverse what the old management did, but what is done is done.

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by Ididntdothis on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:36PM (#20739253)
As far as I know the purpose of a corporation is to conduct lawful business. I don’t believe the law says anything about shareholder returns.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vikramkr on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:54PM (#20741198)
The law definitely doesn't, otherwise it would be illegal to do things like donate to charity as a corporation. If all shareholders get together and vote unanimously to take all the money in the corporation and give it away, then they can totally do that. If the law mandated maximizing shareholder returns then shareholders would no longer be free to instruct the entity they own to do what they want it to if it conflicts with increasing profits
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:34PM (#20741542)
Ok, you are nitpicking. The legal purpose is to advance the interests of shareholders. Sure, shareholders can give away all the money and earn zero returns ( presumably they would register a non profit if they wanted to do that ) but it would be illegal to do something that shareholders didn’t agree to. Did shareholders of the signatories agree to forego profits in order to make customers happy ? Of course not.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vikramkr on Monday August 19, 2019 @06:48PM (#20742487)
I'm not nitpicking, and the legal purpose of a company is not to deliver shareholder returns. IIRC, most company incorporation specify the legal purpose of the corporation to be to do the business that the corporation is made to do. Here's the excerpt from my certificate of incorporation:

"The purpose of the Corporation is to engage in any lawful act or activity for which corporations may be organized under the Delaware General Corporation Law. "

And the same agreement vests in the officers the ability to do whatever is necessary to further that purpose. You obviously can't go against the results of a direct shareholder vote but officers have enormous leeway. If they decide to forgo profits in order to make customers happy, whether or not that is meant to drive long term growth, that is completely legal as long as there are no conflicts of interest.

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @01:33AM (#20744100)
You are nitpicking. The shareholders own the corporation. I concede that the purpose isn’t returns but the purpose is to further shareholders interests. The purpose isn’t in any way, shape or form to further employees interests.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by my_username_is_ on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:40PM (#20739295)
>The legal purpose of a corporation is to generate returns for shareholders. >Goes without saying that corporations should maximize shareholder value using legal means only.

But why? This line of thinking typically assumes that people start companies strictly to make money--an assumption that I see as patently false. There are plenty of for-profit social enterprises (which is to say nothing of non-profits).

For example, Patagonia recently changed their mission statement "We’re in business to save our home planet" [1]. To think that they continue to exist just because Yvon Chouinard doesn't have enough cash in the bank is laughable.

[1] https://www.patagonia.com/company-info.html

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by aodin on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:12PM (#20739592)
Patagonia is also a B Corp [1], and it has a legal obligation to the mission statement that you've mentioned, not just maximizing shareholder value. I think the parent comment is just snidely remarking that the C Corps that have signed the letter are still required to maximize shareholder value, or they will face legal action.

I am uncertain how this letter changes the established case law regarding C Corps.

[1] https://www.patagonia.com/b-lab.html

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vonmoltke on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:40PM (#20739869)
> C Corps that have signed the letter are still required to maximize shareholder value, or they will face legal action

No corporation is required to "maximize shareholder value". In fact, they cannot be because there is no possible legal standard for what constitutes "maximizing value".

B Corporations have no special legal standing. It's just a certification created by a group that tries to push corporations towards responsibility (or, more cynically, provides virtue-signalling-as-a-service). Any corporation can adopt any or all of the principles set out for B Corporations, if the changes to their charter and by-laws are approved. It is the existence of such requirements in the corporate governance documents that provides the legal requirement, not a private certification.

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by aodin on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:22PM (#20740298)
> B Corporations have no special legal standing

You're correct that B Lab's certification has no special legal standing. A "benefit corporation", however, is a recognized legal entity in many US states [1]. Patagonia is both a certified B Lab B Corp and a private benefit corporation. I should have made this point clearer.

> No corporation is required to "maximize shareholder value"

The rise in benefit corporation legislation was in part caused by the 2010 eBay v. Newmark decision in Delaware, which included the statement, "Promoting, protecting, or pursuing nonstockholder considerations must lead at some point to value for stockholders." [2] Note that this is still a vague statement, not using "profit" or any specific timeframe. I know that this case is still hotly debated, and I don't know enough to comment on all its implications.

Outside of a legal framework, it can be argued that all corporate directors that are non-majority owners of their public companies do have a requirement to "maximize shareholder value", or, to radically oversimplify the process, they will be replaced by shareholder vote.

So I should drop the "legal" modifier to my comments, and just refer to "obligations" to the shareholders and "action" by the shareholders.

Again, I do not know what significance the recent letter has on any of this.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefit_corporation [2] https://www.delawarelitigation.com/uploads/file/int51%281%29...

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:52PM (#20741720)
Well, they could start a non profit with a mission to be self sustaining through business operations. If they didn’t, if they started a regular corporation, we don’t know for sure, but it’s a good guess their goal is to make money.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vonmoltke on Monday August 19, 2019 @08:30PM (#20742907)
Non-profits come with a whole lot of baggage that some people do not want to do with. Also, only certain types of corporation qualify to be non-profits in the first place.