News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by joshuamorton on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:50PM (#20739982)
> The legal purpose of a corporation is to generate returns for shareholders.

This is legally incorrect. It's a meme that should die. This idea is based on the assumption that not acting to maximize shareholder value is defrauding investors. But this isn't at all true. Corporations are free to do whatever they want, as long as they're transparent about doing so.

Or to make the same point in the opposite direction: companies must act ethically, because not doing so ends up being securities fraud[0]. Since stock price is in a large part based on perception, things that negatively affect perception that aren't disclosed could be (and are) construed as defrauding investors.

[0]: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-26/everyt...

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:37PM (#20741566)
No, if it’s secutities fraud it’s illegal. Unethical and illegal are not the same thing. A corporation cannot do what it wants, but it can do what shareholders want.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by joshuamorton on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:42PM (#20741604)
> No, if it’s secutities fraud it’s illegal.

Right, and acting unethically can be securities fraud. Hence illegal. Even if the unethical thing is on its own not illegal, and in pursuit of higher short term profits.

>A corporation cannot do what it wants, but it can do what shareholders want.

Yes it can, as long as it makes sure to inform shareholders of what it intends to do. As long as shareholders have information with which to make an informed decision, it doesn't matter what that information is.

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:48PM (#20741672)
You made the claim that corporations must act ethically or its securities fraud. That claim is not correct. Some unethical behavior can indeed be illegal but unethical in itself doesn’t automatically break the law.

As for information, management of the corporation works for the shareholders. If the shareholders don’t like management decisions,they can replace management. So, ultimately the corporation is an entity designed to advance the interests of shareholders.

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by joshuamorton on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:57PM (#20741755)
> You made the claim that corporations must act ethically or its securities fraud. That claim is not correct. Some unethical behavior can indeed be illegal but unethical in itself doesn’t automatically break the law.

Not exactly no, I made the claim that a lot of unethical, but not directly illegal, behavior has been successfully called securities fraud.

> So, ultimately the corporation is an entity designed to advance the interests of shareholders.

Which is not the same as "generating returns for shareholders". Of course this also gets even more confusing with voting/non-voting shares, where for the majority of shareholders, your interests don't matter at all.

Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vasilipupkin on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:11PM (#20741865)
We can dance around semantics, the point is corporations cannot do things that shareholders collectively find as bad for them. For example, corporations cannot benefit employees at the expense of shareholders. If management decided to write a big fat check to employees and shareholders didn’t agree, they can call an emergency meeting cancel the check, fire management and appoint new management.
Re:Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation by vonmoltke on Monday August 19, 2019 @08:28PM (#20742901)
> they can call an emergency meeting cancel the check

No, they can't. If management took an action that is within their power to take it cannot be reversed at shareholder whim. They can certainly throw out the current management and install new management who will attempt to reverse what the old management did, but what is done is done.