News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spraak on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:08PM (#20044778)
The goal of Mars to me is silly. Mars is already worse off in terms of climate than Earth. Why not work to improve what we have? The only appeal I see is "uncharted territory" / wild west
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by zaroth on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:23PM (#20044964)
Little Elon had a dream that he will one day walk on Mars. He thought to himself, well why can’t I? All I need is billions of dollars, and rockets (lots of rockets), and space ships, and renewable energy, and tunnels, and,...

And then Little Elon started a little company during the dot com boom called Zip2 and sold it to Compaq for $300 million. Then X.com which led to PayPal. Then SpaceX, Tesla, and all the rest.

It’s anything but “silly”. It’s incredible, it’s aspirational, it’s undeniably impressive. I love that his goal is so audacious as to be entirely implausible, and he keeps taking step by tiny step toward to realization of his mission.

And even though the goal may be entirely pointless to 99.999% of humanity, the steps taken along the way are reaping tremendous benefits to our lives and those of future generations.

Back to TFA, again I think they are missing the significance of what Boring will be doing here. An underground autonomous system which otherwise would have cost hundreds of millions for $50 million risk free is a perfect win-win for Boring and Vegas. Boring gets a beautiful test bed for a whole array of new tech, and a marketing demonstration of what they can accomplish if all goes well. Vegas saved a boat load of money, and gets a tourist attraction to boot.

It’s sad hearing/reading all the comments that this is stupid, just build a train, etc. Because that misses entirely the point that while this deployment could be served by a train the bigger vision is not one that could be served by trains, and the whole point, like everything Elon does, is to take a step on the path toward the Big Vision in a way that provides incremental value that can be monetized in order to fund and drive future R&D.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by btilly on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:41PM (#20045842)
This is a cool story. But the dream of Mars started later than that.

In fact if the Russians had been willing to sell the dot com billionaire some rockets for his publicity stunt of getting a plant to Mars, SpaceX would have never been formed.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by computerex on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:40PM (#20047577)
> An underground autonomous system which otherwise would have cost hundreds of millions for $50 million risk free is a perfect win-win for Boring and Vegas.

How do you think the boring company is going to be able to achieve these cost savings? If this system is otherwise going to cost hundreds of millions how the hell is the boring company going to achieve orders of magnitudes improvement?

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by zaroth on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @11:05PM (#20048003)
For now, Boring company uses the $50mm to subsidize their R&D cost as they move up the “learning curve” toward the realization of an order of magnitude in cost savings.

I would guess the engineers at Boring have a list of a hundred things they think they could do differently that would lower overall cost. I imagine the biggest ROI is automation which removes humans from the vicinity and therefore the presumably huge cost of allowing humans to safely coexist with the machine while the tunnel is being dug.

Boring will surely spend a lot more than $50mm building this thing in Vegas. Investor dollars (which in this case I think is mostly checks from Elon) make up the rest. But rather than subsidizing glorified taxi rides like investors in Uber/Lyft where the learning curve is questionable, here the theory is there’s a lot of learning to be done in construction of a reusable and highly automated boring machine that isn’t just entombed in the tunnel at the end of the project.

I think the biggest cost savings initially is smaller bore tunnels using much smaller scale transport pods (e.g. reworked Model 3s).

Also, who else would be able to develop the custom small scale transport pods or the autonomous software that they will run on for just this project? Elon has access to all the Tesla IP as a starting point. They can build TM3s without the steering wheel or pedals pretty easily, and they already demo’d the software for driving in the tunnel.

Handling the pickup, drop off, and coordinating multiple vehicles I’m sure is not trivial but depending on exactly how they design the loading/unloading zones could be contained.

I’m just as interested as anyone in how they will be handling safety, and particularly what happens when a vehicle ends up stopped midway in the tunnel.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by computerex on Thursday May 30, 2019 @02:31AM (#20048896)
> For now, Boring company uses the $50mm to subsidize their R&D cost as they move up the “learning curve” toward the realization of an order of magnitude in cost savings.

What makes the Boring company have the exclusive monopoly on R&D? There is billions of dollars available for R&D. If it was just a question of money anyone could idealize those cost savings. Your entire post is mere speculation. There is not a shred of actual fact based evidence to support anything you have said.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by atq2119 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @02:58AM (#20048998)
While I do think you have a bit of a point, the same could have been said (and probably was said) about SpaceX and reusable rockets.

Their competitors had a huge headstart and billions of dollars available for R&D, and yet it wouldn't have happened without SpaceX.

[dead]
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by embwbam on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:29PM (#20045716)
I'd like to live in a world where rich dickheads act more like Musk and do cool things. It's like living in a comic book. It's fun.

But that's not our way forward. Forget the billionaires, we need to assemble, reinvest in our political system, and start building a better future from the ground up.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by serf on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:53PM (#20046950)
> I'd like to live in a world where rich dickheads act more like Musk and do cool things. It's like living in a comic book. It's fun.

Not to nitpick, but if you were to go by the typical comic-book example most 'rich dickheads' end up being super-villains.

If the question is : Do I want the immensely rich to start moving the world around from under my feet with their unlimited resources in order to do 'Cool Things'?

A: No, I don't. 'Cool Things' is too loosely constrained a parameter to allow trillions of dollars to flow into unchecked. What happens when some ultra-rich individuals definitions of Cool Things involves morally unethical behavior?

Do I like Musks' ideas and plans?

A: Yes.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by jimmaswell on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:30PM (#20045727)
> But that's not our way forward. Forget the billionaires, we need to assemble, reinvest in our political system, and start building a better future from the ground up.

Good luck with that. For now people like Musk and Gates are doing a pretty good job of things in various areas though.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by embwbam on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:37PM (#20045802)
I agree, it looks pretty hopeless sometimes, and I definitely appreciate what Musk and Gates are doing.

I’d highly recommend reading “Winners Take All”, as it completely flipped my opinion on this subject. The author argues that giving up and trusting rich philanthropists to fix things further undermines our faith in the political system, requiring us to give billionaires even more power. And it distracts us from the question of whether we should change the system to prevent individuals from having that much power in the first place.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by indigochill on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:11PM (#20046694)
Although I appreciate the sentiment, I actually think this is impossible.

Some people are going to be inherently extremely ambitious. Those people will compete/cooperate and somebody's going to come out on top.

Supposing you establish a system explicitly designed to stop this from happening, you need someone to enforce that system. Congratulations, you just created a role for the ambitious people to fight over.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by embwbam on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:46PM (#20046903)
There will always be people in power. But maybe it is better if those people are elected, and operate in view of the public
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ericd on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @11:02PM (#20047993)
I’ve read the book you’re referring to. We absolutely should not try to prevent people from amassing enough individual power to do what Elon et al are doing. Bureaucrats are generally good at some things (eg reliably running services that are well known quantities and should be provided to everyone regardless of profitability), and generally awful at others (eg efficient innovation in new fields). You need a mix of both types to both run the world and keep it moving forward. I for one am very happy that sufficiently motivated and skilled people are sometimes able to amass enough resources to try crazy things like competing with each other to start orbital launch companies and deploy a world-wide network of thousands of communications satellites to break the government granted chokeholds a few telecom companies have on internet access.

For me, the main takeaway of the book was that we should stop revering consultants/MBAs and their process.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by roenxi on Thursday May 30, 2019 @12:34AM (#20048420)
That is a bold claim, for which you will need some pretty solid evidence.

An election is basically a popularity contest. Winning a popularity contests does not guarantee competence, reliability or even correctness of opinion.

We've got a couple of centuries of evidence that private individuals who stand to feel the effects of their choices are much better at conserving and rationing resources than elected officials.

If you make a list of the horrors of history and rank them from worst to mildest, you'll find that public officials (even in democracies) are much scarier than rich people operating private concerns.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by hdfbdtbcdg on Thursday May 30, 2019 @12:55AM (#20048519)
Sorry I don't quite understand. Are you seriously saying democracy is a bad idea and that you would like to live in an oligarchy?
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by chr1 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:46AM (#20048734)
Private property and decentralisation are good ideas.

50%+1 liking the way someone talks doesn't mean that the person is fit to manage the whole economy for four years.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by roenxi on Thursday May 30, 2019 @02:40AM (#20048930)
Oligarchies are even worse. The point is that people who win elections, and political leaders in general, are a much more concerning threat than wealthy, powerful & unlikable business leaders.

I'd be quite happy if governments had less power. People aren't threatened by rouge business magnates in the same way as they are by rogue public policy.

A few years of bad public policy does much more damage than any businessman can in a decade. Voters & governments are seriously not good at technical questions like resource allocation. Businessmen will stop doing something if it isn't working, voters usually push on regardless long after it obviously makes no sense to do so.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by Retra on Thursday May 30, 2019 @10:46AM (#20051693)
That all depends on who is doing the voting.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by Causality1 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:20PM (#20047473)
Why do you think those things are mutually exclusive?
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by embwbam on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:38PM (#20047870)
Because I think we need to change the system so that unelected rich folks don’t have that much power. The more we legitimize their work the harder that will be. I’m all for them continuing their work in the meantime though. I’m doing a poor job explaining it. Defining check out the book I recommended. “Winners take all”
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by qaq on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:37PM (#20045801)
"He's not a genius" thats pretty debatable statement he has very deep technical expertise in a number of fields that alone can easily qualify him as genius.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by serf on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:56PM (#20046973)
>"He's not a genius" thats pretty debatable statement

Sure, it's debatable, but 'genius' is a non-standardized poorly defined opinion, anyway.

I don't care if he's a genius or he isn't. He's done very well for himself, and that's praiseworthy by itself without needing arbitrary titles stacked onto it.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:58PM (#20046984)
> He's done very well for himself, and that's praiseworthy

Eh. Doing well for others is praiseworthy. Doing well for yourself is it's own reward, and neither deserves nor needs praise.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by jimmaswell on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:33PM (#20045752)
Re: unelected, people like to use the phrase "vote with your dollar" around here, so maybe all the people who liked X.com/PayPal and now Tesla cars have "elected" him according to that sentiment.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by jjeaff on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:17PM (#20046204)
Voting with your dollar is how you elect the best products and services.

No one used PayPal because they liked Elon and thought he would make a great ruling oligarch.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by nothrabannosir on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:34PM (#20045769)
Why can't OP not agree with (what he deems to be) Elon's vision? Because Elon Musk is rich? What had he been poor; would it have been Okay then?

I'm no Elon fanboy, but to patronisingly push someone down because they admire someone you don't idolise is... a bit rich.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by WhompingWindows on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:15PM (#20044862)
1. Potential for finding evidence of life outside of the Earth, never mind scientific research into dozens of other topics.

2. Joy and sheer inspiration; why go to the moon, run a marathon, or compose a symphony? Joy and inspiration.

3. Potential to improve our own technology as we strive for the above points. Clear, clear evidence of this in parent's comment and after NASA's innovative tech.

It's irrelevant if you personally don't care, you don't have to do it. It seems there will be billions of dollars and thousands of willing individuals, you can sit back and relax while the rest of us explore the stars.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ridgeguy on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:18PM (#20044892)
4. Removal of single-point extinction event if/when another dinosaur killer asteroid strikes Earth.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by throwaway2048 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:09PM (#20045527)
A dinosaur-killer sized asteroid strike would still leave earth far, far more habitable than mars is (there would at least be air and water) as would essentially any other conceivable natural or cosmic disaster.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by wuliwong on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:01PM (#20046043)
I hadn't really thought about that before. But I still think the sudden, cataclysm still could render humans extinct on Earth even if Mars is a more difficult climate. Mars dwellers would have had a great deal of time to prepare for that environment. On Earth, it would be suddenly thrust upon them. This is also assuming that the Mars colony was at a point where it could exist without supplies from Earth.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ridgeguy on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:57PM (#20045989)
I thought so too, until I read this New Yorker article [1].

It’s about a site in the Hell Creek formation that seems to show, in incredible detail, what happened in the first hour after the Chicxulub strike a couple thousand miles away.

It reset my ideas about Earth’s habitability after the impact.

[1] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/04/08/the-day-the-di...

(AFAIK, not paywalled unless you’ve used up your monthly quota of free NY articles)

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by chepaslaaa on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:53PM (#20045342)
you're just making the single point bigger
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by NullPrefix on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:58PM (#20045405)
This could be said for any expansion, until your single point becomes "everything that is".
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by smileysteve on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:02PM (#20045450)
It so happens, that the Sun's expansion will eventually consume most of the planets in the galaxy; of course, it will also be so cold long before that point humans won't be alive.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by vageli on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:10PM (#20045536)
> It so happens, that the Sun's expansion will eventually consume most of the planets in the galaxy; of course, it will also be so cold long before that point humans won't be alive.

In the galaxy or solar system?

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by redisman on Thursday May 30, 2019 @01:58AM (#20048766)
I can see Arcturus right now and the galaxy still seems to exist so I'm gonna guess b)
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by morgancmartin on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:59PM (#20045423)
By a minimum of about 33.9 million miles, yes.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by philwelch on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:43PM (#20047262)
Colonizing Mars actually introduces challenges to knowing for sure whether any life is native to Mars as opposed to introduced from Earth. But then I’m more of an “O’Neill cylinders in Earth orbit” kind of guy.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by cygx on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:29PM (#20045047)
And people are free to work on that. If Musk wants to take a shot at colonizing other planets, more power to him. We're blowing trillions of dollars on pointless wars or 'frivolous' entertainment, so even if you don't agree with his vision, Musk's efforts should be pretty far down on the list of things to criticise...
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by toephu2 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:36PM (#20045140)
Musk has said Mars is the backup plan for earth. What if one day there is a disease or meteor that wipes out the entire human population on Earth? (e.g., see the dinosaurs)

Even if the only appeal was the wild wild west and uncharted territory, what's wrong with that?

Look at what exploring the Moon has brought us, many unexpected innovations and inventions useful for life on earth.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by bunderbunder on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:54PM (#20045345)
The meteor strike wiped out the dinosaurs, but not all life. Mars currently has no life. The strong implication is that, Earth post meteor strike would still be far, far, far more habitable for humans than Mars ever will be.

As far as why describing Mars as Earth's backup plan rubs people the wrong way, I think it's a bit like Noah's Ark. While there is absolutely the cute story about the boat full of animals, and it does make for a good story, there's also the "meanwhile literally everyone aside from a minuscule elect ends up dying" bit. Which would be nothing but sour grapes if you didn't see people holding up the possibility of colonizing other planets as a mitigating factor that implies that we really shouldn't be quite so worried about all the environmental damage that's happening here on Earth. But you do.

Put it all together, and the complete narrative starts to sound like, "Sure, we're recklessly hurtling toward turning the planet into an inhospitable shithole for billions of people, but don't worry about that, because 0.00000005% of them are going to get to live on a completely different inhospitable shithole instead!"

Which, disclaimer, I'm not wanting to pan human space exploration. But I much prefer the "exploration for the sake of adventure and discovery" narrative. If that's not good enough, the ground to retreat to should be robots, not messianic fables for rich people.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by aeternus on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:02PM (#20045447)
What is the actual goal of environmentalism on earth?

If it is to preserve diverse species, then it absolutely makes sense to colonize other planets and spread the wide variety of plants, animals, and other organisms. The earth will eventually be burned up by the sun.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by bunderbunder on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:06PM (#20045492)
Let's keep a sense of perspective here. What the sun's going to be doing a billion or so years from now seems like a rather remote concern compared to entire countries being underwater in a few decades.

If interstellar space travel is ever practically attainable - and, FWIW, that is still a controversial subject - then humans absolutely will figure it out. Or rather, they will just so long as they manage to extend both their existential and economic trajectories far enough for it to matter. Ain't nobody gonna be able to develop that kind of technology from Mars; they'll be way too busy on more prosaic tasks, like repeatedly checking their domes for leaks.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spurgu on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:16PM (#20045596)
> Let's keep a sense of perspective here.

So like a few million years?

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by wongarsu on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:42PM (#20046422)
> The meteor strike wiped out the dinosaurs, but not all life. Mars currently has no life. The strong implication is that, Earth post meteor strike would still be far, far, far more habitable for humans than Mars ever will be.

Sure, but nobody today is researching the technology to survive a post-dinosaur-meteor earth. If it gets developed at all that's due to our space programs and our desire to survive on the Moon and Mars. So unless we go there we won't survive the aftermath of that theoretical meteor.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by idlewords on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:23PM (#20046270)
What did exploring the Moon bring us?
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by toephu2 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @03:02AM (#20049009)
CAT scanner, computer microchip, cordless tools, ear thermometer, insulation, satellite television, etc [1]

[1] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/science/space/5893387/Apoll...

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by idlewords on Thursday May 30, 2019 @09:04AM (#20050727)
Not sure about the ear thermometer or cordless tools, but I'm pretty certain we would have gotten the computer chip and satellite TV without sending a guy to the Moon.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by A2017U1 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @02:36AM (#20048915)
A photo of one tiny world in a vast cosmos. A worldwide symbol that no amount of propaganda or violence could ever achieve.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by HNLurker2 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @04:08AM (#20049290)
You sound like Carl Sagan. Stop this nihilism
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by moogly on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:14PM (#20046170)
Life on Mars would be so horrible as to not be worth it for the vast majority of people, I'm sure. "Beats being dead", you might say, but I disagree.

Not to mention it's still unclear if it's physiologically possible for humans to survive long-term off planet Earth.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by pesfandiar on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:13PM (#20044837)
Agreed. Let's first try and "colonize" places like Nevada. Getting safe drinking water to many major urban centres could become a challenging engineering problem in the upcoming decades, much more worthwhile to solve than living on Mars.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by niftich on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:35PM (#20045132)
There are large parts of Nevada that could be 'reclaimed' (in the Bureau of Reclamation sense) without too much effort -- just a couple of well-placed dams, berms, and canals. Large parts of the state are in closed basins, from which the water just evaporates anyway, so using it first within the basin would make sense. Extensive projects like this were once the norm, but fell out of favor as the 1970s transitioned into the 1980s, feeling the impact of the environmentalist movement, the opposition of Jimmy Carter, and the failure of the Teton Dam.

Some big urban areas already need to rely on interbasin transfers for their water supply: LA, NYC, San Diego, Mexico City, SLC, Denver. Tunnels for water would actually be a sensible and 'boring' pivot for the Boring Company.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by cycrutchfield on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:26PM (#20044997)
Why not both?
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by borkt on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:46PM (#20045265)
Also much, much easier to solve, and more than possible with existing technology. May require more clean energy but it can be solved.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by tdb7893 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:11PM (#20044821)
I think the idea is that they aren't mutually exclusive. I think in fact the projects are generally good examples of how you can do both.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by Jimpulse on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:14PM (#20044850)
There's also mitigating the Great Filter: https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/05/fermi-paradox.html
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ryanbrunner on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:39PM (#20045172)
If you accept the great filter hypothesis to explain Fermi's paradox, wouldn't that make interplanetary exploration a bit pointless? Presumably many other civilisations would have been able to achieve the same thing, and they were still wiped out by the filter event.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by munk-a on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:46PM (#20045257)
Not really, it could be that the great filter is apathy and single world habitation for instance - maybe we've been really lucky in terms of asteroid collisions so far and putting our eggs in two baskets is the necessary step for survival.

We don't know what the filter is, so it's sensible to reject pessimism and just keep on trucking.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by petschge on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:05PM (#20045481)
The alt text on https://xkcd.com/893/ fits really well here:

“The universe is probably littered with the one-planet graves of cultures which made the sensible economic decision that there's no good reason to go into space - each discovered, studied, and remembered by the ones who made the irrational decision.” -- Randall Munroe

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by vkou on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:53PM (#20046521)
And I postulate that "The universe is littered with one-planet graves of cultures which made the sensible economic and game theory decision of having thousands of thermonuclear weapons pointed at eachother, hoping that MAD will make that whole bit of lunacy sensible." -- vkou

It's got about as much empirical evidence to back it as RM's postulate. (And a similar sample size of N=0)

Anyone care to get on the train for my pet issue, and get around to nuclear arms reduction, already?

The beauty of making arguments, based on observing experiments with a sample size of N=0, is that you can argue whatever the hell you want.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by gitgud on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:11PM (#20046139)
A good quote I can relate to:

I'm perfectly happy with all the people who are walking around and just staring at the clouds and looking at the stars and saying, "I want to go there."But I'm looking at the ground, and I want to fix the pothole that's right in front of me before I fall in. This is the kind of person I am. - Linus Torvalds

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ineedasername on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:19PM (#20046230)
Sure-- I think it's fair to say that society & civilization as a whole is better off with both types of people.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by _Microft on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:20PM (#20044918)
It's not a replacement, it's a backup. You don't do these after a headcrash either but start doing them as soon as possible.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by quickthrower2 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:08PM (#20046110)
I came here to say this. If Earth gets struck by a large object we might be glad (i) we have another planet and (ii) we have a way to survive on an otherwise uninhabitable planet that Earth has become.

In fact living on mars might be the perfect preparation for what Earth might be like after climate change in a few hundred years time.

The technology generated by colonising Mars might help with climate change.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by charlesju on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:35PM (#20045130)
I think it's more than a back up. A lot of the problems, like the original poster pointed out, to survive on mars, are solutions that'll greatly benefit us on earth.

You cannot name one endeavor to get to Mars that doesn't have immediate byproducts that are incredibly useful to everyone on earth.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by SmirkingRevenge on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:40PM (#20045186)
There's a 100% chance of all life on earth going extinct, eventually, unless we colonize other planets.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by hndamien on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:52PM (#20045326)
This guy gets it.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by gnahckire on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:13PM (#20044841)
It sure is but, I believe the ultimate goal is to become an interplanetary species which would be pretty cool.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ekianjo on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:05PM (#20047035)
Going to the New World was also silly for Europeans at the time. Everything was going to be more dangerous, more risky and life threatening. But pushing ourselves to go beyond risk is what makes humans progress in the long run. Going to another planet is a huge, difficult step forward. By all means everyone who goes there will be worse off, but think beyond their existence, 300 years in the future. It may become a pretty nice colony once we figure things out.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spraak on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:19AM (#20049560)
I think the analogy is poor, because the "New World" was abundant with resources. The new world of Mars is not, and nearly everything would need to be brought there.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ekianjo on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:35AM (#20049625)
abundant with resources? How do you explain the first colonies starved to death in several different locations?

Its not the resources that matter as much as the ability and capability to extract something from them.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spraak on Thursday May 30, 2019 @12:05PM (#20052572)
No matter how large the numerator (the ability), divide by zero (lack of resources) is still an error.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ekianjo on Thursday May 30, 2019 @07:06PM (#20056844)
There is no shortage of chemical matter and minerals on Mars.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by dahfizz on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @11:29PM (#20048123)
Why did the aboriginals hollow out a tree and float across the ocean? Why did prehistoric humans walk all the way from Africa to the southern tip of America?

We explore. It is literally in our DNA. It's what makes us human. It's also why we outlive the neanderthals, who never left the geographic region they were "born" in.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by mymythisisthis on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:28PM (#20045696)
Having a small group of people on Mars would be a great scientific boom. Einstein was inspired because as a patent clerk he worked across from the railway station and was very aware of time, time standards, physical trains. We'd give up our earth centric imaginations of time, gravity, and many other things.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by gus_massa on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:58PM (#20046010)
> Einstein was inspired because as a patent clerk he worked across from the railway station and was very aware of time, time standards, physical trains.

[citation needed] I guess he was more inspired by the Michelson experiment and the Lorentz transformations.

> We'd give up our earth centric imaginations of time, gravity, and many other things.

Gravity works exactly like here (But you can jump higher). Time works exactly like here too (The length of the day and the year are different, it will be a problem to choose a good calendar, but it's already a mess here. Anyway, it's not a scientific or technological problem, people just don't want to change the calendar they are use to.)

Perhaps they will find a few new interesting cases for climate science an geology???

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by fhbdukfrh on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:43PM (#20045857)
They would spend all their time struggling to stay alive; no real science would ever get done. Look at the space station today. They're in a low earth orbit, completely dependent on resupply and accomplish very little other than siphon funding from unmanned exploration that actually leads to amazing breakthroughs because, "humans in space!"
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by PopeDotNinja on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:20PM (#20045639)
There is anything plenty of stuff that could irrevocably nerf the viability of Earth as a habitable world. Something will wipe out all remaining life on Earth eventually. A billionaire wanting to go to Mars makes more sense to me than a billionaire trying to build the world's biggest private yacht.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ineedasername on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:16PM (#20046189)
The moon might have been seen as similarly silly. US might much more easily have focused on nearer space with a greater ROI on the project itself. But apart from the geopolitical bragging rights, the technical constraints of a moon shot meant the development of all kinds of technologies that rippled outward through society. We see some of the same effects with the LHC. Its direct uses have limited (immediate) practical impact, but the technologies required to build it, harness & process those volumes of data, etc., have spurned on all sorts of more immediately practical innovations.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by idlewords on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:22PM (#20046259)
Sorry, what's an innovation that came out of the moon program or the LHC that has broader social benefit?
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ineedasername on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:30PM (#20046817)
Here is a good starting point for the LHC: https://www.quora.com/Could-any-practical-benefits-of-the-La...

And here's a good starting point for the Apollo moon missions: https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/80660main_ApolloFS....

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by edmundsauto on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:33PM (#20046835)
Quite a few things, to name a few:

* improved firefighting protective gear

* Athletic shoes

* Sports stadiums being able to move the field of play

* seismological monitors for everything from trains to trucks

* base defibrillator tech

* cordless power tools

* skin care: "Estee Lauder uses digital image analyzers and software based on NASA lunar research to evaluate cosmetic products."

[0] https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/80660main_ApolloFS....

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by idlewords on Thursday May 30, 2019 @09:06AM (#20050738)
Putting a dude on the Moon seems like a roundabout way to get better skin cream and footwear.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ineedasername on Thursday May 30, 2019 @09:52AM (#20051107)
And if that had been the only benefit then of course the whole program would be questionable. You asked for examples for the moon program and LHC, and you were given them in ample supply. If they aren't satisfactory in budging your opinion, this flow of discourse puts the burden on you to say something intelligent, and cherry picking only a single, and perhaps least relevant example doesn't really accomplish that.

There's no lack of material demonstrating that NASA's accomplishments contribute more to the economy than they drain in tax dollars [0] and it's difficult to ignore the volume & leaps of technical advancements achieved by earlier missions. You clearly have a different view though, so perhaps sharing that in a constructive way would be more beneficial than posting shallow comments that obviously ignore the information you requested.

[0]https://www.thebalance.com/nasa-budget-current-funding-and-h...

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by prepend on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:42PM (#20045854)
Mars is not full of people. Improving climate on Earth, means billions of people to deal with.

Also, these aren’t exclusive tasks. Everything that works for Mars also helps earth and in many cases specifically with climate change.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by kilroy123 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @07:48PM (#20046915)
I disagree. The technology that will come out of doing so will drastically improve life here on Earth. (Could potentially at least)

Just going to the Moon and living in low orbit has resulted in a ton of new technology.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by kpU8efre7r on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:58PM (#20046015)
Mars at its best is far less hospitable than the most inhospitable places on Earth. With that said- Earth is still only one planet and it would be wise for us to spread out for survival and resources.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spraak on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:20AM (#20049564)
Existentially I don't understand the need to perpetuate our species.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by maxxxxx on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:15PM (#20045583)
Totally agree. Mars seems a miserable place. I would prefer we sent probes to Europa, Enceladus and upper atmosphere of Venus first to see what’s going on there.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by hnzix on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @09:11PM (#20047418)
> The goal of Mars to me is silly. Mars is already worse off in terms of climate than Earth. Why not work to improve what we have?

Earth's biosphere has already had five (5) mass extinctions. Guess what happens to humanity if number six shows up before we colonize another planet? Mars is simply the closest option.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by halter73 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:12PM (#20047747)
The thing about the last five mass extinctions is they didn't involve a species so good at adapting the environment to serve its own needs that said species could colonize Mars.

Of those 5 mass extinctions, did any of them make Earth less habitable than Mars is today? I'm genuinely curious.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by hnzix on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:39PM (#20047876)
The Cretaceous–Paleogene extinction event is theorized to be a massive asteroid strike which "release[d] the equivalent energy of several million nuclear weapons detonating simultaneously" and killed off 75% of extant species.

Sure, the preppers will be gleefully LARPing Fallout from their bunkers, and a small percentage of humans would probably pull through. Maybe.

If we have a seed colony on Mars, it significantly de-risks human extinction from an asteroid strike. Elon is the ultimate prepper.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by sambull on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:08PM (#20046105)
Personal opinion, Elon believes that the earth is going to be uninhabitable by us in fairly short order. Mars is a fantasy to develop life support tech for earth, knowing full well saving ourselves would have been out of the question.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by austhrow743 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:42PM (#20045847)
"Uncharted Territory" / wild West is easily enough appeal to make it worth it.

Musk could be the sheriff of a colony in his very own space Western. People have worked hard their whole lives for much less.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by Causality1 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:01PM (#20046036)
Because being a multi-planet species is required for long term survival. Could be tomorrow or a hundred years from now, sooner or later there will be fifty mile diameter asteroid with our name on it.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by 127 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:00PM (#20045427)
Some find better ways to live on other planets, some find better ways to educate people how to live sustainably on this one, without fucking it up. It's all positive in my book.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by inamberclad on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:25PM (#20047817)
Do you propose not going to space at all? Or is there somewhere better nearby? The Earth won't support us for much longer.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spraak on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:22AM (#20049570)
And yet somehow Mars will [support us]? To me this is like having a car in need of repair (Earth) and instead finding some abandoned junker (Mars) rusting in the forest and saying "yes, I need that one!"
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spookware on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:21PM (#20044933)
For me its to get away from religion.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by whatshisface on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:28PM (#20045022)
You think nobody will bring their faith with them?
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by vntok on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:50PM (#20045316)
Precisely. Religions are in decline among the younger generations. By the time we go to Mars as a colonizing species, hopefully we won't bring "faith to a deity" with us.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ineedasername on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:25PM (#20046278)
There's plenty of other damaging ideologies to take their place. Look at the extremist 1% on either side of the left/right political divide for examples. Religion isn't a cause of negative ideological/extremism, it's a symptom of cognitive tendencies that give rise to it.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by mensetmanusman on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @11:47PM (#20048197)
In decline among young people who are not having replacement levels of offspring.

Social science has taught us religion imparts survival benefits (as does ‘politics’)

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by HNLurker2 on Thursday May 30, 2019 @04:13AM (#20049310)
>Religions are in decline among the younger generations.

And ideology is rising, see

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by DeonPenny on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:09PM (#20046118)
Redundancy. Plus the earth as it's is now is very hard to change and improve.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spullara on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @04:52PM (#20045328)
We will eventually be wiped out by an asteroid strike no matter what we do.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by mr_toad on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:13PM (#20047092)
Most species don’t last long enough to get wiped out by asteroids. I’d say that unless we evolve into something else, we’re unlikely to make it to the next big extinction event.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spullara on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @08:16PM (#20047115)
We are done evolving naturally, at this point it would all be genetic engineering.

We can have our eggs in more than one basket this century as long as we put effort into it. That is plenty of time to avoid getting wiped by an asteroid in all likelihood.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by epanchin on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:29PM (#20045724)
Ironic that you use the Wild West as an example.

Do you think the world would be better now if the British had just worked on improving Britain rather than settling in America?

I’m sure there were many people calling the settlers silly back then too.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by perfmode on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:32PM (#20045745)
It's a coin toss. America, as it came, came at a huge cost. And over the course of 300+ years, it was carried out in possibly the least ethical manner possible.

I for one would have been happy for the Europeans to evolve for another 1000 years before they set foot in the Americas, in earnest, under the aspect of eternity.

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by notahacker on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:57PM (#20045992)
> Do you think the world would be better now if the British had just worked on improving Britain rather than settling in America?

I suspect quite a few Native Americans do...

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by spraak on Thursday May 30, 2019 @05:24AM (#20049581)
I meant it as in "the freedom to do what one wants", not so much literally. And even so, Mars has probably less resources than even the (physical) Wild West did. In another comment I made the analogy that Earth is like a car in need of repair, and Mars is a rusting junker in the forest - in far worse of a state than Earth, but somehow there is the desire to go there.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by Retra on Thursday May 30, 2019 @10:48AM (#20051725)
The settlers back then were not trying to settle a barren rock with no breathable atmosphere or heat. If Britain had tried settling Antarctica, things would have gone very differently.

And as others pointed out, America was already settled when Europeans arrived, so what innovation even occurred there?

Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by megaremote on Thursday May 30, 2019 @12:59AM (#20048538)
Asteroid?
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by jobseeker990 on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:00PM (#20045425)
Why am I not allowed to downvote this nonsense?
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by ineedasername on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @06:26PM (#20046289)
Because you have zero karma. The right to negatively impact someone else's comment is predicated on having first positively contributed to numerous discussions.
Re:The Boring Company will develop an underground “people mo... by F_r_k on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @05:03PM (#20045463)
That's exactly why: because you cannot (yet) discern nonsense from something you don't agree on