News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by ryder9 on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:40AM (#20001311)
NASA requested $1.4B in increase

for comparison, Military budget increased from $586B in 2015 to $713B in 2019

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by tjpnz on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:29AM (#20001901)
NASA got a 1.6 billion USD increase. Around the same time it was announced that Wellington City (the third largest city in New Zealand, also the capital) had been given the equivalent of 4.5 billion USD for a revamped public transportation system. As far as public spending goes the two couldn't be more different. Yet it really did put into perspective the futility of NASA's situation, at least for me.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by georgeecollins on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:50AM (#20001426)
Or they just asked for (and presumably will get) an additional $15 B of subsidies for farmers to compensate for the trade war. Nothing against farmers, but if it is so easy to do that, why not fund NASA a bit?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by wallace_f on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:58AM (#20001518)
To be fair, the banks got over 400+ billion in TARP money plus over 4 Trillion in newly printed Fed Reserve dollars to buy literally "toxic assets," synthetic mortgage-backed securities, and government debt purchased off their books to shore them up after they negligently destroyed themselves(1). Fundamental, necessary banking services which they are subsidized to perform are not rocket science, either. This was subsidizing risk-taking. This transfer of wealth to Wall St is by far the most egregious heist in the history of humanity.

1-https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2017/08/18/the-hutch...

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by nickik on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:47AM (#20002743)
You cant compare money created by the Fed to money spent by the government. Thats just a surefire way to musunderstand everything. Tax payers to not have to pay interest on that money.

You are right about tarp however, that was idiotic and totally unneeded.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by georgeecollins on Friday May 24, 2019 @06:15PM (#20005769)
I am not sure that is true in terms of monetary policy. When the Fed "creates" money, is it really that different then the government "creating" money by selling bonds? That is, if you assume the government backs the Fed which most people do. Certainly the Fed creating money adds to the ratio of debt to GDP, and raises interest rates on government debt. But I am no expert so correct me.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by outside1234 on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:09PM (#20003468)
Well TARP was needed but there should have been systems in place to prevent it being needed (not allowing firms to grow to "too big to fail")
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by jessaustin on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:12PM (#20003960)
The firms have been big enough to control who is appointed to supervise (and bail out, when necessary) them for a long time. Nothing that happened in 2007-10 was going to change that. All the promises were bullshit, because that's all they possibly could have been.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by wallace_f on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:07PM (#20002947)
Money doesn't get its value from the Fed. It gets its value from what economists call real goods and services. If nobody was willing to exchange their work product for our money, it would be virtually worthless. So when the Fed electronically debits and credits their account with newly created money and a new purchase of a toxic asset, they're necessarily stealing someone else's (everyone else's, really) work product, in real terms.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by nickik on Sunday May 26, 2019 @08:30AM (#20014577)
You should really actually learn how monetary economics work. Its 100% incorrect to claim that every newly created $ is stealing somebodies work.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by wallace_f on Sunday May 26, 2019 @10:05AM (#20014991)
Lol I have formal training in this subject.

Is English a language you rarely use?

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by georgeecollins on Friday May 24, 2019 @06:11PM (#20005738)
Yeah I am not against the farmers or the banks. I'd just like to see some love for space exploration.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by wallace_f on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:53PM (#20006248)
This reminds me that scarcity is the central problem of economice, but in modern politics people seem to pretend it doesn't exist.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by dTal on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:05AM (#20002265)
It was the refutation to end all refutations that the reason we don't do $IMPORTANT_THING is "we can't afford it". Almost any utopian goal you can imagine is achievable with that budget. Switch the entire power infrastructure to solar? Easy. Food, houses for everyone? Petty cash. University education for all? Well within the budget.

Essentially, it amounts to socialism for huge corporations, but not for little humans. "Too big to fail" for them - "too poor to survive" for us.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by rayiner on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:51PM (#20003795)
You're wrong on two fronts.

First, you're ignoring the basic difference between expenditure and investment. When the government spends a dollar on healthcare, that may be an "investment" in an abstract sense, but the government is not directly getting that money back. In budgetary terms, it's expenditure.

That is not true for the financial bailouts. There, the government didn't just spend money, it got assets in return. With respect to TARP, the government got most of that $400 billion back. It made a nominal profit, and adjusted for inflation maybe you can book it as a $24 billion loss: https://www.nationalreview.com/2015/01/overselling-tarp-myth....

With respect to quantitative easing, what you're referring to is the Fed's SOMA operations. The Fed bought $3.5 trillion in assets (securities and treasuries--i.e. the right to be repaid money in the future). It is getting that money back as those assets mature. Right now, the Fed has about a $67 billion unrealized loss on those assets: https://seekingalpha.com/article/4225750-deterioration-fed-b.... That means the fair market value of the assets is $67 billion less than the Fed's purchase price.

So the actual cost of those programs is the $24 billion and $67 billion losses, not the $400 billion and $4 trillion it cost to purchase those assets. To put those numbers into perspective, the government has a portfolio of $1.5 trillion in student loans. Losses on that portfolio will cost the government $180 billion over the next decade: https://www.forbes.com/sites/prestoncooper2/2017/08/04/why-g....

Second, you dramatically underestimate the cost of those social welfare programs. If we scaled up our welfare system to Swedish levels, that would cost an additional $2.2 trillion more per year.[2] That is five times the upfront cost of TARP ($400 billion), and 100 times the actual cost of TARP ($24 billion). Welfare is expensive. Even if universal healthcare reduces our healthcare spending to German or French levels, we're talking 10-12% of GDP, or $2.3 trillion: https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm. Unlike the financial bailouts, that's (1) money you have to spend every year, not just once-in-a-generation; and (2) money you're not getting back.

Put it another way. Together, all levels of government already spend about $7.4 trillion per year. $400 billion--what the government spent on a once-in-a-generation bailout, was just 6% of what it spends every year. $24 billion--the actual long-term cost of TARP, is just 0.3% of government's yearly expenditures.

[1] Real-world example. Say in 2008 my parents house was worth $500k. The housing market collapses, and suddenly my parents need to sell their house. If they put it on the market, it would go at fire sale, say $200k. I bail them out, buying it for $450k. What was my cost of bailing them out? It wasn't $450k. It was $450k minus whatever I can ultimately sell the asset for. Say the market never recovers and I sell the house for $400k, 20% below the peak. The "bail out" cost me $50k, not $450k.

[2] Swedish government spending is 49% of GDP, versus 38% of GDP in the U.S. https://data.oecd.org/gga/general-government-spending.htm. That 11% of GDP difference amounts to about $2.2 trillion.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by wallace_f on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:51PM (#20006244)
>It is getting that money back as those assets mature.

The Fed printed trillions in new money and pumped it into asset classes, mainly the housing market, through a middleman--Wall St.

Even if you ignore everything wrong there and just say "they eventually got some of their money back" like you did, it still matters that they printed (ie effectively stole in real terms) 4 trillion dollars that they didn't own.

If you or I went out and printed US currency and bought securities with them--we'd go to jail. They wouldn't care that we made money on our investments.

Most of the profits from QE appear to have gone to Wall St (1), whom made 650M from it.

If the Fed is going to print trillions, at least buy healthcare or space exploration with it. Stop this circle jerk nonsense with Wall St.

1-http://fortune.com/2014/07/23/big-banks-made-650-million-off...

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by rayiner on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:44PM (#20006623)
> Even if you ignore everything wrong there and just say "they eventually got some of their money back" like you did, it still matters that they printed (ie effectively stole in real terms) 4 trillion dollars that they didn't own.

Printing money might be bad policy, but how is it stealing? The U.S. has the sovereign (and Constitutional) right to create money. (Also, the Fed's job is literally to create money to meet economic targets. SOMA was unprecedented not because the government "printed money" but because it bought an asset class it previously did not buy--securities.)

> If the Fed is going to print trillions, at least buy healthcare or space exploration with it. Stop this circle jerk nonsense with Wall St.

This is again ignoring the fundamental difference between printing money for consumption, and printing money to buy assets. If the fed prints money to buy healthcare or space exploration, it doesn't get that money back. If it prints money to buy assets, it gets almost all of that money back.

This is not an esoteric or meaningless distinction. The federal government originated $1.4 trillion in student loans since 2009. Would you call that a $1.4-trillion "free college" program? Of course not. People have to pay the money back, and the government will get most of their money back. The actual cost will be about $180 billion. By contrast, the government had spent that $1.4 trillion on healthcare or space exploration, it would have actually cost $1.4 trillion.

You can argue about the merits of bailing out Wall Street. But what you can't argue about is what it actually cost the government about $100 billion, not $4 trillion.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by dTal on Monday May 27, 2019 @04:46AM (#20020476)
Seems to me like it depends on what happens to the money after it comes back, if indeed it does so. If the government "un-prints" the money, destroying it, then indeed it was merely a loan from everyone that holds dollars, and not outright theft. But if that money goes back into some kind of general fund, then it doesn't matter what happened in between.

Also, I wouldn't say it's clear that healthcare or space exploration aren't assets, even in the strict financial sense you mean. What's the expected taxable value of a citizen? If you invest less than that on keeping them alive, then their life is an appreciating financial asset. Similar logic applies to space programs, if the space capacity you fail to build out ends up being something you buy from another country (as in the case of US astronauts riding to the ISS on Soyuz). And of course this is the shallowest of analyses - there are substantial additional hidden (financial) costs to letting your citizens die, or being dependent on foreign powers for space infrastructure.

The thing I find puzzling, and possibly telling, is that conventional wisdom tells us inflation ought to have spiked after the 2008 bailout. Instead it plummeted, indeed briefly became deflation. This tells us that money became very scarce. Why, after so much money was printed and handed out? Because it all went to the banks, and they essentially pocketed it and didn't lend it out. So what exactly was the purpose of doing that?

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by wallace_f on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:27PM (#20006745)
>The U.S. has the sovereign (and Constitutional) right to create money.

The right is actually with congress to have the power to do this. The Fed doesn't have any constitutional authority to do this.

Money gets its value from real goods and services. So when someone prints new money it steals that value from those who created it. The Fed likes to claim they create value, but they are just money changers.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by tptacek on Sunday May 26, 2019 @12:31PM (#20015745)
If that's the case, Congress could simply have voted to prevent Treasury or the Fed from doing it. By not doing so, it consented.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by wallace_f on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @01:25AM (#20027435)
Would you say that about every othe injustice, instance of cronyism, unconstitutionality or civil rights breach?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by tptacek on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @11:37PM (#20036647)
I would say that about most instances in which people claim an administration has overstepped in its use of authority delegated to it by Congress. The people you should be mad at in these situations is Congress.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by anigbrowl on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:18PM (#20004519)
Brilliant as you are Rayiner, I can't help noticing a certain Panglossian trend in your exegeses.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by lsc on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:13PM (#20004887)
>First, you're ignoring the basic difference between expenditure and investment. When the government spends a dollar on healthcare, that may be an "investment" in an abstract sense, but the government is not directly getting that money back. In budgetary terms, it's expenditure

What does healthcare do for people of working age? It allows us to work more and more effectively, to make more money and either consume fewer subsides or to pay more taxes.

Good healthcare means more and more effective workers.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by rayiner on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:30PM (#20005010)
The government cannot book the projected increased tax revenues from a healthier populace as an asset that offsets the money it paid to provide healthcare. The government can book a mortgage-backed security it purchased as an asset that offsets the purchase price of the asset.

Now, I think that universal healthcare certainly provides benefits that make it worthwhile, just as the bailout provided financial stability benefits that made it worthwhile. But those things are in the benefits column. I'm talking about how much an accountant would say that a government program cost.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by dragonwriter on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:38PM (#20005065)
> The government cannot book the projected increased tax revenues from a healthier populace as an asset that offsets the money it paid to provide healthcare.

From an MMT perspective, the government (any one using it's own fiat currency) creates and destroys money rather than spending and receiving it, even if it pretends otherwise in an outdated effort to ape a commodity-/representational-money system.

So, viewed that way, it really has no need for such an asset.

> Now, it is true that money spent on universal healthcare isn't being lit on fire--the government and the people gain some benefit from it. But that's in the benefit column, not the cost column.

In the cost column is a reduction in private healthcare costs exceeding the I crease in public expenditures, as shown in every analysis (including ones from hostile sources), so if the government raised taxes so as to leave private taxpayers in the same position as they would be in with status quo policy, net government outflow would be reduced without any adverse impact on taxpayers.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by rayiner on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:55PM (#20005635)
> From an MMT perspective, the government (any one using it's own fiat currency) creates and destroys money rather than spending and receiving it, even if it pretends otherwise in an outdated effort to ape a commodity-/representational-money system.

Even under that view, you can still see a difference. Spending $1 trillion in healthcare requires the government to create $1 trillion permanently. Spending it to purchase mortgage backed securities that are eventually sold or mature requires creating that $1 trillion only temporarily (while the asset is held).

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by lsc on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:22PM (#20005391)
So, I mostly agree on the costs of the '08 bailout, there's a lot of cases where problems of too much leverage become easy to solve if you have enough reserves, and my understanding was that the fundamental problem of '08 was too much leverage causing a downward spiral where everyone was forced to sell into that spiral. The private sector solution would have been to let that spiral go down much, much further before recovery; that would have caused a lot more pain and misery (and if we compare to past panics, probably wouldn't have made the resulting economy that much healthier) - The government is in a unique position because it credibly has infinite reserves and therefore can set a price floor (I mean, houses fundamentally have real value. People can live in them. but leverage can force the private sector to dramatically undervalue those real assets due to a lack of liquidity.)

Buffett's investment during the time were an example of what the private sector can do (and my opinion, as a shareholder of brk.b, who is otherwise not a finance expert, is that the man wasn't nearly greedy enough when others were fearful, but even berkshire doesn't have unlimited reserves.)

I think the big mistake of '08 was 'bailout with insufficient regulation' - if the government does need to do a bailout, that bailout should come with rules to prevent that sort of thing from happening again, and I think that there wasn't enough of that rule making after the '08 crisis.

I was just making a more general statement about the role of government in response to what I thought you were implying by pointing out the differences between how an investment in a failing company (that then doesn't fail because of your money) is accounted for differently than an investment in another person's health or education, even if the latter may net more.

In general I think the government should mostly stick with things that the private sector can't do well. The private sector is really bad at investing in things like healthcare and education for the poor that make people go from being net consumers to net producers. Government should largely focus on the things that government can do effectively but that the private sector can't do effectively. Usually this means providing services to the indigent and providing regulation (not direct ownership) of markets. But there are obviously exceptions, and I agree that '08 was one of those, it was a market failure that was big enough that the private sector couldn't really handle it, and I think direct interference was a net positive, even if I think the government could have done a much better job of it.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by matt4077 on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:04AM (#20001595)
TARP didn't cost anything. From Wikipedia[0]:

"On December 19, 2014, the U.S. Treasury sold its remaining holdings of Ally Financial, essentially ending the program. TARP recovered funds totalling $441.7 billion from $426.4 billion invested, earning a $15.3 billion profit or an annualized rate of return of 0.6% and perhaps a loss when adjusted for inflation"

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Program

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by howard941 on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:49AM (#20002105)
The tremendous moral hazard generated by risk-proofing the FIRE industry's bad practices w/r/t fraud-laden risk measures, CDOs, and CDSs caused orders of magnitude greater losses to ordinary Americans than the one time $15.3B windfall to the treasury. Better that the govt had cut $40K checks to every taxpayer than saved the banks' shareholders.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by TomVDB on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:04PM (#20003441)
You're not wrong, but all of that is a moral or unquantifiable point.

And it doesn't change the fact that TARP didn't cost any real money.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by aqme28 on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:27AM (#20001875)
Why is TARP the only program we judge with ROI?

Investment into NASA or infrastructure or education also has a return on investment, but anytime TARP is mentioned in comparison someone will bring up its ROI.

I know the answer is that the ROI for TARP is so much easier to quantify, but I still want to make the distinction that it's not unique for a government program.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by naasking on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:55AM (#20002816)
> Why is TARP the only program we judge with ROI?

Seriously. The ROI of solving the homeless and mental health crisis to the point where most of them can get back to work and become tax paying citizens is probably pretty good too.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by reallydude on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:19PM (#20003057)
There's not a lot of evidence that homelessness and mental health welfare will generate net positive tax revenue. Ever met someone on anti-psychotics? They go through the rest of their life barely able to grasp new concepts with a drug specifically designed to mute that part of their brain, alongside the side effects on their relatively short-lived organs being poisoned by the same drug cocktail.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by DanBC on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:43PM (#20003260)
> Ever met someone on anti-psychotics?

Yes, I meet very many people who take a variety of anti-psychotic meds.

> They go through the rest of their life barely able to grasp new concepts with a drug specifically designed to mute that part of their brain,

This describes a few of them, but not most of them.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by naasking on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:39PM (#20003240)
Those needing anti-psychotics are a small subset of the population I mentioned.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by wallace_f on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:26AM (#20001864)
I guess when you pump 4 trillion dollars and a federal guarantee of "we wont let these assets fail" into "toxic assets" then they become worth something.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by runako on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:26AM (#20001862)
> TARP didn't cost anything

This assumes zero value of having the Treasury backstop a business. There is always a cost associated with making an investment (which TARP was). In a sense, the entire discipline of pricing risk is based on calculating this cost.

Whether or not the chosen risk eventually paid off is a different question than the whether the risk had a cost to begin with.

* - I was a proponent of TARP as one of the better risks on the table.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by monetus on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:18AM (#20001773)
and perhaps a loss when adjusted for inflation... I've seen some spectacularly detailed comments on this from other hn users, specifically in regards to the inequity of QE. If anyone more knowledgeable could comment, I would appreciate it.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by aqme28 on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:28AM (#20001892)
They made back money, but less than they would have if they had just parked it in regular bonds. It's not an absolute loss of moneyt--it's a loss relative to what they would have done if they hadn't invested in TARP.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by maxxxxx on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:14PM (#20003017)
If TARP was such a great deal why did the government have to do it? Why didn't private investors jump in and support the banks?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by snowwrestler on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:25PM (#20003111)
If highways are such a great deal, why does the government have to fund them?

If national defense is such a great deal, why does the government have to fund it?

If FDIC insurance is such a great deal, why does the government have to fund it?

Why does the government have to do anything? Why don't private investors jump in and do everything?

The answer is: because there are certain things that are only a great deal if they are done by everyone all at once. Left to individual players, sometimes the incentives align like running from a bear--I don't have to outrun the bear, I just have to outrun one other person.

This is why we have government at all. Humanity was not handed a government, we invented it to solve problems that could not solved by piecemeal individual action.

And for TARP, a reminder that it came after Lehman failed and money markets broke the buck. The first House vote on TARP failed. It was adopted at the last minute, only as it became clear that it was necessary.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by maxxxxx on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:43PM (#20003266)
I accept that national defense is not a profit center, neither are highways. But they are good for everybody so it's ok that the taxpayer pays for them. The same may be true for TARP but I don't like to hear that TARP made profit because it didn't. Since 2008 we had huge deficits, banks got a backstop for free, the fed had to take on a lot of assets it normally should't have to, interest rates are very low. These all have a price.

TARP was not a benign thing but instead we should make sure this never happens again.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by zaroth on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:56PM (#20004313)
Highways are absolutely a profit center. The Fed spends ~$50 billion/year on highways and gets ~20% of the entire productivity of the nation in return. ($4 trillion on $20 trillion GDP)

If the entire highway system increases GDP at least $250 billion (1.25% of GDP) then highways are profitable.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by wallace_f on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:40PM (#20006197)
There do exist a lot of private roads. If govt did not build them for free, there would obviously be a lot more of them.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by zaroth on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:58PM (#20006273)
But the government didn’t build them for free. We collectively paid to build them, and now they more than pay for themselves. Roads are arguably the greatest investment the American taxpayer has ever made.

Building pubic-use roads without government planning, permitting, and eminent domain is frankly not going to scale, aside from the nightmare of how all the different owners of these roads would go about rent-seeking.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by jessaustin on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:16PM (#20003992)
"National defense" is such a poor example that it throws everything you've said into doubt. It is not a great deal to spend more than every other nation on earth combined, just to murder lots of people in other parts of the world. Those murders are of negative value to decent Americans.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by snowwrestler on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:06PM (#20004406)
I'm talking about government spending on national defense in general, not the current U.S. budget specifically.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by jessaustin on Friday May 24, 2019 @08:27PM (#20006380)
The rest of us are talking about USA spending during the time that NASA has existed.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by 2Ccltvcm on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:56AM (#20001488)
America should reduce corn subsidies. Corn works its way into the American food ecosystem in many ways to the detriment of the Americans' health. It is highly inflammatory by itself and it is processed into compounds which also modulate inflammation in other ways. See high fructose corn syrup and its inflammatory pathways. Processed corn products are a multi pronged attack on Americans' health. End corn subsidies.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by ajross on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:15AM (#20001732)
I'm not aware of anything specific to HFCS and inflammation that doesn't apply to any other fructose source. It's cheap sugar. Sugar is bad for you.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by behringer on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:38AM (#20001990)
I think that's the point. By ending corn subsidies, we'd raise the price of sugar.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by A2017U1 on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:05PM (#20003910)
Sugar prices in the states are double what everyone else on Earth pays due to perverse protectionism funded by the taxpayer. So many of my American friends never believe this either but it's true. Same with corn which is very much related.

https://www.thebalance.com/markets-for-us-and-world-sugar-80...

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by ajross on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:09AM (#20002324)
Marginally, yeah. But spinning that as "corn is toxic" is a bit much. Corn is perfectly fine as a food and a feed.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by sathackr on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:59AM (#20001529)
[citation needed]

Not that I dispute what you say, but I don't buy it hook-line-and-sinker.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by ryandrake on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:25PM (#20003586)
Not to mention befouling our fuel supply with engine-destroying and (energy-equivalent) expensive ethanol.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by bregma on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:16AM (#20001745)
Maybe NASA should just ask for farm subsidies to grow corn on the moon?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by pjmorris on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:25AM (#20001849)
Or, could they get Lockheed-Martin to build a moon-based F-35?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by 52-6F-62 on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:52AM (#20002140)
I, for one, support this goal of awesome space jets. Wake me when I can play Starlord.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by petercooper on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:03PM (#20002901)
I wonder if there were a viable commercial motive if NASA would suddenly get a ton of funding. For example, let's say platinum was discovered on the moon in large quantities.. would the money suddenly appear?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by emiliobumachar on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:59PM (#20004340)
The price would collapse from excessive supply before the mining costs could be recouped.

Though there are companies seriously considering mining asteroids, they're supposedly cheaper than the Moon because they have no appreciable gravity.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by TeMPOraL on Friday May 24, 2019 @06:47PM (#20005964)
Mining asteroids will be crucial for space economy, but there's little point in shipping mined resources downwell. What makes sense is to move manufacturing of space-related hardware and possibly of things benefiting from fabrication in microgravity up there, and then use asteroids and the Moon as resource base for building things in space, and mostly for space.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by azeotropic on Friday May 24, 2019 @08:00PM (#20006282)
No. Even if it were pure platinum that required no refinement it would still be more expensive to return it to earth than to mine and refine earth platinum.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by Rooster61 on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:26AM (#20001860)
Sounds like a Cave Johnson initiative.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by Loughla on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:04AM (#20001585)
If you only consider the near future, food and food security is more important than space.

If you consider long-term, we should be pouring everything we have into figuring out space colonization and travel, but I also just want to live in The Culture already, so I'm biased.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by adrianN on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:18AM (#20001772)
If you consider mid-term we should pour everything into de-carbonizing the economy.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by JTbane on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:35AM (#20001964)
Not to be pessimistic but all signs are pointing towards the world economy expanding emissions and fossil fuel usage.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by noir_lord on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:26AM (#20001867)
It sometimes annoys me I was born too early to live in a possible culture like society.

Then I realise I'm happy to have been born at all, getting to appreciate the universe for 39 years (next Thursday) was a good deal.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by gremlinsinc on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:55AM (#20002174)
being a newly born atheist/agnostic (ex-mormon), I have to say I never felt as spiritual and in 'awe' of the galaxy as I do post-belief-in-god, as I see it life is a miracle, to be able to be here, in this time of technology, to have a family that I adore two little babies that make me feel lucky every day.

To experience daily beautiful music like Queen, it's truly amazing what we have and if it is all random how much more beautiful is it that this all came from chaos? Maybe our chaos that is politics/divisions might work itself out into something more beautiful as we lift ourselves up and move into the universe. It's inevitable that life on earth will end someday, entropy and all. I'm hoping mankind doesn't. I'm hoping we figure out how to get past the great filter if we haven't already. I sure as hell hope we get past climate change, as that could be the filter and it's ever looming, even on my own children's heads.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by howard941 on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:51PM (#20004752)
The Culture would be an awesome place to live. Banks demonstrated that utopian visions needn't all be disguised dystopias, didn't he? Happy birthday.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by braythwayt on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:38AM (#20001986)
Let me be the lone voice of dissent fervently hoping that mankind (at least in any form I can envision us) does not leave our solar system.

Why do we need to "colonize space?" Show me mankind living peacefully and within its means on our enormous rock, and then I'll get excited about us spreading elsewhere.

Until then, I get the uneasy feeling that what we really want to do is shit our own bed, and instead of cleaning it up, simply spread out and start shitting in other beds.

---

Jeebus, I'm cranky!

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by adrianN on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:13AM (#20002362)
Space colonization does not allow us to shit our beds. Lifting things off Earth is too expensive to move our whole civilization. On the other hand, successful colonization of hostile environments like space or other planets requires great improvements in sustainability. Space ships and domed cities are too small to fuck around with the ecosystem for hundreds of years before you kill yourself.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by TeMPOraL on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:00PM (#20006034)
You could assume the pessimistic vision in which we never start "living peacefully and within its means" (and barring large-scale changes in our biological makeup and/or totalitarian governments you can't imagine, it seems likely simply from game-theoretical considerations). But even in that pessimistic vision, we should colonize space. Why? Because in that vision, we're going to shit our bed anyway, and there's a whole universe of wooden planks and feathers waiting to be turned into more beds.

Seriously, it's not like there's some intrinsic worth in all these rocks spinning around fusion reactors. To the best that we can tell, there aren't any other sapient beings around who could claim we're infringing on their sense of beauty. It's just us, the only ones possessing the spark of giving meaning to things, and a lot of dead rocks waiting to be used.

Personally, I don't think we'll stop fighting and doing stupid things, but I feel it's entirely possible that - assuming we survive the next few decades as a technological civilization - we will fix up this planet. And space habitation could be very helpful in this in multiple ways - beamed energy, geoengineering, moving some kinds of manufacturing to orbit, experience in managing ecosystems gained on running closed-loop habitats, etc.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by braythwayt on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:38PM (#20006192)
Manifest Destiny, 20xx Edition.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by TeMPOraL on Friday May 24, 2019 @08:02PM (#20006290)
Nah. It's the belief that we shouldn't venture out because we're not perfect that's kind of Inverted Manifest Destiny - the belief that universe is divine and we need to be worthy to partake in it.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by Loughla on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:43AM (#20002038)
I'm with you. I'm not convinced it will happen because we can't get our shit together on Earth. We're screwing this planet up, and I'm not convinced we'll ever even have the opportunity to screw up another one before some sort of massive extinction-level event of our species.

That being said, read The Night's Dawn trilogy. The undercurrent of those books is that we settled many planets specifically due to social/racial differences that we couldn't settle on Earth, but that aren't such a problem in space. It's an interesting take on the whole mess.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by gremlinsinc on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:50AM (#20002122)
I'm with you on that's probably how it'll happen, but IF we're the only intelligent life in the galaxy, I also don't want to see the miracle that it is intelligence snuffed out, I have HOPE that as we evolve, equality will rise, if we become space faring maybe scientists will become the leaders as well, and will lead by intelligence and not greed and deception. After we get to a post-scarcity society -- assuming nobody 'wants' for anything and the ai robots do most of the menial tasks I like to think that all our great grandchildren will be scientists and the only thing left for mankind to do is research and explore.

Edit/to add: Maybe we'll be star trek and NOT firefly/star wars?

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by SEJeff on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:32AM (#20002598)
I'd love to be a Special Circumstances member aboard one of the Interesting Times Gang Ships. They always find the fund problems.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by ianai on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:54AM (#20001470)
They could fund nasa at DOD levels and not risk hyper inflation nor any other ills. They could probably be coaxed into helping employ more rural communities too. (Ref: modern monetary theory)
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by dylan604 on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:55PM (#20003828)
The subsidies are entirely a political decision in an attempt to soften the pain of the tariffs. The farmers would much rather be selling their crops than accepting handouts.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by joncrane on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:18AM (#20001770)
Because farm subsidies are a very subtle form of vote buying but launching space ships isn't as effective in garnering votes.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by nickik on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:44AM (#20002715)
Think of it as an elaberate system of bribes payed to interest groups in order to buy votes.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by rayiner on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:56AM (#20002178)
Because NASA hasn’t produced anything useful in decades?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by sorenn111 on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:58AM (#20002198)
Because NASA has had no funding to do so? Even still that's probably not true. I don't have the sources in front of me, but I know most of modern climate monitoring is done with recent NASA innovation.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by nickik on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:49AM (#20002764)
Wrong. NASA funding now is high as it was during avg. appollo years.

NASA now does more different things but in terms of human spaceflight they have basically totally mismanaged it for 60 years.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by bardam on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:29PM (#20003141)
> Wrong. NASA funding now is high as it was during avg. appollo years.

That's not a true statement, unless you're talking about non-adjusted nominal dollars (that while technically true, is somewhat misleading). In inflation adjusted terms, the current budget is less than half of what it was during the Apollo years. Expressed as a percent of the federal budget, current funding is 1/8th of what it was at its max, though that's largely a function of the growth of non-discretionary federal spending.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_NASA

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by dahart on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:03PM (#20002913)
> NASA funding now as high as it was during avg. appollo [sic] years.

Well that’s easy to fact check... so how do you figure? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_NASA

NASA's budget peaked in 1964–66, when it consumed roughly 4% of federal spending. The agency was building up to the first Moon landing; the Apollo program involved more than 34,000 NASA employees and 375,000 employees of industrial and university contractors.[18]

In March 1966, NASA officials told Congress that the 1959–72 "run-out cost" of the Apollo program would be an estimated $22.718 billion. The total cost turned out to be between $20 and $25.4 billion in 1969 dollars (about $136 billion in 2007 dollars).[19]

The costs of the Apollo spacecraft and Saturn rockets came to about $83 billion in 2005 dollars. Apollo spacecraft cost $28 billion, including the command and service module, $17 billion; lunar module, $11 billion; and launch vehicles (Saturn I, Saturn IB, Saturn V cost about $46 billion in 2005 dollars).[20]

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by myself248 on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:42AM (#20002700)
Where do you get your weather forecasts from, sheep entrails?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by logfromblammo on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:31PM (#20003161)
If NASA produces nothing else, it can still fund parking spaces for the highly skilled individuals that cannot afford to self-fund their skills upkeep during the long interval between the megaprojects that may require expertise from their niche.

An economy that lives paycheck-to-paycheck will eventually lose the skills that it does not pay for every two weeks.

Also, if you need to educate 1000 people to hire the best 100, those other 900 still need decent jobs, otherwise students may choose to be educated into skills with better payoffs.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by georgeecollins on Friday May 24, 2019 @06:22PM (#20005811)
Inspiration? I found the Space Shuttle to be pretty inspiring.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by api on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:10AM (#20001670)
For the current military budget we could probably build O'Neill cylinders in Lunar orbit and start a terraforming project on Mars.

(Of course don't get me started about what we could do on Earth for this money.)

We are just very clever tool using animals, not yet a truly intelligent species. I don't think we'll truly be "intelligent" until our intelligence is able to overcome both our evolutionary legacy and game theoretic effects that emerge in our economies and societies. A true intelligence would be the master of these things. We are slaves to them.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by magduf on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:53AM (#20002153)
If we had the technology to build O'Neill cylinders, I can't imagine why we'd want to bother terraforming Mars. Mars is pretty crappy by comparison: the gravity is too low, it's cold and kinda far from the Sun (and from Earth, compared to Lunar orbit), and it's questionable what kind of resources are there which we don't have easier access to on the Moon or nearby asteroids. Most of the interest in it just seems to be nothing more than nostalgia for planet-based living.

Also, I think you'd want to build your O'Neill cylinders in one of the Langrangian positions between Earth and Moon, not Lunar orbit.

A truly intelligent species would actually be working substantively on these projects, instead of merely talking about them.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by vkou on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:31PM (#20003632)
A truly intelligent species would be working on not killing its own planet, instead of figuring out space habitation.

The ROI on the former is many orders of magnitude better.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by elsonrodriguez on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:48PM (#20003765)
A truly intelligent species would be doing both.

Also an extinction level event happening on this planet is a certainty, so it's actually an infinite order of magnitude better to figure out how to live in space than to only focus on saving the earth.

But again, a truly intelligent species would do both.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by magduf on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:05PM (#20004394)
Exactly. A truly intelligent species doesn't put all its eggs in one basket. Plus, a truly intelligent species knows that expansion (in population) is good for the survival of the species and civilization, and the way to get more resources and space is to go to space and acquire resources there and also learn to live there.

The dinosaurs are a good example of a group of species that weren't far-sighted enough to invest in a serious space exploration and settlement program.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by vkou on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:48PM (#20005591)
> The dinosaurs are a good example of a group of species that weren't far-sighted enough to invest in a serious space exploration and settlement program.

If we knew that a cretaceous extinction event will happen five, fifty, or five hundred years from now, it'll be orders of magnitude easier for civilization to survive on Earth, then it will be for it to survive in space.

If dinosaurs had opposable thumbs, and technology, they would have been better off bunkering down. No matter how uninhabitable some freak civilization-ending event would leave the Earth, it would still be more habitable then anywhere else in the Solar system.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by magduf on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:28PM (#20031667)
With the correct technology, that's not true: it's perfectly possible to build very nice habitats in space with O'Neill cylinders, but you need a lot of technology and space-based infrastructure to make that happen. A truly intelligent species would be working hard on that problem, because the technologies needed to make big O'Neill cylinders would also have many, many other uses. A stupid species, on the other hand, would dedicate its most intelligent members to figuring out how to advertise to each other more effectively and sell each other useless crap.

It's also quite possible to do multiple things at once when you have a civilization with many members. So as I said before, a truly intelligent species would not put all its eggs in one basket. They'd work on figuring out how to colonize space at the same time as figuring out how to deflect asteroids and also handle asteroid impacts if they did happen.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by vkou on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:41PM (#20005533)
> A truly intelligent species would be doing both.

When you have limited resources, you deal with a problem that's going to affect half the population of the planet in the next 20 years, as opposed to dealing with a much harder problem that might affect the entire population of the planet in a once-per-fifty-million-years lottery.

We are currently putting all of our eggs in one basket, because climate change will kill modern civilization much faster then we can move the entirety of modern civilization into a <even less hospitable off-planet environment>.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by magduf on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @12:30PM (#20031694)
This isn't true at all. A somewhat-intelligent species with limited resources would indeed work no dealing with such a problem. However, a stupid species would simply ignore the problem, which is exactly what we're doing.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by vkou on Tuesday May 28, 2019 @06:28PM (#20035053)
Do you live in an off-the-grid nuclear bunker, or a home? Do you wear a bulletproof vest, and a motorcycle helmet when driving a car, or walking on a sidewalk? Do you hoard decades worth of food?

An 'intelligent' person would do all of those things - because, after all, nuclear war can start any moment, our roads and sidewalks are dangerous places, and you never know where your next meal is going to come from.

Worrying about planet-ending disasters, and establishing civilization in space is much like doing any of the things I've listed. It's not intelligent - it's a non-cost-efficient response to incredibly unlikely occurrences. Especially when there are incredibly likely occurrences, that we'd be much better off preparing for, instead.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by magduf on Wednesday May 29, 2019 @10:58AM (#20040940)
These are bad comparisons. There are too many people on Earth now for us to acquire all our resources here without a large environmental cost, which even without a killer asteroid is going to bite us in the ass. There's endless resources in space, so logically we should be building the technology and capability to go there and harvest them. A by-product of that is also being able to live there and have an insurance policy just in case there's a planet-ending disaster.

In short, planet-ending disasters are not the only reason to develop these capabilities, and it's shortsighted and stupid to continue to destroy our environment here without taking advantage of all the resources and opportunities outside our gravity well.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by vkou on Friday May 31, 2019 @01:37PM (#20063109)
The economic cost of extracting Earth resources + environmental restoration/remediation is many orders of magnitude lower then the cost of extracting space resources, and will remain many orders of magnitude lower for any realistic projections of the future.

If we cared about this sort of thing, we would be doing it now, as opposed to sitting on our hands, waiting for magical space unicorns to be invented.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by InternetUser on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:43AM (#20002040)
Well, the Military will soon include the Space Force[0][1], so let's see how the funding of space-related activity goes in the next couple years.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Space_Force

[1] https://www.military.com/space-force

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by anthuman on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:31AM (#20002589)
I suspect more and more funding will go to the Space Force and less and less will go to NASA. Looking at the budgets, it's clear that the military has far more pull in washington than NASA. Seems like whatever the military wants, it gets. While NASA has to beg, plead and grovel for every crumb.

And if SpaceX, Blue Origin and the private sector become viable players in space, then NASA might be shut down or absorbed into Space Force.

With China, EU, Japan, India, etc getting involved in space exploration, it's inevitable that space is going to be a new frontier of militarization and privatization. Space Force and the private sector are natural players in this new arena. Not sure where NASA fits in this picture.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by thowaway9883 on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:24PM (#20005406)
The majority of NASA's missions are instrument-driven science missions designed to answer questions about space (ex: JWST). Neither SpaceX or Blue origin has displayed serious interest in replacing this function of NASA. They are mainly engineering organizations, and while they are effective at doing what they do, they are organizationally not pursuing models that research fundamental astrophysics, heliophysics, or earth science.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by tptacek on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:28AM (#20001889)
No, it's closer to $70B, over the 9-year lifetime of the Artemis project. The "$1.6B" this article talks about was a "down payment".
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by broahmed on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:56AM (#20001493)
Great way to visualize the size of the military budget in comparison to other programs: https://us.wikibudgets.org/w/united-states-budget-2016

Looks like the latest year they have for 2016, but still useful.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by siffland on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:41AM (#20002684)
Yeah but Russia hitting us with hypersonic weapons and China sabotaging us with electronic warfare or North Korea nuking us is a far greater possiblity that may occur than aliens invading. That is why our money is pumped there.

But at least Will Smith is still around in case the aliens invade, so i feel safer......

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by mLuby on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:21PM (#20003069)
Come on, you know that "potential damage to US * likelihood of occurring" is not how funds get allocated. If that were true, they'd have ended our dependence on many foreign markets (especially oil), solved global warming (or at least built a great seawall), and headed off a bunch of social issues that threaten the stability and cohesion of the US.

Follow the money.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by SketchySeaBeast on Friday May 24, 2019 @09:46AM (#20001366)
Maybe they can hitch a ride on that ridiculous new "Space Force"?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by booleandilemma on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:42AM (#20002035)
And why is it ridiculous exactly?

Where do you think the next frontier is? Do you think that humanity, which has warred with itself for its entire existence, is going to stop warring with itself when it’s living in space? If so, I have a wall to sell you.

Do you not want the US to have a military presence up there?

Do you want the US to take a backseat while China and Russia build out their own military capabilities in space?

You’re like a person in the 1400s laughing at a country for building a navy.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by blackguardx on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:07AM (#20002296)
The Air Force already does the job that the Space Force is supposed to do. Creating another military branch would duplicate a lot of administrative functions and not be very cost effective, IMHO.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by taftster on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:26AM (#20002520)
> "If established, it would be organized as a military service branch within the Department of the Air Force, one of the three military departments within the Department of Defense." [1]

So yes, any new military service branch is going to have overhead. But the Air Force already provides the structure and overhead for the space initiatives

The Space Force is more about formalizing (and potentially funding) this branch of the AF separately from the main budget of the AF. There will still be a little additional overhead, but not really like you're implying.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Space_Force

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by Rebelgecko on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:17PM (#20003995)
Another perspective— that "little bit of overhead" for starting up the Space Force is almost as large as NASA's annual budget. At least that's if you believe the budget numbers from Heather Wilson (outgoing secretary of the Air Force). Unfortunately, I doubt that standing up a new military service is something that the government would actually be able to accomplish without going over budget.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by anigbrowl on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:23PM (#20004551)
If so, I have a wall to sell you.

Ha ha, only a rube would believe in a grift like a wall, the smart set are over here with the guy running the Wall scam to finance his real 'insider' project, the 'Space Force' which is totally legitimate and not at all a procurement bonanza. Sure there's a treaty about the non-militarization of space but let's ignore that and pretend it's already obsolete, while we also pretend that the air force hasn't been handling our Sekrit Space Stuff just fine for decades.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by maxxxxx on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:17PM (#20003036)
Instead of getting into a new weapons race I would prefer more effort into negotiating an international agreement to not weaponize space. The stance of the US in the past few years seemed to be to produce more weapons than anybody else and not negotiate.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by misterprime on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:39AM (#20002007)
Space Force may have a funny name, but with the new threat of predator satellites it seems that orbit may be a legit theater of battle.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by craftyguy on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:52AM (#20002138)
If anything, creating a 'space force' will ratchet up the number of 'predatory' satelites. It's a self-fulfilling prophecy..
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by misterprime on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:56AM (#20002181)
How do you suggest avoiding it? Let other countries take that space while the US holds their head high with the moral high ground? That's not a winning strat IMO.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by gmueckl on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:02PM (#20002894)
The problem is the aggressive language implied in terms like "space force" rather than the capabilities involved. Develop them in secret, store/shelve them until they are truly needed (hopefully never) and never talk about them because that would give others bad ideas.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by kazagistar on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:21AM (#20002445)
Who cares? Any country that has space war abilities is a country that fighting a war against would nearly end humanity regardless.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by phil248 on Friday May 24, 2019 @01:41PM (#20003721)
By negotiating arms control treaties.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by jryle70 on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:57PM (#20005236)
I'm all for this, but says if Burkina Faso today demands the US to enter agreement not to weaponize the space, do you think the US would feel the need to respond? how about after Burkina Faso has successfully demonstrated its satellite shoot-down capability?
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by craftyguy on Friday May 24, 2019 @07:39PM (#20006193)
Why must a country possess the capability to shoot down satellites in order to demand that other countries stop doing it? If Burkina Faso pays ESA to put something in space for them, they probably don't want some hot-shot US commander in chief waking up on the wrong side of twitter and deciding to blast it out of orbit. That seems like a perfectly reasonable excuse to demand others not use any capabilities they possess for shooting down satellites, even if Burkina Faso does not possess the ability.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by craftyguy on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:59PM (#20004796)
And making it very difficult for incompetent heads of state to arbitrarily pull out of them.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by hsnewman on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:23AM (#20001825)
Even better, we need to build a wall on the moon.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by SketchySeaBeast on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:37AM (#20001980)
What I'm hearing is if Mexico could land a man on the moon the US would be there tomorrow.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by sambull on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:21AM (#20001803)
I feel really shitty that we're watching our future generations get outright robbed of living a good life.
[dead]
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by clarkmoody on Friday May 24, 2019 @12:36PM (#20003206)
You might want to read a little history of the presidents for real examples of dictator-like behavior, from Democrats and Republicans.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by gremlinsinc on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:00PM (#20003874)
Idealizing Duterte, Kim Jong Un, and the leaders of Russia and Saudia Arabia and creating concentration camps for kids while shitting all over our friendly democratic leaders from UK, France, Canada seems like a good start at becoming a dicator. What makes other presidents more dictatorial, I'd like to know.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by grayed-down on Friday May 24, 2019 @03:12PM (#20004467)
That's one view through the leftist lens, but at least you ended your comment with an appropriate question.
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by boapnuaput on Friday May 24, 2019 @04:46PM (#20005138)
What is the "leftist lens" here? Salvadorans [0] and Guatemalans [1] want to know why their citizen has died while in USA custody under curious conditions. When USA citizens die under custody of North Korea [2], or when USA citizens die under state actions orchestrated by the USA [3], we are upset and wonder what has happened; is that an inappropriate response here? It is confusing and dismaying that we are not getting a clear insight and understanding into how the USA government is managing its camps on the southern border [4].

[0] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/migrant-children-death-a-10-yea...

[1] https://thehill.com/latino/444584-guatemalan-teen-dies-in-bo...

[2] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-northkorea-detainee-i...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Teruggi

[4] https://thehill.com/homenews/house/445167-gop-votes-to-strik...

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by simonsarris on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:23AM (#20002468)
Your "for comparison" figures do not seem true:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_...

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by rayiner on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:56AM (#20002183)
The military budget buys you global dominance and never having to bend domestic policy to account for what anyone else thinks. What has NASA bought us?

I think space is cool. I have a degree in aerospace engineering because of that. But if you look at space exploration in terms of ROI it has sucked.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 24, 2019 @10:59AM (#20002208)
Better question: what WILL it buy us?

Things like asteroid mining, colonization. Worth trillions. No, we don't have a convenient number for what asteroid mining is worth - a better unit would be 'civilizations'?

It even could bring space dominance if that's important.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by jraines on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:01AM (#20002225)
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by balabaster on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:22AM (#20002462)
> What has NASA bought us?

I'll leave this here:

https://spinoff.nasa.gov/Spinoff2008/tech_benefits.html

Highlights -

- Water purification

- Land mine removal

- Freeze drying technology

- Fire resistant reinforcement

- Solar power

- Satellite phones

- GPS

All having significant military applications, as well as public benefit.

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by cr0sh on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:44PM (#20004202)
I'd also argue SMT technology; while things were moving in that direction before then, it seems like the Apollo program really kicked it in high gear with the need for the compact AGC:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_Guidance_Computer

I'd have to think that SMT was available prior to the AGC development, but I don't think it was as widely used commercially (maybe more for the military and avionics?).

Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by compuguy on Friday May 24, 2019 @05:58PM (#20005648)
DARPA was also apart of the development of GPS...
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by Rebelgecko on Friday May 24, 2019 @02:22PM (#20004033)
GPS is kind of a stretch
Re:NASA executive quits weeks after appointment to lead 2024... by myself248 on Friday May 24, 2019 @11:45AM (#20002723)
Prestige. Admiration. Beating the USSR even after their stronger start.

All the positive aspects of America's place in the world's consciousness rest on our achievements and leadership in technology, education, and exploration. In other words, NASA.

We have a lot of black marks on our reputation, too. If we keep neglecting our proudest achievement, that's all we'll have left.