Lyft has bled money from day 1, so justifying stiffing the workers on the basis of accelerating losses isn’t logical at all.
Now that the investors have cashed in, perhaps they can double down on patents on robo-cabs and stop bleeding money on tech that will probably arrive too late to save them.
Drivers are subcontractors, and if they are looking at striking, that's a signal that their pay isn't sufficient. Ride sharing providers encourage their contractors to perform accept tasks in a way that resembles full-time employment, but the message they recruit with is that "you're making extra money with your car, which is "free"". It's a bad deal because they pay $0.85/mi, and operating the car costs around $0.58/mi (which is a lowball estimate for livery use, and $0.23 of that is depreciation). When you factor in additional wear and tear, brakes, etc, full time drivers probably have another $0.10 of expense.
It's inherently exploitive, as Lyft subcontractors are working for cashflow and operating at a loss.
Where the money comes from is Lyft's problem. They can cut operational overhead, raise prices, reduce R&D science projects, take measures to eliminate unprofitable routes, etc. The usual reply is "robot cars are coming and this goes away"! That's not really right either -- there are no sentient robots driving around looking to be exploited, so they will need to own or lease those assets, which will depreciate at something like $0.50-0.75/mi (your robot cab isn't going to be cheap), and they will need to manage, insure and maintain the assets, which isn't cheap either.
Congrats to the folks who cash out. As amazing as ridesharing is, it's a fucked business.
This is not how the minimum wage works currently. This is not all Uber/Lyft's feet, it's a broader problem in the economy. I understand this is more complex than Uber flipping a "fair wages" switch.
The trick is essentially that at the end, the loan (or the shares that replace it) goes into default(become worthless).
This is an old, old game, and one that can be run for a few short years, before it all ends in tears, and "whocoodanode" (to coin an americanism). Let´s just hope there isn´t too much pension fund money tied up in all this.
Overall, they are losing money as a company. And if you divide that out by the number of rides, you can make it seem like they are losing money.
So to think they couldn't be cheating drivers because of that is like saying we know Donald Trump never cheated anyone in business from 85-95 because he lost money for every year that decade.
Minimum wage is the floor. If tips don’t bring your cash wage up to minimum, the employee has to get paid.
That's Lyft's problem, not the drivers'. They could always find more money by charging higher fares and maintaining a fleet of identical cars for drivers to rent, but then they'd just be a taxi company, not a "tech platform." If they want to keep offering VC-subsidized rides, that's fine by me. And when they run out, they can decide whether they want to stiff their drivers even more, or raise their fares.
And yes, the American tipping system needs to die.
It's not clear that they'd actually end up with more money as a company or more money for drivers this way. I'd expect they could pay many fewer drivers somewhat more, but total payments to drivers would be much less.
I get it that WhatsApp and StackOverflow and Instagram have/had a lot less legal, financial, and marketing requirements. But Uber has almost 1000 times the amount of employees WhatsApp, Instagram, and StackOverflow had when they reached similar scale.
I get it that there's a lot more analytics and geospatial complexity in Uber. I get it that they have to manage tens (hundreds?) of thousands of drivers.
It just seems like there's a LOT of unnecessary fat that could be cut.
Facebook only had 4k employees when they IPOed. Google had only 1,900!
That's where a lot of the 22,000 employees are, and if Uber could thrive without them, it surely would have already done so. Among the tasks I see listed in a current Uber job ad:
--Walk driver-partners through the onboarding process and all of the tools they need to be successful on the Uber platform
-- Help existing driver-partners troubleshoot any issues they experience (i.e. a delayed payment)
-- Help brand the Uber name and get driver-partners excited to be on the road
-- Assist with events and promotions as needed (occasionally off-site, during off-hours or weekends)
Why is this essential? It seems like a fluffy marketing position to me.
Just get one of the engineers to write code to get driver-partners excited to be on the road. Seems like an easy weekend hack.
That's uber's position, that doesn't make it so.
The more interesting figure to me would be how many of those 22k are developers.
Here are some calculations:
Currently per mile cost of car (fuel, vehicle, insurance) to driver is about $0.50. Uber/Lyft typically charge $2.00 per mile so $1.50 goes to driver. Subtracting cost of car, driver pockets about $1 per mile which translates to $30/hr in urban areas.
One issue however is upper limit on the business. There is probably demand for 100,000 cabs each hour in US. That translates to may be 2-3 million miles per hour. if Uber can capture 30% of this, then their US revenue would be at about $4B. The international revenue perhaps adds another 2X so we are looking at total revenue of about $12B @ 30% market share. There is room to grow by almost 100% here in terms of market share so with $24B revenue and $2B of minimally needed fixed cost for operations, this seems fairly sustainable and astoundingly profitable business to me.
Average depreciation cost per mile driven is ~ $0.6 [0]. Commercial insurance is ~ $0.2 Cost of gas per mile (in CA at 20 mpg, since most cars are non-hybrid) ~ $0.2
So cost of driving per mile is ~$1 to the driver
So really driver makes ~$15/hour when it is busy, less most of the time
Additionally the average occupancy for an uber/lyft is much higher than typical privately used cars. Adding hundreds of pounds of passenger weight for a shared ride will yield below average MPG on a typical car, making expenses above average.
Uber's costs of providing a specific ride are: Driver's cut, maps licensing, cloud charges, data transfer. That is rarely more than the cost of the ride. Remember, Lyft took flack for the outrageously high 14 cents a ride in cloud costs.
No, I'm (correctly) excluding it from the list of things they have to pay for to provide one more ride.
>It’s like saying a gigabyte of data on a wireless carrier cost them pennies in electricity and bandwidth.
It's more like:
Verizon is unprofitable.
People keep repeating the claim that, "lol, Verizon mobile actually loses money for every byte of data they transmit to you."
I reply that, "No, Verizon loses money in the aggregate. The cost of sending one more byte of data, on average, is less than they charge for it, but not by enough to cover their fixed costs."
We really don't know what the "fair" rate is for running a ride-hailing business. We know what's been collected to date in a venture-funded duopoly with limited public disclosure.
But my guess is that 22% is not the long-term equilibrium. Lots of outside pressures (regulators; new competitors) could drive Uber's share down. It's hard to see any forces that would cause it to expand.
If you factor in the way Uber can dictate price, you may actually be "paying" a higher fee versus what you could've made on your own. If they force you to accept a 40% discount that's got to be factored in, too.
Apple takes 30% but they don't tell you what price you can charge.
Are they really, in addition to all their other costs, going to stock up on millions of expensive autonomous vehicles? That's unrealistic. And if they don't, what stops for example peer-to-peer solutions to emerge that let's people rent out their cars directly? It's very possible we don't need a middleman here when autonomy is ready.
I'm usually sceptical of all the decentralised, smart-contract stuff, but renting your car to some agreed upon destination or for some time through a open-source free application sounds actually doable.
People talk about being "a Ford family". "This is a Chevy household". They cheer on their favourite brand in races.
I don't hear much in the way of "we bleed Uber blood".
A RE agent has to put in significant work for each commission they earn.
I paid a broker $8k to rent an apartment I found online on my own. The landlord paid them another pile of cash, probably comparable to that. I'm not sure that constitutes "putting in significant work"
No comparison to other businesses is exact, but the basic point is that if we make the rounds of commissions charged throughout the economy, not many fields have settled out at the above-20% level that Uber is currently defending.
The Eventbrite comparison honestly makes 22% sound reasonable. Uber does a lot that Eventbrite doesn't do:
- Make the market (you don't go to Eventbrite to find an event to go to, you find an event you want to go to and get routed through Eventbrite)
- Provide a form of ID verification on both buyer and seller
- Resolve disputes (Eventbrite probably does something like this at much lower volume).
- Navigate the regulatory environment.
- Provide real time assistance throughout the transaction (ie navigation for both buyer and seller)
Not to mention, event at that 14% Eventbrite stock is down nearly 50% on the year.
Of course Grab gets a share of the income, but I’d guess it’s less than or equal to 30%.
I few of those trips a day should be decent income to the average Thai.
Given the dynamic, I'd expect people to charge the company more for their time for gig work than for a stable job.
[Edit: Is that incorrect? Why would this be down-voted.]
How would you feel if your boss took a part of your salary and spent it on new technology intended to eliminate your job?
This is not 'a work only when you want' job. People do it full time to feed their families and after doing it for years find it difficult to move to a different role for a variety of factors. I'm sure they would go get a better paying job elsewhere if it was easy.
It used to be a 40 hour job when they joined but Uber/Lyft have gradually reduced earnings. Now it's 60-70 hour a week job. That's the problem. The gig work/contractor aspect of Uber/Lyft is a smokescreen to avoid paying minimum wage. The drivers are doing it because they have to but the work conditions are pretty bad. Hence the strike.
The strikes were small so the effects on both companies were negligible. I would be curious to understand what changes the drivers (who work only when they want) expect and how they think a company running deep in the red could meet them. Not trying to pass judgement on the strikers just trying to understand.