If you factor in the way Uber can dictate price, you may actually be "paying" a higher fee versus what you could've made on your own. If they force you to accept a 40% discount that's got to be factored in, too.
Apple takes 30% but they don't tell you what price you can charge.
Are they really, in addition to all their other costs, going to stock up on millions of expensive autonomous vehicles? That's unrealistic. And if they don't, what stops for example peer-to-peer solutions to emerge that let's people rent out their cars directly? It's very possible we don't need a middleman here when autonomy is ready.
I'm usually sceptical of all the decentralised, smart-contract stuff, but renting your car to some agreed upon destination or for some time through a open-source free application sounds actually doable.
People talk about being "a Ford family". "This is a Chevy household". They cheer on their favourite brand in races.
I don't hear much in the way of "we bleed Uber blood".
A RE agent has to put in significant work for each commission they earn.
I paid a broker $8k to rent an apartment I found online on my own. The landlord paid them another pile of cash, probably comparable to that. I'm not sure that constitutes "putting in significant work"
No comparison to other businesses is exact, but the basic point is that if we make the rounds of commissions charged throughout the economy, not many fields have settled out at the above-20% level that Uber is currently defending.
The Eventbrite comparison honestly makes 22% sound reasonable. Uber does a lot that Eventbrite doesn't do:
- Make the market (you don't go to Eventbrite to find an event to go to, you find an event you want to go to and get routed through Eventbrite)
- Provide a form of ID verification on both buyer and seller
- Resolve disputes (Eventbrite probably does something like this at much lower volume).
- Navigate the regulatory environment.
- Provide real time assistance throughout the transaction (ie navigation for both buyer and seller)
Not to mention, event at that 14% Eventbrite stock is down nearly 50% on the year.
We really don't know what the "fair" rate is for running a ride-hailing business. We know what's been collected to date in a venture-funded duopoly with limited public disclosure.
But my guess is that 22% is not the long-term equilibrium. Lots of outside pressures (regulators; new competitors) could drive Uber's share down. It's hard to see any forces that would cause it to expand.