News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:18PM (#19639316)
What part of the first amendment exonerates knowingly attempting to crack NTLM keys of US military logins?

Or is the reasoning that the law should give him special treatment and exemptions not given to others?

Also, is the 1st amendment protection even applicable to foreigners on foreign soil?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by apsec112 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:30PM (#19639442)
Yes, First Amendment protections apply to non-Americans. However, as you say, Assange is being prosecuted for conspiracy to hack computers, not for his speech.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by rayiner on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:22PM (#19639872)
The First Amendment probably does not apply to non-Americans with respect to their conduct abroad. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Verdugo-Urqui...

> The Court held that the Fourth Amendment's prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures did not apply where United States agents searched and seized property located in a foreign country owned by a nonresident alien in the United States. Chief Justice Rehnquist authored the opinion for the Court, joined by Justices White, Scalia, Kennedy and O'Connor, contending that "the people" intended to be protected by the Fourth Amendment were the people of the United States, and that the defendant's "legal but involuntary presence" on U.S. soil (a direct result of his arrest) failed to create a sufficient relationship with the U.S. to allow him to call upon the Constitution for protection.[1]

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by dragonwriter on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:52PM (#19640493)
> The First Amendment probably does not apply to non-Americans with respect to their conduct abroad.

How does a Fourth Amendment case turning on the interpretation of specific language that is not present in the First Amendment lead to that conclusion?

(Also, since the alleged conspiracy was related to acts that would be committed within the US, by a US citizen, it's far from clear whether, even if the rationale of the case you cite did apply, the result would still be that there was insufficient relationship to the U.S. with regard to the act in question.)

Note that I don't think the First Amendment has any bearing on this case because of the actual conduct at issue, but if it did, I'm not seeing how the case you point to would make it inapplicable based on Assange’s citizenship and location.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by mike00632 on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:21AM (#19642452)
>... that is not present in the First Amendment lead to that conclusion?

It's commonly understood that the conduct of foreigners abroad is not protected by American rights. That is the legal basis for most of the 'War on Terror' military actions and one of the key reasons why the assassination of Anwar al-Awlaki was objectionable. The way our system understands the law means that American citizen Anway al-Awlaki (and his son) had rights that were violated when he was killed.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by dragonwriter on Friday April 12, 2019 @03:50AM (#19642881)
> It's commonly understood that the conduct of foreigners abroad is not protected by American rights.

So we're backing away from legal argument to conventional wisdom?

> That is the legal basis for most of the 'War on Terror' military actions

No, it's not. About the closest that comes to the truth is that a lot of the War on Terror actions are based on the legal principle that certain, mostly procedural,. Constitutional rights do not apply to actions taken by the US government overseas against non-citizens, but there is no principal under which the limitations imposed by the first amendment (“Congress shall make no law...”) don't apply to the application of a law underlying a criminal prosecution in regular US federal courts, regardless of the nationality of the defendant or the location of the crime.

> The way our system understands the law means that American citizen Anway al-Awlaki (and his son) had rights that were violated when he was killed.

That's debatable. It's fairly well established that being a US citizen does not exempt you from being targeted in war, and also that an authorization of military force requires no magic words to be a valid exercise of the power to declare war. There's a decent precedential bases that for someone not immediately engaged in active hostility, that is restrained within US territory when and where the civilian government and court system are not impaired, but there is no precedent that I am aware of creating a citizenship-based immunity to war conducted overseas.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by mike00632 on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:48PM (#19660963)
>So we're backing away from legal argument to conventional wisdom?

I meant understood by legal professionals according to judicial rulings. As far as we can determine the law, foreigners abroad are not afforded the same rights as American citizens. And I don't think the law has so much nuance as to allow the US government to legally kill people but not abridge their freedom of speech.

>... targeted in war...

Anwar al-Awlaki was a non-combatant killed in Yemen, which was not a war zone at the time (same with his son). Those words have a lot of legal implications against the actions of the United States.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by amanaplanacanal on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:48PM (#19640461)
Well... the first amendment doesn't mention the people. It just says "Congress shall make no law..."

So I'm not sure the same logic applies.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by KorematsuFred on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:24PM (#19641077)
American law can not apply to non-Americans abroad.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by tyingq on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:28PM (#19641410)
Maybe "should not". "Can not" has been disproved many times.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by KorematsuFred on Thursday April 18, 2019 @03:19AM (#19689331)
Either cases it is irrelevant if the parent country of that person supports that individual. Like how it happens with a lot of Chinese citizens that US routinely tries to entrap.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by burfog on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:14AM (#19642422)
This should obviously be the case, with both pros and cons. The non-Americans like Assange might not need to follow American law, but they are also unprotected by it. If the CIA wants to take care of a matter overseas, they just do that.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by pytester on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:49PM (#19639614)
He's being prosecuted for allegedly extracting a password from a hash value on behalf of Manning and encouraging him to leak more information (Obama's DOJ refused to make this charge because it's something all journalists do).
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by acqq on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:03PM (#19639729)
> He's being prosecuted for allegedly extracting a password from a hash value

They don't claim Assange extracted a password. They just claim that Assange said in the chat "no luck so far"! That is, that he wrote to Manning that he tried.

https://www.justice.gov/usao-edva/press-release/file/1153481...

The indictment is "conspiracy" with Manning.

So there's certainly something to back up the claim from this title

https://www.cbc.ca/radio/thecurrent/the-current-for-april-11...

namely, that "Assange's arrest is 'a vendetta, not justice'"

For more context, at the moment this news from ca one month ago have even more sense:

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/mar/08/chelsea-mann...

"Chelsea Manning jailed for refusing to testify to grand jury in WikiLeaks case"

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by nickysielicki on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:29PM (#19639924)
> Manning did not have administrative-level privileges, and used special software, namely a Linux operating system, to access the computer file and obtain the portion of the password provided to Assange.

Fun to see them exonerate themselves for using broken security by calling a hash a, "portion of the password".

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by arduanika on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:27PM (#19641407)
Because all journalists encourage sources to leak, or all journalists extract a password from a hash value?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by StanislavPetrov on Friday April 12, 2019 @04:33AM (#19643079)
Both. If a journalist gets a story on French, is it a crime if they publish it in English? Should it be a crime to decode information you possess?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by uryga on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:28PM (#19640345)
that'd be "encouraging her", unless you're not referring to Manning here?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by jessaustin on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:47PM (#19640854)
Good point, but some leniency is probably in order. We certainly want to honor Ms. Manning's wishes, but they weren't yet publicly known at that time.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by eridius on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:33PM (#19641718)
They are known now, and has been known for a very long time.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by pfisch on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:26AM (#19641978)
When you change your gender does it apply retroactively? I assume it doesn't because that is needlessly complicated.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by mike00632 on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:28AM (#19642484)
I remember this being settled on the Chelsea Manning talk page. In short, you refer to women as women even if they previously identified as men.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Chelsea_Manning

>This article should adhere to the identity guideline because it contains material about one or more trans women. Main biographical articles should give precedence to self-designation as reported in the most up-to-date reliable sources, even when it doesn't match what's most common in reliable sources. Any person whose gender might be questioned should be referred to by the pronouns, possessive adjectives, and gendered nouns (for example "man/woman", "waiter/waitress", "chairman/chairwoman") that reflect that person's latest expressed gender self-identification. This applies in references to any phase of that person's life, unless the subject has indicated a preference otherwise. Other articles should use context to determine which name or names to provide on a case-by-case basis. If material violating this guideline is repeatedly inserted, or if there are other related issues, please report the issue to the LGBT noticeboard, or, in the case of living people, to the BLP noticeboard.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style#Iden...

>Give precedence to self-designation as reported in the most up-to-date reliable sources, even when it doesn't match what is most common in reliable sources. When a person's gender self-designation may come as a surprise to readers, explain it without overemphasis on first occurrence in an article. Any person whose gender might be questioned should be referred to by the pronouns, possessive adjectives, and gendered nouns (for example "man/woman", "waiter/waitress", "chairman/chairwoman") that reflect that person's latest expressed gender self-identification. This applies in references to any phase of that person's life, unless the subject has indicated a preference otherwise. Avoid confusing constructions (Jane Doe fathered a child) by rewriting (e.g., Jane Doe became a parent). Direct quotations may need to be handled as exceptions (in some cases adjusting the portion used may reduce apparent contradictions, and "[sic]" may be used where necessary). MOS:MULTIPLENAMES calls for mentioning the former name of a transgender person if they were notable under that name. In other respects, the MoS does not specify when and how to mention former names, or whether to give the former or current name first.

[dead]
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by pfisch on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:53AM (#19642584)
Avoid confusing constructions (Jane Doe fathered a child) by rewriting (e.g., Jane Doe became a parent). Direct quotations may need to be handled as exceptions (in some cases adjusting the portion used may reduce apparent contradictions, and "[sic]" may be used where necessary). MOS:MULTIPLENAMES calls for mentioning the former name of a transgender person if they were notable under that name.

This is needlessly complicated. Editing all previous quotes and trying to rewrite past events is confusing.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roguecoder on Friday April 12, 2019 @03:22AM (#19642735)
But she didn’t father a child, since she isn’t a father. The expectation that one be accurate is not “complexity”: it’s how you avoid saying things that are wrong. It is often simpler to be wrong. “Pi is 3” simplifies infinite complexity, in fact. But that doesn’t make it acceptable.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by pfisch on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:54PM (#19646594)
At that time she was identifying herself as a father though. There is no need to whitewash history.

When people get married and change their last name they don't make people go into quotes from the past and change them, and that is far less of an identity change then we are talking about here.

Bruce Jenner won an olympic medal. They don't need to scrub Bruce Jenner from old episodes of the Kardashians.

Bruce Jenner then became Caitlyn Jenner. There is just no reason to try to change history.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by eridius on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:19PM (#19649562)
When people change their last name, newly-created references to them do in fact use their new name, even if talking about old events. That said, it's not really an analogous situation, because when people change their last name it's generally in response to a life event, and so references to them that predate that life event weren't inaccurate, they're just old. Transgender people who change their name aren't doing so in response to a life event, they're doing so because their old name was never who they were. It was a name forced upon them by their parents and society. Chelsea was always a woman, it's just the world didn't know until she came out. The name she used to go by was never really her, and continuing to use it is supremely disrespectful to her.

Or to put it another way, if you have a friend that comes out of the closet and announces they're gay, do you ever talk about "when they used to be straight", or do you recognize that they were always gay and you simply didn't know?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by arduanika on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:25PM (#19641394)
This is clearly the crux of the case.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:04PM (#19639733)
No, he's being prosecuted for allegedly agreeing to extract a password from a hash. Not for actually doing so, massive difference.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by rosser on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:24PM (#19639886)
The definition of a criminal conspiracy requires intent and an agreement to act in furtherance of that intent, and only one of the conspirators to have committed overt acts.

Everyone with mens rea is guilty of conspiring, not just the person who committed the actus reus.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by dragonwriter on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:02PM (#19640560)
> Everyone with mens rea is guilty of conspiring, not just the person who committed the actus reus.

That's not strictly true; the agreement is the individual actus reus.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by slg on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:46PM (#19639584)
Non-Americans are certainly protected by the Constitution while in the US, but I thought there was still a legal debate about whether the US Constitution fully applies to foreign nationals while outside the US. Hasn't that long been the legal excuse used for things like international mass surveillance and what goes on in Guantanamo Bay?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ceejayoz on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:49PM (#19639613)
The First Amendment doesn't apply to anyone while outside the US. A US citizen in Saudi Arabia doesn't have First Amendment protections there.

For the US to prosecute Assange, they have to prosecute him in the US, where he does enjoy First Amendment protections, as the First Amendment limits what Congress (and via the Fourteenth, state/local as well) can do.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by slg on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:09PM (#19639767)
I think you are misinterpreting the question. The US Constitution obviously has no legal impact on the laws of Saudi Arabia. The question is whether the US government needs to follow the US Constitution when dealing with a non-US citizen on non-US soil.

There seems to be a precedent that US citizens have different legal protections from the US government while abroad when compared with non-citizens. That is why US citizens involved with Al-Qaeda, ISIS, or similar hostile organizations will occasionally receive a domestic trial in the criminal justice system while non-citizens generally only face military trials if anything.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ceejayoz on Friday April 12, 2019 @01:58PM (#19647310)
> There seems to be a precedent that US citizens have different legal protections from the US government while abroad when compared with non-citizens.

It's an interesting situation, as there's counter-examples; the Constitution doesn't, for example, appear to permit assassinations (certainly not of citizens without a trial), but they went ahead and droned Anwar al-Awlaki without any apparent legal consequences.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by cbnotfromthere on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:33AM (#19652150)
You seem to willingly confusing "assassinations" with "acts of war".

Anwar Al-Awlaki was unquestionably an enemy combatant due to his overt belonging to a non-state actor engaged in military combat with the United States.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by oliveshell on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:55PM (#19639669)
Exactly.

If a person is on trial in the U.S. for breaking U.S. law, then U.S. constitutional protections apply— regardless of citizenship or where the alleged crime took place.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by droithomme on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:39PM (#19641462)
> The First Amendment doesn't apply to anyone while outside the US. A US citizen in Saudi Arabia doesn't have First Amendment protections there.

First Amendment deals with US federal government and states.

Neither the federal government nor the states can prosecute you for free speech you engage in as US citizen or resident while in Saudi Arabia. The Saudi Arabian government might choose to prosecute you, but the first amendment does prohibit the US government from prosecuting you for speech made overseas as well as on US soil.

An american journalist is living in Brazil and writes an article critical of the US government. The US government can not prosecute them simply because they wrote the article while out of the country.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by village-idiot on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:53PM (#19639647)
It also limits what speech congress can make illegal, effectively controlling what the executive branch can do because of speech.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by Iv on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:43AM (#19642039)
It would be a pretty fucked up logic if US laws applied outside US but the document that prevents US laws from becoming tyrannical would not.

That would simply be evil.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by austincheney on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:45PM (#19640838)
Guantanamo Bay is American soil similar to embassies in foreign cities.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:58PM (#19640918)
Embassies aren't "foreign soil". There are restrictions based on international treaties, but they're nothing like foreign soil at all.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by slg on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:00PM (#19641258)
>Guantanamo Bay is American soil

That doesn't seem to be 100% settled law either. The US government has argued both sides in different court cases.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by toufiqbarhamov on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:16PM (#19641023)
That’s true, but you don’t get clicks from outrage by just saying the boring truth. I’ve also been reading rants from people who think the US is going to throw a bunch of other charges at him when he gets here, which is just hilariously wrong. In general a state can’t request extradition on charge A then throw B-Z into the mix when the plane lands. The only way to expand on the original charges are with permission from the country which received the original request on the basis of new information.

But again, that doesn’t feed the conspiracy-minded mob or generate clicks.

Edit response to emiliobumachar:

If the US broke international law and their treaties with the UK it would be a really bad look at the very least. Conversely if that doesn’t happen what are you going to be convinced of?

(Sorry about responding this way, but after two months of getting no response from the mods about rate limiting me, I’m just adapting.)

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by acqq on Friday April 12, 2019 @03:33AM (#19642794)
> In general a state can’t request extradition on charge A then throw B-Z into the mix when the plane lands. The only way to expand on the original charges are with permission from the country which received the original request on the basis of new information.

Does anybody think UK would not give all the permissions when asked?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by toufiqbarhamov on Friday April 12, 2019 @06:40PM (#19649687)
The charges have to be based on new information, and the UK judiciary isn’t overtly political. All told I think Assange will go down for the hacking, and then be off to Sweden. After that I suspect the world at large will be done with him. He isn’t anything like as important as he and his few supporters seem to think.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by emiliobumachar on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:29PM (#19641103)
If charges B-Z are in fact thrown into the mix after the plane lands, would you then be convinced of a politically motivated conspiracy?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by tomohawk on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:29PM (#19640351)
The US Constitution protects US Persons regardless of where they may be. This is a broader category than US Citizens. It includes, for example, green card holders. The US Constitution also protects, to a certain extent, non US Persons, but only in the US or on US territory.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ehaliewicz2 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:35PM (#19639471)
The 1st amendment simply prohibits the united states government from abridging freedom of speech.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ehsankia on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:01PM (#19641262)
Putting thousands of people's lives in danger because you're not careful isn't freedom of speech [0]. If Assange cared about freedom of speech, he wouldn't have called the Panama leaks an attack on Putin fueled by Soros [1]. Is it a coincidence that almost all Wikileaks cables are about the US, and never anything about Russia, China, Saudi Arabia, and so on?

I definitely don't think he should be prosecuted for journalism, but if it is shown that he was Putin's puppet and intentionally helped meddle in US election, then he does deserve whatever sentence he receives.

[0] https://www.spiegel.de/international/world/leak-at-wikileaks...

[1] https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/717458064324964352

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by fit2rule on Friday April 12, 2019 @03:53AM (#19642900)
> Is it a coincidence that almost all Wikileaks cables are about the US, and never anything about Russia, China, Saudi Arabia, and so on?

Perhaps it makes Americans feel bad about themselves to hear this, but there are people in the world who feel that America and its 5-eyes allies are actually doing more harm to the world than Russia, China, Saudi Arabia, and "so on" - by way of endless, illegal, heinous wars wherein crimes against humanity are constantly ignored by the only people who have the power to do something about it: The American People.

Alas, The American People are being dragged, kicking and screaming, into the realisation that many outside of America's reality-distortion fields have already had: America is a net evil force in the world, and its illegal wars must be stopped at all costs.

Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Yemen. 500,000+ dead victims of America's illegal wars. When Russia and/or China have invaded and destroyed as many sovereign states as the USA has, then the moral stance you propose would be relevant. But, since neither Russia or China have started and engaged in countless, endless illegal wars of aggression in the last decade, the equivalence you desire is inappropriate. America and its allies are committing war crimes daily and have been doing so for decades. Without doing something effective about that, The American People have no chance to do something, next, about Russia or China. It simply doesn't work.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ehsankia on Friday April 12, 2019 @01:28PM (#19647004)
> America is a net evil force in the world

I never claimed they weren't. But it would be naive to think that Russia is much better. But for some reason, WikiLeaks has nothing to say about them, even if it's clear that they are doing pretty dodgy stuff (IRA, poisoning, etc). That to me shows that Wikileaks is not about transparency, but rather has a very strong bias about exposing a very specific target.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by fit2rule on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:14PM (#19647476)
Maybe America has more serious covered-up crimes to reveal than Russia? Maybe America is killing more innocent people, daily (one bomb dropped every twenty minutes for the last 20 years, mostly on innocent people)?

Maybe you simply haven't read what Wikileaks has published about Russia.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by lostjohnny on Friday April 12, 2019 @04:13AM (#19642988)
> When Russia and/or China have invaded and destroyed as many sovereign stats as the USA has

It's already happened.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by fit2rule on Friday April 12, 2019 @04:21AM (#19643022)
"As many sovereign states as the USA has".

The #'s are not in Americas favour. Also: war crimes being covered up/suppressed.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by cbnotfromthere on Saturday April 13, 2019 @06:38AM (#19652169)
" America is a net evil force in the world, and its illegal wars must be stopped at all costs."

How about you move to Russia or Venezuela and stop USA's illegal wars at any cost from there?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by fit2rule on Sunday April 14, 2019 @01:38PM (#19660614)
America's illegal wars can be stopped from anywhere. All it takes is for the truth to be revealed by those brave enough to stand up to the establishment, and reveal their crimes.

It can be done from anywhere on the globe, as we have learned from Wikileaks and others working to expose the crimes of US's criminal military-industrial complex.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ehaliewicz2 on Friday April 12, 2019 @04:08AM (#19642967)
I didn't mean to imply that freedom of speech necessarily applied to this case, just that if it did, the US government would hopefully (?) respect that.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by freeflight on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:30PM (#19641421)
Afaik that Wikileaks tweet about the Panama Papers was referring to the fact that the full papers were never released [0].

While at the same time most of the MSM coverage focused solely on the Russian/Putin angle, making the Panama Papers more about Putin than anything else.

[0] https://www.dw.com/en/wikileaks-slams-panama-papers-trickle-...

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ehsankia on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:44PM (#19641782)
But what was the purpose of throwing Soros in there?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by nabla9 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:47PM (#19639591)
> 1st amendment protection even applicable to foreigners on foreign soil?

It seems to do so.

>The Constitution does distinguish in some respects between the rights of citizens and noncitizens: the right not to be discriminatorily denied the vote and the right to run for federal elective office are expressly restricted to citizens.12 All other rights, however, are written without such a limitation. The Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment due process and equal protection guarantees extend to all "persons." The rights attaching to criminal trials, including the right to a public trial, a trial by jury, the assistance of a lawyer, and the right to confront adverse witnesses, all apply to "the accused." And both the First Amendment's protections of political and religious freedoms and the Fourth Amendment's protection of privacy and liberty apply to "the people."

https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?a...

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by rayiner on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:17PM (#19639828)
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by nabla9 on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:48AM (#19642560)
That's decision on 4th amendment requirements for issuing warrants.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by StanislavPetrov on Friday April 12, 2019 @04:31AM (#19643070)
>What part of the first amendment exonerates knowingly attempting to crack NTLM keys of US military logins?

The whole First Amendment, which explicitly exists to defend the freedom of the press. What sort of person thinks that its legal, desirable, or consistent with a free society for the government to tell individuals at the point of a gun what they are allowed to do or say? What sort of sick society do we live in where a significant portion of the populace thinks that its acceptable that government claims of secrecy are sacrosanct and beyond question? The whole case against Assange is based on Wikileaks' exposure of US war crimes via the Bradley/Chelsea Manning leak almost a decade ago. None of the war criminals exposed by those leaks have been prosecuted - only those who exposed their crimes. Anyone who isn't absolutely outraged and disgusted by this is a blot on society and a moral failure in every way.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by amanaplanacanal on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:07PM (#19646045)
> What sort of person thinks that its legal, desirable, or consistent with a free society for the government to tell individuals at the point of a gun what they are allowed to do

Isn't this the basis of all law?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:34PM (#19639469)
Isn’t that essentially the hacking equivalent of jaywalking? Why should it be prosecuted?

I can’t really imagine a less serious offense than (maybe) trying and failing to crack hash.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by sigmar on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:36PM (#19639486)
Someone asking for your help in hacking a DoD network doesn't seem like jay-walking.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:38PM (#19639504)
But they didn’t hack into the DoD network. Manning had already leaked everything by the time this happened.

Assange didn’t succesfully crack the hash, it’s questionable if he even did anything with it.

At best his crime is agreeing to help hack into the DoD network, not actually doing anything in furtherance of that. That’s a ridiculous thing to prosecute someone for.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by jcranmer on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:42PM (#19639538)
On the other hand, if the alleged facts are true, it does suggest mens rea: Assange wasn't a mere vehicle for reporting information (which would entitle him to free press defense), but he was actively soliciting the crime of leaking confidential information.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:08PM (#19639758)
>Assange didn’t succesfully crack the hash, it’s questionable if he even did anything with it.

So if someone tried to break into your home and failed, that means they never committed a crime?

>At best his crime is agreeing to help hack into the DoD network, not actually doing anything in furtherance of that.

That's why the maximum sentence is only 5 years.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:16PM (#19639822)
>So if someone tried to break into your home and failed, that means they never committed a crime?

If someone acquired the same lock as me, tried to pick it in the privacy of their own home and never actually broke into my home I would sure hope that they wouldn't face criminal charges.

>That's why the maximum sentence is only 5 years.

10 for what he's being charged with, no? I could very well be wrong here, but I thought that's what the 1030(a)(1) carries.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:36PM (#19639978)
>If someone acquired the same lock as me, tried to pick it in the privacy of their own home and never actually broke into my home I would sure hope that they wouldn't face criminal charges.

Acquiring the same lock is bad phrasing, since the same model has different keys.

So what you're implying is that people who go around cloning locks to crack them at home, and generate keys, with the intent to break into homes or military installations, have committed no crime?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:46PM (#19641797)
>So what you're implying is that people who go around cloning locks to crack them at home, and generate keys, with the intent to break into homes or military installations, have committed no crime?

Of course not (although it wouldn’t be a crime where I’m from until you actually try to break in somewhere).

I’m only implying that this shouldn’t be a crime, not until you actually try to do the deed.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by sigmar on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:02PM (#19639724)
Manning was definitely still leaking while talking to Assange.[1] and there is no public information about whether or not Assange cracked the hashes (only that he offered to).

[1] https://twitter.com/pwnallthethings/status/10634797776323747...

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:07PM (#19639753)
Okay, it seems like Manning was uploading the leak to WL when this happened. Did Manning provide any new data after this conversation?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by paulddraper on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:39PM (#19639508)
Jaywalking isn't protected by the first amendment.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by decebalus1 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:14PM (#19640260)
> Also, is the 1st amendment protection even applicable to foreigners on foreign soil?

If the US can prosecute foreigners doing foreign things on foreign soil, it should also strip them of all their rights. Is that your reasoning?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by gnu8 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:41PM (#19640018)
For someone who isn’t a citizen of the United States, it’s not illegal to fight against the military of the United States. It’s not possible for Assange to have committed a crime here.

Would you suggest indicting a drone operator of the US Air Force for violating Afghanistan’s law against murdering people?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by torstenvl on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:51PM (#19640082)
Yes. Actually, it is. You have to be a lawful combatant to receive combatant immunity under international law.

The U.S. Air Force consists of lawful combatants. They are members of the armed forces and wear uniforms that readily distinguish themselves as combatants, which permits the opposing party to a conflict to abide by principles of distinction and proportionality. They are therefore disanalogous.

CIA operatives, however, engaged in spying or armed conflict, arguably do not enjoy combatant immunity. If the Taliban had captured a CIA drone operator, there is a strong argument that they could have tried, convicted, and sentenced the operator without violating international law.

What part of The Hague Convention of 1907, the Third Geneva Convention of 1949, or the 1977 Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions of 1949 did you rely on in forming the opinion you've just shared with us?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by gnu8 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:48PM (#19640465)
The United States itself does not respect international law and does not permit its soldiers to be prosecuted in the ICJ under any circumstances. Therefore there is no reason to afford it any similar consideration.

International law is largely a myth due to the extreme power differential between the United States and most other countries. The only hard and fast rule is that might makes right.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by torstenvl on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:15PM (#19640659)
The ICJ handles dispute between states. It has no authority to prosecute the soldiers of any country.

You are, perhaps, referring to the ICC, established by the Rome Statute - to which the United States is not a party.

The issue of whether the United States respects international law is not likely to be conducive to productive conversation on HN. It is also beside the point of this specific topic.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ru999gol on Friday April 12, 2019 @01:36AM (#19642249)
its not productive conversation with any american, as you are all brainwashed anyways by your corrupt government and media. As far as I'm concerned any american is complicit in war crimes.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by dang on Friday April 12, 2019 @08:03PM (#19650127)
Please don't post flamebait here or engage in nationalistic flamewars. Yes there are huge challenges to conversation across deep divides—but the site guidelines require that we make good-faith efforts to overcoming those challenges or—if you can't or don't want to do that—simply not to post.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by Nasrudith on Friday April 12, 2019 @09:03AM (#19644399)
Operatives aren't protected and they don't even need to give the spook a trial - summary execution is allowed for spies and saboteurs but most governments usually find capture and trade more productive.

One thing I have wondered about is why we haven't seen any organized crime trying to claim uniformed combatant protections - they already have several process steps in many cases.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by lostmyoldone on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:21PM (#19646190)
Following your argument, isn't then drone operatators in some respects illegal combatants? Or really anyone not easily identifiable as enemy combatants?

Not that I think that arguing from the point of international law, and especially war time international law is of much relevancy in this case.

US has in recently shown little respect for many aspects of what was thought to be international law, but through US acts the water has been muddied. The relationship with the ICC, one of the foremost attempts at establishing a legitimate international court for war crimes comes to mind. It is however far from the only issue where US recently shown an amount of disrespect to international law usually only seen from totalitarian regimes.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by shhehebehdh on Friday April 12, 2019 @03:33PM (#19648242)
Military drone operators will be found on military bases in military uniform. They will be easily identified as soldiers if captured.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by shhehebehdh on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:45PM (#19640044)
Doesn’t this depend on the person’s combatant status? I do suspect that enemy combatants in uniform are afforded the protections you mention, but I don’t think Assange can reasonably be assigned to that class.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by cm2187 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:45PM (#19640040)
I do not believe Australia is at war with the United States.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by abugheratwork on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:37PM (#19639986)
> What part of the first amendment exonerates knowingly attempting to crack NTLM keys of US military logins?

Is doing math a form of expression? Breaking a password amounts to thinking for a very long time about all the ways you could rearrange some bits, and choosing one. I'd call it an expression of preference for certain possible results over others, by way of saving one and letting the rest go.

I know, I'm laughing at the thought of framing a cracked password because you're so proud of your expressive art. Still, I am deeply uncomfortable with a government having the authority to say, "You may not run that program."

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:42PM (#19640028)
>Is doing math a form of expression? Breaking a password amounts to thinking for a very long time about all the ways you could rearrange some bits, and choosing one. I'd call it an expression of preference for certain possible results over others, by way of saving one and letting the rest go.

Isn't shooting a gun at someone a matter of depressing a lever? It's about applying pressure on a lever with your finger.

>Still, I am deeply uncomfortable with a government having the authority to say, "You may not run that program."

Are you also deeply uncomfortable with a government having the authority to say "You may not press that lever".

Isn't the US firing nukes a matter of the US president entering numbers and pressing some buttons?

Isn't running into and maiming a pedestrian while driving a car at a traffic crossing a matter of actually doing nothing instead of braking?

Are you deeply uncomfortable with the thought of govt jailing you for literally doing nothing?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by bubblethink on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:51PM (#19641529)
You are reducing the OP's point, which is rather important, to silly analogies about intent. The OP's point is also why, for eg., many govts' attempts to ban encryption are stupid because you cannot outlaw math. Which is why the legality of both having and breaking encryption needs to be detached from intent.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:26PM (#19641690)
OP's point is that cracking passwords is a form of art, so Assange should be able to claim cracking a DoD Administrator password was a performance of art and thus legal. It's not an important point, it's a silly one.

>many govts' attempts to ban encryption are stupid because you cannot outlaw math

Huh? You can outlaw math. It'd be a stupid idea and quite hard to successfully enforce, but you can outlaw it.

>Which is why the legality of both having and breaking encryption needs to be detached from intent.

This does not make sense at all. Otherwise there would be no legal difference between using a battering ram to break into someone's house and then claiming it was research for materials testing. It also comes down to privacy and property rights.

Case law is well settled in the physical door locks space which also applies pretty well to the digital space with a good balance between research and not breaking into others property. It's perfectly legal to crack your own NTLM hashes, and those of which you have permission to. Imagine someone going around with a saw sawing up doors and then claiming it was their right because the doors weren't properly secured and made of 12 inches of reinforced steel.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by bubblethink on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:34PM (#19641723)
My point is that analogies from the real world do not extend very well to digital things, and you can end up with some extremely broad laws that are misused. We already have problems like DMCA because of that. Ultimately, it's very difficult to have consistent laws around encryption.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:02AM (#19641874)
Sure, and that's why intent is important. I fully understand encryption being fully legal, but I don't seen any benefit to legally being able to crack/decrypt other's information without their permission and knowledge, against their will.

This has zero implications on crypto-research because it's always legal to try your cracking on your own encrypted data, or on others' data with their permission, like public challenges. What good will it do to extend it to everyone encrypted data?

There are also privacy and property rights issues at hand. Should you be able to crack someone's private key and impersonate them without legal issues?

Reducing something to its basics and then claiming it should be legal by ignoring the real world consequences like the GP was doing is disingenuous.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by bubblethink on Friday April 12, 2019 @12:37AM (#19642016)
> benefit to legally being able to crack/decrypt other's information without their permission and knowledge

>privacy and property rights

This is precisely the issue with DMCA. It is illegal in the US to decrypt a DVD/blu-ray etc (for reference, see why fedora cannot play dvds). So what should have been a reactive law against piracy is now a proactive prohibition codified in law. That's why, laws around encryption should decide on the actions after the fact. You can then use existing law on the actions and encryption is out of the picture. In this case, the actions would be protected by free speech and other protections afforded to journalists.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roguecoder on Friday April 12, 2019 @01:07AM (#19642131)
You can’t break and enter and then claim that it was legal because all you did was read documents you used to write a New York Times article.

Indeed, actual journalists have ethics departments that help ensure they don’t step over the line from accepting information gained illegally into encouraging people to commit illegal acts to get them information, and if they commit illegal acts to get information that is always a crime. It’s not even a grey area here.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by bubblethink on Friday April 12, 2019 @01:24AM (#19642196)
"Breaking and entering" is a well defined thing in the real world. It does not extend well to digital stuff, and if you go down that road, you end up with the failure to decrypt DVDs. There is no digital property per se. It's just a proxy for other things. So decouple the two. There is no breaking and entering in the digital world. There are just actions you take after the fact, and you can rule on the actions.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by mike00632 on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:38AM (#19642522)
If you use someone else's credentials to log in as them then you are breaking the law, even if you didn't have to crack the password. I feel like this is very clearly defined. It's just like if you steal someone's purse because they set it down without securing it. It doesn't matter how easy it was or if you consider your act "art", it's still clearly breaking the law and easy to understand why it's illegal.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by thanatos_dem on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:48PM (#19640458)
> Are you deeply uncomfortable with the thought of govt jailing you for literally doing nothing?

Yes? I’d be concerned for anyone who isn’t. And to be clear... he didn’t crack it. I’ve run password hashes through rainbow tables for shits and giggles. Should I be dragged out of an embassy next?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:12PM (#19640994)
Sorry if I was unclear, that quote is in continuance of the earlier line, full argument:

>Isn't running into and maiming a pedestrian while driving a car at a traffic crossing a matter of actually doing nothing instead of braking? Are you deeply uncomfortable with the thought of govt jailing you for literally doing nothing?

>And to be clear... he didn’t crack it.

Attempting to commit a crime is a crime even if you failed at it.

>I’ve run password hashes through rainbow tables for shits and giggles. Should I be dragged out of an embassy next?

People shoot at the range all the time but are not prosecuted. But gun murderers are. Dont you see the difference?

Were you cracking an Administrator password of the United States Military protecting classified war logs with an intent to distribute them to the public?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roguecoder on Friday April 12, 2019 @01:30AM (#19642227)
Just because we don’t usually get prosecuted for something doesn’t make it legal.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by Nasrudith on Friday April 12, 2019 @08:56AM (#19644340)
But that usually means there is a problem with the law in either enforcement(insufficient or only existing to be abused via selective enforcement) or basis(it shouldn't be illegal in the first place).
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by rocqua on Thursday April 11, 2019 @08:05PM (#19640581)
How did you get those hashes?

What did you (intend to) do with the resulting passwords.

Luckily, intent still counts for something legally.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by henryfjordan on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:53PM (#19640502)
You're welcome to crack the password and frame it on your wall. Using or intending to use it is the crime.

The state would have to argue your intent to log into their computers and you'd have the chance to respond. The jury would decide whether you meant to gain unauthorized access to a computer system or just geeked out over password cracking.

Practically, I could see things going poorly for the over-enthusiastic cracker, but theoretically they'd be within their rights.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roguecoder on Friday April 12, 2019 @01:22AM (#19642188)
IANAL, but math is explicitly exempted from copyright law, so “art” wouldn’t apply.

As for the more general “expression”, running a program is a function: it transforms one thing into another thing in a deterministic way. That is applying a tool: you would have to argue that the thing you were doing with it, in this case “breaking a password”, was expression, which, well, good luck with that one: you are back to trying to argue that an explicit crime is actually performance art.

All of this is just facts and tools: there is no creativity involved at any stage.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by wallace_f on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:34PM (#19639470)
As a layman on the subject, I guess cryptographers are attempting to crack keys every day...

With house locks, it's a plain distinction between breaking into a lock and breaking into a house. With cryptography, I imagine that distinction is really problematic?

Though I'm aware in Assange's case they do have proof of intent, but I wonder if it sets bad precedent, or is a case where they just dug up either far-reaching, obscure, or some law which is practically never really enforced?

Edit: my original comment was written poorly

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:49PM (#19639610)
It's illegal if someone "intentionally accesses a computer without authorization or exceeds authorized access, and thereby obtains... information from any department or agency of the United States; or... information from any protected computer". It doesn't matter that much how you try and do it, cracking a password would seem to naturally count. It doesn't matter if you guess the password because you knew the owner's dogs's name and date of birth, it's still intentional access (and it doesn't matter if you failed because the password was too tricky, attempted crimes are still crimes).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act#C...

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:52PM (#19639638)
Attempting to crack a hash locally is distinctly different from trying to gain access to someone elses computer.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:59PM (#19639695)
Intent is very important in the judicial system.

If Assange can show that he was cracking the password of a US military login as a hobby, he might get away with it.

But I don't think even his ardent supporters would buy that theory.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:00PM (#19639701)
I would hope that the government would have to show actual acts in furtherance of the conspiracy to charge people, but that's not what happened here.

The only supposed criminal act here is agreeing to help, not actually providing help. This does nothing at all to further the conspiracy.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:47PM (#19640058)
How is Assange attempting to crack a password locally not an act in furtherance of the conspiracy? Attempting to drive a getaway car that breaks down is still an act even if it failed.

That is what is being alleged and the chat logs seem to support it. It might come out at trial that he didn't actually do it, of course, but that's what the trial is for.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by dragonwriter on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:19PM (#19639844)
> I would hope that the government would have to show actual acts in furtherance of the conspiracy to charge people

It does, in fact, have to allege such an act in order to charge conspiracy (but the act in furtherance can be by any party to the conspiracy; that's how conspiracy works.)

Three such acts are charged in the indictment; two by Manning, one by Assange.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by throwawayjava on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:13PM (#19639807)
It's not aupposed.

The court's job is not to enforce ryanlol's idea about what the law should be. The court's job is to enforce the actual existing text of the actual existing laws.

The actual existing laws say that attempting to break into a computer to which you do not have access is a crime, even if your effort alone is not the lynchpin. And that conspiring to help someone else attempt is also a crime.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:14PM (#19639811)
>The court's job is not to enforce ryanlol's idea about what the law should be.

Ah great. Did I ever suggest that?

>The actual existing laws say that attempting to break into a computer to which you do not have access is a crime, even if you do not succeed. And that conspiring to help someone else attempt is also a crime.

This is correct, but doesn't mean that it's right.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:33PM (#19639956)
So if someone tried to poison you to death, but failed because he mistakenly bought sugar instead of poison, there was no crime committed? Is that how it works in your country? Is that right?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by FireBeyond on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:34PM (#19641724)
Similar to A Few Good Men, my brother's high school suspended him for selling oregano as weed.

"He's selling it as weed, not oregano, so we're punishing him as if he was selling weed".

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by throwawayjava on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:32PM (#19639946)
> Did I ever suggest that

You called it a "supposed criminal act". Usually "supposed" used in that way means something similar to ostensible. That's why I started my post with "It's not supposed". In fact, that's the first definition Oxford gives for supposedly...

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ABCLAW on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:10PM (#19639782)
So you're saying he... conspired to do something illegal?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:12PM (#19639800)
Yes, but where I'm from you need to actually do something in furtherance of the conspiracy to face prosecution.

I'm not trying to make a legal argument, this just feels fundamentally wrong to me.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ABCLAW on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:21PM (#19639864)
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1030#b

"(b) Whoever conspires to commit or attempts to commit an offense under subsection (a) of this section shall be punished as provided in subsection (c) of this section."

Seems pretty straightforward.

Please don't post about how the law works from your gut feelings about the matter. This forum is awash in people just imagining what the law is every time it comes up. Go look at the law itself. There's no requirement as you've imagined there is.

This was a bit snarky before my edit - please excuse me.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:28PM (#19639919)
Assange wrote in a chat "No luck so far" to Manning.

Where you are from, can you go around trying to pick locks on front doors and are only prosecuted if you succeed? And the same with cars?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by nocturnial on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:07PM (#19640203)
This is a very poor analogy and I think you know it. Cracking the password isn't the same as using it to log in. There are still some extra steps required. In the case of picking locks there are no extra steps, you gain access immediately.

I'm only critizing the analogy, what he did, or tried is still illegal but it's barely a hack attempt and it's obvious they are desperate to charge him with anything, no matter how small the charge.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:47PM (#19640457)
That's how conspiracies work. Each participant does only a part of the overall conspiracy. If I forge a document and give it to you so you can sneak into a secure area and commit a murder, I am not just guilty of forgery, I am guilty of conspiracy to murder.

They guy who drives the getaway car is guilty of murder as much as the people who walk into the building.

This is the entire point of conspiracy law. Driving a car is not a crime! But it is if you're conspiring with other people who are committing crimes. Otherwise, you would be able to take part in a murder and be let off, because all you did was act as lookout.

If you and a friend plan to poison someone, and you buy the poison and give it to your friend who then poisons the target, you are guilty of conspiracy to murder, even though buying the poison may not actually be a crime. Prosecutors may legitimately not have anything else on you because that's "all" you did!

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by nocturnial on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:09PM (#19640974)
I think you read over the part where I said it was illegal.

You don't need to invent scenarios, you can use the facts of this case.

Manning already had access and didn't need the password to be cracked. Wikileaks already received information from Manning. Someone in the chat log told Manning they would pass the hash to someone else. They then told Manning "no luck so far".

Keep in mind, they haven't provided any proof that the person Manning was talking to was Assange. They haven't provided any proof that Assange did in fact try to crack it He never wrote that he would try, only that he would pass it on. Or that he actually send the hash to someone else to crack it, and that this person did in fact tried to crack it.

And to top it all off, Manning did not need the password in the first place! People keep forgetting this. The case against Assange appears to be very weak and is probably only intended to get him on US soil to question him about things other than what he is charged with.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:41PM (#19641157)
>Or that he actually send the hash to someone else to crack it,

Still a crime.

>And to top it all off, Manning did not need the password in the first place! People keep forgetting this.

Still a crime.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by nocturnial on Friday April 12, 2019 @01:56AM (#19642335)
What are talking about? Is it because I said it was illegal instead of it being a crime?

The first sentence you quoted was also part of a larger piece about we still need to see the proof that he actually sent it to someone else. So replying "Still a crime" makes zero sense.

In any case, the point is that these are trumped up charge probably to get him to the US so they can question him about russiagate.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Friday April 12, 2019 @11:01AM (#19645350)
> Manning already had access

To Manning's account. She didn't have access to the account she was trying to crack. Getting access to accounts that aren't yours ("exceed[ing] authorized access")- or conspiracy to do so- is more or less exactly what the CFAA is meant to prohibit. Maybe that account had exactly the same permissions that her account did, but the fact remains that she was not authorized to log in to that account.

> proof that Assange did in fact try to crack it

Proof is for trial. A grand jury just has to find probable cause to bring the indictment. Probable cause is quite a low burden of proof. You may not like it! but this is extremely normal in the American system. You don't need proof to bring an indictment, just probable cause. Assange is not special here. A chat log of someone saying "brb gonna go do the crime" followed by "no luck so far" seems pretty probable-causey to me.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:31PM (#19639940)
I suppose Assange's defense will be that he never actually even tried to crack the password- if he was lying or bloviating, he would not have actually done anything in furtherance of the conspiracy. If that turned out to be the case I'd be with you. But if you have chat logs saying "I will do the thing to try and help you commit a crime" then that sure seems like evidence that you did the thing, or at least tried to.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by pytester on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:54PM (#19639656)
>intentionally accesses a computer without authorization or exceeds authorized access

In this case it was Chelsea Manning accessing the computer. Assange didn't touch it.

>It doesn't matter if you guess the password because you knew the owner's dogs's name and date of birth, it's still intentional access

...by Chelsea Manning, not Assange.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:56PM (#19639673)
Conspiracy to commit a crime is a crime.

Cracking a password is one thing; cracking a password for someone else so they can commit a crime (and you knew this was what they were doing with it) is a crime.

If I know Joe's password, and I pass it on to Steve so Steve can log in and steal Joe's secrets and pass them back to me, I am in a conspiracy to commit a crime under the CFAA.

The guy driving the getaway car is on the hook for the bank theft!

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by pytester on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:04PM (#19639737)
In this case it was cracking a password to blow the lid on US war crimes in Iraq.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:07PM (#19639754)
I'm not saying anything about whether it was morally here or there, but that it's not at all an unreasonable application of the CFAA.

The guy driving the getaway car from the FBI field-office break-in* (or whoever) is going to be on the hook for burglary, even if the burglary was done for laudable reasons. I think Obama 100% did the right thing commuting Manning's sentence, and was pleased to see her go free. I'm not at all sure prosecuting Assange for essentially the same crime is in the interest of the nation or justice or whatever.

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens%27_Commission_to_Inve...

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roenxi on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:40PM (#19640012)
Exposing government corruption (and sketchiness) isn't really the best area to apply black-letter law though - it is usually going to be illegal; governments routinely try to stop people publishing embarrassing information.

If a whistleblower can't intend to get information of a government network, how are they meant to make an allegation with some substance behind it? Are they meant to have unsubstantiated word of mouth? We had that for years with ECHELON, the moderate middle just didn't take any of it seriously until the breaking-the-law levels of leaking happened (yes, the legal details are different with Snowden, but the strategy is very similar - leaker gets hit with incidental charges).

The argument here seems to be that while in theory whistleblowing would be OK; none of the ways to attempt a credible whistleblow in the real world are legal. There is a lot of disagreement in this article's comments about what the law says, so it isn't obvious how a whistleblower, who could be anyone here, is meant to follow the details of what they are and are not allowed to attempt.

Assange isn't even a US citizen, so he isn't expected to know US law. Functionally, all this rigmarole is to ensure that if the US government does something sketchy or even illegal then any foreigner who talks about it is legally subject to one of the US's famous black-bag-over-the-head abductions. The charges seem to be independent of what he leaked.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by mike00632 on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:44AM (#19642544)
>Assange isn't even a US citizen, so he isn't expected to know US law.

Ignorance of the law is not a legal defense. Most Americans are not aware of the bulk of laws that apply to them.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by pytester on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:16PM (#19660809)
Apparently there was a solid legal defense for the journalist murderers in the videos released by assange. They are not facing any kind of legal action.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by mike00632 on Sunday April 14, 2019 @03:05PM (#19661064)
What defense are you suggesting? I'm not defending the killing of those journalists and I agree that what Assange did is petty in comparison. But nobody looks good in this saga. There are no good guys and bad guys. Assange exposed instances of over-classification and the potential cover-up of war crimes by the United States but eventually became a propagandist for Russia and their war crimes in Syria. Assange shouldn't benefit because some of his actions were in line with a benevolent ideology. This shouldn't be seen as an ideological clash between proponents of free speech and war hawks because it's not that black and white.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by pytester on Sunday April 14, 2019 @04:40PM (#19661576)
Assange can't even get a hostile media to report what he said correctly. The idea that he is running a propaganda campaign is as fantastical as the idea that you are running your own personal propaganda campaign.

Assange cannot frame narratives, suppress journalism or push talking points through media outlets under his control. He didn't control anything except one twitter feed.

The only thing that people really pay attention to and the only reason he has a platform at all is because of what he leaks. Most people don't even have any idea what his opinions are - although the effect of the leaks is felt far and wide.

This absolutely SHOULD be seen as an ideological clash between proponents of journalism (it's not even about freedom of speech, it's about freedom of journalism) and war hawks. And taking the side of the journalist murderers? Not a good look.

It is that simple and you can tell it's that simple because Assange is getting prosecuted for exposing the murders and the murderers are going free and nobody even disputes (except in a very legalistic sense) that they were murderers.

The idea that he's a stooge for Russia? There's your propaganda - it's pretty much no different to the red scare of yesteryear.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:17PM (#19639826)
Robbing or attempting to rob a bank to donate to the local food bank is still a crime.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by the_watcher on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:23PM (#19639879)
That is irrelevant to the fact that he's being charged with conspiracy to, which doesn't require that he's the person who actually gains access.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:57PM (#19639680)
Yes, but US seems to like to slap conspiracy charges on people who've done essentially nothing in furtherance of the conspiracy.

Maybe it's a crime in the US, but it's still a ludicrous crime.

> If I know Joe's password, and I pass it on to Steve so Steve can log in and steal Joe's secrets and pass them back to me, I am in a conspiracy to commit a crime under the CFAA.

This is of course not at all similar to what happened here, a very strange example.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ceejayoz on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:57PM (#19639679)
The indictment alleges Assange induced Manning to do it, which makes it a conspiracy.

I do think that presents big press freedom issues; it'd be easy to see news organizations under fire in this fashion. Convincing a source to hand over stuff isn't much (or at all, really) different than the behavior described in the Assange/Manning case.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:27PM (#19639907)
Yes, that concerns me too. Where does inducement start? There must be case law on it and maybe it really is a bright line, but it seems like a bit of a reach.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ceejayoz on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:43PM (#19639550)
> I assume attempting to "crack keys" is something cryptographers do every day?

Sure, but context matters. I drive a car every day. If I drive off in someone else's car without permission, I've stolen it.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by andrewnicolalde on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:38PM (#19639499)
I believe in this case it is because that key belonged to a US military computer system and was being cracked to access the data it protected.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by wallace_f on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:44PM (#19639565)
I guess with house locks, it's a plain distinction between breaking into a lock and breaking into a house. With cryptography, I imagine that distinction is really problematic?

Though I'm aware in Assange's case they do have proof of intent, but I wonder if it sets bad precedent, or is a case where they just dug up some law which is practically never really enforced?

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by throwawayjava on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:58PM (#19639686)
He took specific steps (cracking a hash) with the clear intent of helping break into a government owned computer system.

I'm not sure what the gray area is supposed to be here.

If I teach you lock picking skills as a fun hobby, that's clearly okay.

If I teach you lock picking skills knowing you aspire to be a house robber, that is grayish legally and wrong ethically.

But if I break into a specific bank vault for you to help you steal stuff, and we talked about stealing the stuff before I helped you, then I'm clearly involved in a criminal conspiracy.

Assange committed a crime, and if he played the same role in helping to empty your bank account you'd want these laws to exist.

The ethical question here is about whether that crime was ethically jusified. I.e., it's about civil disobedience, not about whether blatant conspiracy should be legal.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:02PM (#19639725)
>Assange committed a crime, and if he played the same role in helping to empty your bank account you'd want these laws to exist.

But for your bank account comparison to make sense Manning would've already have emptied your bank account before JA broke the law.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:44PM (#19641176)
How do you know the Administrator account wouldn't have yielded more documents compared to a user account?

Regardless, imagine two independent people trying to murder someone. The first shoots a fatal bullet and the victim is about to imminently die, even if the best medical aid were to be immediately provided. Then the second murderer comes on the scene, does not realize that the victim is fatally wounded, and shoots another bullet, instantly killing him.

Both these people would be fully responsible for the murder, not just attempted murder. Arguments from them saying "no, the other killed him, I did not", do not fly in court.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:49PM (#19639617)
He's charged under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by maccio92 on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:50PM (#19639623)
I would say a more accurate distinction is breaking into someone's home vs trying to break into a military base. In the first case you're likely to get arrested, in the second they'll probably shoot first and ask questions later
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by roywiggins on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:54PM (#19639650)
Picking your own door lock is legal.

Picking someone else's door lock is legal if they ask you to.

Picking someone else's lock, if it's not actually in a door and isn't protecting anything, is not illegal, even if they don't ask you to or give permission. You're just picking up a lock and fiddling with it, there's no trespass.

Picking someone else's door lock to burgle their home is illegal.

Handing someone a lockpick so that they can burgle a home for you is illegal.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by FireBeyond on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:44PM (#19641786)
> Handing someone a lockpick so that they can burgle a home for you is illegal.

Even more so, trying to create a key that you can hand to someone to get into that home....

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @05:54PM (#19639663)
It's like as if Manning copied the lock at the military base and Assange agreed to see if he can figure out how to pick the copy, but failed (or never even tried, we don't know).