News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by rayiner on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:22PM (#19639872)
The First Amendment probably does not apply to non-Americans with respect to their conduct abroad. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Verdugo-Urqui...

> The Court held that the Fourth Amendment's prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures did not apply where United States agents searched and seized property located in a foreign country owned by a nonresident alien in the United States. Chief Justice Rehnquist authored the opinion for the Court, joined by Justices White, Scalia, Kennedy and O'Connor, contending that "the people" intended to be protected by the Fourth Amendment were the people of the United States, and that the defendant's "legal but involuntary presence" on U.S. soil (a direct result of his arrest) failed to create a sufficient relationship with the U.S. to allow him to call upon the Constitution for protection.[1]

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by dragonwriter on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:52PM (#19640493)
> The First Amendment probably does not apply to non-Americans with respect to their conduct abroad.

How does a Fourth Amendment case turning on the interpretation of specific language that is not present in the First Amendment lead to that conclusion?

(Also, since the alleged conspiracy was related to acts that would be committed within the US, by a US citizen, it's far from clear whether, even if the rationale of the case you cite did apply, the result would still be that there was insufficient relationship to the U.S. with regard to the act in question.)

Note that I don't think the First Amendment has any bearing on this case because of the actual conduct at issue, but if it did, I'm not seeing how the case you point to would make it inapplicable based on Assange’s citizenship and location.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by mike00632 on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:21AM (#19642452)
>... that is not present in the First Amendment lead to that conclusion?

It's commonly understood that the conduct of foreigners abroad is not protected by American rights. That is the legal basis for most of the 'War on Terror' military actions and one of the key reasons why the assassination of Anwar al-Awlaki was objectionable. The way our system understands the law means that American citizen Anway al-Awlaki (and his son) had rights that were violated when he was killed.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by dragonwriter on Friday April 12, 2019 @03:50AM (#19642881)
> It's commonly understood that the conduct of foreigners abroad is not protected by American rights.

So we're backing away from legal argument to conventional wisdom?

> That is the legal basis for most of the 'War on Terror' military actions

No, it's not. About the closest that comes to the truth is that a lot of the War on Terror actions are based on the legal principle that certain, mostly procedural,. Constitutional rights do not apply to actions taken by the US government overseas against non-citizens, but there is no principal under which the limitations imposed by the first amendment (“Congress shall make no law...”) don't apply to the application of a law underlying a criminal prosecution in regular US federal courts, regardless of the nationality of the defendant or the location of the crime.

> The way our system understands the law means that American citizen Anway al-Awlaki (and his son) had rights that were violated when he was killed.

That's debatable. It's fairly well established that being a US citizen does not exempt you from being targeted in war, and also that an authorization of military force requires no magic words to be a valid exercise of the power to declare war. There's a decent precedential bases that for someone not immediately engaged in active hostility, that is restrained within US territory when and where the civilian government and court system are not impaired, but there is no precedent that I am aware of creating a citizenship-based immunity to war conducted overseas.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by mike00632 on Sunday April 14, 2019 @02:48PM (#19660963)
>So we're backing away from legal argument to conventional wisdom?

I meant understood by legal professionals according to judicial rulings. As far as we can determine the law, foreigners abroad are not afforded the same rights as American citizens. And I don't think the law has so much nuance as to allow the US government to legally kill people but not abridge their freedom of speech.

>... targeted in war...

Anwar al-Awlaki was a non-combatant killed in Yemen, which was not a war zone at the time (same with his son). Those words have a lot of legal implications against the actions of the United States.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by amanaplanacanal on Thursday April 11, 2019 @07:48PM (#19640461)
Well... the first amendment doesn't mention the people. It just says "Congress shall make no law..."

So I'm not sure the same logic applies.

Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by KorematsuFred on Thursday April 11, 2019 @09:24PM (#19641077)
American law can not apply to non-Americans abroad.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by tyingq on Thursday April 11, 2019 @10:28PM (#19641410)
Maybe "should not". "Can not" has been disproved many times.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by KorematsuFred on Thursday April 18, 2019 @03:19AM (#19689331)
Either cases it is irrelevant if the parent country of that person supports that individual. Like how it happens with a lot of Chinese citizens that US routinely tries to entrap.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection by burfog on Friday April 12, 2019 @02:14AM (#19642422)
This should obviously be the case, with both pros and cons. The non-Americans like Assange might not need to follow American law, but they are also unprotected by it. If the CIA wants to take care of a matter overseas, they just do that.