Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection
by ryanlol on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:14PM
(#19639811)
>The court's job is not to enforce ryanlol's idea about what the law should be.
Ah great. Did I ever suggest that?
>The actual existing laws say that attempting to break into a computer to which you do not have access is a crime, even if you do not succeed. And that conspiring to help someone else attempt is also a crime.
This is correct, but doesn't mean that it's right.
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection
by belltaco on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:33PM
(#19639956)
So if someone tried to poison you to death, but failed because he mistakenly bought sugar instead of poison, there was no crime committed? Is that how it works in your country? Is that right?
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection
by FireBeyond on Thursday April 11, 2019 @11:34PM
(#19641724)
Similar to A Few Good Men, my brother's high school suspended him for selling oregano as weed.
"He's selling it as weed, not oregano, so we're punishing him as if he was selling weed".
Re:Julian Assange Deserves First Amendment Protection
by throwawayjava on Thursday April 11, 2019 @06:32PM
(#19639946)
> Did I ever suggest that
You called it a "supposed criminal act". Usually "supposed" used in that way means something similar to ostensible. That's why I started my post with "It's not supposed". In fact, that's the first definition Oxford gives for supposedly...
The court's job is not to enforce ryanlol's idea about what the law should be. The court's job is to enforce the actual existing text of the actual existing laws.
The actual existing laws say that attempting to break into a computer to which you do not have access is a crime, even if your effort alone is not the lynchpin. And that conspiring to help someone else attempt is also a crime.