News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by sanxiyn on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:47PM (#19589078)
Comments here are out of their mind. Samsung's smartphone business hasn't been a profit center for quite some time. Majority of profit came from DRAM and NAND, and profit fall is directly attributable to recent price crash of both.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by foobar1962 on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:16AM (#19589539)
I just had a conversation with somebody who asserted that Apple was bad (proprietary etc) and Samsung was good, and that Apple was 3rd phone maker behind Samsung and Huawei.

He may be right about Apple being 3rd, but Apple looks to be the only one making a decent profit from their phones.

How do they manage that when they have to pay for both hardware and software development, when all the others get the software for free?

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by malux85 on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:24AM (#19589557)
Because when the iPhone came out it was very expensive but significantly ahead of competition.

People paid for it, even people who couldn’t afford it found a way to pay for an iPhone

The huge cash burst into Apple meant everyone was scrambling to deal with them.

Then economies of scale, negotiating leverage with third parties and sheer momentum propelled them

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by AceJohnny2 on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:36AM (#19589590)
> Because when the iPhone came out it was very expensive but significantly ahead of competition.

From a CPU perspective, they still are:

https://www.anandtech.com/show/13392/the-iphone-xs-xs-max-re...

(for the rest of the features, that's indeed debatable)

Fun fact: Samsung made the chip for the first iPhone. Steve Jobs was so dissatisfied with the experience that Apple bought PA Semi to design the chips in-house.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by tooltalk on Saturday April 06, 2019 @04:29AM (#19589861)
>Fun fact: Samsung made the chip for the first iPhone. Steve Jobs was so dissatisfied with the experience that Apple bought PA Semi to design the chips in-house.

I thought PA Semi's specialty was in power management and many didn't consider the acquisition a success as most key figures left the company not too long after the acquisition. Are you sure that Apple actually designed the SOC in-house? Wasn't it Intrinsity, Samsung's collaborator, that co-developed Samsung's Hummingbird core (also used in Apple's A4) to compete with Qualcomm's APs and go beyond the 1Ghz barrier, changed the game?

I always thought the Hummingbird was the breakthrough that made the A chips competitive -- Apple bought Intrinsity afterward.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by oblio on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:58AM (#19589646)
The thing is, that CPU bit is not really relevant for the average consumer, anymore. Flagship phone CPUs have been good enough for web browsing and casual app use for about 2 years.

Not that I'm against extra horse power, we'll find a use for it. But we're in "desktop land", almost, for smartphone CPUs. They're good enough.

The real smartphone battles now are in camera quality, gaming oomph and battery usage.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by praveenweb on Saturday April 06, 2019 @03:11AM (#19589679)
CPU bit might be relevant for those who care about Privacy. Apple markets the fact that all processing (some ML/AI stuff) is done on device and not on the cloud, hence requiring good processing power. But as you mentioned the battle is skewed towards Camera and Battery usage.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by viraptor on Saturday April 06, 2019 @04:23AM (#19589851)
> Flagship phone CPUs have been good enough for web browsing and casual app use for about 2 years.

I think it's been longer. I'm on a non-flagship from last year, watching YouTube in PiP mode while writing this comment. Way more than necessary power for causing use.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by Beldin on Saturday April 06, 2019 @06:36AM (#19590144)
Depends of course on your use case. I've been using my flagship phone for 7 years now. It has fulfilled all my needs without any problems, with one hand tied behind its back even.

Probably also a case of modest needs, but still.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by Retric on Saturday April 06, 2019 @08:05AM (#19590354)
CPU is far more relevant if you want to keep your phone for 4+ years. The 2 year upgrade cycle on a smartphone is a major expense for many people.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by oblio on Saturday April 06, 2019 @09:06AM (#19590517)
Smartphone tech has matured. A smartphone CPU from 2011 would have been a drag in 2015, a CPU from 2018 will probably still be adequate in 2022.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by Retric on Saturday April 06, 2019 @07:55PM (#19593798)
That's less true for low end phones. People design software and websites for the average to slightly below average phone.

When you buy the highend they become average in a few years which is completely useable. However, low end phones quickly fall behind the curve and only keep dropping.

Now, that’s not to say the phone will physically last longer. Just that having headroom becomes more noticeable over time.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by flashmozzg on Wednesday April 10, 2019 @08:14PM (#19629927)
Still pretty much true. Sub 150$ Xiaomi phones from 2016 are still going strong (Redmi 3). And there are plenty of sub 150$ offerings with something like Snapdragon 636/710 and 4GB of RAM which will be more than enough for years to come unless you are into some hardcore smartphone gaming (oxymoron).
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by lancesells on Saturday April 06, 2019 @10:20AM (#19590848)
I've got an iPhone from 2014 and it holds up for me in 2019. I replaced the battery last year and it was like a new phone.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by cronix on Saturday April 06, 2019 @12:29PM (#19591540)
Not sure how my 4 year old Galaxy S6 still chugs along as fast as the day I got it. I'll purchase a new battery before getting a new phone (still on the original, which still makes it through the day on a charge). I'm pretty sure I could easily get another 4 years out of this. CPU and RAM are not an issue. I don't need or want AR or gimmicks that don't actually add value or productivity. Just a tool. My email and texts all still work fine as well as all of the business apps I need, websites I visit, etc. You don't need to upgrade every 2 years, or probably even every 4 years. People are more than welcome to spend the money if they wish, though. They've been trained well into thinking they do.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by Retric on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:08PM (#19592136)
That was a high end phone when you bought it. Samsung still sells the S6 and the people buying it today have less headroom to keep it 8 years.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by pjmlp on Saturday April 06, 2019 @10:57AM (#19591029)
In many countries people keep their phones until they die, loose them or get stolen. There isn't a 2 year upgrade cycle.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by riku_iki on Saturday April 06, 2019 @12:41PM (#19591592)
During last 4 years probably RAM increase is more relevant than CPU: 1GB -> 2GB -> 3GB and now some have 6GB.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by jquery on Saturday April 06, 2019 @10:14AM (#19590814)
It’s directly tied to battery power, and battery life is still a big concern. But largely I agree.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by anthony_doan on Saturday April 06, 2019 @03:10AM (#19589675)
> How do they manage that when they have to pay for both hardware and software development, when all the others get the software for free?

It's their ecosystem, all their hardwares work very well between each other. You have Apple messenger on a macbook connecting to your iphone. For android you need to download pushbullet. I'm not in the ecosystem I prefer Android but I can see why people such as consumer would continue to buy Apple stuff. I'm not entirely sure about their laptops though...

Also Apple make a lot of money from services such as itune and their app store. Itune made more than Spotify. It all works together with their close ecosystem.

It's a real pain to move from apple to android because text messages goes straight to apple server. You need to sign off and jump a hoop to get text message back to android. Also getting mp3 off of itunes or getting bandcamp mp3s on to itune. It's like LA fitness, at least in 2010, where if you want to cancel your gym membership you need to download the pdf from their website and then mail it to the provided address and then they'll charge you anyway one extra month.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by eridius on Saturday April 06, 2019 @03:17AM (#19589692)
You're saying Apple's making the money from the ecosystem, but that's not what the parent is asking. The parent is asking how Apple is making a money on each individual iPhone, which they absolutely are. Even if you never buy into the rest of the Apple ecosystem, merely purchasing an iPhone means Apple is making a profit from you.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by joesb on Saturday April 06, 2019 @03:34AM (#19589729)
Lots and lots, I might even say majority, of people who bought iPhones don't have Mac or any other Apple device but iPhones.

It's also only recently that the Apple ecosystem is relevant with Continuity stuffs. Before that, iPods, iPhones and iPads are all very isolated and don't require Apple ecosystem much.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by Krasnol on Saturday April 06, 2019 @04:45AM (#19589897)
> For android you need to download pushbullet.

TIL people are still sending SMS from their PC...

I'd say most of us will either use the Signal client or web.whatsapp.com without bothering connecting the actual devices together.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by cglace on Saturday April 06, 2019 @08:45AM (#19590456)
If you use google messages you can text through https://messages.android.com/ .
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by grey-area on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:26AM (#19589561)
They target the high end where all the profit is.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by on_and_off on Saturday April 06, 2019 @03:14AM (#19589681)
I am of 2 minds about this.

On one hand, smartphones are more or less commodities now. Most established smartphone makers can make great phones (at this point I only compare cameras and even then, they also to all be great) so it is only natural that margins become pretty thin. But right now they are just too thin and the ecosystem is not really healthy.

We don't really need another Apple making huge margins on its smartphone business though.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by tonyedgecombe on Saturday April 06, 2019 @04:48AM (#19589903)
>We don't really need another Apple making huge margins on its smartphone business though.

I think I'd argue we need another two or three. Monocultures are almost never a good idea in the long term.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by pjmlp on Saturday April 06, 2019 @11:02AM (#19591056)
I bet monoculture will come to an end when most devices get to run web sites good enough.

Even Google is now facing the issue that despite Project Treble, most OEMs don't care to release newer versions or provide the respective upgrades, thus rending useless whatever they show at IO.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by Redoubts on Saturday April 06, 2019 @04:32AM (#19589870)
> when all the others get the software for free?

Because it shows.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by jayalpha on Saturday April 06, 2019 @04:40AM (#19589888)
"How do they manage that when they have to pay for both hardware and software development, when all the others get the software for free? "

Content and Apps. Apple takes a nice bite.

Samsung sells a commodity. Then people use the Google Play store and google makes money. I guess Samsung dreams of it's own phone OS. Was it LG or Samsung who bought WebOS?

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by sanxiyn on Saturday April 06, 2019 @06:38AM (#19590153)
It was LG.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by chx on Saturday April 06, 2019 @01:44AM (#19589459)
> price crash of both.

Example: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07N124XDS a few months ago 32GB SODIMM was near unobtanium, a less known brand on eBay alone sold 'em for like 350-375 and now the Samsung ones are on Amazon at below 230 USD. Still has a 25-30% premium over smaller sticks but that's expected.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by graton on Saturday April 06, 2019 @12:52AM (#19589320)
Even with the price crash the prices are still higher than 2016. I purchased memory in 2016 and the price now is still about 30% higher than 2016.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by sanxiyn on Saturday April 06, 2019 @01:01AM (#19589343)
Yes! People, Samsung Electronics is a public company. Here are public info on operating profit in USD:

25B (2016), 47B (2017), 54B (2018). 2019 Q1 profit is similar to 2016 Q1 profit. Things are simply going back to 2016 before DRAM/NAND price craze.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by ksec on Saturday April 06, 2019 @01:30AM (#19589416)
May be that was early 2016 or mid 2016? The price hike started in somewhere near the the last quarter of 2016. The current price are already back to 2016 average, we expect the price to keep falling as we have yet to see any price floor. At the current rate, with nothing in sight to turn things around, we should see the early 2016 prices this year, and expect to see historic new low in DRAM $/GB within the next 12-14 months.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by benj111 on Saturday April 06, 2019 @05:51AM (#19590042)
"we expect the price to keep falling"

Who's 'we'? Are you speaking on behalf of someone. Your sig doesn't hint at anything.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by tooltalk on Saturday April 06, 2019 @04:38AM (#19589887)
Yes, there was a major DRAM market crash in 2016 and it wouldn't probably make good sense to use that as a proper baseline.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:49PM (#19589088)
What caused a price crash of both DRAM and NAND??
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by a_bonobo on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:52PM (#19589100)
There is more background in other articles on Samsung's prediction:

>Samsung said it received fewer orders from cloud service providers, such as Amazon, as well as from handset makers, such as Apple, which has recently seen a slowdown of its own smartphone sales. This low demand in the cloud services and smartphone markets for both DRAM and NAND flash chips have pushed the prices of these chips down.

>According to Bloomberg, data centers are still going through their unused memory chips right now, Apple has cut its forecasts for iPhone sales and China’s economy, which is Samsung’s largest market for embedded components, has also slowed down this year.

>According to IHS Markit, a research firm, the market for DRAM is set to reach $77 billion in sales this year, which is a drop of 22% compared to last year. In this last quarter, DRAM prices fell over 30% (38% for server DRAM), which is the “sharpest decline since 2011," according to TrendForce.

https://www.tomshardware.com/news/samsung-q1-2019-earnings-p...

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by ksec on Saturday April 06, 2019 @01:48AM (#19589469)
I have never trusted this Datacentre narratives because it doesn't make sense. On one hand you have you Intel saying they can not supply enough CPU because of high demands, on the other hand Component manufacture are blaming the low Supply in the channel for their lower than expected sales. All while AMD is taking server and desktop side market shares, no matter how small the percentage that is.

I think it basically boils down to few things.

1. Surprise Drop of Smartphone Unit Sold, we saw the first YoY decline in total Smartphone Unit shipment. ( Unit, not revenue ). Out of a 1.3B Smartphone market, even a 5% drop is a huge volume to fill.

2. Better than expected yield of 3D NAND. Which means you actually have an increase in output. And it just happen all three, Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron were able to yield better at the same time. To be fair they have been very conservatives with their estimate.

3. More Chinese DRAM and NAND are being used in the Domestic market. Which is unofficially required for selling phones in China.

All these along with the improved efficiency of DRAM and NAND Fabs for trying to fill orders during 2017 and 2018 without building new Fabs. Meant the DRAM / NAND are hit with a perfect storm.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by lrem on Saturday April 06, 2019 @06:16AM (#19590102)
These are not at odds. You want your machines to be uniform. If Intel calls you saying they'll deliver only two out of the ten thousand Xeon 1234-5 units you ordered this quarter, you call Samsung and cancel 80% of the order there.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by sanxiyn on Saturday April 06, 2019 @02:06AM (#19589517)
I heard from grapevine that cloud vendors accumulated DRAM stockpile. That's why CPU demand is high but DRAM demand is low.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by iClaudiusX on Saturday April 06, 2019 @01:00AM (#19589339)
All the major SSD NAND flash producers finally hit volume production of 3D TLC NAND at roughly the same time last year which sent prices falling precipitously.

I'm not aware of a similar pattern in DRAM, which if anything has been suspiciously high for a while to the point that many assume price fixing was to blame as has happened in the past.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by sanxiyn on Saturday April 06, 2019 @01:06AM (#19589354)
I think people attributed DRAM demand to cloud computing hyperscaling. Demand was higher than actual demand, because all of Amazon, Microsoft, Google purchased DRAM assuming their market share would increase. Predicted market share probably totaled well over 100%.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by blihp on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:54PM (#19589110)
At least part of the DRAM issue is related to Intel's CPU supply issues being a drag on new PC sales.[1] But overall for DRAM and NAND, it's probably a case of market saturation in many sectors.

[1] As well as AMD has been doing with Ryzen, most large computer purchasers are still Intel buyers and are slow to change.

Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by sanxiyn on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:51PM (#19589096)
Oversupply.
Re:Samsung warns profit to fall 60% by caprese on Friday April 05, 2019 @11:59PM (#19589129)
> Majority of profit came from DRAM and NAND, and profit fall is directly attributable to recent price crash of both.

finally