News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by js8 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @07:47AM (#19143021)
It is an important technology, but it will not really help right now.

It will always be cheaper to prevent creation of CO2 (burning fossil fuels) than to catch CO2 back from the atmosphere.

So, the first thing we need to do is to move to completely carbon emission free technology of energy production. Then we can perhaps produce more than we need (e.g. in the peaks) and can start thinking about catching some CO2 back from the atmosphere to reverse the climate changes.

Unfortunately, there is not even global consensus on getting to zero emissions. In this situation, I can't imagine how there can be a consensus on doing something (like utilizing this technology) on the mass scale that helps to save the environment for free.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by DennisP on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:32AM (#19143271)
I don't think it's a given that it will always be cheaper to avoid emissions. Long-haul air travel, for example, isn't likely to go electric anytime soon, and it could well be that the cheapest option is to absorb their emissions from the air and inject them into the ground, rather than producing carbon-neutral jet fuel.

If this technology really does get down to $94/ton, then a $100/ton price on carbon emissions is likely to give it a role. People can reduce emissions whenever it costs less than $94/ton to do so, and if it costs more, they could pay for absorption instead.

$100/ton CO2 would raise the price of gasoline by a dollar a gallon, which doesn't seem all that unattainable, especially if the collected funds are redistributed as a dividend.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by ebiester on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:46AM (#19143359)
Or add 100 dollars to the average cost of a NY-London flight, from my quick calculations. Flights would go up 50-200 dollars each way. That's not the end of the world.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by ancientworldnow on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @03:32PM (#19147221)
This figure doesn't take into account radiative forcing which makes that 1 ton figure act more like 3 or 4 tons in actual heating capability. Airline offset programs always ignore this (in addition to way under pricing carbon offsets because that market is mostly scams built around green guilt).

Even at $100 a ton, you're talking a few hundred of dollars of price increases to offset damages. This probably reduces the number of people flying which of course raise the per capita damage and therefore cost even more.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by stevesimmons on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @02:51AM (#19151238)
How does it raise the per capita damage?

Airlines are only profitable if they fly at high load factors. If price increases reduce the number of passengers flying, the airlines will try to fly fewer planes that are just as full as today. Thus the per passenger cost is the same.

(... based on a consulting project I did 20 years ago on airline network economics/route capacity optimization)

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by Scarblac on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:07AM (#19144022)
> $100/ton CO2 would raise the price of gasoline by a dollar a gallon

I need to check that number... according to https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/co2-emission-fuels-d_1085..., there is 9.20 kg CO2 released per gallon gasoline. So a dollar per gallon would be $100 per 920 kgCO2, close enough to a metric ton. OK :-)

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by Retric on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:12AM (#19144060)
Currently, up to around 50% as much CO2 is produced making and transporting a gallon of gasoline as from burning a gallon of gasoline.

Some of that would be mitigated, but it’s probably closer to 1.30$ vs 1$ a gallon.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by thinkcontext on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:00AM (#19144567)
California LCFS credits are at around $200/ton, so if $94/ton is achievable they'll make quite a bit of money.

https://www.arb.ca.gov/fuels/lcfs/credit/lrtweeklycreditrepo...

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by nradov on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:58AM (#19143941)
Eventually I expect we'll use renewable power to produce carbon neutral synthetic liquid hydrocarbon fuel for long-range transportation.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by js8 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @03:50PM (#19147351)
> it could well be that the cheapest option is to absorb their emissions from the air and inject them into the ground, rather than producing carbon-neutral jet fuel

I am not sure if you want to capture carbon or just CO2. If you want just to capture CO2, that's a different consideration but there is AFAIK no scalable technology that can store CO2 reliably.

So what you need to do is to actually break the C-O bonds in CO2, which is very energy expensive.

In theory you could burn methane (natural gas) or other hydrocarbon in system (airplane) A, producing more energy than needed by system (factory) B, which would recapture carbon from the air and convert it to pure carbon. That way, you would produce net energy by burning hydrogen into water (methane and carbon, respectively, are the most efficient choices for this).

Somebody can calculate it precisely based on the enthalpy, I am sure, but it seems to me that the both systems together would have to be at least 40% efficient (that is the product of their energy efficiencies would have to be that) for this to be energy positive. I don't think anybody has demonstrated this level of efficiency yet, and it might well be impossible (if we also consider the dispersal of CO2 in the atmosphere, as somebody else has noted).

Assuming this is possible (unlikely), in practice this would also require the operator of the system A to pay (at least) the cost of energy used by the operator of system B for the recaptured carbon. And this can be a practical problem, because people cheat in various ways and they would probably lobby to pay less at the expense of the environment. It seems much more transparent solution is just to forbid drilling for hydrocarbons outright.

That's why one should be careful about using dollars for these calculations. All externalities are rarely counted in costs. It is easy to fool yourself or other humans this way, however, the nature cannot be fooled.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by DennisP on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @07:03PM (#19149021)
It looks like the most promising idea for sequestering CO2 (rather than C) is injecting it into basalt formations, where it turns into minerals in a year or so. So far it's been tested in Iceland and Washington State, with promising results. Basalt is widespread so this could be very scalable. But it does use a lot of water; I don't know whether salt water would work.

https://www.futurity.org/basalt-carbon-storing-conversion-17...

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-43789527

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by comex on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @04:58PM (#19147995)
It doesn’t have to be energy positive if the energy used for capture comes from a non-carbon-emitting source.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by fallingfrog on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:47AM (#19143843)
But if you're pulling the CO2 from the air anyway, why not just use the extracted carbon as fuel rather than pull it out of the ground?
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by DennisP on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:54AM (#19145155)
Because you'll have to use energy to separate C from O2, and more energy to get hydrogen from water, so you can put them together and make hydrocarbons. One of these companies is planning to do exactly that, but with a price on carbon it might be cheaper to use fossil and pump captured CO2 underground. (I'm not saying it will be, just that it's not obvious either way.)
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by lucisferre on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:10AM (#19144046)
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by jonathankoren on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:04AM (#19143997)
Because CO2 isn’t petroleum, or any other hydrocarbon, and that’s what you need. It’s not easy, nor cost effective, to convert it.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by ARandomerDude on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:00AM (#19143962)
Cost. The average American family uses 24 metric tons a year (at least as of 2007, but we're ball-parking here) [1]. The article says it's $500 - $600 to extract 1 metric ton of CO2.

(24 metric tons * $550/metric ton) / 12 months = $1,110 per month.

That's $1,100 for raw CO2. Once you factor in CO2 => fuel, then transport, delivery, etc. your cost is dramatically higher.

Suppose scale could help and the entire process were $1,110 per month. For for most of us, that's still much more than we pay each month in electricity + gas.

1. http://blogs.edf.org/climate411/2007/02/20/picturing-a-ton-o...

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by jdietrich on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @01:56PM (#19146349)
According to the World Bank, America produced 16.5 tons of CO2 per person in 2014. Germany produced 8.9 tons per person, Britain produced 6.5 tons, France produced 4.6 tons and Switzerland produced 4.3 tons.

Can we all agree that 16.5 tons per person is an absurdly large amount of CO2?

https://databank.worldbank.org/data/reports.aspx?source=2&se...

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by snuxoll on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @03:42PM (#19147296)
Doesn’t help that so many in the US have no realistic choice for transportation beyond an automobile.

I’m a 90 minute walk from the nearest bus station, I work from home luckily (and have no license either) but my wife has to drive literally everywhere. We bought a used 2006 Prius now almost four years ago, so we’ve reduced our emissions as much as is feasible for now - but we still use roughly 300 gallons of fuel a year at 40MPG average.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by fallingfrog on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:40AM (#19144359)
The parent comment was about airplanes. The argument was that batteries are too heavy and that airplanes will still need to run on hydrocarbon fuel. And the argument the parent made is: you burn the fuel in the airplane engine and then sequester it later. And my response is: ok, but if you're sequestering carbon anyway, then use carbon you just sequestered instead of burning new carbon. You didn't understand my point.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by kaybe on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:54AM (#19145157)
It still makes a difference when you move the CO2 to the stratosphere, which is what you essentially do here. I'm not sure we've run the models on this (without the rest of the changes), so I don't know at what point it becomes a problem, but we should keep this in mind.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by chris_overseas on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:01AM (#19143097)
> So, the first thing we need to do is to move to completely carbon emission free technology of energy production. Then we can perhaps produce more than we need (e.g. in the peaks) and can start thinking about catching some CO2 back from the atmosphere to reverse the climate changes.

We should be doing both in parallel. The article talks about this:

"Last year’s I.P.C.C. report noted that it may be impossible to limit warming to 1.5 degrees by 2100 through only a rapid switch to clean energy, electric cars and the like. To preserve a livable environment we may also need to extract CO₂ from the atmosphere. As Wurzbacher put it, “if you take all these numbers from the I.P.C.C., you end up with something like eight to 10 billion tons — gigatons — of CO₂ that need to be removed from the air every year, if we are serious about 1.5 or 2 degrees.” "

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by SiempreViernes on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:53AM (#19143410)
No, we should have started going carbon neutral in the 1980's when the science case for precautionary was solid.

It is only given that carbon industry got us to ignore the dangers for more than thirty years that we now are so desperate to keep inside the carbon budget that even very inefficient solutions like carbon capture are seriously being considered.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by dotancohen on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:32AM (#19143703)
The best time to plant a tree is twenty years ago. The second best time is now.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by FreeFull on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:19AM (#19144127)
Speaking of trees, massive reforestation could be one way to pull CO2 out of the atmosphere. As a bonus, you end up with a lot of lumber you can use for things like buildings.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by dotancohen on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:39AM (#19145000)
My country has a holiday where the children plant trees every year.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by schoen on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @12:50PM (#19145723)
Maybe there could be a holiday where children and adults plant trees every month or every week!
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by jamesblonde on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:21AM (#19144143)
No idea why you're being downvoted. I think everything you said is supported by strong evidence.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by benj111 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:52AM (#19143885)
I'm not sure its reasonable to require such a massive upheaval as a precaution. Remember those 'X causes cancer' articles, should we phase out everything implicated, as a precaution?

I agree we should have moved earlier, and we should be moving faster though.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by lozenge on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:17AM (#19144113)
“present thinking holds that man has a time window of five to 10 years before the need for hard decisions regarding changes in energy strategies might become critical."

Exxon's senior scientist, 1978.

"Victory will be achieved when: (a)Average citizens "understand" (recognize) uncertainties in climate science; recognition of uncertainties becomes part of the "conventional wisdom" ... (e) Those promoting the Kyoto treaty on the basis of extant science appear out of touch with reality" (American Petroleum Institute memo, 1998)

“Doubt is our product, since it is the best means of competing with the ‘body of fact’ that exists in the minds of the general public” (B&W tobacco company 1969).

https://www.ucsusa.org/sites/default/files/attach/2015/07/Th...

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by benj111 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:36AM (#19144311)
What's a tobacco company quote got to do with anything?

The parent was talking about the precautionary principle. Im not really old enough to remember the 1980s global warming debate, so not agreeing or disagreeing with the factuality of that statement. Yes your first quote is damning, are you saying the science was more settled?

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by lozenge on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:57AM (#19144531)
Yes the science was settled, well the direction we needed to go in (decarbonisation) was clear, just not the speed or extent - there were bigger error bars. As figure 1 in the link shows, things went the other way.

The NYT published a good history of how settled the science was, but I'm going to link to a response to it: https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/08/nyt-mag-...

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by moosey on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:01AM (#19143970)
> Remember those 'X causes cancer' articles, should we phase out everything implicated, as a precaution?

This is a problem with how the media reports science, not science itself. It's why so many people believe that scientists thought we were going to have an ice age 30 years ago: awful reporting.

And back then, the upheaval wouldn't have been nearly as massive. There was less 'wealth' (read as 'carbon usage') and fewer people. It's a real pity.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by benj111 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:30AM (#19144227)
It's bad reporting in the sense of, it's only one study, but if you follow the precautionary principle it surely becomes logical to ban, then investigate further?
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by SiempreViernes on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:04AM (#19144001)
It is certainly cheaper to stop smoking than cure lung cancer, if that is what you mean.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by benj111 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:44AM (#19144402)
What I mean is should we be banning smoking on the basis of one study?

If a study does show a link then you repeat it, get more data, work out the extent of the problem. Then you have the info to make decent public policy.

And banning smoking something that's fairly easy to do, that isn't spending billions of $s of public funds, telling people they can't fly,drive,eat meat. And we still havent banned smoking.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by ForHackernews on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:39AM (#19143313)
> if we are serious about 1.5 or 2 degrees.

Hint: We're not.

The Americans are expecting +4C https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/trump...

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by SamBam on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:40AM (#19144360)
I think that the point is that if, today, you could spend $100 on pulling 1 ton of CO2 from the air, or spend $100 on green energy which prevents 2 tons of CO2 going into the air, the second is more important, even if we need to be extracting CO2 from the air.

There's no point in extracting 1 ton of CO2 and putting 2 tons of CO2 back up there.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by darepublic on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:00AM (#19143956)
I might be mistaken about this, but it puzzles me when people confidently state that people should NOT approach the problem from this angle. I feel like there is a great deal of uncertainty in this problem space and any genuine attempt to solve should be welcome.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by RGamma on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:50AM (#19145114)
Direct air capture is already _theoretically_ inefficient due to dilution effects of climate gasses. Just imagine all the natural ressources that will be embodied in just these direct-air-capture machines!

It is important that we think about lowering emissions first and foremost. Thinking "ah well, let's continue as usual, we'll fix it sometime later with <insert unproven technology>" is hella dangerous and most likely won't work:

We're fucking with a planetary climate system powered by the sun after all. The forces and scales at work there easily escape one's imagination...

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by tozeur on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:45AM (#19144409)
Exactly, it’s called experimentation! The above comment is equivalent to someone telling Bosch to quit because that ammonia capture process too expensive...
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by gus_massa on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:12AM (#19144693)
The difference is that ammonia is expensive, you can sell the ammonia (or something produced with ammonia) to make fertilizers or explosives or something. There is a market for ammonia.

When you capture CO2, what you can make? Some liquid like oil or gas that can be burn. Some solid like coal that can be burn. Some rock like limestone or marble that is more expensive than the natural one. You can't sell the products.

A big chunk of the man made CO2 is in power plants. It's not a good idea to burn oil to produce energy and CO2, and then use a bigger amount of energy to transform the CO2 into something that is easy to store like oil.

Perhaps you can use less energy to transform the CO2 into something like coal instead of oil, but in this case it would more efficient to make a new type of power plant that transform oil into a coal like product.

(Essentially burn the Hydrogen in the oil and keep the Carbons alone. I'm not sure if this is thermodynamically posible, but IIRC the C-H bound has more energy that the C-C bound. And even if this is possible, there are the technological problems.)

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by aurelwu on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:28AM (#19144872)
CO2 has some commercial uses too (greenhouses, chemical industry), so they can actually sell some of it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide#Agricultural_an...

Carbon Capture - like every single other measure - won't save the climate alone but it can be a useful element in those situations where there is so much solar/wind in the grid that you need some extra consumers to not waste it. Research in that area definitely is useful, in the end it will come down to the actual prices they can achieve in reality.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by ComputerGuru on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @02:09PM (#19146462)
The answer is to fine CO2 emissions to the point where carbon capture makes a killing.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by robomartin on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @12:00PM (#19145226)
This is the primary fallacy in this domain: Getting to zero emissions will not bring atmospheric CO2 down by 100 ppm for at least 50,000 to 75,000 years. Full stop.

This is scientific fact BTW.

I’ll go further than that: If we erased humanity and all we have built from planet earth on Monday —Captain Kirk beams everything into space and we all die— it would still be 50,000 to 75,000 years before CO2 levels drop by 100 ppm.

Again, scientific facts. No doubt at all that what I just said is true. Irrefutable.

In this very real context the only solutions will be found in technology that can consume CO2 in large quantities and hold on to it for as long as possible.

Here’s another scientific truth: We already have this technology. It is easy to deploy world-wide and we know it to be effective.

Even with that, this is a problem that will require generations to resolve; with a time scale in the thousands of years being likely.

This is an issue that has been politicized so far —on both ends of the belief scale— that most everyone is focusing on nonsense politically-driven non-solutions rather than having true science-based conversations.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by SubiculumCode on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @12:56PM (#19145791)
Small comment. For anything with dynamics this complex, science doesn't provide what can be fairly called 'facts', just projections based on current understanding. Other than that quibble I agree with your comment.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by robomartin on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @03:58PM (#19147426)
Fair comment. The data I am relying on is based on ice core sampling at the poles. We know, to a very high degree of certainty, what our atmosphere did for the last 800,000 years.

Taking this as to be my factual basis it is very easy to see what the planet has done and will do without humanity being around to muck things up. In rough strokes, atmospheric CO2 accumulates at a rate of about 100 ppm per 25,000 years and is reduced at a rate of, again, roughly, 100 ppm per 50,000 to 75,000 years.

This forms the basis of my assertion that erasing the entirety of humanity, our buildings and toys would only result in a 100 ppm reduction in 50K to 75K years. In other words, as far as a human scale is concerned, this might as well be forever. We might not even exist in 75,000 years.

The only way this assertion could be refuted is if someone is able to prove there is a way to take a planet-scale system and accelerate it's natural rate of atmospheric CO2 accumulation decay from 100 ppm per 75K years to something fast enough to be of practical significance to humanity.

Well, I suppose the other way to refute it would be to prove that our ice core sample data is fake or flawed in some manner. That will not happen. This quality and veracity of this data is well supported in the literature and accepted to be extremely accurate.

Without even attempting any math at all we can say the amount of energy required to accelerate planetary-scale effects from 100 ppm/75K years to, say, 100 ppm/100 years is likely astronomical in scale. And that much energy is rarely without consequences.

Remember, if we evaporate from this planet nothing changes faster than 100 ppm/50K years at best. In order to prove de-industrializing and crippling entire nations and continents would have any merit at all someone has to prove the physics and chemistry that would deliver the desired 100 ppm change in atmospheric CO2 concentration massively faster than 50K to 75K years.

This is why I am really down on the entire Climate Change business. It's a political football. Deniers are crazy and so are proponents or believers (at least politicians). They things they are talking about doing are utterly pointless and would only serve to damage countries and societies.

I mean, let's say we absolutely erase the United States from the face of the planet. Why just try to go "green", let's completely erase the US from earth. What would that accomplish? Absolutely nothing. Atmospheric CO2 concentration would continue to rise exponentially at about the same rate. It certainly isn't going to go down at all. So, what are these proponents talking about? Well, nonsense, that's what they are talking about. It has become a political tool with religious undertones on both sides.

I also spoke of us already having a technology that could be brought to bear on this issue world wide with relative ease. The questions to ask when looking at ice core atmospheric sample data are:

1- What made CO2 concentration increase? 2- What made it decrease.

The answers are simple:

1- Fires. Massive continent-scale fires. No firemen and water dropping helicopters to stop them.

2- Weather and trees. Water precipitates CO2. So, hurricanes, cyclones, storms, rains are good. They "wash" the atmosphere. And over tens of thousands of years they'd chip away at the problem.

And trees, well, trees take CO2 and turn it into, well, trees! They are a fantastic bit of technology that only requires water and soil to work! And we know how to grow trees at scale!

So, instead of a lot of the nonsense being floated out there what we have to do is:

1- Control or stop deforestation. This is terrible for the planet.

2- Plant trees like our lives depend on it. All of these lawns in front of homes in a city like Los Angeles are almost criminal when you consider they do nothing but waste water and require a guy with a gasoline powered mower and blower to maintain every week. We need to seriously consider changing the culture to plant a couple of trees in front of every home of every city wherever possible. Our cities need to look like forests to the extent possible. And there you go, CO2 sequestration using the very same technology the planet has probably used for millions of years to achieve the same kind of balance.

Anyhow, that's my humble opinion.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by pdabbadabba on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:49AM (#19143863)
> It will always be cheaper to prevent creation of CO2 (burning fossil fuels) than to catch CO2 back from the atmosphere.

Maybe. But the politics could be totally different. Scrubbing would not be perceived as suppressing the activities of an existing industry. Hopefully, therefore, huge sectors of the existing economy would not mobilize against it the way they have against proposals to suppress CO2 output.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by jpfed on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:49AM (#19145110)
One problem from the fossil fuel industry's perspective is that, while scrubbing doesn't suppress their activity, doing it is essentially an admission that there's a carbon problem. And once you do that, you give up the protection that controversy and doubt affords you, and people might start demanding more extreme measures to curb carbon.

Paying people to spread misinformation that maintains controversy and doubt (e.g. https://cei.org/ , who also helped maintain doubt surrounding the link between smoking and cancer) is far cheaper than the reckoning that could eventually result from admitting that carbon is a problem.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by lucisferre on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:13AM (#19144068)
This claim definitely feels like a fact not in evidence. I have not seen any number for the cost to society to completely transition from CO2 creating activities and move to a CO2 negative state. Because that is what it is going to take to prevent climate change at this point. A reduction in CO2 isn't going to cut it.

I would guess that cost is much higher than they think.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by Retric on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:53AM (#19143896)
I suspect large groups would organize to prevent spending 100+ Billion per year. Which would still make an insignificant change assuming we continue to produce CO2.

The scale of CO2 emissions are hard to conceive. You see human heath effects in areas with poor ventilation from high CO2 levels, but as CO2 rises what constitutes poor ventilation changes. At current rates even ignoring climate changes old buildings will start to cause headaches from high CO2 levels. Buildings built at 275ppm are generally still fine at 400ppm, but that changes as you keep going.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by deytempo on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:59AM (#19143466)
One thing we can do is try to hire more remote workers. Each person that doesn’t need to drive everyday is someone who doesn’t need to emit carbon every day
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by IfOnlyYouKnew on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:26AM (#19143662)
Remote work also enables low-density and rural living, which is far more carbon-intensive than urban environments. You may just turn someone taking the subway to work into someone taking their SUV to the grocery store, and heating/cooling their far larger house with four walls exposed to the outside.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:09AM (#19144038)
Is that really true. Perhaps comparing like for like but the last figures I saw showed 50% of the population live in cities but 70% of the emissions come from cities.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by llukas on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:53AM (#19144492)
It is not as clear cut and may be different with first-world economies and developing ones.

In developing ones cities are typically wealthiest more -> CO2 emissions due to higher standard of living.

In first-world cities are more efficient.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2009/mar/23/city-dwe...

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by benj111 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:58AM (#19143938)
While in principle I agree with you. Home food delivery is becoming a thing, houses can be insulated, and country doesn't have to equal bigger house etc.

I'm thinking European levels of rural, where food delivery is possible, don't know if it would be doable at US rural levels though.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by barbecue_sauce on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:44AM (#19144403)
Delivery is just someone producing CO2 coming to you instead of you producing CO2 going to them.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by TheShrug on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:54AM (#19144507)
That is true if deliveries are made one at a time, but if a delivery truck is making multiple deliveries at a time and makes an attempt to optimize it's route there would be less CO2 produced.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by ComputerGuru on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @02:10PM (#19146471)
People can just, you know, not go to the grocery store every day.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by justtopost on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:02AM (#19143488)
Pets contribute more co2 than most people. Taking care of your friends and family more than a furball may be a good alternative too.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by jeromegv on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:09AM (#19143530)
Pets do NOT contribute more co2 than most people. https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/4/16094674/cats-dogs-meat-di...

Pets do contribute surprisingly a lot of CO2 when you add them up, based on their meat consumption. But it's less than what a human would consume in meat and especially a lot less when you add how much humans transport themselves around.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by StavrosK on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:12AM (#19143548)
> Taking care of your friends and family more than a furball

For many people, pets are family. How do they contribute more co2 than most people, anyway, when they rarely drive?

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by bengale on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:12AM (#19143547)
Do you have more info on this? It seems counterintuitive on the face of it, my dog doesn't take a lot of flights or drive far for example.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by benj111 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:08AM (#19144032)
I think the idea is that, dogs for example have a high meat diet, and large dogs probably eat more than a person.

And they might not drive but a lot of owners like to drive some where to 'walk' their dog. Although considering the levels of obesity, that the exercise might be a net benefit.

Now I don't think dogs or cats cause anything like as much co2 as humans, but it is significant, and given the scale of reductions in co2 required, I think we are probably going to get to a point where large pet ownership is at least questioned.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by kakarot on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:23AM (#19144155)
You can't seriously believe that.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by thanatropism on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:27AM (#19144194)
At this point we'd be moving from policy to wide-scale social engineering.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by PakG1 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:11AM (#19143539)
Could you break down how that's possible? The only way I can think of that being possible is if you move the goal posts for one group and compare apple mathematics to orange mathematics.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by vinceguidry on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:17AM (#19143588)
Pets can love you back. The same isn't necessarily true of most people.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by benj111 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:20AM (#19144134)
What is love?

My dog only sticks around because I feed it. But then that's the same for my partner.

I suppose you could say its some kind of need for companionship? For me and my partner that's evolutionarily good for raising our spawn. But my dog has been genetically bred for 1000s of years for our purposes, maybe for a dog, it's unnatural to love, and a form of genetic enslavement? Maybe they've just learnt they get rewarded when they show 'love'.

Of course theres also the chance that you're anthropomorphising an animal.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by cowb0yl0gic on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:57AM (#19144529)
I want to knee-jerk and say "you've got it backwards; humans are mammals, mammals are social organisms, love is part of that profile". At the base, of course, everything is genetics; however, that doesn't make our experience of it any less real (just like our appreciation of beauty). I would say if your dog (or your partner) is just sticking around because you feed it, you are not doing something right.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by kakarot on Wednesday February 13, 2019 @05:38AM (#19152028)
If I was out of food my dogs would make sure we all got fed.

There are ways to have a symbiotic relationship with another animal without strict verbal communication. Maybe you just haven't taken the time to learn about your animal and the things that make it unique and worth loving. Because it might already be doing that about you.

I know I wake up every morning to my cat purring on my face and nestling into me and she starts purring the moment I pick her up. She's not sticking around for table scraps.

I used to own rats. If you want to really learn just how emotionally intelligent pets can be, get a pair of those. Some of the most social creatures you'll ever meet.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by vinceguidry on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:45AM (#19144421)
Mammals have the same limbic systems we do.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by ovi256 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:17AM (#19143191)
>always be cheaper to prevent creation of CO2 (burning fossil fuels) than to catch CO2

Why ? Where does this comes from ?

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by pjc50 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:25AM (#19143235)
One of those processes emits energy, the other requires energy input - and to overcome the entropy, the capture process requires more energy.

Edit: one barrel of oil produces 0.43 metric tons CO2 and costs about $60. Therefore, if your price of CO2 capture is more than $140/ton, it's cheaper to "capture" the CO2 by buying a barrel of oil and "sequestering" it as you would the CO2. So if carbon capture prices are more than about $150 it would be a viable business to operate a "reverse oilfield" buying oil on the open market and pumping it underground.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by WillPostForFood on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:24AM (#19144168)
Shouldn’t you include the value of the energy that the barrel creates in the calculation?
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by pjc50 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:35AM (#19144291)
It was mostly a piece of elaborate sarcasm about the value of reducing consumption rather than capture. Going down that route, should the value of energy used in carbon capture be counted at the market rate or its opportunity cost?

It's valid to point out that the value of a barrel of oil is more than its cost and this gives rise to a "consumer surplus", which leads to the carbon tax arguments.

(Although, as Retric points out upthread, there are consequential CO2 side-effects from oil extraction more than just burning it, so maybe those should be counted too?)

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by nicoburns on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:47AM (#19144441)
This might not always be the case if for example solar energy prices keep falling as fast as they have been.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by js8 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:28AM (#19143251)
This is just law of conservation of energy (1st law of thermodynamics). If burning carbon to CO2 produces certain amount of energy (part of which then can be used to do useful work), then the reverse of that process, breaking up CO2 to carbon and oxygen, will require at least the amount of energy that was produced in burning it.

So yeah, it's nice to have the technology to take CO2 from the air and create C and O2, however, the catch is, it requires energy. If that energy comes from fossil fuels, you will be better off not to do this thing at all, because you will end up creating a bit more CO2 in the process.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by mhandley on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:37AM (#19143755)
If we're going to depend on renewables for almost all electricity generation, this will require both energy storage, and installing more renewables than are needed for typical usage. This wouldn't be true if we had cheap energy storage that could supply load for weeks at a time through unusual dips in generation, but that seems unlikely. In practice it's cheaper to install excess generation than excess storage.

Now, if you've got excess generation for electricity, then at times of good generation, you want to use that electricity for something, as otherwise the electricity price will be negative. Using it to produce synthetic fuels for aviation seems like a really good match, as that electricity would be effectively free.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by SilasX on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:21AM (#19144791)
>If burning carbon to CO2 produces certain amount of energy (part of which then can be used to do useful work), then the reverse of that process, breaking up CO2 to carbon and oxygen, will require at least the amount of energy that was produced in burning it.

Except that you don't have to do the exact reverse of the process, you just have to extract it from the atmosphere (or emission point) and contain it somehow, which could be any number of mechanisms that may or may not require significant energy (beyond the cost of distillation).

Edit: Your argument is like saying that garbage collection (in the municipal sense) can never be economical because because it has to cost at least as much as making the products-to-be-disposed.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by jbay808 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:06AM (#19144631)
The second law makes it much worse.

If you take concentrated oxygen and concentrated carbon (soot), you can burn them in a sealed chamber into pure CO2. If you are very careful about extracting the energy, you might get most of it.

But already the entropy has increased, because now the carbon and oxygen have mixed together. Attempting to reverse the reaction will need extra energy to deal with that.

It gets much worse though, if you open up our chamber and vent the gas into the atmosphere. The entropy goes through the roof as the CO2 concentration drops to a few hundred PPM, and the cost of reversing the reaction goes up even more.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by DougN7 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:16AM (#19143586)
If the energy to do the reverse is not from carbon fuels (solar, wind) then it gets interesting though, right?
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by SubiculumCode on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @12:49PM (#19145720)
I do not think all methods of CO2 capture require an active energy source. I believe there are sequestration methods involving volcanic rock.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by est31 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:46AM (#19143829)
If we want to meet the 2 degrees goal by any means then given current trends we'll have to start removing net amounts of CO2 from the athmosphere. Of course, it makes most sense to do that once we are already carbon neutral, but once we are there, we should have the technology available for deployment and therefore investing in research right now is a good idea.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by furyg3 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:01AM (#19143969)
I'm very much in agreement here, I'm glad someone's investing into researching the tech, as we may need to use it even after we've stopped burning dinosaurs.

What I do like about it is that it quantifies how much it costs to recover the CO2, which is useful in calculating externalities. For example, there was recently a Canadian court ruling that bankrupt oil firms first need to fund well cleanup before creditors... to which reddit joked how progressive such a concept is. No, a 'progressive' statement is that we need to calculate how much it would cost to pull all the CO2 that was generated by using the oil as fuel and finance that as well, before creditors are paid...

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by radicalbyte on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:50AM (#19144467)
We should be running full speed to cut emissions whilst also implementing things like this https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vpTHi7O66pI which both sequesters an enormous amount of carbon and improves our planet.

In Europe at least these are things we can do without extra costs by just changing the farm subsidies so they encourage good behaviour. Just as we can do the same my moving fuel subsidies away from fossil to renewables.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by agumonkey on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:55AM (#19144508)
Savory has been heavily heavily criticized. I'm not versed enough but it seems he's preaching more than proving.

That said if you get to make people walk into places to produce carbon sequestration areas/devices instead of burning fuel .. you'd get squared returns

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by radicalbyte on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:59AM (#19144561)
I don't know much about his methology but from what I've been reading it's possible to sequester a huge quantity of co2 in soil via active land management. I'd love to know if it was economically viable to do.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by agumonkey on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:30AM (#19144900)
the few bits I've read about him was not about capture but turning arid land back to green pastures, and studies concluded that none of his theories made a difference

maybe he's right about co2 capture but be dubious

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by dalbasal on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:52AM (#19143401)
Depends on the energy economics.

If it gets to (for example) a point where capturing carbon uses less energy than burning the same amount of carbon fuel releases... it's at least theoretically useful. At that point it's about costs.

Otherwise... Say we get to 0 emissions by 2035. There will be (is) already a troublesome amount of carbon in the atmosphere. We might have to do some carbon capture even if we're not releasing new carbon.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by wcoenen on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:56AM (#19143435)
> Depends on the energy economics. If it gets to (for example) a point where capturing carbon uses less energy than burning the same amount of carbon fuel releases

Not allowed by thermodynamics. Otherwise you could create free energy by continuously burning and recapturing the same carbon.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by speakeron on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:36AM (#19143746)
> Not allowed by thermodynamics. Otherwise you could create free energy by continuously burning and recapturing the same carbon.

That doesn't have to be the case; the carbon you capture may not be in a burnable form. E.g. if carbon dioxide were captured, additional energy would be required to split off the oxygen before the carbon could be 'burned' again.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by llukas on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:24AM (#19143649)
Just capturing might be possible - it doesn't have to be in form that can be easily used to generate energy.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by tom_mellior on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:42AM (#19143796)
It would suffice to use less non-carbon-based energy to capture the CO2.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by fallingfrog on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @02:00PM (#19146385)
"If it gets to (for example) a point where capturing carbon uses less energy than burning the same amount of carbon fuel releases"

Sorry, that's forbidden by the laws of physics.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by jeffreyrogers on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @12:28PM (#19145513)
Isn't something like half of emissions from construction (steel and cement) and agriculture? Limiting fossil fuels is a good idea, but as that declines the significance of other sources of CO2 will increase. And those two sources are already increasing in absolute terms as well and will continue to increase as long as global population and living standards do as well.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by DougN7 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:12AM (#19143542)
Arter reading your comment I was envisioning a world that emitted no carbon. It made me wonder if the pendulum could possibly swing so far in the other direction that plants could start suffocating. Certainly not something we need to worry about now, but we humans aren’t great at avoiding unintended consequences.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by sunir on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:15AM (#19143575)
Zero carbon from human energy production doesn’t arrest the natural carbon cycle. Plants will continue as plants.

The problem is we are literally digging carbon out of the ground and putting it into the atmosphere, thereby increasing the amount of atmospheric carbon over time.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by IfOnlyYouKnew on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:16AM (#19143579)
The answer is somewhere between “no” and “what??” .

As but one factor, dying plants would release CO2. The total amount of carbon in the atmosphere is (was) at equilibrium.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by DougN7 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @11:06AM (#19144633)
Of course. I shouldn’t comment so early in the morning :(
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by gus_massa on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:56AM (#19143921)
You [1] emit CO2 from the food you eat, so absolute zero CO2 emission is impossible. There are also emission from volcanos.

For a somewhat similar scenario, you can read about the Carboniferous period https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carboniferous . Essentially, the plants invented the wood but nobody know how to eat it, so the dead plants accumulated sequestering a lot of CO2. So the CO2 concentration dropped and the O2 concentration skyrocket. As a side effect, the high O2 concentration allowed bugs to became giant. (It ended when fungus learned how to eat wood.)

[1] And all the other animal, fungus and even plants. And also bacteria and archaea.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by SlowRobotAhead on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @09:58AM (#19143935)
>So, the first thing we need to do is to move to completely carbon emission free technology of energy production.

I’m very interested when a statement right off the bat throws out that we should completely and unquestionably stop using hydrocarbons which are the most efficient, portable, easy to use and safe source of energy we have ever seen. Not to mention it’s current absolute requirement in long range transport, making plastics, lubricants and production of composites that make the efficient renewable powered machines possible.

How is it some people get a pass on willfully ignoring reality just because the goal is reducing emissions?

So on the topic, you better hope recovering CO2 is efficient because we won’t stop using oil until it’s gone.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by pjc50 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:47AM (#19144436)
You can't claim people are "willfully ignoring reality" without acknowledging that capture is necessarily going to consume more energy that was emitted in release.

> making plastics, lubricants and production of composites

These don't put CO2 into the atmosphere until they are burned. Also given sufficient energy input they could also be outputs of a capture process...