News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by pjc50 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @08:25AM (#19143235)
One of those processes emits energy, the other requires energy input - and to overcome the entropy, the capture process requires more energy.

Edit: one barrel of oil produces 0.43 metric tons CO2 and costs about $60. Therefore, if your price of CO2 capture is more than $140/ton, it's cheaper to "capture" the CO2 by buying a barrel of oil and "sequestering" it as you would the CO2. So if carbon capture prices are more than about $150 it would be a viable business to operate a "reverse oilfield" buying oil on the open market and pumping it underground.

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by WillPostForFood on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:24AM (#19144168)
Shouldn’t you include the value of the energy that the barrel creates in the calculation?
Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by pjc50 on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:35AM (#19144291)
It was mostly a piece of elaborate sarcasm about the value of reducing consumption rather than capture. Going down that route, should the value of energy used in carbon capture be counted at the market rate or its opportunity cost?

It's valid to point out that the value of a barrel of oil is more than its cost and this gives rise to a "consumer surplus", which leads to the carbon tax arguments.

(Although, as Retric points out upthread, there are consequential CO2 side-effects from oil extraction more than just burning it, so maybe those should be counted too?)

Re:A tiny Swiss company thinks it can help stop climate change by nicoburns on Tuesday February 12, 2019 @10:47AM (#19144441)
This might not always be the case if for example solar energy prices keep falling as fast as they have been.