Frankly, I think it’s better that these cans and bottles are being recycled, fraudulently or otherwise. I’m sure it hurts the Oregon pocketbook, but according to the article, the cost of the program is only six figures. This is only a problem (cost wise) when redemption is over 100%.
Why do you doubt that it could be a high percentage? A huge number of folks live in Vancouver across the OR/WA border and commute into Portland every day, and do their shopping in OR for the lack of sales tax.
Which makes it quite convenient for them to “return” bottles gathered from other people who shop near where the returner loves in WA to Oregon for the deposit.
You seem to be only considering people returning bottles purchased for their own consumption.
100 bottles is only $10! Think about the amount of effort required for this
[0]: http://articles.latimes.com/2012/oct/07/local/la-me-can-frau...
Edit: more info.
One thing about the recycling centers though - you have to have an account, and you have to prove you are an OR resident to use them. I imagine that cuts down on a lot of out of state cans.
Map: https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-1-ab&q=portla...
More info on the recycling centers: https://www.bottledropcenters.com/
Oh, and stores would limit what kind of returns they'd accept. So I'd have say, sorry, we don't sell that here so you can't return it here.
So, I'd imagine some of that is why they created the centers. Which, btw, I only just learned about from this topic.... :)
Just a small amount of "excess" returns (bottles for which OBRC did not initially collect the dime, but pays out the dime) can push the overall program into the red. In the example above, only a 3% increase in return rate (from 80 to 83%) pushes the program into the red.
If you're claiming that the scheme is currently funded in such a way that something like a 3% improvement in return rate (fraudulent or genuine, OBRC can't tell) is a problematic financial event, then I suppose I get it.
The externality argument based on the cost of landfill (made by another commenter) is sensitive to whether the bottles come from out of state.
The program doesn't on a per bottle bases, but the effectiveness at dealing with the problem the program aims to solve (local landfilling recyclable containers) is impacted by the substitution; in the context of the function served, imported bottles that would not otherwise be imported are not fungible with local bottles.
Insofar as part of the purpose is local waste stream diversion (because landfilling has costs), yes.
It's true that the local cost is coupled with a remote benefit, but remote benefits have less value, ceteris paribus, to the people paying the costs.
If Oregon returns hit 100%, leaving no funds to pay for the program, the program isn't likely to continue without state taxpayer funding (currently, it's funded from the program itself and not the state's taxpayers).
As a theoretical point, even with a 100% return rate, it's still possible to make money on the float. Buy a 12-pack, deposit $1.20, return 1 week later, get $1.20 back, but in the meanwhile that buck-and-change could make ~1/50¢ in interest.
The same report says they do about 2 billion containers / year, which at 10¢/container is $200M. In the optimistic case of 1 year between purchase and return, assuming 2% interest, that's $4M. Assuming 1 week, I think it's $100K, so not much.
A more likely income source is the profit from selling relatively clean metal, glass, and PET. That report says 151.0 M Aluminum Cans per quarter. I see numbers around 2¢/can for the metal value, so that's $3M/quarter or call it $10M/year.
So even with 100% return rate, there is still money coming in. Just (as you say) not enough to pay for the program.
FWIW, https://www.obrc.com/Content/Reports/OBRC%20Annual%20Report%... says that there was "$25 million" in "Estimated value of 2017 unredeemed deposits". That plus the Al can value is easily enough to pay for the program.
If there really was a problem I'd expect to see a different barcode for cans/bottles sold in Oregon vs other states.
Probably not systematically from CA, which also has a bottle deposit (though there may be some arbitrage opportunity since the CRV is, IIRC, 5¢ for some containers that have a 10¢ deposit on Oregon.)
The fear that these rates were the product of fraud even lead to amendments to the recycling act in 2008, namely adding a state-specific mark to bottles. Yet the redemption rate remains over 90%.
At least that's how I got over the limit in Michigan when I was in college. We used to save all our cans and bottles for the whole year and return them all at once.
You're not going to make much profit off the effort though, unless you value your time at $0.
This is not hypothetical stuff. Large scale operations have already been caught:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2018/12/03/recycling-smu...
> Three suspects were arrested in a case that resulted in fraudulent payouts totaling $16.1 million over three years, the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery reported Monday.
> Authorities said the Bustillos' trucking operation existed entirely to smuggle cans and bottles into California.
As an Oregon resident I actually feel like those bottles getting redeemed from out-of-state is better off than them going into a landfill. I think we can take whatever the offset to revenue is.
That’s a valid bottle, but an abuse of the system because they are getting 10 cents from Oregon that was never paid. The point of the program is you pay 10 cents and get it back if you recycle.
The point of program is to recycle bottles. Exchanging money is means to an end not an end itself.
As long as returns are <100%, I don't think it matters who bought the bottle.
The cost is covered because many bottle deposits end up going unclaimed.
But nobody paid 10 cents for that bottle.
You photocopy a sheet of barcodes and stick them on the bottles.
Some machines you can even hold the barcode in your hand, and put the bottle in, then you can put anything in and reuse the barcode endlessly.
This sounds like a dozens of dollars level scam, not millions.
> not millions
No, not individually, but if tons of people are doing it all day, it adds up.
And bumping the fee to $0.10 makes it $36/hour which is very attractive to someone who doesn't have a job.
Again, the actual earnings are lower, but I think it's a realistic type of fraud.
There is a viable way to do recycling fraud, but DIY stickers isn't it.
Maybe they don't in practice because consumers don't rationally consider the net numbers, but theoretically they should.
100% of deposits have been paid for by people. If someone else returns their bottle and the deposit payer can't be bothered, that's a win win surely.
I get that Washington bottle buyer hasn't paid a deposit. But if Oregon bottle buyer has paid a deposit for a bottle, but chooses not to recycle it, there is a deposit that has been paid, but not claimed. What is the problem with the Washington bottle buyer returning their bottle in return for the deposit back? A bottle is returned, which is surely the aim of the deposit. The return rate is below 100% so there aren't unfunded deposits.
Separately, it's not clear the bottles illegally being returned for deposit are increasing the recycling rate. The article I linked suggests that they are being scavenged from recycling bins, and that (possibly as a result) collected glass recycling in an Oregon-adjacent county in Washington was down 9% after the deposit went up.
I guess Oregon is pretty close to finding out what happens when the return rate hits 100.1%; that would be interesting.
There's even a whole Seinfeld episode about why it doesn't work.
One thing's for sure -- and this was discussed when China first reneged on recycling the plastics: Commingled recycling at the curb has been a disaster. In my opinion, predictably so. I remember being surprised when it first began, to think that it could be economical or efficient to have to separate the streams further downstream. Turns out I was right.
Sorting and separating isn't that hard, and people would've learned and mastered it by now, if they'd been required to do it. Contrary to the hope, if you coddle people they will not show their appreciation by meeting the new, lower minimum expected of them; they will continue to push the bar even lower.
Some local breweries are moving to reusable bottles that are washed and used many timees before recycling. We're building a washing plant in PDX this year to grow the program.
Yea, I'm in Oregon, and this happens to me too. Honestly, who cares? What they are "stealing" (lol) is being recycled. If this senator cared enough, he would take his bottles/cans to the store and get credit for it. The point is, he doesn't care that much, but somehow feels entitled to something he doesn't care about.
There's a related issue where the residents don't always trust that the salvagers will content themselves solely to collecting redeemable cans.
What's the real fear here? That this Senator hasn't had her name in the papers in a while?
You mean they're 3d printing fake bottles? No?
Oh, did they buy their own injection molding equipment and producing bottles? No?
Oh, so they're gathering corporate trash and returning it? And you call _that_ fraud? Uh huh. Sounds like the bottle return is doing a hell of a job.
Here's a recent article about the problem: "Oregon senator to introduce bill to thwart return of bottles, cans bought in Washington: She says grocery stores ‘drowning’ in out-of-state containers"
https://www.columbian.com/news/2018/dec/04/oregon-senator-to...
Has anyone seen more exact numbers that would either support or refute this?