Re:Oregon Bottle Deposit System Hits 90 Percent Redemption Rate
by nkurz on Thursday January 24, 2019 @01:13PM
(#18991246)
I think the usual argument is that the program costs something to run, and was designed with the assumption that returns would not actually be 100%. Any returns beyond the planned level mean that the program is underfunded, and thus potentially unsustainable. It's also generally considered bad for illegal activity to be allowed to continue.
Separately, it's not clear the bottles illegally being returned for deposit are increasing the recycling rate. The article I linked suggests that they are being scavenged from recycling bins, and that (possibly as a result) collected glass recycling in an Oregon-adjacent county in Washington was down 9% after the deposit went up.
Re:Oregon Bottle Deposit System Hits 90 Percent Redemption Rate
by LeifCarrotson on Thursday January 24, 2019 @04:30PM
(#18993188)
Ah, I understand. You're assuming the deposits are fungible. I wasn't.
I guess Oregon is pretty close to finding out what happens when the return rate hits 100.1%; that would be interesting.
Re:Oregon Bottle Deposit System Hits 90 Percent Redemption Rate
by RandallBrown on Thursday January 24, 2019 @04:55PM
(#18993422)
Michigan has had a 10 cent deposit for decades and fraud isn't an issue.
There's even a whole Seinfeld episode about why it doesn't work.
I get that Washington bottle buyer hasn't paid a deposit. But if Oregon bottle buyer has paid a deposit for a bottle, but chooses not to recycle it, there is a deposit that has been paid, but not claimed. What is the problem with the Washington bottle buyer returning their bottle in return for the deposit back? A bottle is returned, which is surely the aim of the deposit. The return rate is below 100% so there aren't unfunded deposits.