News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by brownbat on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:11AM (#18458956)
99PI's coverage of forest fire policy and design was really provocative:

https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/built-to-burn/

1. Our entire approach to fighting forest fires may just be making them worse.

2. Smart and simple design decisions can save houses.

A house can be thirty feet from an entire forest on fire and never burn down.

We learned this through hardcore experiments in Canada where they built homes to test and lit forests on fire nearby.

One of the immediate takeaways was to change roofing materials to resist embers, but there are other options for materials and landscaping that could make homes basically impervious.

The problem is probabilities. Fires are common, constant. They are exceedingly rare in any one location though. So fire resistant design is no one's urgent problem, fires are always something that seems like it will happen to somebody else.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by nixpulvis on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:34AM (#18460638)
My best friend in high school lost his house to a fire in the mountains of CO. The house was made out of clays and other highly fire resistant materials, to the point it was designated the safe house for the fire crew of the area... when the four mile canyon fire swept through it was so hot it even melted all the metals like copper and steel. There was nothing left.

I'm sure there are lots of ways to build houses to resist fire more, and we should be doing that, but "basically impervious" is an overstatement.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:04PM (#18462175)
> The house was made out of clays

> when the four mile canyon fire swept through it was so hot it even melted all the metals like copper and steel. There was nothing left.

But exposing clay to really hot fire just hardens it into fired clay. Hence the term. What happened there?

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by chrismorgan on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:24PM (#18464466)
FYI, if you expose clay to really really hot fire, it still melts. A mere 4,000°C will even melt everything in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high-temperature_ceramic....

I have no real concept of the sorts of heats involved in fires like the one described above. But even if the clay isn’t melting, it’s fun to know that ceramics aren’t magical non-melting, non-burning things—they just require unusually much, typically impractically much, heat to achieve it.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by givehimagun on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:48PM (#18464649)
Looks like wildfires get up to about 1,200°C when really hot.

https://nhmu.utah.edu/sites/default/files/attachments/Wildfi...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by derefr on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:42PM (#18464594)
It surprises me to learn that there are wildfires on the surface of the Earth that get hotter than a rocket nose-cone experiencing re-entry.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by zhengyi13 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:21PM (#18462338)
Fire resistance would be orthogonal to structural stability, I expect. If the steel beams melt, and they're what's holding up the clay, clay/structure can certainly collapse, even if you can still say nothing burned, as such.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by londons_explore on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:45PM (#18464623)
Even in stone/brick houses, they normally still have wooden roof beams. Typically embers set things like guttering and dry leaves in guttering on fire, and that then spreads through vents in the rafters into the rest of the building.

A fire suppression water spray to keep the roof wet would probably save most brick buildings. Most fires burn out within half an hour or so, so one wouldn't even need too big a supply of water.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by brownbat on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:36PM (#18466170)
I'm very sorry to hear that, that's got to be a devastating experience to watch someone you know go through that.

Basically impervious was an overstatement for emphasis, you're right. I was trying to draw a stark contrast with the sometimes thoughtless status quo, but I should have been more precise.

And to be fair that crown fire study was just looking at thermal ignition, which isn't the whole picture. The strategies to prevent spread through embers are more complex and sometimes not possible in all areas -- vegetation control, standoff zones, irrigation...

Still, as I think we both agree, much more can and should be done.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by dbcurtis on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:31AM (#18460603)
> A house can be thirty feet from an entire forest on fire and never burn down.

In zero wind. The fires in Santa Rosa were driven by 60 mph (100 kph) winds. Even 30 mph winds will pick up the top 15 meters of a burning Ponderosa Pine and carry it 400 meters away and start a new fire.

After the Santa Rosa fires I saw newspaper photos of melted barbeque grills. A fire hot enough to melt cast iron is going to light or melt any roofing material I can think of.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by xenadu02 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:08PM (#18461048)
No one is claiming you can fireproof a house; did you even look at the link?

With some simple actions you can change the odds of 100% of homes burning down to 10-50%. This isn’t made up, these are facts proven by evidence and experiment.

Your comment is like saying no one should bother building basements in tornado country because a strong F5 will kill you anyway. The vast majority of tornadoes aren’t strong F5s so taking some precautions absolutely will save lives and property.

The biggest ones are:

- fire-resistant roofing; the vast majority of homes that burn in these evens are set on fire by embers long before the fire line even gets close, which makes firefighting efforts basically pointless

- fire-resistant siding; if a fire is near this makes it much less likely that the siding will catch from brief contact or by being heated to its ignition point. If the side walls catch the house is a goner.

- keep tree tops 30-60 ft away from structures. Fires often leap from treetop to treetop, then from there to the structure.

- use non-flammable landscaping near the home.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by dbcurtis on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:39PM (#18461374)
> Your comment is like saying no one should bother building basements in tornado country because a strong F5 will kill you anyway. The vast majority of tornadoes aren’t strong F5s so taking some precautions absolutely will save lives and property.

No, my comment is like saying clearing 30 feet around your house is an absolute no-brainer, of course do it, but don't expect that alone to miraculously save you from a fire.

Saying this as someone who's mountain cabin survived the Detweiler fire, largely because of vegetation control.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by hueving on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:01PM (#18461588)
>No, my comment is like saying clearing 30 feet around your house is an absolute no-brainer, of course do it

Ok, but that's not what you said. You just ignored it completely like you were disregarding it. If it was such a no-brainer everyone would have done that in California, which was clearly not the case and it's why we're having this discussion now.

It's like someone posting stats about seatbelts saving lives in response to tons of vehicle deaths where people weren't wearing seatbelts. Then you come along and point out that if you drive off a 500 ft cliff a seatbelt won't save your life and some of the deaths were caused by driving off of a cliff.

Either the implication is that the safety mechanism would not have helped, or you are offering a useless observation that it's not making them impervious.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by haberman on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:10PM (#18462226)
> or you are offering a useless observation that it's not making them impervious.

Considering that the original post literally used the phrase "could make homes basically impervious", I don't consider this a useless observation. I found it quite informative.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by pixl97 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:43PM (#18462000)
>my comment is like saying clearing 30 feet around your house is an absolute no-brainer, of course do

Watch the videos coming out of the area. These people have trees touching their homes.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by apersona on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:11PM (#18463378)
Quoting the original poster: > but there are other options for materials and landscaping that could make homes basically impervious > basically impervious

That (for a layman like me) can easily be interpreted as fire proofing.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by jjoonathan on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:18PM (#18464000)
It's very generous of you to suggest that the miscommunication is due to a lack of expertise on your part. I'm pretty sure it isn't, though.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by zzzeek on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:19PM (#18461771)
> No one is claiming you can fireproof a house;

the quoted line "A house can be thirty feet from an entire forest on fire and never burn down." says exactly that.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kbenson on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:05PM (#18462181)
I think it's a matter of interpretation. "A house can be thirty feet from an entire forest on fire and never burn down" is not equivalent to "A house thirty feet from an entire forest on fire will never burn down."

It's a bit tricky because in truth a house may be touching trees that are one fire and "will never burn down" (in the sense that it won't that time) can also be a true statement.

I think a generous interpretation is that "A house can be thirty feet from an entire forest on fire and never burn down." is meant to mean that a house thirty feet away from the forest fire likely won't while a house right next to the forest fire likely will.

It was poorly worded, but it isn't necessarily saying what you state.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by vorpalhex on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:12PM (#18462841)
You're arguing semantics in a non-cooperative way. I had to re-read your first sentence five or six times to glean the meaningful difference. It's unfortunately put you in the camp of either trying to make a moving target argument, or dismissing your peers as children - neither of which is a positive end.

Like with anything, you have to pick what the likely scenario should be and build to it. You can build a nuclear power plant to resist 40ft high swells and still get a 50ft swell and be powerless. Obviously more protected is better, but also more expensive (which makes housing less available and affordable, etc). The recurrent nature of the problem suggests to me that the code may be too lax currently, and that the solutions are non-trivial: likely major work for existing homes (from a homeowner perspective, forest management may be able to do more).

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kbenson on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:34PM (#18463014)
> You're arguing semantics in a non-cooperative way.

Huh, I think that's the first time I've been accused of being non-cooperative for saying what is essentially "I think perhaps how you're interpreting that statement is not how it was meant and you're talking past each other."

All I was saying is that it appears that zzzeek interpreted the original statement as "do X and Y can't happen" when I think ambiguous wording was used and that wasn't the intent, as I didn't interpret it that way.

I'm arguing semantics because I think there is a misunderstanding of people's positions because of those semantics. I understand that it got a little long into the weeds, but there was a point.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by erikpukinskis on Friday November 16, 2018 @06:12PM (#18472727)
You should read it again and understand what’s behind said. If you’re missing the grammatical structure you are probably misunderstanding a huge percentage of the language people are using around you.

The word used was “can” and it means something is possible.

Your misunderstanding is quite commmon in English these days. People say things like “men are pigs” or “chickens fly” and many will interpret that as if a broad claim was made. But “all chickens fly all day long” is a totally different sentence than “chickens fly” and “chickens can fly“.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Filligree on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:40PM (#18461977)
Implicitly, that requires luck. Some houses will burn down, just not everyone.

Nothing will save a house that's close to a forest fire while not being fire-resistant, however.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by briandear on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:24PM (#18461214)
Keep tree tops 30-60 feet away from structures is certainly good advice, but the environmental extremists are virulently opposed to any efforts to permit homeowners from being able to do that sort of tree management on their own property.

Here is a page from such a group attempting to oppose a measure that would allow private citizens to cut down trees on their own land, if that land is under 300 acres in area: http://winewaterwatch.org/2018/08/kill-ab-426-allowing-road-...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by oasisbob on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:55PM (#18464255)
That strikes me as a misleading read on AB 425. It expands the existing exempted activities which don't require a forestry management plan, like temporary road building:

https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...

The ability of "private citizens to cut down trees on their own land" doesn't turn on AB 425. The code already has specific provisions for firebreaks, and AB 425 doesn't change them one way or another:

https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/public-resources-code/prc-sect-...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by megablast on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:43PM (#18461406)
How about don't build your house in the forest?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by rblatz on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:49PM (#18461465)
Or more accurately, don't build your house in the middle of a forest that has fire as an important part of its life cycle.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:03PM (#18462165)
What would be an example of another kind of forest, where fire isn't an important part of the life cycle?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by sjf on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:48PM (#18462628)
Temperate broadleaf forest
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by bronson on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:14PM (#18462267)
rainforest
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by hueving on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:56PM (#18461538)
Cast iron BBQ grills? Where does one buy a grill made from cast iron? How do you stop it from immediately rusting out once you get it?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Theodores on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:37PM (#18461943)
By 'seasoning' it. You slather it with some type of cooking oil and that protects it from turning bright orange with rust.

Cast iron is the material of choice as it is cheaper than surgery grade stainless steel, it retains the heat and it is a traditional material that people expect.

As for where you can buy yourself a grill made from cast iron, the options are many. In towns there are shops that sell such things. You can walk into such a shop, exchange money and get your own BBQ grill in genuine cast iron.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by giobox on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:45PM (#18462589)
Pretty much all Weber (a very, very mainstream grill brand available the world over) grills/“grates” are cast iron. It works fine! You do typically have to replace them every three to five years, but this isn’t that big a deal, the replacement grates are stocked at most home improvement stores.

It’s extremely common in mid to high end grills.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by dragonwriter on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:21AM (#18467130)
> Pretty much all Weber (a very, very mainstream grill brand available the world over) grills/“grates” are cast iron.

No, they are “plated steel” for the cooking grate, and “heavy gauge steel” for the charcoal grate; at least per the specs on their website. (Which matches every Weber I've used over several decades.)

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by giobox on Friday November 16, 2018 @04:05PM (#18471945)
While I believe they receive some kind of coating, Weber themselves refer frequently to them being cast iron.

From their site, “how to care for your cast iron cooking grates”. Quoting Weber’s website, “All our 2017 gas grills except for the Summit and Genesis II LX come with porcelain enameled cast iron cooking grates.”. The spec sheet on the site for virtually every gas grill lists a cast iron grate.

https://www.weber.com/US/en/blog/tips-techniques/how-to-care...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by dragonwriter on Friday November 16, 2018 @08:36PM (#18473369)
Oh, Weber gas grills. When you said all Weber grills, I thought of and only checked their charcoal grills, the round charcoal grill being their iconic product.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by schwabacher on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:30PM (#18461279)
Slate and ceramic tile roofs are good options - they are not combustable and will not melt. I'm not sure they would hold up to a 15 meter log landing on them, but they really do reduce the chance of your house burning.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by dbcurtis on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:43PM (#18461398)
Yes, true. Slate is not common in the west. Tile is, although I think faux-tile is getting common.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by jjoonathan on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:43PM (#18463684)
Highly flammable polymer faux-tile or somewhat-fire-resistant fiberglass faux-tile?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by jacobush on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:16PM (#18463983)
Fiberglass faux-tile sounds like "polymer with a nice wick embedded in it".
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Cthulhu_ on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:46AM (#18459570)
> A house can be thirty feet from an entire forest on fire and never burn down.

That test in Canada seems to have been done under pretty much zero wind conditions though; the California ones (as also mentioned in the article) deal with high winds as well.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by fouc on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:52AM (#18460199)
The linked article mentions a 100 feet buffer zone, perhaps to take that into account.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by asah on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:34AM (#18460635)
These does are affecting urban areas of California, not just wilderness.

100 feet of urban California real estate costs substantially more than the house - houses are often built right up to the property line, and lots are measured in sqft, not acres.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by nostrademons on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:38PM (#18461949)
The article mentions that as a problem.

Dense urban areas have a compensating advantage, though: it's much more economically efficient to set up a firebreak and prevent the fire from reaching 100,000 residents in a densely-packed neighborhood, than it is to set up a perimeter around the one wealthy person's home built in the middle of the forest.

The article seems to be suggest (but doesn't explicitly state) a policy like this: "Use public resources to provide a fire protection around the urban growth boundary of major cities, but if you're a homeowner outside that boundary, you're on your own. Design your structure to survive a fire in the surrounding wilderness. We won't suppress fires within the wilderness anymore." In other words, instead of shooting for containment, where the firefighters attempt to control the size of the fire and eventually put it out, they just let the wilderness burn periodically and protect habitation. The added benefit of this is that once the brush is cleared out, future wildfires will be less strong, since there's less fuel.

Also makes sense in economic free-market terms, where public resources are used only when they can defend many properties at much lower cost than the property owners defending them themselves, and property owners who are not situated to benefit from these efficiencies of scale are responsible for defending their own property.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kbenson on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:11PM (#18462240)
Just about every street plus sidewalks is well over 30 feet. The question is whether there is shrubbery or trees at the edge of the street that provides a much shorter path between homes.

My home was built in a new division 2014, and it requires low maintenance front yards (all wood chips and plants/shrubs), and came with a young tree in the front yard and young trees planted on the other side of the sidewalk easement, so eventually it will be very easy for a fire to spread. I live in Santa Rosa.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by gnud on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:37PM (#18461946)
Presumably, if space is that expensive, there's not vegetation next to your house, but another house.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by labster on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:18PM (#18462307)
100 feet is not enough in Santa Ana wind events, as I've seen homes half a mile from the fire line burn to the ground. I'd recommend clearing at least 3000 feet in Southern California.

The only way to do this, of course is not to live on the urban-wildland interface, but to live behind agricultural fields. Or do like Pepperdine in Malibu and water the world's largest lawn.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by fouc on Friday November 16, 2018 @03:47AM (#18467449)
Think about it like an electromagnetic field, where the probability of the house getting burned drops rapidly, inversely proportional to the square of the distance. So 30 feet is the minimum, 100 feet is even better, etc.

If you read the article, the issue was embers floating the air and gathering on roofs and parts of the house that are not resistant to flames. So that's why the material has to be changed too, it's not about distance.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by microcolonel on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:14AM (#18459834)
Add in some sort of tarp, maybe. If you don't have whole rows of houses on fire at the same time, you can actually fight those fires.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by athenot on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:16AM (#18458986)
That's the same problem in the South East with tornadoes. They happen nearly every week (in summer) and can destroy neighborhoods. Yet we build lightweight framed houses and rely on insurance because the overall odds are low.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by danielvf on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:24AM (#18459025)
I agree with your general point.

Though we are talking many, many orders of magnitude less damage from tornadoes in the Southeast when compared with California forrest fires. My state gets an average of 20 per year, and almost all of these hit uninhabited areas. If a tornado destroys four houses, it makes state news.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by js2 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:33AM (#18460008)
A better comparison is hurricane prone locations. After Hurricane Andrew in 1994, Florida conpletely revised its building codes to require homes to withstand a major hurricane.

It’s possible to build a home on the beach to even withstand a catastrophic hurricane, but at possibly double the construction cost.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/14/us/hurricane-michael-flor...

I recall after there were bad fires in the Everglades many years ago there had been some work to build a foam that could be sprayed on a home to protect it in advance of an approaching fire. I think the person who came up with the idea was inspired by the amount of liquid diapers can hold. I wonder what came of that.

Edit: http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2006/jul/19/gel-inspired-by...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Klathmon on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:29AM (#18460576)
I know some people in South Carolina whose beach house (on stilts and everything) withstood Irma just fine, however it had to be demolished because the beach had eroded enough that it was basically over the ocean now, and it was infeasible for them to dump enough sand there to have it be over dry land again.

It's absolutely possible to build solid safe housing from most natural disasters, but it costs money, and often a lot of it.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by cortesoft on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:23AM (#18460523)
I mean, are we sure that isn’t the right choice? Depending on the difference in cost and probabilities, it might make economic sense to act this way.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by neilc on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:36AM (#18460655)
"Insurance policies for extreme weather-related losses -- especially for floods and for coastal wind damage associated with hurricanes -- are not priced to reflect the real risk ... as a result of government intervention in property insurance markets, through either rate regulation or direct government provision of subsidized insurance, private markets no longer generate price signals regarding the cost of living in severe-weather regions."

https://repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by pixl97 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:45PM (#18462020)
Tornadoes are rather improbable at any one particular spot. Wildfire occurs at regular intervals.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by rconti on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:50PM (#18462061)
Pretty much every wildfire I remember since I moved to CA has happened in a place that hasn't burned before. I'm not sure your theory holds up. In particular, because a truly burnt-out area is VERY unlikely to burn again any time soon.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by pixl97 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:09PM (#18466022)
This is why we use data and not your memory.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by iambateman on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:02AM (#18459262)
That 99PI episode was one of their best. The image of a mudslide happening because of denuded mountains was terrifying.

I’m reading antifragile right now and he’s talking about systems which improve with a certain amount of volatility and stress. It seems forests are “antifragile” on their own, and our efforts may in fact introduce fragility.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by curiousgal on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:21AM (#18459383)
>I’m reading antifragile right now

I commend you for that, I just find his writing style to be so annoying that I can't even finish reading a simple article of his.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by iambateman on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:11AM (#18460399)
Totally agree. I lived with a guy from the Middle East for several years, and it actually helps to imagine his voice when I read Taleb.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by claytoneast on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:40AM (#18460076)
His books are less grating than his short pieces.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by stouset on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:06AM (#18460337)
They really aren’t.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by raesene9 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:56AM (#18460233)
I live near the Rest and be Thankful in Scotland, we know all about land/mudslides due to deforestation :) The hillside above the road has no trees and there are regular landslides that'll close the road (which is the main road into the west of scotland) for a week at a time.

After spending millions on nets and ditches, they've lodged a plan to replant trees above the road...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by gowld on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:07AM (#18459766)
Seems obvious that if you expose a system to stress, whatever survives will be stress-proof; while if you hide stress from a system, it's a disaster waiting to happen. Same story with allergy immunities and used cars.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by darkerside on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:47AM (#18460793)
What's the used cars example?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by jonathankoren on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:04PM (#18461013)
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by darkerside on Friday November 16, 2018 @06:58AM (#18468150)
I'm sure that's partly true, but it doesn't seem to account for the lack of alternatives to selling a used car. A car offers no utility, and yet continues to depreciate, sitting in the garage. Assuming you want or need to participate in buying/selling a car for life reasons (growing family, moving houses, or moving upmarket into just vehicles), how else do you class back any value from this asset? Other alternatives (donation, trade-in) aren't going to get you even lemon prices in return.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by jonathankoren on Friday November 16, 2018 @06:52PM (#18472924)
I don’t understand. If you sell the car, you get money which has the maximum utility, because you can trade it for other things. Donating and trading are essentially selling, so what would an alternative that provides positive utility look like?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by darkerside on Sunday November 18, 2018 @12:38AM (#18479021)
They are alternatives to selling, but you typically receive less money than you would in a straight sale. I think I'm asking the same question as you.

> Given the fixed price at which buyers will buy, sellers will sell only when they hold "lemons" (since plemon < pavg) and they will leave the market when they hold "peaches" (since ppeach > pavg).

My point is that this is a highly idealized and theoretical model. Life doesn't work this way.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by jonathankoren on Monday November 19, 2018 @01:57AM (#18484607)
I would argue that the alternatives you've listed (e.g. donation), are functionally equivalent to selling. You're trading a good (the car), for money.

> My point is that this is a highly idealized and theoretical model. Life doesn't work this way.

Such is every nonbehavioral economics paper ever written.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by darkerside on Tuesday November 20, 2018 @12:01PM (#18495364)
You're missing my point. Those alternatives typically provide you LESS money than selling. How are people supposedly "leaving" the market? Parking an unused car on the street?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by tlrobinson on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:18PM (#18461762)
Some new housing developments in wildland-urban interfaces are built and maintained such that it's considered safer to "shelter-in-place" than evacuate in some circumstances.

Here's a document explaining Rancho Santa Fe's approach (PDF): https://www.rsf-fire.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/SIP_for_...

Some of the requirements:

* Boxed or Heavy Timber Eaves

* Non‐Combustible (Class‐A) Roofing

* Fire Sprinklers

* Ember‐Resistant Vents

* Landscaping

* Roadway Width

* Defensible Space

* Spark Arrestors

* Tempered Windows

* Water Supply

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by londons_explore on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:49PM (#18464656)
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:32AM (#18459459)
The article doesn't mention it, but controlled burns are actually a regular occurrence in the east and southeast US. I always assumed it was some decision by the Californian state government to not do so. The rest of the country is not stuck in the mindset described in the article.

Fires are necessary for ecological reasons. You can either start them on purpose and control them, or you can wait until they happen anyway and watch them get totally out of control.

Exacerbating the situation, I heard on NPR this morning that some POAs in California forbid cutting down trees on your property. Something has to change. Even if you put a complete stop to human-caused fires somehow (not possible) and stop climate change tomorrow, you will still have fires from lightning strikes, etc. You can either thin forests and underbrush (incredibly labor intensive) or you can have controlled burns.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by sgc on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:55AM (#18459657)
I have not heard of extensive controlled burns in any western state. It is just too large and the forests here burn too hot and fast in terrain that is too rugged. Of course there are some controlled burns in California and other states, but the large scale burns required are not practical by any measure. California is considered to have one of the most advanced firefighting forces in the world. They inform the fire control decisions, and know the importance of controlled burns. Maybe it is just a tougher nut to crack rather than assumed incompetence?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kyleblarson on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:08PM (#18461671)
I live in Mazama in the Methow Valley in North Central Washington and we have had fairly extensive thinning and prescribed burns in the last few years: https://www.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=021ff...

edit: We also had a Firewise grant over the last few years to provide free thinning on private property.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:01AM (#18459714)
> I have not heard of extensive controlled burns in any western state. It is just too large and the forests here burn too hot and fast

...Because of the lack of controlled burns combined with weather conditions.

California is not larger than the eastern US. We do very large controlled burns here in rugged terrain. As far as I can see, it's a lack of political will and funding, combined with the reality that it's gone so long that its much more difficult than it should be. There are a few prescribed burns done in California, they're just not anywhere near the necessary scale.

California can either bite the bullet now and dramatically increase the number and area of controlled burns, or watch as things get worse and worse. There is no alternative. I'll repeat again: fires are a natural part of the ecology, with or without human intervention. You can either do it yourself and lessen the impact, or wait for nature to do it and have regular disasters.

EDIT: Just to get a sense of scale, the southeast burns eight million acres in prescribed burns annually. The west burns about three million. California looks to be only in the tens of thousands. The Camp fire has burned approximately 138,000 acres at the last report I can find.

http://www.stateforesters.org/sites/default/files/publicatio...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by romed on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:13AM (#18459822)
Vast majority of California’s forests are fossils. If you burn them they don’t grow back, you get something else. Climate change is reducing the length of the rainy season, worsening summer droughts, expanding the range of bark beetles, and moving snow lines uphill. Under these conditions our existing forests can survive but not become established.

You discuss this issue as if there is some steady-state solution that can be applied. This is not the case. The climate is in now in transition from one state to another, much warmer and drier state. Controlled burns are difficult or impossible to apply under such a transition, with the number of dead standing trees (hundreds of millions in California) and the unprecedented soil moisture levels and evaporative load.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:20AM (#18459888)
First of all, California already expects to (insufficiently) increase their insufficiently small number of prescribed burns.

https://www.arb.ca.gov/smp/progdev/pubeduc/pbfs.pdf

Secondly, if that is what you believe, then the solution is to burn now, not later. You cannot save forests already damned by climate change, and the longer you wait, the worse it will be.

> Vast majority of California’s forests are fossils. If you burn them they don’t grow back, you get something else.

Then how did they get there in the first place? Human-started fires have been a normal and natural part of California's ecology for thousands of years. Waiting for the weather to get even warmer and drier will just result in more forest being destroyed, more homes being burned, more people dying, because there will be fires, no matter what you do. You can choose to limit their fuel now and save some forest, or you let natural fires have more fuel and burn even hotter and wider and lose all your forest.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by danans on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:01AM (#18460287)
> Then how did they get there in the first place?

Presumably they established themselves when climate conditions were different than today.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:11AM (#18460398)
The climate conditions of today are not dramatically different from those historically. There have been many, and much longer, dry periods throughout the past few thousand years. In fact, the past century has been unusually wet.

> Stine, who has spent decades studying tree stumps in Mono Lake, Tenaya Lake, the Walker River and other parts of the Sierra Nevada, said that the past century has been among the wettest of the last 7,000 years.

https://www.mercurynews.com/2014/01/25/california-drought-pa...

Fires have similarly been a natural part of the ecology for thousands of years.

What's new is not very dry conditions or fires. What's new is the California fire management over the past century or so. The biggest different climate condition isn't the weather, it's the lack of regular fires burning up fuel. Now, tons of fire-fuel has accumulated and fires burn hotter than normal. But there is no way to solve this other than by ripping off the band-aid now. If you don't, things get worse.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by danans on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:35PM (#18461917)
> What's new is not very dry conditions or fires. What's new is the California fire management over the past century or so.

Sounds like you don't accept that climate change is exacerbating these fires. As others have noted, average and historical rainfall isn't a direct indication of fire risk.

London [1] has the same annual rainfall (23") as San Francisco, but they have very different fire risks.

Timing of the rainfall and other weather events matters a lot more when it comes to particular events - and the ever later onset of rains in CA is a big factor.

Even then, the fire management practices you point out are in part a response to increasing populations near fire-prone areas. People expect fires near their homes to be suppressed. Unless we stop building homes in such areas, or build fireproof homes, that demand isn't going to go away.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_of_London

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco#Climate

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:19PM (#18462328)
Climate change is absolutely exacerbating these conditions, just as climate change in the past exacerbated these conditions. The climate is not regular in the absence of modern human activity. The timing and amount of rainfall have varied throughout history.

These dry conditions are not abnormal when looking at any longer timeframes. The severity of the fires is abnormal, but only because both humans and nature were regularly setting fires and letting them burn until they burnt out for many, many thousands of years. Only recently did mankind intervene in the natural ecology by stopping fires.

> People expect fires near their homes to be suppressed.

Then they will have to readjust their expectations. I would also say they should pay attention to the Cal Fire messaging about the necessity of fires. ( http://www.calfire.ca.gov/communications/downloads/live_w_fi... )In the rest of the country, we have prescribed fires even in and near residential areas. Clearly they must be managed more carefully now that Californians have allowed the situation to get so bad (e.g., fires started in wetter conditions which won't burn enough, followed by a second fire in drier conditions), but they are the only thing short of everyone leaving that can resolve the situation.

I'm not sure why Californians believe they are special and different. People in this thread keep citing terrain (mountainous areas are burned in the rest of the country), wind (the highest-wind states are actually those with the most controlled burns according to the wind map posted and the forestry website I linked), dryness (not out of historical norms, just recent history.)

Human-driven climate change is a factor, but what we're seeing is Californian climate returning to recent (in a relative sense) historical norms, not some kind of incipient Armageddon. We're not seeing something that's never been seen before. Again, the entirely dominant factor is the insufficient amount of prescribed burns.

Regardless of the cause, the only long-term solution is more controlled burns. The climate is going to get drier and hotter. Fires will happen. There is absolutely nothing you can do to prevent this. Even if you waved a magic wand and took fire away from mankind, fires still occur naturally. The longer you wait, the more dry fuel you accumulate and the worse the fires will be. It might hurt in the short term, some houses may indeed be destroyed in controlled burns (it happens elsewhere, too), but the alternative is more houses burned and more ecological destruction and more people dead. You cannot get around this.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by danans on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:25PM (#18463512)
I think we're basically in agreement, although I don't think the issue is about California's thinking they are different. California just has large populations in fire-prone areas.

There is a significant risk in building in these areas, exacerbated by all the aforementioned factors. This will probably be accounted for in insurance rates going forward, which will hopeful deter people from building flammable houses in wildfire zones.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by twtw on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:34AM (#18460629)
Another thing that is new is that the rainy season in CA is starting later, such that the winds come before the rain.

Paradise is a wet place that gets quite a bit of rain - what matters is that it is coming too late.

For this reason, I don't think it is very relevant that the last century has been the wettest in awhile.

That said, there are likely many factors involved, and it is probably not super useful to point at one thing and ignore all the rest.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by romed on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:43PM (#18461409)
Weather in the Mono basin is irrelevant to conditions in the Feather River canyon. California, it turns out, is a large state with multiple distinct climate zones. As you note, it is the length of the summer drought which is increasing. This is not even contradictory with increasing or stable annual precipitation. It just means more of the water is coming in a shorter, rainier season.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by ip26 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:35AM (#18460029)
Colorado does controlled burns in the prairie, and burns forest slash piles in winter.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kryogen1c on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:12AM (#18459820)
> The article doesn't mention it, but controlled burns are actually a regular occurrence in the east and southeast US. I always assumed it was some decision by the Californian state government to not do so.

Wait what? California doesn't do controlled burns?

Mother of God: https://www.quora.com/Why-does-California-not-institute-a-co...

I find this _unfathomable_. I'm from a desert state where during dry times it was illegal to light fires and we absolutely did controlled burns.

California's plan is to let everything burn down and then blame a utility (true or not is irrelevant) and try to collect $20B they definitely don't have? This is unbelievable.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by gamblor956 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:42AM (#18460739)
California has millions of dry, dead trees owing to a bark beetle infestation and multiple, 100-degree+ heat waves. Do you know how hot that wood burns? More than a few trees together, and it burns hot enough to spontaneously combust trees up to a few dozen feet away. Without wind. California's forests are dense. They're dense enough that fires, even controlled burns, can and have generate firestorms--where the heat of the fire generates its own atmospheric wind system that feeds the fire.

Do you know what sort of embers these sorts of fires generate? The kind that fly hundreds of feet, retaining enough heat to light structures on fire when they land. Take a look at the shots of the Malibu portion of the Hill/Woolsey fire: there are structures that burned almost a quarter of a mile away from the closest flora.

So the reason that California cut back on controlled burns? Because due to the factors described above, controlled burns very quickly become massive, uncontrolled conflagrations. Controlled burns are something you can do when the trees and climate is relatively wet, since only the stuff you set on fire burns, or where flora is far enough apart and weather patterns mild enough that the fire can't spread on its own.

But you know what's really unbelievable? Someone who doesn't know diddly squat about what they're talking about who thinks they know better than the people who actually have to deal with this on a regular basis.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kryogen1c on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:37PM (#18461940)
> So the reason that California cut back on controlled burns? Because due to the factors described above, controlled burns very quickly become massive, uncontrolled conflagrations.

Yeah what a disaster a massive, uncontrolled burn would be.

> But you know what's really unbelievable? Someone who doesn't know diddly squat about what they're talking about who thinks they know better than the people who actually have to deal with this on a regular basis.

Your righteous indignation falls pretty flat when there is plain evidence that they are doing a bad job. Here is a list of the 20 largest CA fires https://www.fire.ca.gov/communications/downloads/fact_sheets... 19 are from the last 50 years, 16 in the last 20. How many more hundreds of thousands of acres have to burn before the approach is changed?

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:02PM (#18461595)
Let's assume everything in this comment is perfectly true. The past century has been unusually wet in California. Your choice is to burn now, or burn later when its even drier and hotter.

Meanwhile, California apparently agrees with hs, because they plan on increasing the number of prescribed burns.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by sp332 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:30AM (#18460588)
Snark218 over on Ars Technica claims to be involved in land management decisions, and has some details about why it's not feasible across the state. E.g. https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/11/what-is-going-on-wit...

And like I keep saying: these fires are not burning in forests. They are burning in suburbs, exurbs, and dense residential areas. In towns. Up steep canyons that are treacherous to hike up, let alone tote a pulaski and mattock. In many of the pictures, it's obvious that trees are damaged but survive. It's shrubs, grasses, brush, and chaparral that's burning.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/11/what-is-going-on-wit...

I mean, yeah, we can intensively thin and manage forests to protect high-value, critical areas. We can encourage landowners to pursue defensible space treatments, and maybe save their home, if not their neighbors'. But honestly, I don't see any practicable way to prevent fires like the Camp Fire. Or the Thomas. Or Carr and Mendocino and Ferguson and County and Delta and Hirz and the other 7,579 fires that have burned in California this season. I wish I could claim otherwise.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:35AM (#18460642)
All I can say to that is in the southeast we do prescribed burns even in residential areas, and even in rough terrain.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by gamblor956 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:44AM (#18460769)
All I can say is that in the southeast, your trees are wet, and controlled burns do not burn far past the controlled area.

In California, everything is dry enough that even a tiny ember escaping the burn area can turn a controlled burn into a massive fire. In fact, excluding the massive fires of the past 3 years, some of California's biggest blazes were controlled burns that got out of control.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by twtw on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:04AM (#18460314)
> I find this _unfathomable_. I'm from a desert state where during dry times it was illegal to light fires and we absolutely did controlled burns.

Many of the answers on that quora link seem to indicate that ca does in fact do controlled burns?

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kryogen1c on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:25AM (#18460541)
Some of the comments indicate they try to burn as much as they can. The ambivalent, uncertain language is a sign the game is already lost. If you ask you car mechanic if the lugs on your tire are tight, the answer is yes; the answer is not some lugs are federally owned so we did the best we could.

This is a serious public safety issue which if left alone is guaranteed to end in widespread death and destruction.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Johnny555 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:38PM (#18463049)
I think it's more like if you ask your neighborhood mechanic to inspect the brake system, and he said "I inspected everything I could, but the master cylinder is leaking and sealed and only the dealer has the tools and knowledge to open it up" so you have to go to the dealer.

California shouldn't be expected to maintain forests on someone else's property.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by zgramana on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:50AM (#18460836)
If you live on the East Coast then you take the wind for granted. On the Pacific Coast, the winds blow fast and furious, especially as you go up in altitude. Its very hard to control a burn here on most days, especially given the water cycle here. There is vastly more fuel in October and November than earlier in the year as the last rains are about 6 months past.

Controlled burns are probably done best during a short 1-2 month window when ground cover is dry enough, but those are also typically high wind months. To have any control of a burn here you need to be lucky (low winds for a few days), it needs to be a very small prescribed area, and probably needs to be at less than peak fuel.

This all amounts to a very small window for doing a prescribed burn. Given how big many of the forests are, and how much of the state is covered with them, I don’t see how you can have much of any control over a prescribed fire started there.

Certainly not without the heroic effort it takes to put out wildfires. I don’t know how we can ask firefighters to risk their life for a prescribed burn.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by sharkmerry on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:22PM (#18461800)
the winds look slightly worse on the west coast, but not to a degree that they cant be doing burns like on the east coast

https://windexchange.energy.gov/maps-data/325

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by zgramana on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:33PM (#18517783)
The problem with that map is that the annual average obscures the wide seasonal variation, which was the main thrust of my comment. The high winds come during the dry season, then die down during the bulk of the wet season.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by s0rce on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:41AM (#18460718)
Yah, I'm not sure where that information is from, I've run into controlled burns frequently in the Sierra. I called the FD once in South Lake Tahoe as I hiked right up to the fire but missed the signage on the road.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by jartelt on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:48PM (#18464648)
Many of forests in California are National Forest land controlled by the federal government. The Californian State Government is not able to go do prescribed burns in the National Forest. A lot of your beef should be with the National Forest Service.

Also, the recent drought is really exacerbating things. A lot of the trees in the forests are dead now and are just waiting to burn. Yes, we should remove some of this dead wood and thin the forests, but this will be a huge task given the large amount of forest.

As far as POAs and local laws... I am sure some of then are overreaching on things. But, some of them also protect areas from legitimate threats. Many people would gladly cut down all the trees on their property around Lake Tahoe so they can have an unobstructed view. Pretty soon we would have no trees around the lake and the landscape would be drastically changed. Some degree of protection is warranted in places.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by briandear on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:58PM (#18461558)
> that some POAs in California forbid cutting down trees on your property.

https://www.sonomacountygazette.com/cms/pages/sonoma-county-...

This article gives a sense of the actual nonsense a homeowner must endure to cut down a tree. It might sound good to some people on paper, but I can feel the frustration of following such an expensive, bureaucratic process just to cut a tree in your own land. That entire process sounds ridiculous when looking at the aftermath of one of these fires such as the Camp or Malibu fires. The environmentalists responsible for such tripe should be made to work with a fire crew for a single hour to see the consequences of their horrid, naïve and completely ignorant policies.

Here is the money paragraph:

“What does Cal-Fire consider to approve a plan?

Basically, they want to make sure that trees are removed in a way that does the least amount of harm to wildlife habitat, that diversity of plant life is maintained, shade and sun balanced for a particular environment, and watersheds and watercourses are disturbed the least amount possible.

For instance, if protected species are in the area, then either the work is not done, or it is postponed during mating and rearing stages. If trees are removed on a hillside, then potential erosion is part of what is considered, monitored and controlled. There are many factors, and they all need to be taken into consideration.”

Sorry, but Cal-Fire should be concerned about preventing fires first. There are protected species everywhere; so delaying fire prevention forestry so some salamander can do whatever it is salamanders do; that’s just ridiculous. Over 17,000 acres of “protected” stuff just burned up in Paradise, California, so perhaps tripping over a dollar to pick up a nickel doesn’t make the best sense for either the environment or people.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by vkou on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:34PM (#18463011)
> If trees are removed on a hillside, then potential erosion is part of what is considered, monitored and controlled. There are many factors, and they all need to be taken into consideration.”

> Sorry, but Cal-Fire should be concerned about preventing fires first.

I'm sorry, but soil erosion is not some boogieman invented by pot-smoking hippies who live in a commune. It's a real and serious problem, and leads to landslides, wash-outs, loss of topsoil, loss of other trees (Which often act as windbreaks).

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by nradov on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:11AM (#18460400)
The building code for high risk fire areas should require roof top sprinkler systems. Those exist but haven't been widely installed. Keeping the roof and exterior walls wet is usually sufficient to keep a building from catching on fire unless the fire is very close and hot.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by s0rce on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:38AM (#18460682)
The house I rent part of has sprinklers on the roof. The owner installed them after the 91 Oakland Hills fire (we're just down the hill a little from the edge of that fire), as a newcomer to California this was somewhat frightening, but seems like a good precaution. Depending on where your water pipes are and how big your house it it doesn't seem like a huge project.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by ivalm on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:51PM (#18461481)
Isn't part of the problem that the water pressure (if everyone turns these one) is bad which hinders firefighters when they need to tap the water supply to fight fires. They specifically ask people to turn off sprinklers/water hoses/other water use cases before evacuating.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by mattlondon on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:30PM (#18461871)
I recently read something (cant find the link, sorry) about having a generator and pump on-site, and then pumping water from your swimming pool to your sprinklers. I suppose not everyone has a pool, but collecting rainwater etc in an underground sump could be sufficient.

You could even imagine a closed-system that collects rain/sprinkler water from the roof guttering and drains around the property and channelling them into the pool/sump. You'd lose a lot of water to evaporation/steam in a fire I guess, but it could buy you some time.

The other alternative I guess is just dont build your house out of combustible materials. I guess some stuff might just melt in hot-enough conditions, but by that stage where ceramics and metals are just melting in ambient temperatures I think its pretty much a game-over situation regardless... but before that extreme you can probably get a lot of mileabe by building your houses out of brick (there seems to be a lot of brick foundations left in the footage I am seeing on TV)

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 20, 2018 @01:23PM (#18496231)
> but before that extreme you can probably get a lot of mileabe by building your houses out of brick (there seems to be a lot of brick foundations left in the footage I am seeing on TV)

Brick construction itself is seismically unsound, which makes it a bad choice for California. You can use brick cladding to make a building more fire resistant, though, but this isn't a panacea.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by rconti on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:51PM (#18462066)
I'd say very few people, relatively speaking, have pools in CA.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Domenic_S on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:53PM (#18462697)
California has the most residential pools of all the states - over 1.5 million inground and aboveground units.

PDF warning: http://www.apsp.org/Portals/0/2016%20Website%20Changes/2015%...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by makr17 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:32PM (#18464101)
Well, yes. But California _also_ has the highest population of the states.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_states_and_territories...

Might be more fruitful to look at a per-capita metric?

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Domenic_S on Thursday November 15, 2018 @07:42PM (#18465093)
Imagine a state that has only two houses, both with a pool. 3 people live in one house, 1 person lives in the other. That’s 0.5 pools per capita, but for our purposes is a sufficient number of pools - 1 pool per structure.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by rconti on Tuesday November 20, 2018 @01:13PM (#18496109)
So, we're in the low double-digits in terms of percentage? Seems like relatively few.

As in, it's not uncommon to live here and not know anyone with a pool.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by lozaning on Thursday November 15, 2018 @05:33PM (#18464110)
Silly metric though. We have the most people/homes so of course we have the most pools. Arizona kicks our ass in the number of pools per person though.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by idontpost on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:31PM (#18464513)
Depends on the neighborhood. They're fairly common in upper-middle class or nicer neighborhoods.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 20, 2018 @01:25PM (#18496242)
Upper-middle-class or nicer neighborhoods are a fairly small share of all neighborhoods.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by briandear on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:38PM (#18461361)
Not these current California fires. Anyone who thinks sprinklers will help hasn’t seen this hell-fire inferno up close. The Camp Fire was spreading at up to 80 acres per minute. It grew to 17,000 acres in 5 hours.

High risk fire areas should be made lower risk by proper forest management — forest management that has been ridiculously incompetent in California for a long time.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by rblatz on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:35PM (#18461921)
I've suddenly started hearing the assertion that forest management is incompetent. But I've not really heard any details as to what is actually wrong and what should be done. Can you please elaborate?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by nostrademons on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:43PM (#18462005)
The other weird part about this assertion is that forests in which the Camp Fire started are federal land (Plumas National Forest), under the responsibility of the Forest Service. So while it's entirely possible that forest management in California has been incompetent, that responsibility lies on the federal government.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by manigandham on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:17PM (#18462882)
The general idea is that there can and should be more done.

Lots of open space that builds up vegetation and then dries out, turning into perfect fuel for a fire. Cutting these shrubs, creating firebreaks, and doing controlled burns would at least create much more manageable zones if a wildfire does start.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by nradov on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:43PM (#18463098)
Please be specific. What exactly can and should be done? Clearing brush is labor intensive and expensive. Who will pay for it? Controlled burns are difficult to manage in many parts of the state; there are often no fire breaks so a slight shift in the wind can quickly turn controlled into uncontrolled.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by manigandham on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:54PM (#18463204)
That is specific: create firebreaks and remove brush. That alone would drastically limit fire spread and damage. Controlled burns are hard but certainly not impossible, and can be done in colder seasons as weather and wind are predictable.

Taxpayers are already paying for it, and the state has plenty of labor. The prison system alone runs many firecrews that can engage in this work. Compared to fighting fires and rebuilding damage, the maintenance cost is trivial.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by gowld on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:05AM (#18459750)
If an individual house can fireproof itself, than it should fall out of insurance rather easily -- if you want to save $1000/yr or something on home insurance, build to the insurance code, or declare that you are happy paying a higher insurance rate.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by ortusdux on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:17AM (#18459863)
Great episode. I talked to a friend that is an environmental scientist/forester about it. She is doing more and more fire risk surveys for homeowners. She said their portrayal of the situation was very accurate.

Another relevant podcast episode is this one from planet money:

https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/02/16/586600540/epis...

They explore wildfire investigations and the legal fallout. It is a great explanation of why PG&E's stock lost 1/3 of its value.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by onetimemanytime on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:18AM (#18459870)
>>A house can be thirty feet from an entire forest on fire and never burn down. We learned this through hardcore experiments in Canada where they built homes to test and lit forests on fire nearby.

Fires in CA apparently went as high as 300 feet (~100m) so no, that would not have helped. Heat alone, with zero wind would probably melt everything with xx meters. If they want to build, don't build in forests or clean out a zone and build a 50-100m buffer. If it was not burned today, it will be burned tomorrow.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by nostrademons on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:54PM (#18462095)
Air is a ridiculously bad thermal conductor - it's thermal conductivity is 0.024 W/mK, so to deliver the same heat flux as a 100W light bulb through a meter of still air would require a temperature difference of about 4000 K. Most heat transfer through air occurs through convection (wind). Even then, if you can keep a 5 foot buffer zone of still air between combustible material and the raging inferno, you're fine. This is how you see pictures of scientists standing 5 feet away from a moving lava flow.

As the article states, though, it really is all about the embers. If you keep burning material from landing on other combustible material, fire is not going to start. That's why it suggests using non-combustible materials for roofing, avoiding areas where embers can catch, and keeping treetops away from structures.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by nkurz on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:36PM (#18466166)
While you are right that conduction is not really a problem, and right that embers are really important, it's worth mentioning that radiation from a fire can also be a significant source of ignition. And a large "flame front" can ignite structures from surprisingly large distances!

I haven't read whole article yet, but here's an abstract:

Residential losses associated with wildland fires have become a serious international fire protection problem. The radiant heat flux from burning vegetation adjacent to a structure is a principal ignition factor. A thermal radiation and ignition model estimated structure ignition potential using designated flame characteristics (inferred from various types and densities of vegetation) and flame- to-structure distances. Model results indicate that ignitions from flame radiation are unlikely to occur from burning vegetation beyond 40 meters of a structure. Thinning vegetation within 40 meters has a significant ignition mitigation effect.

https://www.fs.fed.us/rm/pubs_other/rmrs_1998_cohen_j001.pdf

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by fouc on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:49AM (#18460177)
Height doesn't necessarily imply width. The linked article does mention a 100 feet buffer zone.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by onetimemanytime on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:00AM (#18460272)
width or not means that there's a LOT of material to be burned and to collapse into the next lot. I've burned wheat fields after 90% of straw was removed and I can tell you that in certain days it rises to 10 feet and you cannot stay close to it, it's unbearable. Not necessarily flames but heat, that barely visible thing. A week later you see trees 20 feet away with burned leaves. The other thing you learn when you clean canals and lots is that fire is unpredictable. Very.

Now imagine real forests with underbrush and 150 feet tall trees.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by crazynick4 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:21AM (#18460505)
I didn't notice anyone mention shipping container homes. If built with fireproofing in mind (ie the builder refrains from adding any flammable materials to the outside walls), I'd imagine they'd be fairly impervious by default.

Granted, they're not very pretty 'by default' (although they can be made so and still remain flame-proof) but as far as practicality/value/safety goes, that is what I would do if I was buying/building a home in a place like CA.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by skybrian on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:00PM (#18462765)
I'm not sure what "fairly impervious" means but this article looks interesting:

“We know from the experience of the 2009 Victorian bushfires that some people did perish in what they thought were bushfire shelters that they’d built themselves. Whether it was secondary to a wine cellar or it was some sort of building container, shipping container, they died. And it wasn’t necessarily they died because of fire; they suffocated. The oxygen was extracted out of the bunker because it wasn’t air-tight or the heat essentially killed them.”

https://www.gatewaycontainersales.com.au/shipping-containers...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Pinckney on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:47PM (#18463724)
Right, you would definitely want some oxygen candles if you were trying to hunker down and ride out a fire.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_oxygen_generator

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by crazynick4 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:18PM (#18462886)
Right, I should have been more specific, you definitely wouldn't want to stay inside if there is a fire outside in hopes that it will insulate you, the containers are definitely not air tight.

What I meant is that the interior of the house would have been protected from burning up, so any inanimate things inside would have been safe.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by dbetteridge on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:14AM (#18459326)
See also

http://www.as3959.com.au

And the australian BAL standard for bushfire rating houses

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by roel_v on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:38AM (#18459506)
I'm working in an Australian research project (for the Bushfires Crown Research Center) in which we're modeling risk, from bushfires but also earthquakes and flooding, using (amongst others) upgrading BAL levels as an intervention option. It's incredible how little is known about bushfire modeling at scales that are relevant for policy making, our work is met with a a lot of interest at e.g. firefighter's conferences.

The crux of the issue is though (from a policy perspective) that defending against low recurrance interval events is most cost effectively done by restrictive zoning, which is (politically) a very hard sell. Observed preference is that people actually prefer band aids over real solutions. It's a hard problem.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by abandonliberty on Friday November 16, 2018 @02:52AM (#18467254)
Trees are a crop that have a nasty habit of burning. Firefighting is another example of government subsidy for industry.