News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:32AM (#18459459)
The article doesn't mention it, but controlled burns are actually a regular occurrence in the east and southeast US. I always assumed it was some decision by the Californian state government to not do so. The rest of the country is not stuck in the mindset described in the article.

Fires are necessary for ecological reasons. You can either start them on purpose and control them, or you can wait until they happen anyway and watch them get totally out of control.

Exacerbating the situation, I heard on NPR this morning that some POAs in California forbid cutting down trees on your property. Something has to change. Even if you put a complete stop to human-caused fires somehow (not possible) and stop climate change tomorrow, you will still have fires from lightning strikes, etc. You can either thin forests and underbrush (incredibly labor intensive) or you can have controlled burns.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by sgc on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:55AM (#18459657)
I have not heard of extensive controlled burns in any western state. It is just too large and the forests here burn too hot and fast in terrain that is too rugged. Of course there are some controlled burns in California and other states, but the large scale burns required are not practical by any measure. California is considered to have one of the most advanced firefighting forces in the world. They inform the fire control decisions, and know the importance of controlled burns. Maybe it is just a tougher nut to crack rather than assumed incompetence?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kyleblarson on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:08PM (#18461671)
I live in Mazama in the Methow Valley in North Central Washington and we have had fairly extensive thinning and prescribed burns in the last few years: https://www.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=021ff...

edit: We also had a Firewise grant over the last few years to provide free thinning on private property.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:01AM (#18459714)
> I have not heard of extensive controlled burns in any western state. It is just too large and the forests here burn too hot and fast

...Because of the lack of controlled burns combined with weather conditions.

California is not larger than the eastern US. We do very large controlled burns here in rugged terrain. As far as I can see, it's a lack of political will and funding, combined with the reality that it's gone so long that its much more difficult than it should be. There are a few prescribed burns done in California, they're just not anywhere near the necessary scale.

California can either bite the bullet now and dramatically increase the number and area of controlled burns, or watch as things get worse and worse. There is no alternative. I'll repeat again: fires are a natural part of the ecology, with or without human intervention. You can either do it yourself and lessen the impact, or wait for nature to do it and have regular disasters.

EDIT: Just to get a sense of scale, the southeast burns eight million acres in prescribed burns annually. The west burns about three million. California looks to be only in the tens of thousands. The Camp fire has burned approximately 138,000 acres at the last report I can find.

http://www.stateforesters.org/sites/default/files/publicatio...

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by romed on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:13AM (#18459822)
Vast majority of California’s forests are fossils. If you burn them they don’t grow back, you get something else. Climate change is reducing the length of the rainy season, worsening summer droughts, expanding the range of bark beetles, and moving snow lines uphill. Under these conditions our existing forests can survive but not become established.

You discuss this issue as if there is some steady-state solution that can be applied. This is not the case. The climate is in now in transition from one state to another, much warmer and drier state. Controlled burns are difficult or impossible to apply under such a transition, with the number of dead standing trees (hundreds of millions in California) and the unprecedented soil moisture levels and evaporative load.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:20AM (#18459888)
First of all, California already expects to (insufficiently) increase their insufficiently small number of prescribed burns.

https://www.arb.ca.gov/smp/progdev/pubeduc/pbfs.pdf

Secondly, if that is what you believe, then the solution is to burn now, not later. You cannot save forests already damned by climate change, and the longer you wait, the worse it will be.

> Vast majority of California’s forests are fossils. If you burn them they don’t grow back, you get something else.

Then how did they get there in the first place? Human-started fires have been a normal and natural part of California's ecology for thousands of years. Waiting for the weather to get even warmer and drier will just result in more forest being destroyed, more homes being burned, more people dying, because there will be fires, no matter what you do. You can choose to limit their fuel now and save some forest, or you let natural fires have more fuel and burn even hotter and wider and lose all your forest.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by danans on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:01AM (#18460287)
> Then how did they get there in the first place?

Presumably they established themselves when climate conditions were different than today.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:11AM (#18460398)
The climate conditions of today are not dramatically different from those historically. There have been many, and much longer, dry periods throughout the past few thousand years. In fact, the past century has been unusually wet.

> Stine, who has spent decades studying tree stumps in Mono Lake, Tenaya Lake, the Walker River and other parts of the Sierra Nevada, said that the past century has been among the wettest of the last 7,000 years.

https://www.mercurynews.com/2014/01/25/california-drought-pa...

Fires have similarly been a natural part of the ecology for thousands of years.

What's new is not very dry conditions or fires. What's new is the California fire management over the past century or so. The biggest different climate condition isn't the weather, it's the lack of regular fires burning up fuel. Now, tons of fire-fuel has accumulated and fires burn hotter than normal. But there is no way to solve this other than by ripping off the band-aid now. If you don't, things get worse.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by danans on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:35PM (#18461917)
> What's new is not very dry conditions or fires. What's new is the California fire management over the past century or so.

Sounds like you don't accept that climate change is exacerbating these fires. As others have noted, average and historical rainfall isn't a direct indication of fire risk.

London [1] has the same annual rainfall (23") as San Francisco, but they have very different fire risks.

Timing of the rainfall and other weather events matters a lot more when it comes to particular events - and the ever later onset of rains in CA is a big factor.

Even then, the fire management practices you point out are in part a response to increasing populations near fire-prone areas. People expect fires near their homes to be suppressed. Unless we stop building homes in such areas, or build fireproof homes, that demand isn't going to go away.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_of_London

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco#Climate

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @02:19PM (#18462328)
Climate change is absolutely exacerbating these conditions, just as climate change in the past exacerbated these conditions. The climate is not regular in the absence of modern human activity. The timing and amount of rainfall have varied throughout history.

These dry conditions are not abnormal when looking at any longer timeframes. The severity of the fires is abnormal, but only because both humans and nature were regularly setting fires and letting them burn until they burnt out for many, many thousands of years. Only recently did mankind intervene in the natural ecology by stopping fires.

> People expect fires near their homes to be suppressed.

Then they will have to readjust their expectations. I would also say they should pay attention to the Cal Fire messaging about the necessity of fires. ( http://www.calfire.ca.gov/communications/downloads/live_w_fi... )In the rest of the country, we have prescribed fires even in and near residential areas. Clearly they must be managed more carefully now that Californians have allowed the situation to get so bad (e.g., fires started in wetter conditions which won't burn enough, followed by a second fire in drier conditions), but they are the only thing short of everyone leaving that can resolve the situation.

I'm not sure why Californians believe they are special and different. People in this thread keep citing terrain (mountainous areas are burned in the rest of the country), wind (the highest-wind states are actually those with the most controlled burns according to the wind map posted and the forestry website I linked), dryness (not out of historical norms, just recent history.)

Human-driven climate change is a factor, but what we're seeing is Californian climate returning to recent (in a relative sense) historical norms, not some kind of incipient Armageddon. We're not seeing something that's never been seen before. Again, the entirely dominant factor is the insufficient amount of prescribed burns.

Regardless of the cause, the only long-term solution is more controlled burns. The climate is going to get drier and hotter. Fires will happen. There is absolutely nothing you can do to prevent this. Even if you waved a magic wand and took fire away from mankind, fires still occur naturally. The longer you wait, the more dry fuel you accumulate and the worse the fires will be. It might hurt in the short term, some houses may indeed be destroyed in controlled burns (it happens elsewhere, too), but the alternative is more houses burned and more ecological destruction and more people dead. You cannot get around this.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by danans on Thursday November 15, 2018 @04:25PM (#18463512)
I think we're basically in agreement, although I don't think the issue is about California's thinking they are different. California just has large populations in fire-prone areas.

There is a significant risk in building in these areas, exacerbated by all the aforementioned factors. This will probably be accounted for in insurance rates going forward, which will hopeful deter people from building flammable houses in wildfire zones.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by twtw on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:34AM (#18460629)
Another thing that is new is that the rainy season in CA is starting later, such that the winds come before the rain.

Paradise is a wet place that gets quite a bit of rain - what matters is that it is coming too late.

For this reason, I don't think it is very relevant that the last century has been the wettest in awhile.

That said, there are likely many factors involved, and it is probably not super useful to point at one thing and ignore all the rest.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by romed on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:43PM (#18461409)
Weather in the Mono basin is irrelevant to conditions in the Feather River canyon. California, it turns out, is a large state with multiple distinct climate zones. As you note, it is the length of the summer drought which is increasing. This is not even contradictory with increasing or stable annual precipitation. It just means more of the water is coming in a shorter, rainier season.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by ip26 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:35AM (#18460029)
Colorado does controlled burns in the prairie, and burns forest slash piles in winter.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kryogen1c on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:12AM (#18459820)
> The article doesn't mention it, but controlled burns are actually a regular occurrence in the east and southeast US. I always assumed it was some decision by the Californian state government to not do so.

Wait what? California doesn't do controlled burns?

Mother of God: https://www.quora.com/Why-does-California-not-institute-a-co...

I find this _unfathomable_. I'm from a desert state where during dry times it was illegal to light fires and we absolutely did controlled burns.

California's plan is to let everything burn down and then blame a utility (true or not is irrelevant) and try to collect $20B they definitely don't have? This is unbelievable.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by gamblor956 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:42AM (#18460739)
California has millions of dry, dead trees owing to a bark beetle infestation and multiple, 100-degree+ heat waves. Do you know how hot that wood burns? More than a few trees together, and it burns hot enough to spontaneously combust trees up to a few dozen feet away. Without wind. California's forests are dense. They're dense enough that fires, even controlled burns, can and have generate firestorms--where the heat of the fire generates its own atmospheric wind system that feeds the fire.

Do you know what sort of embers these sorts of fires generate? The kind that fly hundreds of feet, retaining enough heat to light structures on fire when they land. Take a look at the shots of the Malibu portion of the Hill/Woolsey fire: there are structures that burned almost a quarter of a mile away from the closest flora.

So the reason that California cut back on controlled burns? Because due to the factors described above, controlled burns very quickly become massive, uncontrolled conflagrations. Controlled burns are something you can do when the trees and climate is relatively wet, since only the stuff you set on fire burns, or where flora is far enough apart and weather patterns mild enough that the fire can't spread on its own.

But you know what's really unbelievable? Someone who doesn't know diddly squat about what they're talking about who thinks they know better than the people who actually have to deal with this on a regular basis.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kryogen1c on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:37PM (#18461940)
> So the reason that California cut back on controlled burns? Because due to the factors described above, controlled burns very quickly become massive, uncontrolled conflagrations.

Yeah what a disaster a massive, uncontrolled burn would be.

> But you know what's really unbelievable? Someone who doesn't know diddly squat about what they're talking about who thinks they know better than the people who actually have to deal with this on a regular basis.

Your righteous indignation falls pretty flat when there is plain evidence that they are doing a bad job. Here is a list of the 20 largest CA fires https://www.fire.ca.gov/communications/downloads/fact_sheets... 19 are from the last 50 years, 16 in the last 20. How many more hundreds of thousands of acres have to burn before the approach is changed?

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:02PM (#18461595)
Let's assume everything in this comment is perfectly true. The past century has been unusually wet in California. Your choice is to burn now, or burn later when its even drier and hotter.

Meanwhile, California apparently agrees with hs, because they plan on increasing the number of prescribed burns.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by sp332 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:30AM (#18460588)
Snark218 over on Ars Technica claims to be involved in land management decisions, and has some details about why it's not feasible across the state. E.g. https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/11/what-is-going-on-wit...

And like I keep saying: these fires are not burning in forests. They are burning in suburbs, exurbs, and dense residential areas. In towns. Up steep canyons that are treacherous to hike up, let alone tote a pulaski and mattock. In many of the pictures, it's obvious that trees are damaged but survive. It's shrubs, grasses, brush, and chaparral that's burning.

https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/11/what-is-going-on-wit...

I mean, yeah, we can intensively thin and manage forests to protect high-value, critical areas. We can encourage landowners to pursue defensible space treatments, and maybe save their home, if not their neighbors'. But honestly, I don't see any practicable way to prevent fires like the Camp Fire. Or the Thomas. Or Carr and Mendocino and Ferguson and County and Delta and Hirz and the other 7,579 fires that have burned in California this season. I wish I could claim otherwise.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Amezarak on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:35AM (#18460642)
All I can say to that is in the southeast we do prescribed burns even in residential areas, and even in rough terrain.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by gamblor956 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:44AM (#18460769)
All I can say is that in the southeast, your trees are wet, and controlled burns do not burn far past the controlled area.

In California, everything is dry enough that even a tiny ember escaping the burn area can turn a controlled burn into a massive fire. In fact, excluding the massive fires of the past 3 years, some of California's biggest blazes were controlled burns that got out of control.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by twtw on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:04AM (#18460314)
> I find this _unfathomable_. I'm from a desert state where during dry times it was illegal to light fires and we absolutely did controlled burns.

Many of the answers on that quora link seem to indicate that ca does in fact do controlled burns?

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by kryogen1c on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:25AM (#18460541)
Some of the comments indicate they try to burn as much as they can. The ambivalent, uncertain language is a sign the game is already lost. If you ask you car mechanic if the lugs on your tire are tight, the answer is yes; the answer is not some lugs are federally owned so we did the best we could.

This is a serious public safety issue which if left alone is guaranteed to end in widespread death and destruction.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by Johnny555 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:38PM (#18463049)
I think it's more like if you ask your neighborhood mechanic to inspect the brake system, and he said "I inspected everything I could, but the master cylinder is leaking and sealed and only the dealer has the tools and knowledge to open it up" so you have to go to the dealer.

California shouldn't be expected to maintain forests on someone else's property.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by zgramana on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:50AM (#18460836)
If you live on the East Coast then you take the wind for granted. On the Pacific Coast, the winds blow fast and furious, especially as you go up in altitude. Its very hard to control a burn here on most days, especially given the water cycle here. There is vastly more fuel in October and November than earlier in the year as the last rains are about 6 months past.

Controlled burns are probably done best during a short 1-2 month window when ground cover is dry enough, but those are also typically high wind months. To have any control of a burn here you need to be lucky (low winds for a few days), it needs to be a very small prescribed area, and probably needs to be at less than peak fuel.

This all amounts to a very small window for doing a prescribed burn. Given how big many of the forests are, and how much of the state is covered with them, I don’t see how you can have much of any control over a prescribed fire started there.

Certainly not without the heroic effort it takes to put out wildfires. I don’t know how we can ask firefighters to risk their life for a prescribed burn.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by sharkmerry on Thursday November 15, 2018 @01:22PM (#18461800)
the winds look slightly worse on the west coast, but not to a degree that they cant be doing burns like on the east coast

https://windexchange.energy.gov/maps-data/325

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by zgramana on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:33PM (#18517783)
The problem with that map is that the annual average obscures the wide seasonal variation, which was the main thrust of my comment. The high winds come during the dry season, then die down during the bulk of the wet season.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by s0rce on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:41AM (#18460718)
Yah, I'm not sure where that information is from, I've run into controlled burns frequently in the Sierra. I called the FD once in South Lake Tahoe as I hiked right up to the fire but missed the signage on the road.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by jartelt on Thursday November 15, 2018 @06:48PM (#18464648)
Many of forests in California are National Forest land controlled by the federal government. The Californian State Government is not able to go do prescribed burns in the National Forest. A lot of your beef should be with the National Forest Service.

Also, the recent drought is really exacerbating things. A lot of the trees in the forests are dead now and are just waiting to burn. Yes, we should remove some of this dead wood and thin the forests, but this will be a huge task given the large amount of forest.

As far as POAs and local laws... I am sure some of then are overreaching on things. But, some of them also protect areas from legitimate threats. Many people would gladly cut down all the trees on their property around Lake Tahoe so they can have an unobstructed view. Pretty soon we would have no trees around the lake and the landscape would be drastically changed. Some degree of protection is warranted in places.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by briandear on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:58PM (#18461558)
> that some POAs in California forbid cutting down trees on your property.

https://www.sonomacountygazette.com/cms/pages/sonoma-county-...

This article gives a sense of the actual nonsense a homeowner must endure to cut down a tree. It might sound good to some people on paper, but I can feel the frustration of following such an expensive, bureaucratic process just to cut a tree in your own land. That entire process sounds ridiculous when looking at the aftermath of one of these fires such as the Camp or Malibu fires. The environmentalists responsible for such tripe should be made to work with a fire crew for a single hour to see the consequences of their horrid, naïve and completely ignorant policies.

Here is the money paragraph:

“What does Cal-Fire consider to approve a plan?

Basically, they want to make sure that trees are removed in a way that does the least amount of harm to wildlife habitat, that diversity of plant life is maintained, shade and sun balanced for a particular environment, and watersheds and watercourses are disturbed the least amount possible.

For instance, if protected species are in the area, then either the work is not done, or it is postponed during mating and rearing stages. If trees are removed on a hillside, then potential erosion is part of what is considered, monitored and controlled. There are many factors, and they all need to be taken into consideration.”

Sorry, but Cal-Fire should be concerned about preventing fires first. There are protected species everywhere; so delaying fire prevention forestry so some salamander can do whatever it is salamanders do; that’s just ridiculous. Over 17,000 acres of “protected” stuff just burned up in Paradise, California, so perhaps tripping over a dollar to pick up a nickel doesn’t make the best sense for either the environment or people.

Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link... by vkou on Thursday November 15, 2018 @03:34PM (#18463011)
> If trees are removed on a hillside, then potential erosion is part of what is considered, monitored and controlled. There are many factors, and they all need to be taken into consideration.”

> Sorry, but Cal-Fire should be concerned about preventing fires first.

I'm sorry, but soil erosion is not some boogieman invented by pot-smoking hippies who live in a commune. It's a real and serious problem, and leads to landslides, wash-outs, loss of topsoil, loss of other trees (Which often act as windbreaks).