With some simple actions you can change the odds of 100% of homes burning down to 10-50%. This isn’t made up, these are facts proven by evidence and experiment.
Your comment is like saying no one should bother building basements in tornado country because a strong F5 will kill you anyway. The vast majority of tornadoes aren’t strong F5s so taking some precautions absolutely will save lives and property.
The biggest ones are:
- fire-resistant roofing; the vast majority of homes that burn in these evens are set on fire by embers long before the fire line even gets close, which makes firefighting efforts basically pointless
- fire-resistant siding; if a fire is near this makes it much less likely that the siding will catch from brief contact or by being heated to its ignition point. If the side walls catch the house is a goner.
- keep tree tops 30-60 ft away from structures. Fires often leap from treetop to treetop, then from there to the structure.
- use non-flammable landscaping near the home.
No, my comment is like saying clearing 30 feet around your house is an absolute no-brainer, of course do it, but don't expect that alone to miraculously save you from a fire.
Saying this as someone who's mountain cabin survived the Detweiler fire, largely because of vegetation control.
Ok, but that's not what you said. You just ignored it completely like you were disregarding it. If it was such a no-brainer everyone would have done that in California, which was clearly not the case and it's why we're having this discussion now.
It's like someone posting stats about seatbelts saving lives in response to tons of vehicle deaths where people weren't wearing seatbelts. Then you come along and point out that if you drive off a 500 ft cliff a seatbelt won't save your life and some of the deaths were caused by driving off of a cliff.
Either the implication is that the safety mechanism would not have helped, or you are offering a useless observation that it's not making them impervious.
Considering that the original post literally used the phrase "could make homes basically impervious", I don't consider this a useless observation. I found it quite informative.
Watch the videos coming out of the area. These people have trees touching their homes.
That (for a layman like me) can easily be interpreted as fire proofing.
the quoted line "A house can be thirty feet from an entire forest on fire and never burn down." says exactly that.
It's a bit tricky because in truth a house may be touching trees that are one fire and "will never burn down" (in the sense that it won't that time) can also be a true statement.
I think a generous interpretation is that "A house can be thirty feet from an entire forest on fire and never burn down." is meant to mean that a house thirty feet away from the forest fire likely won't while a house right next to the forest fire likely will.
It was poorly worded, but it isn't necessarily saying what you state.
Like with anything, you have to pick what the likely scenario should be and build to it. You can build a nuclear power plant to resist 40ft high swells and still get a 50ft swell and be powerless. Obviously more protected is better, but also more expensive (which makes housing less available and affordable, etc). The recurrent nature of the problem suggests to me that the code may be too lax currently, and that the solutions are non-trivial: likely major work for existing homes (from a homeowner perspective, forest management may be able to do more).
Huh, I think that's the first time I've been accused of being non-cooperative for saying what is essentially "I think perhaps how you're interpreting that statement is not how it was meant and you're talking past each other."
All I was saying is that it appears that zzzeek interpreted the original statement as "do X and Y can't happen" when I think ambiguous wording was used and that wasn't the intent, as I didn't interpret it that way.
I'm arguing semantics because I think there is a misunderstanding of people's positions because of those semantics. I understand that it got a little long into the weeds, but there was a point.
The word used was “can” and it means something is possible.
Your misunderstanding is quite commmon in English these days. People say things like “men are pigs” or “chickens fly” and many will interpret that as if a broad claim was made. But “all chickens fly all day long” is a totally different sentence than “chickens fly” and “chickens can fly“.
Nothing will save a house that's close to a forest fire while not being fire-resistant, however.
Here is a page from such a group attempting to oppose a measure that would allow private citizens to cut down trees on their own land, if that land is under 300 acres in area: http://winewaterwatch.org/2018/08/kill-ab-426-allowing-road-...
https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
The ability of "private citizens to cut down trees on their own land" doesn't turn on AB 425. The code already has specific provisions for firebreaks, and AB 425 doesn't change them one way or another:
https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/public-resources-code/prc-sect-...
Cast iron is the material of choice as it is cheaper than surgery grade stainless steel, it retains the heat and it is a traditional material that people expect.
As for where you can buy yourself a grill made from cast iron, the options are many. In towns there are shops that sell such things. You can walk into such a shop, exchange money and get your own BBQ grill in genuine cast iron.
It’s extremely common in mid to high end grills.
No, they are “plated steel” for the cooking grate, and “heavy gauge steel” for the charcoal grate; at least per the specs on their website. (Which matches every Weber I've used over several decades.)
From their site, “how to care for your cast iron cooking grates”. Quoting Weber’s website, “All our 2017 gas grills except for the Summit and Genesis II LX come with porcelain enameled cast iron cooking grates.”. The spec sheet on the site for virtually every gas grill lists a cast iron grate.
https://www.weber.com/US/en/blog/tips-techniques/how-to-care...
In zero wind. The fires in Santa Rosa were driven by 60 mph (100 kph) winds. Even 30 mph winds will pick up the top 15 meters of a burning Ponderosa Pine and carry it 400 meters away and start a new fire.
After the Santa Rosa fires I saw newspaper photos of melted barbeque grills. A fire hot enough to melt cast iron is going to light or melt any roofing material I can think of.