Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by curiousgal on Thursday November 15, 2018 @09:21AM
(#18459383)
>I’m reading antifragile right now
I commend you for that, I just find his writing style to be so annoying that I can't even finish reading a simple article of his.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by iambateman on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:11AM
(#18460399)
Totally agree. I lived with a guy from the Middle East for several years, and it actually helps to imagine his voice when I read Taleb.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by claytoneast on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:40AM
(#18460076)
His books are less grating than his short pieces.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by stouset on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:06AM
(#18460337)
They really aren’t.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by raesene9 on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:56AM
(#18460233)
I live near the Rest and be Thankful in Scotland, we know all about land/mudslides due to deforestation :) The hillside above the road has no trees and there are regular landslides that'll close the road (which is the main road into the west of scotland) for a week at a time.
After spending millions on nets and ditches, they've lodged a plan to replant trees above the road...
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by gowld on Thursday November 15, 2018 @10:07AM
(#18459766)
Seems obvious that if you expose a system to stress, whatever survives will be stress-proof; while if you hide stress from a system, it's a disaster waiting to happen. Same story with allergy immunities and used cars.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by darkerside on Thursday November 15, 2018 @11:47AM
(#18460793)
What's the used cars example?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by jonathankoren on Thursday November 15, 2018 @12:04PM
(#18461013)
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by darkerside on Friday November 16, 2018 @06:58AM
(#18468150)
I'm sure that's partly true, but it doesn't seem to account for the lack of alternatives to selling a used car. A car offers no utility, and yet continues to depreciate, sitting in the garage. Assuming you want or need to participate in buying/selling a car for life reasons (growing family, moving houses, or moving upmarket into just vehicles), how else do you class back any value from this asset? Other alternatives (donation, trade-in) aren't going to get you even lemon prices in return.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by jonathankoren on Friday November 16, 2018 @06:52PM
(#18472924)
I don’t understand. If you sell the car, you get money which has the maximum utility, because you can trade it for other things. Donating and trading are essentially selling, so what would an alternative that provides positive utility look like?
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by darkerside on Sunday November 18, 2018 @12:38AM
(#18479021)
They are alternatives to selling, but you typically receive less money than you would in a straight sale. I think I'm asking the same question as you.
> Given the fixed price at which buyers will buy, sellers will sell only when they hold "lemons" (since plemon < pavg) and they will leave the market when they hold "peaches" (since ppeach > pavg).
My point is that this is a highly idealized and theoretical model. Life doesn't work this way.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by jonathankoren on Monday November 19, 2018 @01:57AM
(#18484607)
I would argue that the alternatives you've listed (e.g. donation), are functionally equivalent to selling. You're trading a good (the car), for money.
> My point is that this is a highly idealized and theoretical model. Life doesn't work this way.
Such is every nonbehavioral economics paper ever written.
Re:PG&E stock plunged 32% after it disclosed a possible link...
by darkerside on Tuesday November 20, 2018 @12:01PM
(#18495364)
You're missing my point. Those alternatives typically provide you LESS money than selling. How are people supposedly "leaving" the market? Parking an unused car on the street?
I’m reading antifragile right now and he’s talking about systems which improve with a certain amount of volatility and stress. It seems forests are “antifragile” on their own, and our efforts may in fact introduce fragility.