[1] https://www.macrumors.com/2018/10/05/sewell-says-fbi-never-h...
owing feudal allegiance to.
"they had for a long period been feudatory to the Norwegian Crown"
So yes, if the old chief counsel was a subject in a feudal society, this all checks out.
Apple's official statement clearly said, they're not under any form of NSL or gag order.
The prevailing logic seems to be that US courts still believe the government can't force you to say something against your will, only prevent you from saying something.
They (apple) have refuted this claim and said they're also not under any form of NSL or gag order.
Your suggestion is that both accounts are false, and that a secret government run investigation was run without Apple management's knowledge, but involving Apple datacenter staff, who are in fact under some form of NSL/gag order?
Perhaps you should go work for Bloomberg, they'll run your theory as gospel next week.
It could be that the actual story is something at some small company, which ballooned into a shit storm of assumptions and embellishment.
Saying nothing is Apple's thing. No one would question them saying nothing.
Except that a NSL can (legally) command the recipient to lie about it.
Do you have a source for this statement? As far as I'm aware, you can be compelled to remain silent but not compelled to give a false statement.
Q: Have you received an NSL? A: No. Q: Now have you received an NSL? A: Still nope. (Government issues NSL) Q: What about now? A: No comment.
^ This would be a clear canary indication that an NSL has been issued, which is in directly contradiction of the terms of the secrecy requirements laid out in the NSL. The only reasonable response (aside from supporting the ACLU and EFF to end this nonsense) is to adopt the "no comment" policy early, which most do. However Apple has now broken that strategy, if they haven't already.
They therefore are not “acting exactly as they would” without a NSL.
Making an explicitly false statement to preserve the silence about an NSL or its subject matter goes well beyond a gag order. The gag order compels your silence; it doesn't compel you to become an active participant in maintaining that silence beyond not acting to break it, let alone persuading people to believe any explanations or stories to explain it or shield the investigation the letter is a part of.
But there's another issue beyond the constitutional problems with trying to order Apple or its officers to make verifiably false statements about the existence of Chinese spy chips: any statement about said spy chips would constitute a material fact to shareholders. And it'd be a a really big one with an effect potentially measured in billions of dollars of market value, multiplied by the fact that Apple lied and destroyed every iota of credibility on privacy issues they've developed over the years. Making that statement--even if ordered to do so by an NSL--would be a blatant breach of the their fiduciary duty to shareholders and SEC regulations.
Even if compelled to do so, Apple (or its officers) literally can't make that false statement. They'd have no choice but to fight an NSL that orders them to make false statements, and even if they lost, they'd limit themselves to "no comment." So while they might be under a gag order on a given subject due to an NSL, if they're commenting about it, we can reasonably accept those comments as true. Or, at minimum, that they are their own words rather than the government's. As a hypothetical, it's plausible that they could be lying about the chips; but if so, it would be because of their own deliberate decision to do. Not that that's very likely, of course.
At this point the major wall has been breached in terms of rights, altering speech for national security, and we can no longer trust anything. If the secret courts decided they were going to compel active speech instead of compelling negative speech, what mechanism would let us know of the change? I don't think there is any
https://www.yalelawjournal.org/forum/warrant-canaries-and-di...
Specifically Section IV, subsection C
"Canaries and the First Amendment Status of Compelled Lies"
Is there a way where the government could either purposefully disclose classified information (or retroactively classify it) so as to force certain individuals into making particular statements or denials via the threat that if they said otherwise they would be guilty of disclosing classified information ...?
Didn't some leaked documents show that a 'shadow' judicial status has been created ( under post 9/11 histeria ) where, in the interest of national security, firms are allowed and even required to lie about things?
I haven’t read anything that says people/companies must lie, but I have read that they cannot divulge information due to gag orders. (See the court case Microsoft vs US Government [1] )
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intell...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_v._United_States_(20...
0: http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/attorneys_fired_by_gm...
Is that true in this case? My understanding is that NSLs are a subpoena with an accompanying gag order _about the subpoena_. I haven't heard of a case where an NSL was used to restrict speech in the manner you're suggesting. In other words, I believe an NSL could be used to hide government interest in such a breach, but not to hide the fact of the breach.
This is one of the main differences between the US and UK approach to classified information; there's no official secrets act in the US.
Ordinarily, yes. But what if this was double secret NSL?
What's the NSL equivalent of adding bacon?
But they didn't detail, like, that there was substantial corroboration of specific details like Apple working with the FBI. That leaves open possibilities that it came from just one source or that the reporters mixed up some details. Whereas the company/govt denials are very detailed and clear to rule out any possibility of misinterpretation. Bloomberg's "double down" is nowhere near that level.
[1] https://daringfireball.net/linked/2018/10/19/cook-calls-for-...
If so, the rest of the 17 are just echoing what the inner group told them, without having done substantial independent verification.
https://iphone.appleinsider.com/articles/18/10/08/security-r...
I'm saying this because I've noticed quite a few 'hit' pieces, coming out of these "news" agencies that seem to have no other agenda than affecting the price of publicly traded stock in these companies.
One moment "this or that" is the worst possible thing that could happen to company A, and the next moment, it's just not as bad as everyone would have you believe... it's like they themselves want to push the stock price down so they can buy cheap shares, and then pump the price back up again so they can sell at a profit... strangest news cycles I've ever seen on this stuff... and it happens repeatedly all the time... analyst A at Financial Institution B "downgrades" stock X, and then sometime later comes a complete reversal...
It seems plausible that it's more along the lines of "journalistic process being broken" for this type of article, that all parties might be acting in good faith and that there is some level of misunderstanding.
I asked people in the CIA about the Bloomberg story and their response seemed to indicate that the story is real.
There’s immense pressure to deny this story for several reasons.
Like the Bloomberg article, your comment is unsourced - or anonymously so, which is only an infinitesimally larger notch better.
(But I presume you were merely being sarcastic; or trolling.)
https://www.wired.com/story/us-china-cybertheft-su-bin/
I wondered why the United States does not care about such state sponsored violations of intellectual property, going as far as to deny the crime.
For Apple to believe that they could get away with outright bare faced lying about this, they would have to be very confident none of those people across dozens of ogrganisations would either break ranks or mistakenly corroborate the story, and none of the copious physical evidence would ever be found.
The question is, do you believe that’s the sort of risk they are likely to take?
Why not just 'reporters talked to a bunch of sources and those sources are wrong or were misinterpreted or were given undue weight/credence by the reporters'. It's unusual and the news org processes are supposed to catch this but it's not that hard to imagine them occasionally failing in some mildly improbable way without any kind of 'hacking to an extreme level' or collusion between companies and spooks.
You'd think the accusers would be able to produce the chip if that were the case.
> Or, they were hacked and an internal team knows and Cook doesn't, which is evidence of U.S. national security having powerful influence inside of Apple.
More plausible but again - there should be hard evidence of this.
The story we published was one woman’s account of a sexual assault at a UVA fraternity in October 2012 – and the subsequent ordeal she experienced at the hands of University administrators in her attempts to work her way through the trauma of that evening. The indifference with which her complaint was met was, we discovered, sadly consistent with the experience of many other UVA women who have tried to report such assaults. Through our extensive reporting and fact–checking, we found Jackie to be entirely credible and courageous and we are proud to have given her disturbing story the attention it deserves.
Three days later they retracted the story.
When it comes to National Security, combined with the most valuable company in the US, all assumptions should be off the table. Apple has many reasons to publicly dismiss the claims: their business in China, their marketing as a security-conscious company, etc. They also operate under immense secrecy. Apple has unmarked buildings, top secret projects, a culture of secrecy within the company. They are the type of company that would have innovative approaches when dealing with national security matters.
It would be odd for Tim Cook to knowingly lie about this situation. If definitive proof came out that the chips were bugged and he had knowledge of it, then he could be punished. But, at the same time, if he were able to prove that he lied in the name of National Security, it could be instantly excusable.
Because barring a Stephen Glass scenario, what's fascinating here is that no matter which side is right, this is evidence of some sort of mysterious power play.
Either Apple was hacked, they know, and are denying, which is evidence of them being under the thumb of U.S. national security.
Or, they were hacked and an internal team knows and Cook doesn't, which is evidence of U.S. national security having powerful influence inside of Apple.
Or, they weren't hacked, and Bloomberg is doubling down, which at this point would mean that someone has successfully hacked their journalistic verification processes to an extreme level.
In all three of those cases, it points to a level of attacker competence that I'm not normally inclined to believe in.