News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by moftz on Friday October 19, 2018 @03:46PM (#18259445)
Tim Cook would have to know. If there is something like a NSL involved, Apple's legal team would have already reviewed it. That same legal team would also be advising Cook on what he publicly says since he is an officer in the company. He could lose his job or be fined for saying false information in the press (think about what happened to Musk) so its in his and his legal team's best interest to only say true things in the press or at least spin things so they aren't blatantly false. An NSL compels you to say nothing. You can neither confirm nor deny anything and its probably against the law for him to outright lie about the situation in the eyes of the SEC so he has to either be spinning things, omitting things, or outright telling the truth. The Bloomberg piece is fantastic but that kind of attack vector does exist however narrow it may be. I don't know why Bloomberg seems to want to double down on this. They are either incredibly stupid and are involved in some murder-suicide plot against Supermicro or they are telling the truth but maybe a little misguided.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by abalone on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:27PM (#18259768)
Just for clarity, there are some cases where the CEO is in fact left out of the loop specifically so they aren't in jeopardy of lying to shareholders. But typically it is the chief counsel who is informed in these scenarios. It is significant the Apple statements have been clear to rule out that possibility.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by chrisdhoover on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:29PM (#18260564)
Apple has a new chief counsel. Hmm the plot thickens
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by abalone on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:34PM (#18260588)
Old one was in place at the time of these alleged events and has publicly denied it as well.[1]

[1] https://www.macrumors.com/2018/10/05/sewell-says-fbi-never-h...

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by saagarjha on Friday October 19, 2018 @07:14PM (#18260748)
Is he under the same burden to tell the truth, legally speaking, as the current chief counsel?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by WrtCdEvrydy on Friday October 19, 2018 @07:44PM (#18260883)
Probably ethical violation to lie (lawyers)
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by neom on Friday October 19, 2018 @10:49PM (#18261446)
Feudatory obligation is feudatory obligation, senior execs almost always have feudatory obligations.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by Godel_unicode on Saturday October 20, 2018 @02:19AM (#18262024)
Do you perhaps mean fiduciary?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by newsbinator on Saturday October 20, 2018 @05:45AM (#18262537)
feu·da·to·ry

owing feudal allegiance to.

"they had for a long period been feudatory to the Norwegian Crown"

So yes, if the old chief counsel was a subject in a feudal society, this all checks out.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by neom on Saturday October 20, 2018 @11:18AM (#18263633)
dyslesia for the win
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by stephenr on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:23PM (#18259740)
> If there is something like a NSL involved, Apple's legal team would have already reviewed it.

Apple's official statement clearly said, they're not under any form of NSL or gag order.

The prevailing logic seems to be that US courts still believe the government can't force you to say something against your will, only prevent you from saying something.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by DuskStar on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:30PM (#18260206)
And how would the CEO know what sort of NSL some datacenter employees are under?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by neom on Friday October 19, 2018 @11:09PM (#18261523)
That's not how it works. The company at large works with the government to figure out and certify who can receive NSL/FISA, and those folks have an internal process to make sure they're compliant with the law as they execute it.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by stephenr on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:46PM (#18260303)
The original claim is that Apple conducted it's own investigation and refused to cooperate with the FBI on the matter.

They (apple) have refuted this claim and said they're also not under any form of NSL or gag order.

Your suggestion is that both accounts are false, and that a secret government run investigation was run without Apple management's knowledge, but involving Apple datacenter staff, who are in fact under some form of NSL/gag order?

Perhaps you should go work for Bloomberg, they'll run your theory as gospel next week.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by kakarot on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:02PM (#18260039)
I'm not saying I don't believe they could be telling the truth, but why should we should take their word for it?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by CamperBob2 on Friday October 19, 2018 @06:10PM (#18260459)
Are you asking Apple, or Bloomberg?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by kakarot on Friday October 19, 2018 @09:50PM (#18261250)
I meant Apple, but the broader implication is that we can't trust either party with the information we have now.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Friday October 19, 2018 @11:09PM (#18261524)
I mean Apple's account seems a lot more believable to me. I know we all want Jason Bourne to be real, but he isn't.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by panda888888 on Saturday October 20, 2018 @04:40AM (#18262387)
Why trust Apple over Bloomberg? What if the hack were so bad (e.g. a keylogger + who knows what else) that none of the tech giants would ever admit it?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Saturday October 20, 2018 @09:26AM (#18263198)
It's not about trust (at least for me). It's about the credibility of the account. "Journalists got something wrong" is a lot easier for me to believe than "there is a massive conspiracy to cover something up and there just so happens to be no evidence of it besides our say so."
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by panda888888 on Saturday October 20, 2018 @01:25PM (#18264308)
Hmm. The involvement of Elemental is enough evidence for me. A then 200-person startup with maybe 10 hardware engineers and lots of government clients would be a great target. It makes me thing the hack was real. Why else would Bloomberg have even bothered to report about Elemental?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Saturday October 20, 2018 @04:43PM (#18265350)
So, are you saying that if a big journalism outlet wants to convince you that a world-shaking hack has occurred, all they have to do is name a plausible target? Interesting. My standards of evidence are higher.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by stephenr on Saturday October 20, 2018 @02:09PM (#18264574)
It's not necessarily all or nothing.

It could be that the actual story is something at some small company, which ballooned into a shit storm of assumptions and embellishment.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by kakarot on Saturday October 20, 2018 @07:44PM (#18266059)
I'm not saying I believe either party in this mess, but to be fair Occam's Razor is used very often to disregard legitimately viable conspiracy theories.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by stephenr on Saturday October 20, 2018 @05:07AM (#18262462)
Then Apple would simply say nothing.

Saying nothing is Apple's thing. No one would question them saying nothing.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by garmaine on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:33PM (#18260225)
> Apple's official statement clearly said, they're not under any form of NSL or gag order.

Except that a NSL can (legally) command the recipient to lie about it.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by vageli on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:40PM (#18260269)
> Except that a NSL can (legally) command the recipient to lie about it.

Do you have a source for this statement? As far as I'm aware, you can be compelled to remain silent but not compelled to give a false statement.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by garmaine on Friday October 19, 2018 @07:08PM (#18260722)
You can be compelled to act exactly as you would as if the NSL had not been issued, and indeed they seem to contain language to that effect. A reasonable response would be to adopt a policy of "no comment" and most do, but if you have previously responded to questions about NSLs in the negative, you would then be required to continue doing the same.

Q: Have you received an NSL? A: No. Q: Now have you received an NSL? A: Still nope. (Government issues NSL) Q: What about now? A: No comment.

^ This would be a clear canary indication that an NSL has been issued, which is in directly contradiction of the terms of the secrecy requirements laid out in the NSL. The only reasonable response (aside from supporting the ACLU and EFF to end this nonsense) is to adopt the "no comment" policy early, which most do. However Apple has now broken that strategy, if they haven't already.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by stephenr on Friday October 19, 2018 @07:13PM (#18260747)
Apple made a statement, that they have are not under NSL/gag. They don’t routinely make these statements, and they weren’t asked directly about it.

They therefore are not “acting exactly as they would” without a NSL.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by garmaine on Saturday October 20, 2018 @01:21AM (#18261896)
They’ve made similar statements in the past, e.g. regarding patriot act requests in 2013.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by moftz on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @09:39AM (#18283252)
Canaries only make sense if the company actually cares about letting their customers know about a possible NSL. They might not be legal as it's a pretty obvious wink wink nudge nudge that they received one. Apple and Amazon are big enough that they aren't going to mess around with utopian EFF rhetoric and will do whatever is required them by the law. None of the big boys care about "don't be evil" mantras anymore. They care about what keeps the stock price up and the federal government off their ass.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by saagarjha on Friday October 19, 2018 @07:14PM (#18260758)
How exactly do canaries work, then? Isn't the point there that you have a canary that you remove later?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by usrusr on Friday October 19, 2018 @09:06PM (#18261127)
I think the point gp was trying to make is that canaries are not working. Schneier for example has publicly doubted their effectivity.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by garmaine on Friday October 19, 2018 @10:55PM (#18261466)
Canaries don’t work. National secrecy laws treat a canary exactly as outright violating the gag order.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by Godel_unicode on Saturday October 20, 2018 @02:30AM (#18262062)
Do you have a citation for this? Ideally one written by a lawyer.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by utopcell on Saturday October 20, 2018 @02:33AM (#18262073)
Reference ?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by x220 on Friday October 19, 2018 @09:03PM (#18261119)
Has anyone been prosecuted for acting similar to your example?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by Bluestrike2 on Friday October 19, 2018 @09:31PM (#18261194)
A NSL can compel the recipient's silence in the form of a gag order, but the government cannot compel speech outside of very particular circumstances, such as consumer warning labels, that don't include verifiably false statements.[0] Thus the concept of warrant canaries, though they haven't been challenged in court.[1] There are other articles on both out there, but the EFF links are decent starting points if you're interested in reading further.

Making an explicitly false statement to preserve the silence about an NSL or its subject matter goes well beyond a gag order. The gag order compels your silence; it doesn't compel you to become an active participant in maintaining that silence beyond not acting to break it, let alone persuading people to believe any explanations or stories to explain it or shield the investigation the letter is a part of.

But there's another issue beyond the constitutional problems with trying to order Apple or its officers to make verifiably false statements about the existence of Chinese spy chips: any statement about said spy chips would constitute a material fact to shareholders. And it'd be a a really big one with an effect potentially measured in billions of dollars of market value, multiplied by the fact that Apple lied and destroyed every iota of credibility on privacy issues they've developed over the years. Making that statement--even if ordered to do so by an NSL--would be a blatant breach of the their fiduciary duty to shareholders and SEC regulations.

Even if compelled to do so, Apple (or its officers) literally can't make that false statement. They'd have no choice but to fight an NSL that orders them to make false statements, and even if they lost, they'd limit themselves to "no comment." So while they might be under a gag order on a given subject due to an NSL, if they're commenting about it, we can reasonably accept those comments as true. Or, at minimum, that they are their own words rather than the government's. As a hypothetical, it's plausible that they could be lying about the chips; but if so, it would be because of their own deliberate decision to do. Not that that's very likely, of course.

0. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/04/warrant-canary-faq

1. https://www.eff.org/issues/national-security-letters

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by roblabla on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:39PM (#18260259)
An NSL cannot force you to lie. You can say "no comment", and that's how it's always been handled. Why would they vehemently deny an NSL (with all the risks involved) when "no comment" would suffice ?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by lovich on Friday October 19, 2018 @08:57PM (#18261103)
Is that still true though? The NSL already compel speech in that they limit what you can say. We already have secret courts making decisions that we find out about years later.

At this point the major wall has been breached in terms of rights, altering speech for national security, and we can no longer trust anything. If the secret courts decided they were going to compel active speech instead of compelling negative speech, what mechanism would let us know of the change? I don't think there is any

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by garmaine on Saturday October 20, 2018 @01:16AM (#18261881)
Most people in this thread have zero experience with national security issues, and the ACLU/EFF opinions are more what those organizations feel should be the constitutional interpretation, not what actual circumstance is. You certainly can be compelled to say certain things to keep classified information secret, at risk of federal prison or worse, and this is the same law that is being abused for NSLs.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by mattzito on Saturday October 20, 2018 @05:48AM (#18262549)
I’ve seen you make this claim several times in this thread, but haven’t provided any evidence. Can you provide a source that says that the federal government can compel false statements as part of national security demands?
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by scrps on Saturday October 20, 2018 @06:43AM (#18262673)
I was curious about this as well and did a bit of searching around (I didn't dig that deeply and IANAL) and found this:

https://www.yalelawjournal.org/forum/warrant-canaries-and-di...

Specifically Section IV, subsection C

"Canaries and the First Amendment Status of Compelled Lies"

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by breatheoften on Saturday October 20, 2018 @06:12AM (#18262614)
That sounds like a pretty nightmarish tactic ...

Is there a way where the government could either purposefully disclose classified information (or retroactively classify it) so as to force certain individuals into making particular statements or denials via the threat that if they said otherwise they would be guilty of disclosing classified information ...?

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by lawnchair_larry on Saturday October 20, 2018 @12:05AM (#18261716)
That is not what compel speech means.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by stephenr on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:43PM (#18260283)
Do you have a reference for this? There is apparently case law from the 1970s' where SCOTUS ruled that the government cannot compel someone to speak against their wishes.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by athrowaway3z on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:22PM (#18259730)
>> its probably against the law for him to outright lie about the situation in the eyes of the SEC

Didn't some leaked documents show that a 'shadow' judicial status has been created ( under post 9/11 histeria ) where, in the interest of national security, firms are allowed and even required to lie about things?

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by ColanR on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:19PM (#18260151)
Do you remember what those documents were, or how they might be found online? (being curious, not confrontational)
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by kylel on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:50PM (#18260331)
See the wiki page for the FISA court [0]

I haven’t read anything that says people/companies must lie, but I have read that they cannot divulge information due to gag orders. (See the court case Microsoft vs US Government [1] )

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Foreign_Intell...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_v._United_States_(20...

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by ColanR on Saturday October 20, 2018 @01:07PM (#18264216)
Thanks for the sources. I've definitely seen/know of the gag order business. It was the suggested extension to that I'm curious about ("firms are allowed and even required to lie about things").
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by losvedir on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:32PM (#18259813)
No.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by lawnchair_larry on Saturday October 20, 2018 @12:06AM (#18261718)
Nope.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by Latteland on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:46PM (#18260305)
I think it's possible to set things up so that leaders of the companies are shielded from the knowledge on purpose. GM notoriously set up their lawsuit handling legal unit to shield knowledge of problems, among other things with the ignition switch [0]. This was a very specifically organized system where they tried to keep the knowledge of agreements on lawsuits from being visible up the chain - it was no accident. So big companies can and will do this when it suits them. I think this was clearly unethical, but I suspect it's common.

0: http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/attorneys_fired_by_gm...

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by Godel_unicode on Saturday October 20, 2018 @02:25AM (#18262045)
> An NSL compels you to say nothing.

Is that true in this case? My understanding is that NSLs are a subpoena with an accompanying gag order _about the subpoena_. I haven't heard of a case where an NSL was used to restrict speech in the manner you're suggesting. In other words, I believe an NSL could be used to hide government interest in such a breach, but not to hide the fact of the breach.

This is one of the main differences between the US and UK approach to classified information; there's no official secrets act in the US.

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by rrcaptain on Saturday October 20, 2018 @07:48PM (#18266077)
It's also possible Bloomberg's sources are lying to them. It's not unwarranted for intelligence agencies to leak things to the press deliberately to create a story.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by moftz on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @09:45AM (#18283300)
It seems irresponsible to leak information that could be so damaging to multiple American companies just to prop up a single tech journalist.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by rrcaptain on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:23PM (#18331643)
I doubt they're trying to prop up a single tech journalist. If I had to speculate on intelligence agency motivations I'd speculate that they're trying to attack SuperMicro.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by freyr on Friday October 19, 2018 @04:20PM (#18259710)
> An NSL compels you to say nothing. You can neither confirm nor deny anything

Ordinarily, yes. But what if this was double secret NSL?

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by stephenr on Friday October 19, 2018 @05:49PM (#18260326)
I'm not sure NSL's are like meat/cheese layers on hamburgers.

What's the NSL equivalent of adding bacon?

Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by Kalium on Friday October 19, 2018 @07:12PM (#18260743)
Prior restraint, I think.
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by tomtang0514 on Friday October 19, 2018 @09:33PM (#18261200)
Also Supermicro is not even a chinese company. It's based in San Jose and founded by taiwanese american...
Re:Apple CEO Tim Cook Calling for Bloomberg to Retract Its C... by moftz on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @09:41AM (#18283277)
All of their manufacturing is in China along with everyone else.