News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by xt00 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @05:39PM (#18135060)
This will help with recruitment, but the sentiment that new workers will essentially get paid the same as older workers is going to immediately be a big sticking point. From watching the Boeing union strikes over many years, I get the sense that once a labor force unionizes they setup their own structure for pay and get that signed off -- where they have seniority and things like that. But it also means the company becomes very adversarial with their work-force and spends most of its time trying to figure out how to get around the demands of the union.

I feel like the concept of unions needs to be rejiggered for the modern era where its less (But still to some degree) about worker safety and more about control over compensation / days off / healthcare stuff.

Maybe somebody could come up with something that is like a union but meant to be more lightweight and more focused on compensation type things and has some self-imposed restrictions on things like strikes and bargaining hold-outs and things like that.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by ravitation on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @05:55PM (#18135172)
A company doesn't become adversarial with its workforce because of unions; a company is forced to treat its workforce more as an equal because of unions. The adversarial nature of the relationship between a workforce and its company is not a result of unions, it exists without unions. It's just that, without unions, companies are free to largely ignore the demands of individual workers.

Control over compensation and healthcare "stuff" (and, I'd argue, even days off) is just as important to the well-being of a workforce as worker safety, especially in a country with a relatively weak "social safety net".

How exactly does a union show that it is worth negotiating with as an equal without things that demonstrate its power, like strikes and bargaining hold-outs?

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by sethammons on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @07:06PM (#18135540)
> A company doesn't become adversarial with its workforce because of unions; a company is forced to treat its workforce more as an equal because of unions.

I'm not convinced. My brother's work has a warehouse. The warehouse unionized (a large push by two folks who are no longer there). Most of the warehouse workers are now making _less_ than they were before due to union dues. There are guys that my brother would love to promote and reward with better pay, but the union does not allow that. The union demands such-n-such, the business pushes back. The workers are in the middle and get shitall. This union (at least) exists to grow itself and for no other reason.

Now the "office personnel" are not allowed to talk anything union related with the "warehouse folks." It went from "us" to "us" and "them." The office people have to be careful on how they say anything or a union rep can file grievances. When you have to watch your behavior in fear of retribution, I'd say that is adversarial and I would say this happened due to the union.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by gnopgnip on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:05PM (#18135912)
>Most of the warehouse workers are now making _less_ than they were before due to union dues.

If most of the workers are making less now, why would they vote to unionize? Before the union formed did workers get vacation and sick time, or were their unaddressed safety issues, or was management treating employees unfairly?

In the US it is a lot of work to convince people to form a union even when the benefits are clear. Companies will bring in professional union busters, force employees to watch anti union propaganda, many employers will illegally fire employees who are pro union, and they will threaten(illegally) to shut down the whole company if a union is formed.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by endtime on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:16PM (#18136575)
> If most of the workers are making less now, why would they vote to unionize?

You seem to be confusing the direction of time...

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by lovich on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:48PM (#18137018)
What we're the expected benefits of joining the union that they didn't get then? For instance in most low level jobs I've had like that, just getting a consistent schedule would be worth half the hourly wage, without a bonus all. You'd be able to have a life or a second job. When you don't have a union you get companies ignoring even basics like that and doing random scheduling with leaves you with the inability to do anything but be ready for work, without being paid for the time.

There are tons of little things like this that all add up to value that's just as good as money and that we take for granted by being in the tech world

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by TangoTrotFox on Thursday October 04, 2018 @03:53AM (#18137969)
Something we also take for granted in the tech world is companies running on ridiculously high net margins. Apple, for instance, makes about $400,000 in profit per employee. They could literally give every single one of their 123,000 workers a $200k raise and still be making tens of billions of dollars in profit per year. Now let's consider WalMart, the largest employer in the US and one many have chastised for poor pay. The make a bit less than $4,300 in profit per employee. And that's one of the largest companies in the world that can take advantage of economy of scale to push their profit margins as high as possible.

Most companies operate on very thin margins, made up for by scale. Selling $300 hardware for $1000 is, fortunately, an exception rather than the rule. But what this means is that unions are not going to suddenly send major benefits towards employees, because the companies simply do not have the money for these benefits. Factor in the frequently unreasonably high union fees and unions are often going to be a negative overall outcome at many companies. For instance the united autoworkers union demands 30 hours of pay, or 1.44% (which is 30/2080) of your annual pay in dues per year. So in other words workers would need to see an extra 30 hours of pay or a ~1.5% raise, just to break even.

But many people don't consider economic realities when they believe they can get more stuff. If you had a national vote on enacting a $50/hour minimum wage you'd have tens of millions people vote for it even though it would lead not only to their direct unemployment, but also throwing the entire nation into complete chaos and crashing the US and world economies as well. For instance you regularly see things like employees trying to unionize at companies that are operating in the red. What exactly do they think is going to be the outcome there?

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by gnopgnip on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:07PM (#18141677)
A union can provide value even if it is not tied directly to a raise, or to benefits like 401k matching, employer paid healthcare, or time off. Requiring just cause before firing an employee, having regular shifts that can be planned around, and having someone to look out for your behalf besides the dept of labor all go a long way to improving the working conditions of a job, and don't directly affect the bottom line. The lower turnover can even improve it in the long run.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by lovich on Thursday October 04, 2018 @08:57AM (#18139444)
On the other hand, you constantly see people defend ultra rich CEOs by dividing their salary across all employees in the company and showing how it would only be a raise of a few hundred a year. Those defenders then claim that's barely a raise so why take from the CEO?

When you are minimum wage even 100 extra a year would have absolutely helped. I thinks it's fairly disengenous for any company to be raking in billions in profits while employees need public assistance to survive.

Yea, you can suddenly double your work forces wage, but you can still improve the situation.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by angry_octet on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:49AM (#18137277)
Yep there are heaps of reasons. For example, 'zero hours' contracts are all too common now. You have to be available for a shift, but if there is no work they send you home. (Or if you don't suck up to the supervisor he gives you less hours.) It's an unfair one way obligation.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by crooked-v on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @07:59PM (#18135875)
So who's running the union? Some measure of nonsensicality exists here in the idea of a union composed entirely of warehouse workers that is somehow magically acting against the best interests of those warehouse workers.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by icelancer on Thursday October 04, 2018 @03:37AM (#18137917)
>> Some measure of nonsensicality exists here in the idea of a union composed entirely of warehouse workers that is somehow magically acting against the best interests of those warehouse workers.

...is this hard to believe? This happens all the time with unions. Professional sports unions fall for this all the time, most notably Major League Baseball and the National Football League. The former butchered their negotiations so bad in the last Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) that they screwed themselves out of hundreds of millions of dollars due to their own ineptitude and the latter settled a concussion lawsuit that didn't require ownership to admit that they negligently and criminally lied about the safety (or lack thereof) of union members at their job.

Unions regularly act against their own interests; rarely do they have legal/arbitration representation nearly as good as ownership, and this is only one factor that causes it. Oftentimes they have leadership that prioritizes the needs of the few (seniority) over the needs of the many, or are just outright corrupt.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by yial on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:33AM (#18147578)
NEA has some great negotiators depending on the state. But of course they do hire lawyers and people to represent for bargaining.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by bradleyjg on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:00PM (#18136203)
The fallacy in your reasoning is that there is a unitary “interests of those warehouse workers”.

Collective decision making and fiduciary duties are directly contrary to each other but unions are supposed to feature both. The way the circle is squared is that unions don’t in fact represent all their members’ interests, only those of 50% + 1.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by etatoby on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:52PM (#18137055)
> only those of 50% + 1

If only! In reality, long-living unions create such a layered bureaucratic structure that they don't represent most workers in most matters anymore (case in point: unions in Italy, since decades ago when they were protected by law.)

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by whatever1 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:06PM (#18136231)
51% is still much more than the 5% that management represents.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by confounded on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:54PM (#18137062)
In my (limited, biased) experience the primary interest of workers is the same everywhere.

Hint: it pays off both mortgages and bar tabs.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by ALittleLight on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:30AM (#18137414)
I think the disagreement is that a new worker who is skilled and hard working wants compensation to be based on output. An older worker who has been there for awhile wants compensation to be based on seniority. Workers with big families and medical problems want better benefits while single healthy folks want more cash. The disagreements are that different people want different things.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by TangoTrotFox on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:24AM (#18138085)
Consider politics. We, citizens, elect other citizens to represent us in office. Is it nonsensical to then suggest that these citizens we voluntarily choose to elect are not acting in the best interests of those that put them into office? The problem is a typical one. The vast majority of people are motivated by their own intimate interests. Elevate them to power and that not only becomes even more true, but their interests also change.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by angry_octet on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:00AM (#18137303)
Traditionally the way it has played out is that casual workers are screwed in favour of permanents (who are more likely to be union members). The company saves on wages overall but some employees get better wages. And of course corrupt kickbacks to prevent industrial action, aka a protection racket.

There can be multiple unions too, and inter-union conflict. Some of the unions are very right wing (hate gays and women basically) and have e.g. opposed paid maternity leave in a zero sum game approach.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by angry_octet on Thursday October 04, 2018 @03:01AM (#18137790)
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by etatoby on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:49PM (#18137027)
> This union exists to grow itself and for no other reason.

This is the case for most unions in Italy, for example, where their existence is protected by law. It's a very sad state of affairs.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by rincebrain on Thursday October 04, 2018 @02:51AM (#18137753)
Their existence is almost always protected by law in e.g. the US, but de facto and de jure are not the same thing, and as with many relationships involving asymmetric power, the risk/reward and burden of proof may be too high to justify the actual legal case about illegal actions versus quietly settling things for more/less than you would have originally earned, but with much reduced legal fees.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by confounded on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:51PM (#18137045)
To be fair, it sounds like your brother is dealing with ‘the other end’ of the union. He’s not necessarily supposed to think it’s a great idea.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by bg4 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:46PM (#18136122)
> a large push by two folks who are no longer there

Did they work for the union? Off to the next warehouse to liberate?

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by empath75 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @07:43PM (#18135766)
> There are guys that my brother would love to promote

Manager complains about unions. I’m absolutely stunned.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by sethammons on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @07:49PM (#18135799)
Does that make the account no longer valid? His problem is not "lazy union members," he has folks he thinks are getting screwed over that he would fight for a promotion for.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by crooked-v on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:36PM (#18136077)
And yet presumably the union would be quite happy with across-the-board raises, so the complaint tries to casually gloss over the implied conflict with management about who deserves a more limited supply of raises.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by DannyBee on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:09PM (#18136245)
I'm sorry, are you suggesting there should be no pay differentiation for performance at all?
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by crooked-v on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:25AM (#18137400)
No, I'm suggesting that management and the union seem to disagree on who exactly has the higher performance in this situation.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by Joky on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:22AM (#18138078)
The only union experience I have was that the whole concept of performance based compensation was something to fight to the teeth (in France, 12y ago). The pay structure was almost exclusively seniority-based.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by jfnixon on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:28AM (#18138102)
No, you aren’t arguing the union has a different idea who has higher performance. You are arguing the case that everyone should be paid more regardless of performance.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by crooked-v on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:16PM (#18141753)
No, I'm not. I raised the "across-the-board raises" example to point out that the union obviously would not be opposed to more money for everyone, so there must be a reason they oppose more money for only the specific people chosen by management.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by ericd on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:20PM (#18136895)
Why should the union decide who gets raises, rather than the manager whose job it is to monitor and grade the performance of his employees?
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by mnsc on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:35AM (#18137230)
Well the manager could decide that the best performance is the people who does their work and don't make a fuss. Those who go to work even when they are sick, do a little extra without expecting compensation. If you reward those "performing" employees you get everyone trying to do the same. The reward then might even be very small but it would be presented as "this year the general pay increase will be 0.69%, but you have broken your back for the company so you will get almost double that, 1.18%". Just to create a divide and something to strive for. Im aware that this is the American Way and as a swede we value the collective more, as a culture. But a divide work force is an obedient work force.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by jazzdev on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:28PM (#18141349)
When it comes to Swedish soccer players, it looks like the top players are valued 5x more than the average.

Source: https://www.statista.com/statistics/867492/leading-swedish-n...

I worked with a software team once where the manager let the team divide up the raise pool. And they didn't divide it evenly. There was consensus about who deserved more each year. Of course that could still be a cultural value of working long hours or working when sick.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by lovich on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:50PM (#18137033)
If the management gets to decide who gets raises, why wouldn't they give it to themselves. You've never seen companies do layoffs right before the end of the quarter so management can get raises, and then immediately go on a hiring spree when the new quarter starts so they can get the work done again?
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by ericd on Thursday October 04, 2018 @02:07PM (#18142168)
I haven't, that sounds like a massive waste of time and energy, so those managers are doing a very bad job if their goal is to get stuff done. Most well functioning companies that I've seen act very much the opposite. I could believe that some companies are crappy enough to do that, though.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by lovich on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:40PM (#18144314)
Their goal isn't to get stuff done. No one in management other than maybe founder's have a goal to get stuff done. Their goal is to make money and getting stuff done is one possible way to do that. Well run companies manage to properly align the interests of the company and the management and the workers all towards those same goals.

A lot of companies are not well run

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by davidwparker on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:53PM (#18136763)
He's talking about a promotion. Presumably, that would come with a raise. But not every member of the union would be "promoted".
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by crooked-v on Thursday October 04, 2018 @01:28AM (#18137407)
I think you missed my point, which is that management and the union seem to disagree on who exactly most deserves a promotion.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by ekianjo on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @07:56PM (#18135849)
if unions were not actively trying to sabotage their own companies most of the time, maybe the sentiment would be different. There are several cases when unions actively push to destroy companies just to get short term benefits.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by aerotwelve on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:04PM (#18136525)
Why would an organized labor force try to sabotage the company they work for? If their company goes bankrupt, they all lose their jobs. I've yet to see a union contract that guarantees the type of golden parachutes that executives routinely line up for themselves (and only for themselves) when their firm goes bust or they start to run for the door.

In general, when a company fails, the rank and file have to find new jobs. Executives, on the other hand, never have to work again. We observe this trend over and over again (unionized workforce or not).

Given this trend, which side is more likely to be the one that blows the whole thing up?

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by mnsc on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:41AM (#18137252)
Unions: we think we are getting screwed over and want better pay and a safe work place.

Company: that seem expensive we will shut down and move the capital to another town and try to hire people that will accept this state of affairs.

Company fails

Innocent bystander: how could the union be so evil!?

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by ntsplnkv2 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:27PM (#18136638)
Are contractors, consultants, etc also trying to "sabotage companies" by negotiating for the best possible contracts for themselves?

When businesses do it, we say "it's just business." Not when workers do, though.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by yardie on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:34PM (#18136064)
If that’s the case then please list them. I can find many more examples of executives destroying companies and employee livelihoods for short term gain.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by FridgeSeal on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:56PM (#18136173)
> There are several cases when unions actively push to destroy companies just to get short term benefits.

And there are many-fold more cases where managers and execs have ruthlessly driven companies into the ground for their own personal short term gain. That's unequivocally worse than workers trying to protect their livelihoods.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by InTheArena on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @07:19PM (#18135616)
This is not always true. For example, the union relationship with Eastern Airline, where the union decided that it was better to eventually kill the airline in exchange for a better contract today. (Reference - Hard Landing by Thomas Petzinger). Unions are yet another human organization. Like all human organizations, it in-enviably becomes about sustaining itself, and that sustaining and power structure can become as destructive as corporations themselves to individual rights when the institution is opposed to the something the individual wants or needs.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by bjourne on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:06AM (#18138021)
> the union relationship with Eastern Airline, where the union decided that it was better to eventually kill the airline in exchange for a better contract today.

Articles from the time paint a different picture. They claim it was mismanagement that caused the bankruptcy of the airline - not union intervention. See https://www.nytimes.com/1991/01/20/us/eastern-airlines-broug..., https://www.jstor.org/stable/20713006?seq=1#metadata_info_ta... or https://commons.erau.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1060&co...

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by PretzelFisch on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:52PM (#18136156)
In most cases it's best to get the money today rather then wait for a future, that may not come to exist.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by sgc on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @11:57PM (#18137076)
Kill the cow to eat, who cares about the milk of tomorrow.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by ardy42 on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:26AM (#18137190)
> Kill the cow to eat, who cares about the milk of tomorrow.

Management is often guilty of this kind of thinking, too. It's not just unions.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by Consultant32452 on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:30AM (#18137205)
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by _Codemonkeyism on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:10AM (#18138034)
(Not arguing about benefits or usefulness of unions)

As an organization unions have the same prime directive as every other organization, survive (and grow). One of the ways of a union to survive (and grow) is to demonstrate that it takes action and to be adversarial. So many unions tend to be adversarial. In Germany in the past especially smaller unions were highly adversarial to gain ground against larger unions in the same company ("grow").

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by wernercd on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:44PM (#18136725)
> A company doesn't become adversarial with its workforce because of unions; a company is forced to treat its workforce more as an equal because of unions.

You act like it can't be both.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by dominotw on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:02PM (#18136515)
> a company is forced to treat its workforce more as an equal because of unions.

Isn't this dream of every company to treat their workers as 'equal' interchangeable cogs. Union is co conspirator in this scheme, turn all workers into 'equals' of each other.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by rincebrain on Thursday October 04, 2018 @03:04AM (#18137795)
I believe the assertion was, rather than equal in the sense of interchangable, that it is a counterweight to the inherent asymmetry of a large body (company or otherwise) and any individual worker trying to negotiate.

In that case, absent other constraints, one party usually has much less reason to accommodate than the other, as not hiring or continuing to employ one worker rarely would deeply impact the company, while the individual is looking at {continuing to commit, committing} a good portion of their available time, along with possibly relocating and however their income is derived, and so has much more to potentially lose by trying to receive even minor concessions.

(Footnote: Not all companies necessarily desire their employees be cogs, as some level of {competition,contention} can result in much better outcomes than any of the parties might have achieved on their own, but there is increasingly a sense that some portion of labor will be ever more readily automated with, indeed, fairly literal interchangeable parts, as well as the historical perception you describe, which can yield incredibly toxic cultures that don't care because they can, more or less, train more people whenever someone burns out or leaves because they find something better. )

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by jungturk on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:07PM (#18136542)
Codetermination seems to work well in Germany. Employees and shareholders are both represented on the board and perhaps that allows better negotiation and less adversity?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codetermination_in_Germany

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by Spooky23 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @06:25PM (#18135332)
Most of the unsolvable adversarial issues are related to the inconsistent legal framework, various holes pinched in labor law and the constant threat of closure.

A place like Boeing is really a government employer in disguise and has entirely different dynamics.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by stephengillie on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @05:44PM (#18135106)
This is how grocery unions (like UFCW) operate. There isn't a lot of debate about health and safety, mostly thanks to government agencies. Most of what the union does is operate the health insurer, and push for pay raises & fewer pay scale steps.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by irrational on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @06:45PM (#18135442)
Are unions anti universal healthcare? It seems like they would be since it would be one less thing they could negotiate about.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by egypturnash on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @06:56PM (#18135491)
No longer having to beg the bosses for healthcare would mean they could spend their time and energy pressing the bosses for other concessions.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by InTheArena on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @07:21PM (#18135628)
They were in the Obamacare debate. Unions fought like hell against the Cadillac care provisions because it did in fact limit health care.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by HarryHirsch on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:56PM (#18136178)
What drove the costs of the "Cadillac plans" up was that the members worked in injury-prone industries, i.e. fishing, construction &c. The benefits weren't particularly rich. Small wonder that the unions in those industries would come out against provisions that would penalize their members for working in their line of work.

There's plenty of things wrong with US unions, but opposition of fishermen to Obamacare isn't amongst them.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:42PM (#18136715)
"Cadillac care" provisions are in no way related to universal healthcare. They are a tax on healthcare plans that are more expensive than some threshold, intended to drive down the cost of healthcare plans by steering companies away from the really high-end plans.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by crooked-v on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:39PM (#18136093)
Obamacare is very, very far from universal healthcare. A more accurate comparison would be Medicare For All, which has broad support from a variety of unions.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by chris11 on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:07PM (#18136544)
I thought a complaint was that Obamacare introduced a tax on health care plans that were unusually generous.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by InTheArena on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:12PM (#18152733)
Which unions were asking to be exempted from. Hence my comment.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by bsder on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @05:53PM (#18135164)
> But it also means the company becomes very adversarial with their work-force

This is due to a combination of lack of social safety net and lack of worker representation.

In the places where unions are noted for being "good", the government covers the social safety net and workers unions are given board seats as well as stock.

This keeps everybody's goals aligned.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by dantheman on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @06:28PM (#18135345)
Public sector unions are notoriously bad.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by TheCoelacanth on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:43PM (#18136722)
For real or according to anti-union propaganda?
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by compcoffee on Thursday October 04, 2018 @07:16AM (#18138851)
>For real or according to anti-union propaganda?

For real. Unlike private sector unions, the people that the unions ares negotiating against are politicians, who have no real incentive to push back. "I'll grant your raises, you vote me back in, then I can grant more raises". The incentives are messed up.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by bsder on Friday October 05, 2018 @02:45AM (#18146182)
Given my description, why in the world would you jump to public sector unions in the US instead of trades unions in Germany? (which is what I was describing)

You might want to do a bit more research into actual unions around the world rather than simply regurgitating propaganda.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by DasIch on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @05:48PM (#18135125)
Before you abandon the idea of unions, you should keep in mind that the situation in regards to unions in the US is fucked up in a rather unique way.

So a much less radical approach of simply copying what other countries do, should work just fine much more reliably.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by rm_-rf_slash on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @05:57PM (#18135182)
The relationship between labor and management/capital has historically been adversarial in the United States.

We can’t just adopt the laws from countries with good labor relations like Germany or Denmark and expect the culture to follow.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by int_19h on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:23PM (#18136612)
The relationship between labor and management/capital has historically been adversarial in all countries, in many cases much more so than US. I mean, US didn't have an attempted socialist revolution, for one - several European countries did.

And yet they developed a working system involving unions out of it all. There's no reason why we can't, too.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by lovich on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:05AM (#18137107)
America didn't get their socialist revolution because the companies and government brutally suppressed every rebellion and even basic strikes. America as a government and capitalist society has been actively against unions since forever, and in the past few decades they've convinced workers to be against unionizing as well

-https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Corn_Rebellion

This one on Blair mountain was big -https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Blair_Mountain

Veterans wanting to get paid in less than 20 years of waiting, so why not beat and shoot them? -https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonus_Army

Just the history of union busting here -https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_union_busting_in_...

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by int_19h on Thursday October 04, 2018 @09:13PM (#18144963)
My point is precisely that there were numerous violently suppressed socialist revolutions in Europe, on a scale far greater than anything that had ever happened in the USA:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutions_of_1917%E2%80%9319...

Any government is going to violently suppress a revolution (or cease to exist immediately). The difference is that there wasn't even an attempt at a socialist revolution in US. The labor movement here was mostly focused on labor rights, not on the broader politics of class struggle. Radical socialists and communists within the movement were never numerous enough to organize a revolution.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by lovich on Friday October 05, 2018 @08:25AM (#18147523)
My understanding was that America got the heads up on what would happen based on Europe's experience and was thus quicker to crack down on any sort of worker movement
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by chottocharaii on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @08:03PM (#18135907)
Try Australia.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by AngryData on Thursday October 04, 2018 @02:09PM (#18142181)
Part of the problem with unions here is the decades of anti-union lobbying which has resulted in locking in unions in place and restricting how they operate. Many places with a union now you HAVE to join and pay them and that is the end of discussion. And your voice doesn't matter for shit in the union, you are just meant to fall in step with your union leader's commands. And the structure of the unions themselves have come to resemble another profit-seeking business with a bunch of financial and business managers from outside taking over all the top positions, not former workers that rose from the ranks of workers and know the business, and then those outsiders raising management pay for themselves. If unions weren't so restricted, if talking about a new union couldn't get you fired, you could easily replace the old unions by a handful of workers freely starting their own union while opting out of the old shitty one ran by non-union workers. It would ideally light a fire under those entrenched union's positions.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by vkou on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @06:07PM (#18135242)
> But it also means the company becomes very adversarial with their work-force and spends most of its time trying to figure out how to get around the demands of the union.

Companies don't become more adversarial when they deal with a union - what happens is that the union shines some sunlight on any existing adversarial relationships.

When your boss asks you to work an extra hour without pay, and you tell him to pound sand, pointing at union rules, the union looks like a bad guy. Rolling over to his demands, because you lack union protection, is, for some reason, not considered 'adversarial.'

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by Fomite on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @09:55PM (#18136497)
This. It's only "adversarial" because now the workers are capable of being a meaningful adversary.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by tropo on Thursday October 04, 2018 @06:39PM (#18144301)
There is no need to be adversarial as long as workers have the right to leave. These are not slaves. They only stay until they can get a better deal (pay, respect, safety...) elsewhere.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by vkou on Friday October 05, 2018 @01:40PM (#18150081)
Workers derive 100% of their income and survival from their employer. Employers dervie some sub-percentage point of their income and survival from any one worker.

Unions level the playing field. Now, both sides have to negotiate from an even position - neither can do without the other.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by burfog on Friday October 05, 2018 @10:55PM (#18153239)
That isn't a level playing field with an even position. The employer can't get other employees (due to union-favoring laws) but the employees can get other employment. The closest thing the employer has to "get other employees" is to shut down the workplace, possibly outsourcing to a different country.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by vkou on Sunday October 07, 2018 @03:57AM (#18159379)
> The employer can't get other employees

Yes, they can. They can just close down the branch in question, and re-open two months later. Why do you think Wal-mart is so successful at union-busting?

Or, they could actually negotiate on an equal basis with the union.

> employees can get other employment

Collectively? For an employer that's big enough, this is not at all the case. Their industry may not be able to absorb them, individuals within the union may not be able to handle the interruption in pay, etc. This is also why striking is used as a last resort.

> The closest thing the employer has to "get other employees" is to shut down the workplace, possibly outsourcing to a different country.

Trying to find another job is very similar to what you've just described. You cut yourself off from your stream of income, and often have to relocate to a different city, or country, at great personal expense.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by burfog on Sunday October 07, 2018 @06:47AM (#18159940)
Temporary shutdown is likely to attract trouble from the federal government.

I forgot to mention that there is something deeply wrong with the presumption that employees (or their union) should be able to negotiate on an equal basis. They didn't risk their money to found the business. They don't own it, and shouldn't own it, because they didn't put up the funds to create it.

It doesn't belong to you. It's not yours. Do not perform a mugging.

Sure, employees want to negotiate from a position of equality or strength, but wanting something doesn't mean you deserve it or get it. To them we must say: find your own business idea and venture capital, and work hard for years with the possibility of losing everything.

Most businesses fail. Most of them fail quickly, causing painful losses. Nobody would bother if they didn't have a chance to get lots of money and power. We need people to bother, because this creates jobs.

Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by jostmey on Wednesday October 03, 2018 @10:32PM (#18136669)
Unions are probably a good thing in general. But unions can become monopolies and perhaps such unions need to be busted up
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by Consultant32452 on Thursday October 04, 2018 @12:37AM (#18137239)
Unions are good for the union members most of the time, and generally bad for everyone else: shareholders, management, customers, etc. I'm not saying that's bad, that's the most obvious position for the union to take, to maximize benefit for itself at the cost of everything else. We don't seem to have any problem acknowledging that corporations do this, but unions, while not technically corporations, operate largely like one.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by ugh123 on Thursday October 04, 2018 @03:58AM (#18137987)
And please, oh please, add in an a high bar of performance. Many non-trade unions are notorious for dwindling down quality of work output.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by baq on Thursday October 04, 2018 @04:14AM (#18138056)
unions should be for labor what HR is for the company - a single force with a comparatively large negotiating power instead of a thousand individual non-professional negotiators. it doesn't always look like this and this is a problem that unions have.
Re:Amazon Warehouse Workers Lose Bonuses, Stock Awards for R... by gaius on Thursday October 04, 2018 @02:14AM (#18137585)
I feel like the concept of unions needs to be rejiggered for the modern era

This is very much a cultural thing. A German union for example ensures that Workers get their fair share but understands that the company must be profitable and successful first - they know not to kill the goose that lays the golden eggs. Whereas unions in the UK immediately try to destroy a company to prove a point about capitalism, union bosses are lavishly paid, and the Workers are mere pawns, in some cases even actively working against their members wishes. That’s why Germany has a strong auto industry and we do not.