News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by the6threplicant on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @08:44AM (#17967967)
A comment from someone who has actually read the article: https://np.reddit.com/r/ukpolitics/comments/9ely8y/why_the_w...

For example:

...the EFF argue that the idea of what constitutes a link is not fully defined. I'm not sure what they're talking about. Recitals 31-36 set out the concepts in article 11, fairly clearly. They make it clear that what is being protected is substantial or harmful copying of significant portions of the text. They also make it clear what organisations this will affect - press organisations - with a fairly clear description of what a press organisation might constitute. (FWIW, memes are not covered, and anyone you hear talking about "banning memes" is getting their news from very poor sources.)

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by dannyobrien on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:59AM (#17969431)
(Disclosure -- I work on this for EFF)

You can read the recitals this commenter is describing here, including the latest amendments that were voted in the Parliamentary plenary. As you'd imagine, I disagree with his interpretation.

https://juliareda.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/Copyright_Se...

Firstly, these are just recitals. They're not a binding part of the Directive, they just lay out the justifications for the law.

If you do read the listed recitals, they mention links once, and don't define the term at all. When they do, the context is that "the act of hyperlinking" is not protected (ie the new ancillary right does not explicitly cover the act of hyperlinking).

This is an attempt to refute an argument that no-one is making (though the language echoes a previous fight that rightsholders are still pursuing, which is links to infringing content should be punished as strongly as hosting content itself. That's what the "communication to the public" is about, and has been ongoing, but that's another story.)

The concern over Article 11 isn't that it would criminalise linking to a news item; it's that if you use any text of an article, including its title, you can be sued or made to sign a license. Such snippets of text are usually used when linking to a news article, especially when you're doing it automatically, so that's where the threat to linking to stories.

A couple of other things to note in these amendments. One of the earlier arguments as to why Article 11 isn't so bad we heard is that there are already exemptions in copyright for quotation and critical review. We argued that under EU law, these exemptions are entirely optional at the national level, and news publishers will lobby to limit the effect of them on this new IP right. If you look at the amendment for Recital 34, this is now being explicitly set up to happen: the Recital now says that member states can apply these exceptions, instead of should.

Just because the recitals aren't law, doesn't mean you can't use them to better understand the motives and justifications of the drafters.

As others have noted, the "banning memes" line is about Article 13. An amendment proposed by a Parliamentary committee to create a "fair use"-style exception for user-generated content, specifically to protect remixes and memes, was struck down in today's vote.

By contrast, an entirely new provision that gave organizers of sports events complete ownership of the IP rights to their games was voted in. https://juliareda.eu/2018/09/copyright-sports-fans/

Basically, this directive remains an IP maximalists' dream. A bunch of new IP rights, some of which only apply online, with clear signals that they should be interpreted as broadly as possible.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by bjelkeman-again on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @05:28PM (#17973559)
> it's that if you use any text of an article, including its title, you can be sued or made to sign a license.

This seems a great place to use automated translation technology, but into the same language. Link to the news article, but rewrite it using a similar meaning, with different words.

(I am an EU citizen and I think this is major overreach by the legislator who thinks they are saving the newspapers, but have no clue as to what effect they will have on the current system, but it still will not save the papers.)

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Guvante on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:00PM (#17974277)
News articles are written with the understanding that the reader could stop reading at any time so information is put as early as possible. This applies especially to the title which is used as the very first filter for user interest. Requiring rewriting titles is a bad idea as you are never in an automated fashion going to make a better title.

As an example note that this very website heavily prefers the original title for the link text, only changing it when substantial updates are made or the original title is heavily biased.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Whitestrake on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @08:57PM (#17975020)
> Requiring rewriting titles is a bad idea as you are never in an automated fashion going to make a better title.

Depends on how you define "better".

I would argue that a rewritten title you can read is "better" than an un-rewritten title you can't read because the site couldn't "link" it without risking a lawsuit or signing an agreement.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by saurik on Thursday September 13, 2018 @12:52AM (#17976151)
That is like claiming you can re-publish someone else's book if you translate it to Spanish or just replace all of the words with synonyms: you are creating a derivative work and are still using the original.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by bjelkeman-again on Thursday September 13, 2018 @11:04AM (#17979164)
Not really. That is a huge differences.

Original title: Hurricane Florence’s Path: Winds of Category 2 Storm Hit Carolina Coast

Alternat title for the link: Hurricane Florence hit Carolina coat, category two

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/13/us/hurricane-florence-pat...

Would that really be the same as translating someone’s book? I’d argue that if I can’t do this then I can’t link at all (without paying a license) and that breaks the web. Which I realise is the argument against the legislstion, but I don’t think is the intent, albeit that the intent is shortsighted.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by majewsky on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:16PM (#17974392)
> the language echoes a previous fight that rightsholders are still pursuing, which is links to infringing content should be punished as strongly as hosting content itself.

There was a story in a similar direction a few years back: A state court in Hamburg decided that when you set a link to some other website, you have to check whether that website contains any illegal content.

The fine journalists at Heise wanted to link to the verdict, and because they are law-abiding citizens, they inquired with the court if they can guarantee that all content on the court website was legal. The request was denied.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by cge on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @06:17PM (#17973974)
Article 11 point 2(a) also mentions hyperlinking, at least in the version linked from the EU press release (http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=-//EP//...).
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by JAlexoid on Friday September 14, 2018 @02:34PM (#17989660)
> I work on this for EFF > Firstly, these are just recitals. They're not a binding part of the Directive, they just lay out the justifications for the law.

Have you ever been in a courtroom in EU? Explanations for the laws are guides to judges to rule on the laws. Judges cannot go against the explanation and apply just the technical bit, their decisions will be overturned 100%.

Sure... This directive is hardly perfect, but it's also only the first step in the process.

When it comes to can vs should, you should know that both are optional. And copyright groups do try to limit the multiple exemptions from copyright every single day.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by PunchTornado on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @04:06PM (#17972668)
Thanks for this one. Reading about it for a while now and all I see is banning links and meme and link tax and other unreal things.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by sputr on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:44AM (#17968641)
The commenter you are quoting has not realized there are two problematic articles (11. and 13.) and that the "memes" story is for article 13 not 11.

The entire point of art. 11 is to transfer money from Google News (and other aggregators, like Facebook) to publishers. This also covers search.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by krn on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:08PM (#17970192)
> The entire point of art. 11 is to transfer money from Google News (and other aggregators, like Facebook) to publishers.

The latest version of Google News has already solved this: it only shows the title and the image, not a single sentence from the article itself, – which was the main concern in Spain and Germany when the relevant laws were introduced.

Facebook and Twitter shouldn't face any issues as well, because they only display the value of the og:description meta tag, set by the publishers themselves.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Al-Khwarizmi on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @05:06PM (#17973323)
Sadly I still can't access Google News (in the normal way) from Spain though. The notice that it's closed due to the law is still there.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Uberphallus on Thursday September 13, 2018 @06:44AM (#17977558)
This is what you get if you try to access Google News from Spain, for those curious.

https://support.google.com/news/answer/6140047?hl=es

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by sputr on Thursday September 13, 2018 @05:18AM (#17977177)
Only the URL is not covered under art. 11, everything else is.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by krn on Friday September 14, 2018 @05:31PM (#17991143)
If a publisher implements the Open Graph protocol[1], it explicitly makes the meta data of the article available to others.

[1] http://ogp.me/

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by IdiocyInAction on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:58AM (#17968807)
Why whould Google not just delist problematic sites like they did in Germany, as they tried to implement something similar there AFAIK?
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by sputr on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:08AM (#17968913)
We've been asking the proponents that for months.

Google got a free license in Germany while Yahoo did not. Even if they ban the free license (which is a whole nother set of even bigger problems) Google can just not list them at all. It's not like they care about Google News all that much.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by simias on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:15AM (#17968972)
I agree that this is probably going to backfire spectacularly but if we give the proponents the benefit of the doubt it could be argued that while the big G might not care about Google News, users may. If these news aggregator shutdown they will look for alternatives which might create an opportunity for people to develop news aggregator that share the revenue more fairly with the newspapers. I doubt this is going to happen but I suppose it might sound right for people who are not deeply familiar with the way the internet works.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @02:04PM (#17971372)
> If these news aggregator shutdown they will look for alternatives which might create an opportunity for people to develop news aggregator that share the revenue more fairly with the newspapers.

The problem is, what revenue? News aggregation is not a huge profit center to begin with. Then you take that already-small amount of money and split it between thousands of independent news organizations, each of which requires its own transaction costs, and the transaction costs sink the whole enterprise.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @06:54PM (#17974253)
And it's not like my news app can't make 50 http requests to do good-enough aggregation itself, for free.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by ivanhoe on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @04:11PM (#17972709)
Well, radio stations don't earn a lot either, but still have to pay licence fees for the music they play. Perhaps some sort of flat fee paid based on some statistics how much content has been shared from which source would make sense. It will not be a huge money, but it's still better than no money at all. Aggregators/ search engines need the content produced at the volume, otherwise they'll be out of business too at some point, so it can be mutually benefitial.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by nostrademons on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @06:04PM (#17973878)
80% of radio stations in the U.S. are owned by one company (iHeartMedia, formerly ClearChannel), and despite this monopoly negotiating power, the company is still operating out of Chapter 11 bankruptcy with a $20B debt load.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by lionsdan on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:33PM (#17974536)
> 80% of radio stations in the U.S. are owned by one company(iHeartMedia, formerly ClearChannel)

They own the most, but it's not 80% (perhaps they cover 80% of listening markets). They own about 850 stations[1] out of roughly 10,000 commercial stations[2]. However, your point does stand as the second largest owner, Cumulus Media at 455 stations also filed for bankruptcy[3].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IHeartMedia [2] https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-352168A1.pdf [3] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/15/business/media/iheartmedi...

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by nostrademons on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:36PM (#17974561)
I think they must've divested some either in the bankruptcy or a previous restructuring, because the figure I saw was about 1250 stations. I'd bet that the 10,000 total stations also includes a bunch of mom & pop or college radio operations as well; maybe the statistic was for 80% of audience share rather than number of stations.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by BryanBigs on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:05PM (#17975363)
If I remember correctly, they built most of that debt load buying up all those stations. Rado stations aren't money losers. Loading up leverage to 12x cash flow on junk debt to buy stations, on the other hand...
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by cortesoft on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @05:40PM (#17973675)
Radio stations make the little that money they do because they are using a limited resource- spectrum. That is not the case on the Internet.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Eridrus on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:39AM (#17969207)
Has this happened in Spain? They've already done this experiment on a smaller scale.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by sputr on Thursday September 13, 2018 @05:19AM (#17977179)
Google simply shutdown it's operation there.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by throwawayjava on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:01AM (#17968839)
The last time I read about these regulations, it sounded like they would explicitly forbid this sort of arrangement between publishers and aggregators (i.e., news sites aren't allowed to agree to those terms). I don't have time to check right now, but that may be the case.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by merb on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:29AM (#17969110)
> it sounded like they would explicitly forbid this sort of arrangement between publishers and aggregators

and than, should they force google to pay instead of cutting these publishers off? in no way would that be legal. you can't force somebody to pay something, by forcing them to obey.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by paulddraper on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:41AM (#17969883)
Yes, you'd like to think it's a free market.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by merb on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:20PM (#17970310)
well google in the end can just shutdown google news.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by geezerjay on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @01:26PM (#17971010)
> well google in the end can just shutdown google news.

That's the expected (and fair) outcome. To be fair, why should a multinational be entitled to profit from unauthirized access and distribution of third-party content while the content creators are left with the bill of creating it?

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @01:54PM (#17971243)
News organizations provide a service (news reporting). News aggregators provide a service (news aggregation). Why shouldn't they both get paid?

Why should news organizations be entitled to profit from unauthorized access and distribution of third-party content while the creators are left with the bill of creating it? Shouldn't they be paying the celebrities they gossip about for doing all the "noteworthy" things they do and giving them something to drive readership with?

The obvious flaw is that it's a symbiotic relationship. News organizations want traffic from Google in the way that celebrities and companies and politicians want news coverage (in the "no such thing as bad press" sense). They see Google's market cap and think they're making all this money, but the money isn't from news aggregation. That's peanuts. And if you're making a dime and they're making a nickel and you demand a dollar more, you don't get a dollar more, you get a dime less.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by geezerjay on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @06:48PM (#17974210)
> News organizations provide a service (news reporting). News aggregators provide a service (news aggregation). Why shouldn't they both get paid?

That's a good question, and it seems to me that's the whole point of this legislation.

Currently there is a mega-multinational company which posts record profits for services that consist of scraping and unauthorized distribution of third-party content, and in a manner that even eliminates any traffic from the content creator's site.

So in the current state of affairs only the scraper gets paid, and the content creators are left with the bill.

How is that fair?

> Why should news organizations be entitled to profit from unauthorized access and distribution of third-party content while the creators are left with the bill of creating it?

For some reason you've invented this silly idea that researching and developing a newspiece is, somehow, the same as scraping websites.

I'm sure that we can agree that journalism and web scraping have nothing in common, just like xeroxing a book is not the same thing as writing a novel.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:16PM (#17974394)
> So in the current state of affairs only the scraper gets paid, and the content creators are left with the bill.

Googlebot respects robots.txt. Anyone who doesn't want to be indexed, isn't. For some reason they still seem to want to be.

> I'm sure that we can agree that journalism and web scraping have nothing in common, just like xeroxing a book is not the same thing as writing a novel.

What do you mean? It's basically the same thing. When a reporter interviews some guy, they put his words in their story -- without compensation. How is that fair?

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @06:58PM (#17974269)
> and in a manner that even eliminates any traffic from the content creator's site

Not true at all. They actually increase traffic. https://www.zdnet.com/article/the-google-news-effect-spain-r...

And you seem to have developed your own silly idea that quoting one or two sentences of a news piece is the same as xeroxing it.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by adrianN on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @03:29PM (#17972278)
Last time I checked the news companies put their articles online for anyone to read. I don't see how Google isn't authorized to access the content. I'm pretty sure they follow robots.txt. If the news companies can't make money from people reading their articles, maybe they should just stop putting them online.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by singularity2001 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @05:11PM (#17973379)
Or they should push for MICROPAYMENT which would change the whole internet (for better or worse).
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by CuriousSkeptic on Thursday September 13, 2018 @08:19AM (#17977988)
How? Without thinking too deep about it (so curious) wouldn’t a micropayment economy look exactly like the likes/views/engagement economy, only, perhaps distributed? What I mean, the change of currency doesn magically solve the problem on how to detect and promote actual value and then organize people into funding that instead of the next shit determined by an algorithm to catch your attention
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by singularity2001 on Thursday September 13, 2018 @09:11AM (#17978298)
If you had a micro-wallet in your browser and could unlock 5cent articles etc with just a click it would be a boon for content producers.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by DoreenMichele on Thursday September 13, 2018 @09:17AM (#17978341)
You can make pennies per article with adsense ads at no direct cost to your audience and people use ad blocker rampantly. You can also use PayPal to give as little as a dollar. I have sites with PayPal tip jars. When people tip, they rarely leave only one dollar. Those that tip usually are more generous than that.

I'm quite convinced that people wanting micropayments to be solved are pretty much like friends who say they would give you money if they won the lottery. In other words, these are people who just don't want to do anything for you, but don't want to admit to that. So they latch onto some implausible scenario and enthusiastically swear up and down that should lightening strike, they will absolutely do X, knowing the odds are very long against that happening.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by CuriousSkeptic on Thursday September 13, 2018 @03:47PM (#17981823)
But why would you spend effort on quality content, the same public getting manipulated into consuming crap in exchange for their time would just as happily waste their “micro money” on the same crap
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by ratacat on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:44PM (#17975548)
Found the crypto nerd!
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by paulddraper on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @02:16PM (#17971490)
> unauthirized access and distribution of third-party content

Are you referring to wholesale reproduction of the content?

Or hyperlinks and short excerpts?

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by EpicEng on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @05:36PM (#17973636)
>unauthirized access

How exactly is it "unauthorized"?

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Tharkun on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:41AM (#17969882)
Next thing you'll have to pay publishers because you read their RSS feed in a self hosted aggregator.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by dvfjsdhgfv on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:03AM (#17969480)
> The entire point of art. 11 is to transfer money from Google News (and other aggregators, like Facebook) to publishers. This also covers search.

Honestly, it doesn't seem a bad thing to me. But lat's see how Google plays it out.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by dnautics on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:11AM (#17969556)
You don't think this will eventually come to screw the little guy?
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by vkou on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:31AM (#17969763)
Who is the little guy, and why are we optimizing for him, instead of making the world better for everyone?

I mean, I think the link tax is backwards, but a vague emotional appeal to the health of... a mom and pop internet news site...(?) is not the argument I'd use.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by gnulinux on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:03PM (#17970149)
Internet is supposed to be THE free platform a mom and pop internet news site can prosper. You are, at this very moment, here in HN, in a mom and pop internet news site.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by rrcaptain on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:17PM (#17970273)
Are you joking? HN is owned by YCombinator, one of the most powerful companies in the Valley. If it's Mom and Pop, than so is Mitt Romney's hedgefund.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by adventured on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:30PM (#17970439)
Nothing fundamentally has changed about HN as Y Combinator has become more successful over time. Your premise pretends that both HN's long-term and initial success rests on the present riches of Y Combinator - that's false.

HN runs on one server and is moderated by just a couple of people typically. It is in fact the definition of a mom & pop operation. It does not have a zillion dollar budget, either for operations or promoting itself. It doesn't need it, the value proposition is the content, community and standards.

I can semi-trivially set up an HN clone for any given industry or concept. It'll be up to me to promote it and garner attention to it, however the point is that it's extremely inexpensive and easy (few regulations, hurdles, compliance issues, etc) to open up that type of expression platform. That's what the parent is referring to.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by rrcaptain on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:34PM (#17975207)
Mom & Pop, by definition, refers to the ownership of the medium. Not how many people work on it.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by gnulinux on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @01:42PM (#17971132)
It's not about who the mom is, or whether she is a billionaire. HN is read mostly by tech workers, which is probably not more than 5% of US population and probably less than 1% of internet users. These numbers are out of my ass, but is there any indication that HN is mainstream media? HN is a niche media like my sister's blog.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by yurishimo on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @06:40PM (#17974160)
I think 1% of the USA is generous. We're talking about mostly programmers and software engineers here. I doubt the level 2 tech support at Comcast is reading HN, much less any significant percentage all IT workers.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Multicomp on Thursday September 13, 2018 @06:58AM (#17977624)
FWIW I'm closer to the L2 Comcast tech than programmer and I was introduced to HN by my dad, a DBA. I thought HN was for the intellectually curoius, not just the coders and programmers of the Valley?
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by DoreenMichele on Thursday September 13, 2018 @07:02AM (#17977633)
I was homeless for nearly 6 years and an active participant. I'm also not a programmer, though I have a Certificate in GIS and, these, days, make part of my money as a "webmaster."

There are a lot of IT people here. This, unfortunately, sometimes convinces some individuals that that's all there is here, which is an inaccurate assumption.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by rrcaptain on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:32PM (#17975197)
Niche yes, but mainstream (like mom and pop) refers to the ownership of the medium. And HN is owned by one of Silicon Valley's most powerful firms.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by singularity2001 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @05:13PM (#17973403)
relative niche maybe. your sisters blog? you must be joking (or Obama).
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by vkou on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @01:30PM (#17971059)
> Internet is supposed to be THE free platform a mom and pop internet news site can prosper.

The internet has the attention economy, which follows a power law of popularity, with a long tail of unpopular content that has <50 readers. I would not consider that 'prosperous'.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by syn0byte on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:48AM (#17969965)
Optimize for the little guy so there can be growth. "Better for everyone" is stasis because "everyone" includes all the people that already have disproportional slices of pie.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by geezerjay on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @12:53PM (#17970708)
To be fair, google and the like have been living off scraping third-party content and making it available in a way that only the scrapers see any traffic from that content, thus earn anything that is there to be earned.

In this scenario, I'm not sure if society should encourage little mom and pop scrapers to spawn while leaving the people who actually created the content with any way to protect their work.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by candiodari on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @01:43PM (#17971136)
The problem is that people don't want what (most of) the newspaper publishers are offering, they want smaller, broader, differently curated summaries of that.

"Publishers" (newspapers) are 99% simply reprinting news they get from "the wire" (Reuters for example, or Bloomberg, or ...), or a few wire services. One way to look at Facebook and Google News is that they are better versions of these wires, available for end users of the content instead of just paying subscribers (Reuters' wire is a subscription service)

The way it works is this: let's say I feel the need to put out a press release. I have an employee write the news (heavily favoring me) and "put out the press release", meaning I submit the article to a news agency [1], including image and text online, paying 35$ for the privilege of having it appear on the feeds newspapers use to put out news. This is why even the BBC is full of "researchers working for IBM have saved the world again".

There are a number of issues. Of course 99% of the news is not exactly neutral or even a little bit researched, because it's just press releases. 1% is, but is produced by reporters working for the news agencies (only huge places like BBC still have their own reporters). And Google is a lot better than even the BBC (which is very high quality) at finding and presenting press releases to the public. Hell, it's actually better at deciding the trustworthiness of them than news desks (mostly because they, for profit reasons, refuse to give humans even half an hour to check things). Furthermore, those algorithms run so cheaply that they actually provide a personalized version of the news of the day based on both your interests and the news. I assume Jeff Bezos has the same service by a newspapers, but I imagine few others do.

So the underlying issue newspapers are having is "Google automated and Facebook crowdsources what we do, and their automated algorithms are much more successful than our humans, please outlaw them".

> To be fair, google and the like have been living off scraping third-party content and making it available in a way that only the scrapers see any traffic from that content, thus earn anything that is there to be earned.

Yeah there is no value at all in having a searchable index, content summaries, and it's unfair that people get paid for that. Furthermore newspapers just use humans to do what Google news does with algorithms. Never mind that that's what people want.

And as pointed out, people see more value in the aggregated, summarized and algorithmically curated versions of the same data.

Did you ever use the phonebook ? Did it have ads or not ? Should we outlaw the phonebook too ? Did you ever use an encyclopedia or a dictionary ? Did you pay for it ?

I feel like your argument has some shortcomings.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_agency

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Natanael_L on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:47AM (#17969953)
The little guy is duckduckgo, small forums and blogs. You think it's fine to erase them from the web if they try to comment on the news?
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by tomp on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:10AM (#17969543)
It's "not bad" in the same way as communism is "not bad" - i.e. in theory, but it doesn't actually exist in practice.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by kazinator on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:12AM (#17969569)
Oh, some would say that communism is already despicable in theory alone.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by oihoaihsfoiahsf on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @09:27AM (#17968437)
I read the articles as well, and this commenter is right that, on their face, they don't seem like they would apply to a site like Google News. That said, everyone, including Google, seems to think they do. And as far as I am aware, nobody at the EC has said anything to the contrary, even though it would be easy to do so. So it seems most likely to me that the naive reading of the text is incorrect, and that both this reddit commenter and myself are missing something.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by tumetab1 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:02AM (#17968855)
Both are missing the point of how this kind of "law" works.

The wording is less relevant than the application of it. You can argue that something is outside of scope, according to the wording, and be correct while at the same time I can argue that the same is covered on how is expected to be applied.

Given my understanding of the copyright lobbying-state officials work in the EU, Google News will be covered. Why? Because news organizations having being crying for long and have strong political connections.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by quadcore on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @10:12AM (#17968947)
The thought of that happening in itself procures fears.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by pbackx on Friday September 14, 2018 @10:01AM (#17987213)
To understand article 11, I think you should look at the reason it was created: Journalists (and newspapers) are looking for a way to get paid for their articles beyond luring people to their sites with clickbait titles and tons of ads.

They want their own "article version" of Spotify, where they get a set amount for every article read. Obviously that's difficult to implement given the current way of the Internet (= Facebook sharing) and this is their attempt at getting their dream.

Is this a good idea? You could say it may improve news reporting if it was well implemented. Or it could be completely abused. Anyway, looking at it like this, explains some of the legalese in article 11.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by bcheung on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:41PM (#17974591)
The problem is it is highly subjective.

"Parliament’s text also strengthens the negotiating rights of authors and performers, by enabling them to “claim” additional remuneration from the party exploiting their rights when the remuneration originally agreed is “disproportionately” low compared to the benefits derived."

"The text adds that these benefits should include “indirect revenues”. It would also empower authors and performers to revoke or terminate the exclusivity of an exploitation licence for their work if the party holding the exploitation rights is deemed not to be exercising this right."

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by belorn on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:00AM (#17969438)
The article itself reference the acts of linking and hyperlinking without any words about "significant portions of the text". I would like to see some support to the claim that "what is being protected is substantial or harmful copying of significant portions of the text".

In particular, the phrase "This protection does not extend to acts of hyperlinking which do not constitute communication to the public." It is all over the text and amendments. What is the exact legal effect of that?

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Aeolun on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:17AM (#17969611)
I assume it means linking on your intranet is not prohibited.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by akerro on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:11AM (#17969558)
Not really, every meme will be a subject to legal actions like Grumpy Cat Limited https://www.catster.com/the-scoop/grumpy-cat-legal-settlemen...
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by zavi on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @11:56AM (#17970075)
News are mostly clickbait cancer anyways, if this is the final nail in their coffin (if Google/Reddit/Facebook stops serving news) so be it. Tech Giants will do just fine under this, just how Chinese tech giants are able to do their own censorship.