News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @01:54PM (#17971243)
News organizations provide a service (news reporting). News aggregators provide a service (news aggregation). Why shouldn't they both get paid?

Why should news organizations be entitled to profit from unauthorized access and distribution of third-party content while the creators are left with the bill of creating it? Shouldn't they be paying the celebrities they gossip about for doing all the "noteworthy" things they do and giving them something to drive readership with?

The obvious flaw is that it's a symbiotic relationship. News organizations want traffic from Google in the way that celebrities and companies and politicians want news coverage (in the "no such thing as bad press" sense). They see Google's market cap and think they're making all this money, but the money isn't from news aggregation. That's peanuts. And if you're making a dime and they're making a nickel and you demand a dollar more, you don't get a dollar more, you get a dime less.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by geezerjay on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @06:48PM (#17974210)
> News organizations provide a service (news reporting). News aggregators provide a service (news aggregation). Why shouldn't they both get paid?

That's a good question, and it seems to me that's the whole point of this legislation.

Currently there is a mega-multinational company which posts record profits for services that consist of scraping and unauthorized distribution of third-party content, and in a manner that even eliminates any traffic from the content creator's site.

So in the current state of affairs only the scraper gets paid, and the content creators are left with the bill.

How is that fair?

> Why should news organizations be entitled to profit from unauthorized access and distribution of third-party content while the creators are left with the bill of creating it?

For some reason you've invented this silly idea that researching and developing a newspiece is, somehow, the same as scraping websites.

I'm sure that we can agree that journalism and web scraping have nothing in common, just like xeroxing a book is not the same thing as writing a novel.

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @07:16PM (#17974394)
> So in the current state of affairs only the scraper gets paid, and the content creators are left with the bill.

Googlebot respects robots.txt. Anyone who doesn't want to be indexed, isn't. For some reason they still seem to want to be.

> I'm sure that we can agree that journalism and web scraping have nothing in common, just like xeroxing a book is not the same thing as writing a novel.

What do you mean? It's basically the same thing. When a reporter interviews some guy, they put his words in their story -- without compensation. How is that fair?

Re:EU approves internet copyright law, including ‘link tax’ ... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday September 12, 2018 @06:58PM (#17974269)
> and in a manner that even eliminates any traffic from the content creator's site

Not true at all. They actually increase traffic. https://www.zdnet.com/article/the-google-news-effect-spain-r...

And you seem to have developed your own silly idea that quoting one or two sentences of a news piece is the same as xeroxing it.