News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by mjevans on Friday August 17, 2018 @06:43PM (#17785919)
I think it has become abundantly clear that a fully peer to peer, encryption required (non-optional), no single central server infrastructure solution is the answer.

No points to tap.

No point in tapping the data.

If they want to capture conversations it's time to go back to the proper old ways of actually spying on high-value targets.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by apatters on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:50AM (#17787081)
This discussion should never be framed as a choice between legal solutions and technical solutions. They are complementary.

The legal approach is correct and easy for the public to understand. Explained correctly it is also popular. The government used to have to do things like get a warrant and investigate specific crimes. They couldn't listen to everyone's phone conversations all the time and they shouldn't be able to do this on the Internet either. Digital dragnets are illegal and unconstitutional.

The technical approach is also correct. If you're building something that makes it harder for criminals inside the government to commit more crimes, you're doing work that is profound and in the best interests of society. Anyone with passion and technical skill can participate in this work. It's the right thing to do.

Both efforts help each other. Keep the government in line and accountable to the people. Make it harder for people inside the government to do the wrong thing. All approaches deserve support and should leverage each other's work. They should cooperate with law-abiding, constitutionally empowered government authorities as well. There are good guys in the government too.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by speedplane on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:57AM (#17787098)
Technical and legal solutions are not complementary, they're relatively unrelated. Legal rules addressing behavior are about what we "should" do. Technical rules are about what we "can" do. Technology is about implementation and enforcement, law is about what we consider to be the correct result.

But the main place where law and tech come together is enforcement. For law to work at all, it has to be enforced relatively evenly. Technology may make a law's enforcement impossible or easy, but it does not make it more or less "right" in the abstract.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by drdaeman on Saturday August 18, 2018 @03:57AM (#17787388)
> Technical rules are about what we "can" do.

And legal is about what recourse we can seek afterwards, when we understand we've messed up the implementation and security had failed.

Relying on legal protections alone is absurd. Relying on technology without any legal recourse for failures maybe somewhat less so, but still not suitable for this "real" world we live in. Not without reconsidering our approaches and attitudes to way too many things.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by speedplane on Sunday August 26, 2018 @05:21AM (#17845053)
> And legal is about what recourse we can seek afterwards, when we understand we've messed up the implementation and security had failed.

Not at all. Legal rules are about what we "should" do, what's right and what's wrong. However, legal rules need to be enforced to be effective. If you create a legal rule that's impossible to enforce and everyone flouts it, not only does your rule not get enforced, but it also creates doubt in the entire legal system.

So legal rules ought to consult with what's possible and impossible, but they should not be dictated by them.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by tomatotomato37 on Friday August 17, 2018 @07:01PM (#17785979)
This is a case of the government trying to force Facebook to essentially strip out their technology; saying technology is the solution here is kinda ignorant of the actual issue
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by ekianjo on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:42PM (#17786600)
technology owned by a single company you can coerce is the issue.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by extralego on Saturday August 18, 2018 @03:10AM (#17787276)
I think that’s close, but until a technical solution to this comes around, we’ve got to look elsewhere.

An easy target is saying the government is too powerful. That would be a mistake. If Facebook were more powerful than the government, we would no be in any better hands.

The problems with the US government are that it does not work for the people.

It would be painfully short-sighted to say this debacle goes to show the gov and private companies are not too involved with one another. This will be handled with some deal that will deepen the coupling and citizens will not have a say. That’s how most things in our lives get handles. Without regard for us, that is.

Private interests have eroded our state of civility. Citizens voices mean nothing and that is all that’s going on here.

We need our government back. Nothing else is going to solve this, unless of course we can actually address the technical issue that you raised. That would be nice.

A government that was our government would simply not step over this line. It’s possible; not easy, but possible.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by ekianjo on Saturday August 18, 2018 @07:30AM (#17788026)
I am not sure what you are onto. People are still voting for about every election so the realization that the government is not what they wanted is not anywhere in the public psyche.

Id say it would be better to decentralize governments so that you dont have any great accumulation of power anywhere, and by bringing government closer to communities you automatically bring back power to the people.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by philipov on Saturday August 18, 2018 @09:03AM (#17788266)
Decentralizing government would not have the effect of stopping power consolidation. It just means power gets accumulated by the megacorporations, which is an even worse outcome.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by seorphates on Friday August 17, 2018 @07:07PM (#17786002)
Is it? You kind of lost me. Isn't the actual issue math?
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by madeofpalk on Friday August 17, 2018 @07:16PM (#17786036)
The issue is laws.

A country that's going to mandate backdoors/access to such communications, are going to outlaw communication methods they can't backdoor.

Say Apple makes a federated end-to-end encrypted messenger app, the government will still go to Apple and say "let us read all the messages, otherwise you can't sell your devices". THAT is the problem, and it can't be solved by more technology and shouting "BLOCKCHAIN!"

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by joe_the_user on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:30PM (#17786261)
Laws are an issue and enforceability is an issue.

If a largish group of users could create end-to-end encryption not with a single company but with "readily available materials", then stopping it could be harder.

So it's a combination of state dictate and the practical ability of users to defy that. This isn't saying I'm optimistic, I'm rather pessimistic on any ability of a wide home-grown encrypted-messaging milieu to appear - if few are aiming for this, those few can easily be picked-off. But I don't think we should just give up on any part of this.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by merinowool on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:40PM (#17786454)
Possession of encryption software could be treated the same as possession of drugs. On the next stop and search you would only had to handover your phone. If police password will not work it will be confiscated. If encryption software is found you go in the dock. It is the future. Society accepted ridiculous laws to jail people for having a plant, they'll accept jailing for programs. Only terrorists, thieves and adulterers encrypt their messages ;-)
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by realusername on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:17PM (#17786551)
> Possession of encryption software could be treated the same as possession of drugs

It's too late for that, every machine, every browser, every user is using encryption software all the time.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by Phlarp on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:23PM (#17786565)
"It's too late to criminalize prostitution, every is already having sex"

"It's too late to criminalize possession of drugs. Half the country takes pharmaceuticals!"

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by cptn_brittish on Saturday August 18, 2018 @02:51AM (#17787241)
The War on Drugs is considered a failure and in parts of the world like NSW, Australia made prostituion legal in 1979 in both cases because criminalising things most people use generally doesn't work and all you do is randomly jail people for doing the exact same thing as a large proportion of the population.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by int_19h on Saturday August 18, 2018 @04:06AM (#17787418)
Sure, it's a failure. But you can still be jailed over it.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by realusername on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:45PM (#17786607)
I fail to see the point, without encryption, there's no modern web, no e-commerce, no smartphones, absolutely everything relies on it like water. Unless you want to go back to pre-2000's technology of course.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by dingaling on Saturday August 18, 2018 @12:56AM (#17786948)
Of course e-commerce will be fine, because browser vendors will obtain licenses to ship TLS modules and as a condition of such will include the .gov root cert.

It's trivial when you can pass arbitrary legislation.

Back in the 90s we had to deal with US gov restrictions on encryption export. Software companies and organisations fell into line. It was a big deal when 128-bit keyed Netscape became available globally in 1997, per State Dept approval, but even then the full-strength server-side SSL was still restricted to 'approved' entities.

And even 56-bit server SSL was only exportable with us.gov key escrow.

I used to use Apache with the 40-bit SSL option. Pathetic strength but no-one was going to risk jail-time by breaking laws.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by paulie_a on Saturday August 18, 2018 @09:42AM (#17788407)
< no one was going to risk jail time

I did at that time, it was just another law to ignore.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by lallysingh on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:18AM (#17786991)
The difference being that there's way too much necessary legitimate use of cryptography to stop now, and as the traffic is encrypted, you can't tell what traffic isn't legitimate. Plus steganography and plenty of places accessible on the net that aren't the United States.

This isn't meatspace, the dynamics are quite different.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by merinowool on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:36PM (#17789560)
There is nothing you cannot legislate for. For example use of encryption could be licensed, just as drugs are. If you don't have prescription, you go down.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by joe_the_user on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:08PM (#17786530)
Possession of encryption software could be treated the same as possession of drugs.

Well, then clearly it would quickly become ubiquitous. I mean, if a war on encryption that was just like the war on drugs were to be launched, why my local stream bed might "place burned passwords here" on the tin-can that currently reads "used needles here." (put there by the other homeless people).

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by croshan on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:30PM (#17786428)
And who would use that system, if it were so closely associated with status as a federal criminal?

You're forgetting that the average user doesn't care enough to sacrifice ease of use for greater political benefit.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by ethbro on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:46PM (#17786473)
There's a difference between running a Tor exit node and encrypting a personal conversation.

At least in the US, if a US citizen is part of a potentially incriminating conversation, the government's going to have a hard time forcing a court to force the citizen to decrypt the conversation.

Lawyers, correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like a conversation wouldn't be subject to the vagaries of "combination to a safe"-production loopholes.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by ekianjo on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:44PM (#17786605)
Its not laws since the US government and probably others have already shown with the NSA and the like that they have no respect whatsoever for the existing laws and nobody actually seemed to care one bit about that.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by tomatotomato37 on Friday August 17, 2018 @07:15PM (#17786034)
The issue is the government wanting to strip the encryption going forward. In other words, even the most decentralized & encrypted app can still have NSA_RemoteConn.Log(dat) written into it's source code
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by noobermin on Friday August 17, 2018 @07:31PM (#17786088)
Stripping encryption is one thing, sure. But for the backdoor, you'd have to have the clients phone nsaserv.spy/writeremoteconnlog then or sure, write some record on the client's device. You can't "tap" encrypted communications unless you can figure out how to factor integers then you'd get a Field's medal.

Or, ofc, get people to adopt insecure protocols. That we know (or have good suspicion) they've tried.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by philipov on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:54PM (#17786331)
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by seorphates on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:28PM (#17786424)
This actually feels more like what I would expect police work to be like given the situation.

They most certainly do not have cause to demand access to swaths of comms no matter whose comms they're after and most assuredly when that access actually entails enabling access to all of the comms.

I posit there is no authority that should be able to demand this as a matter of the right to human existence. Law, order, society and government should not have ultimate authority on private communications no matter what the tech is capable of. We, as humans in a modern world, can speak and if desired do so in private. This is our right as individuals and if encryption helps us accomplish and enforce that right then so be it.

If they have probable cause then they need to beat feet or beat heads but either way they need to get to work. And by work I do not mean trying to impose a different reality than the one that we currently have - where math is fact, compute is cheap and source is open.

What's it going to be? 100 go free or six lines from everyone?

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by dylan604 on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:26AM (#17787010)
set up the device to wipe itself after $x number of incorrect attempts. keep giving the wrong password after every whack from the wrench. then you have plausible deniability. "how can i possibly think straight when you keep hitting me with that wrench?" just need to make $x a value small enough that you can survive the wrench.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by wdh505 on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:43AM (#17787056)
No good, it is already standard for forensic teams to clone and checksum a hardrive before attempting to look through files. The clone is sent to evidence and any password attempts will be made on a copy. The "original" copy will be kept safe and any number of passwords can be used against nth iteration of copying the clone.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by josephagoss on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:51AM (#17787087)
Isn't this the purpose of the secure enclave on iPhones? Taking the drive away from the secure enclave makes the drive useless and the enclave only allows a few password attempts.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by BrandoElFollito on Saturday August 18, 2018 @03:59AM (#17787397)
This is exactly this. It also allows a weak password (4 digits PIN) to de ok. The enclave which holds the actual encryption keyd will refuse to hand them over if the right trigger is hit (too many attempts, too high a rate,...)
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by partycoder on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:44PM (#17786604)
It is not the answer.

What are the building blocks for encryption?

1) An cryptographic algorithm

2) Some form of key generation

3) A software implementation of 1) and 2)

4) A binary distribution of 3)

5) A computer that executes 4)

In practice, chances are those 5 are all rigged. They are rigged because you have so far trusted:

- That there are no tricks in the algorithm or its practical implementation

- That there are no tricks in the key generation algorithm or its practical implementation

- Hundreds of contributors to the software implementation of those algorithms

- The guy that compiled the software into binary form and distributed it

- The compiler used to compile the software and all the libraries and dependencies the software has

- Hardware manufacturers

So, common sense tells me that because you have trusted so many people, in practice, it is very unlikely you can have end-to-end encryption or any real ambition to have privacy.

This does not even consider more aspects, like your operating system, your sources of entropy, etc.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by Xcelerate on Saturday August 18, 2018 @01:17AM (#17786986)
1-5 have worked so far for Bitcoin.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by hsienmaneja on Saturday August 18, 2018 @09:29PM (#17791991)
What’s stopping those with the capability of subverting bitcoin from choosing not to do so?
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by partycoder on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:41PM (#17795829)
It's a card that they only get to use once per capability, unless it's in a discrete manner.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by ReverseCold on Saturday August 18, 2018 @02:46AM (#17787229)
P2P routing is hard (nat bypass only really works on 80-90% of networks which is not good enough and Tor is unviable for mass adoption), and decentralized identifiers are generally not liked by users

Other than that, it's doable.

Spam protection and censorship (necessary for mobile app stores) can be distributed as opt-out blacklists. If it gets to be a huge problem then a "enter this password to add me" type thing could work too.

I've been compiling a bunch of ideas as such for fully P2P decentralized/encrypted chat, but I'm stuck at the two issues I mentioned earlier.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by gmax on Sunday August 19, 2018 @12:58AM (#17792688)
Can routing be solved through an intermediary acting like an always-on mailbox? Along the lines of http://cweb-services.com/protocols.html
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by ReverseCold on Monday August 20, 2018 @11:43AM (#17800858)
Using an intermediary would make it not decentralized unfortunately :(
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by gmax on Monday August 20, 2018 @09:06PM (#17805867)
Intermediary is not the best word here. What if you could use a storage infrastructure to implemented a protocol for storing and retrieving packets across NAT and disconnected devices. If the role of storage is similar to the raw networks transport via ISP, then it is not more centralized than using an ISP.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by wpdev_63 on Friday August 17, 2018 @07:01PM (#17785981)
Keep in mind they do have the infrastructure in place(carriers and oems) to directly tap on cellphones. While a federated encrypted chat services are a step in the right direction, we won't get truly 'free' communication device until an open source hardware to software solution exists.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by joe_the_user on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:18PM (#17786225)
Plus a client which is under complete control of the user - a phone could never be and a laptop running Linux with Intel me stripped-out might be if you're lucky.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by newnewpdro on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:46PM (#17786612)
Even if you got to that level of encryption, the devices themselves forming the Ps in P2P will become the tap points.

Nobody has a 100% open smartphone stack from the baseband up to the application.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by ribosometronome on Friday August 17, 2018 @06:56PM (#17785970)
Moving away from a centralized infrastructure and having fully P2P doesn't necessarily mean there's no points to tap, does it?

It's just mildly more difficult than a subpoena to Facebook asking for all messages.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by ethbro on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:51PM (#17786484)
I believe it's substantially more difficult, legally. CALEA for data-in-transit and judicial interpetations for data-at-rest mean it isn't as strictly protected as personally-controlled data.

So it's definitely covered by a different legal regime, to set aside the technical bits.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by rootusrootus on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:14PM (#17786391)
Or at least something like iMessage, end-to-end encrypted.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by detaro on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:33PM (#17786434)
The article is about the question if the government can force companies to backdoor their end-to-end encrypted apps, so that's not a solution.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by paulcole on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:36PM (#17786279)
Isn’t this what Slack is?
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by Arubis on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:05PM (#17786362)
Slack literally stands for Searchable Log of All Content and Knowledge. It’s incredibly useful and transformative for what it is. It’s about the furthest thing possible from private.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by paulcole on Friday August 17, 2018 @10:06PM (#17786526)
OK, this is all news to me. I have to go delete a bunch of stuff.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by codemac on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:37PM (#17786284)
It's my recollection that Slack is emphatically not p2p, has that changed?
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by fuzzybeard on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:57PM (#17786341)
Slack is multi-tenant hosted SaaS. Single point of failure.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by dboreham on Saturday August 18, 2018 @02:05AM (#17787121)
You're thinking of Signal.
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by SN76477 on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:21PM (#17786237)
Reevaluate the value of the target.

I don't know what government is doing snooping on facebook messenger. I would be blindsided if real crime was happening that way.

Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by javagram on Friday August 17, 2018 @08:25PM (#17786249)
Real crime happens on SMS all the time. Why wouldn’t it happen on Facebook messenger which is one of the most popular SMS replacement apps?
Re:U.S. government seeks Facebook help to wiretap Messenger by sergers on Friday August 17, 2018 @11:05PM (#17786646)
BBM was very popular for illicit purposes when it was in its heyday at RIM.

People moved onto other messengers like WhatsApp for those purposes.

Heck people use snapchat expiring messages to relay info on illicit activities.

It is not farfetched at all people are using FB messenger, signal, anything for that purpose.