News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by Tiktaalik on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @12:56PM (#17767588)
Seems reasonable to me. Housing should be for housing people, not a speculative financial investment.

It's reasonable for cities to ask that people show that they have some skin in the game, that they're living, working, paying taxes and contributing to and enhancing the community.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by kovrik on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @04:03PM (#17769259)
My opinion may be controversial, but I never understood this logic... I live in New Zealand at the moment. I am not Kiwi though, my wife and I moved from Russia. And I disagree.

First, stats show that foreign buyers own ~3% of homes. Everything else is kiwi-owned.

Second, there is another thing going on here -- KiwiBuild. Basically, government funds and builds 'affordable houses'. Prices (in NZD) are $500-650k, but now they want to have even more affordable houses - $300k. For comparison, actual average house price in Auckland is above $1kk.

My wife and I work really hard, NZ is not our country, English is not our language, the culture is different, we have nothing to inherit here. Why should we pay (with our taxes) for poor kiwis who can't afford a house? Shouldn't they work harder instead? Get education, get better job.

We wish we could buy a $1kk+ house in Auckland too, but we can't. If you can't afford a house, then buy an apartment because they are much cheaper. Yes, it is not that fancy, but at least you'll have a place to live in.

I mean, yeah, Labour party is in power in NZ at the moment, hence such policies like 'Let's increase salaries to poor workers, let's give them houses, let's increase maternity leave etc.'. The problem is that somebody has to pay for that.

UPD: another problem in my opinion is that Kiwi culture is very different. NZ is isolated from the rest of the world. It is very quiet here, people are very relaxed, everything goes slow. People are not used to work hard (in my opinion). It is common here to spend a year or two doing nothing, just traveling around the world after graduation. Many people don't want to build a career, they want to 'try many different jobs, find themselves, enjoy life'. Many people live with their parents, start thinking about career at the age of 30-35. At work, if it is 4pm (sometimes 5pm) -- people just leave and go home. "We have an urgent task" here means that it must be done within a week. In schools they teach children that everyone is a winner -- even if you have poor marks. Also, if there are any competitive games/sports, then sometimes they make it that the winner is not the one who actually won, but the one whose turn today is. And so on. Hence many people here, when they grow up, are not used to fight for survival. Just enjoy their quiet life in a beautiful country. But then they are 35, have no money, no career, but want a fancy house...

Sorry if I'm being too harsh, don't mean to offend. But this is my take on Kiwi culture, the way I see it as a non-native.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by Tade0 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @05:49PM (#17770090)
Coming from Poland I had a very similar fist impression when I started living in-and-out in Italy.

Nevertheless at some point I started thinking: Maybe these guys are right and I'm wrong? Maybe there's more to life than this "fight for survival" and I shouldn't value my ability to do so so highly?

There's a level of, for lack of a better word, satisfaction I see on people's faces daily in Italy that I know I won't achieve, because I was born in a poor country in a rather poor family and had to claw myself out of poverty.

I think it's precious. I wish my (future) children lived in a world where they can have, like my SO likes to put it, "two youths" - one spent on doing personally meaningful, fulfilling things, and the other doing what's necessary to live an independent life.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by kovrik on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @06:04PM (#17770165)
Yes, when I first started living in NZ I was baffled by completely alien culture and the way of living. But then I began to understand it, like it, enjoy it (to some extent)!

And I respect people if they choose to live this way, not fight for survival, enjoy their lives. But I don't think it is fair if later they start complaining about lack of money, lack of career and expensive houses they can't afford and start asking the government (read 'other people') to pay for it.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by peterashford on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @10:04PM (#17771331)
Its not a matter of asking other people to pay, it's a matter of there not being enough housing stock and houses being seriously unaffordable relative to wages. BTW: NZ workers do the OECD average amount of work per year.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by kovrik on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @10:28PM (#17771438)
That is what concerns me: if they can't afford a house, then why don't they buy an apartment?

There are apartments in Auckland for $300-400k, which is even cheaper than affordable KiwiBuild houses ($500-650k).

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by lancewiggs on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:13AM (#17772080)
$3-400k gets a tiny 1 bedroom apartment downtown, which I would have loved early in my career. The kiwibiuild homes are being aimed at families and necessarily much larger.

I do agree that NZers have this strange desire for bungalows in the suburbs, commuting and mowing lawns. I'm in an apartment downtown and love it.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by Max_aaa on Thursday August 16, 2018 @02:24AM (#17772382)
And how much are yearly Body Corporate Fees for these apartments?

Also have you look at the minutes from BC meetings? Going through just a handful will turn you off purchasing an apartment in no time.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by vilmosi on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @04:20PM (#17769407)
> Why should we pay (with our taxes) for poor kiwis who can't afford a house?

Why pay taxes at all for a country you're not citizen of? /s

Seriously now, it's because you live there. Their government makes the rules, you decided to live there and, by extension, decided to follow their rules.

> I mean, yeah, Labour party is in power in NZ at the moment, hence such policies like 'Let's increase salaries to poor workers, let's give them houses, let's increase maternity leave etc.'. The problem is that somebody has to pay for that

And, given which democratically elected government is in power, it's their right to choose how to spend their money.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by kovrik on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @04:25PM (#17769448)
Yes, you are right and I don't disagree with you. I understand this. And I really love New Zealand, no regrets moving here at all!

That is just my view on such policies. As you might have guessed, I'm not a labourist.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by lancewiggs on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:23AM (#17772127)
All the political parties here have similar polices - it's a country with a social welfare system. On the margin National/ACT (blue) like to cut taxes and spend less social welfare and Labour (red)/Greens the reverse. After 3 terms with blue we had overshot, and Labour iOS having their turn at the well. I encourage all voters to be swing voters - that way they have a chance to influence policy. There are good politicians across all parties here, and we are lucky for that.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @08:04PM (#17770823)
> Let's increase salaries to poor workers, let's give them houses, let's increase maternity leave etc.

New Zealand is a very wealth country by most metrics. It can definitely afford these things.

When I say "it" I mean: the people of New Zealand can afford to redistribute some of their wealth so the country can avoid the worst types of poverty, and probably a whole lot more.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_wealth_pe...

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by kovrik on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @08:48PM (#17771024)
The thing I don't get though is: why build houses? Why not apartment complex? That'll be much cheaper and much more effective.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by ShorsHammer on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @10:05PM (#17771336)
You'll find serious resistance by existing residents to even moderately increased density, that isn't solely a NZ phenomenon either. People are fiercely protective of anything which may affect the value of their property.

Logic has gone out the window regarding sensible planning, it's all politicised and no longer serves the greater good.

House prices could be slashed overnight with the stroke of a pen in many cities on earth.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by Max_aaa on Thursday August 16, 2018 @02:22AM (#17772377)
The problem is that builders in NZ suck at building apartment buildings. The quality is rubbish, and they are not that much cheaper than houses, in many cases they are much more expensive due to the Body Corporate Fees (~10000 NZD / Year).

At first we were looking for an apartment, but then realised that it was just hopeless to find affordable apartments which a of reasonable quality.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by peterashford on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @09:47PM (#17771258)
Its not an either / or thing. Lots more apartments are being built as well
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by spronkey on Thursday August 16, 2018 @05:43AM (#17773246)
In addition to the issues around lack of industry familiar wtih apartments, many native NZers don't want to live in apartments as it doesn't fit their culture or way of life.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by weberc2 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:56PM (#17768170)
Forgive my ignorance, but if you're investing in property, don't you have "skin in the game"? Presumably it's in your interest that the community thrives, because that will help drive up property values (increasing your ROI)? This is just my naive intuition, so please correct me.

EDIT: Downvoters, what gives? Just asking a question...

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by Tiktaalik on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:00PM (#17768232)
Skin in the game means participating in the community and the local economy.

An investor doesn't buy groceries at the local store, doesn't go to local music venues etc.

They help out the construction industry and the FIRE (finance, insurance, real estate) industry, but local neighbourhoods weakly benefit.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by weberc2 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @03:50PM (#17769127)
That's not what "skin in the game" means, and presumably these properties are being rented, in which case the renters are still buying groceries, etc.?

Again, I'm not advocating for foreign investors; just trying to understand the problem.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by Tiktaalik on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @09:19PM (#17771154)
The properties may not be being rented. Due to data that showed a notable amount of vacant properties Vancouver, another area with high amounts of foreign capital infusion enacted a vacant property tax.

Even if these properties are being rented out, persons with foreign capital buying power that exceeds that of locals have a distortionary and, from the point of view of a local, a negative impact on the real estate market, as they are able to out compete locals and bid up the price of housing. A person which may have normally been able to buy a home can no longer buy, and now has to devote more of their income to renting from a foreigner. Why would any local support this state of affairs?

At a high level "skin in the game" means involvement and having some commitment. That can mean monetary involvement or otherwise and I'd use the broader definition. An absentee foreign buyer has tenuous involvement in a city beyond the impact of their foreign capital. Sure they've risked their capital on an investment, but from a locals point of view they have no real personal stake in the community.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by sgolestane on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @03:13PM (#17768841)
Investor pays property tax without using any of it's benefits.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by sitharus on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @03:51PM (#17769136)
No they don’t, their tenants pay the property tax. I own a rental property in New Zealand (not out of choice, long story) and the rates are paid from the rent. I don’t chuck in the extra $120/month from my other income.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by lancewiggs on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:15AM (#17772092)
Investors fight for lower rates, while people who live in the places want better services.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by kentosi on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:12PM (#17768336)
The problem is when rich investors buy properties to hold, but don't actually rent them out to people. This in turn reduces the number of apartments available to the people that need them, and just drives prices artificially upwards.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by bradknowles on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @07:10PM (#17770533)
And the property tax doesn't cover the costs to the society when the property owner doesn't participate in the society.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by spronkey on Thursday August 16, 2018 @05:47AM (#17773256)
What they're actually doing is increasing the difficulty for local buyers by increasing demand and pushing up prices, and taking money away from them while simultaneously lining the pockets of existing property owners.

Foreign owners are likely to move at least a portion of this money overseas, which takes it out of the local economy, reduces the ability of residents to innovate by taking financial risks etc etc.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by kazinator on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:58PM (#17768212)
Some people just want a roof over their head without paying rent to a landlord and being subject to their whims.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by weberc2 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @03:52PM (#17769153)
So the issue is that foreign investors are significantly driving up the cost of real estate, making home ownership prohibitively expensive for locals? Has anyone quantified the impact in various regions?
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by lancewiggs on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:15AM (#17772095)
That's the issue, and no.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by briandear on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:19PM (#17767829)
If they own a house, they are paying taxes, so they do have significant skin in the game. They pay property taxes despite not using the local schools or most other city services.

As far as not allowing housing as a speculative financial investment, there are some significant unintended consequences there.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by Tiktaalik on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:56PM (#17768178)
The problem with absenteeism is that while taxes are still being paid to maintain city services, the city doesn't function correctly, because there's weak street life.

Here's an article about the struggles of retailers in Vancouver's Coal Harbour neighbourhood, which has estimates of around 20-25% empty housing.

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/real-estate/at-vancouvers-co...

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by toby on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:15PM (#17768358)
Vancouver has a vacancy tax, which strikes me as a really good idea to avoid these problems. Does anyone know why these aren't more popular?
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by ggcdn on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:37PM (#17768546)
I agree with you that it seems like a good idea. However, the vacancy tax is still in its infancy, so we've yet to fully understand its effectiveness or side-effects. A big issue around the housing discussion in Vancouver is the lack of data and amount of misinformation being injected into the discussion.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by peterburkimsher on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:49PM (#17768639)
The Netherlands has a system where vacant properties may be occupied by squatters after they've been empty for a year. There's an active squatting scene in Amsterdam, particularly OT301 (an abandoned cinema, now an arts centre).
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by refurb on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:31PM (#17768499)
Enforcement? People gaming the system so it doesn’t look unoccupied?
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by nedwin on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:30PM (#17768493)
I can imagine they're difficult to enforce.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by TheBeardKing on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @04:10PM (#17769310)
If the vacancies drive away business, which weakens street life, then would not the low street life drive down real estate prices?
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by bradknowles on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @07:12PM (#17770546)
Nope.

Just ask the people in London who live among all the empty properties that have been bought by various Russian oligarchs or other people who want to exfiltrate their wealth from the countries where they "acquired" it.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by user5994461 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:23PM (#17767858)
The tenant covers all the taxes and costs through his rent.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by jpollock on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:56PM (#17768174)
No, they do not, they only cover a portion. As the owner of a New Zealand investment property...

In NZ, ROI on property is targeted to be around 8% [3]. The owner will take that ROI either in capital increase or in rent. [2]

If the property is appreciating, the rents will be allowed to slow down. If the property stops appreciating, then the rents increase to maintain the ROI. The entire market is targeted at 8%, particularly the property management companies.

Changing the property tax rules changes this equation, with a shift to higher rents.

New Zealand is trying everything to remove demand from the housing market. They first brought in new deposit rules (20% min for owner occupier[4], higher for investment properties 35%+[5]), now they've brought in foreign ownership legislation. It might affect the rate of capital increase, but that will only shift the ROI equation towards rental increases.

The government is looking at building more housing (FINALLY), but they are finding that all the regulations (houses with heating and insulation cost more!) means they can't do it for less that 600-650k [1].

[1] https://www.interest.co.nz/property/95345/housing-minister-s...

[2] https://www.interest.co.nz/saving/rental-yield-indicator

[3] https://www.yourinvestmentpropertymag.com.au/expert-advice/l...

[4] https://sorted.org.nz/guides/home-buying/buying-a-first-home...

[5] https://www.rbnz.govt.nz/education/at-a-glance-series/lvr-re...

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by user5994461 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:48PM (#17768630)
This makes no sense. Rents are not linked to the costs of property. They are fixed to as much as local people can pay for a home, roughly 50% of typical household income everywhere in the developed world.

The ROI is the +appreciation + rent - expenses.

If the property depreciates you have least return on investment. There is nothing you can do about it. You can't increase rent to compensate, people can't pay more rent. Your reasoning is absurd, if you could increase rent you should be doing that right now already.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by dahdum on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @03:22PM (#17768913)
Rents are definitely linked, until discretionary income for the local people goes to zero they can still pay more. Housing prices also affect mortgage payments, which rise in tandem.

Looking it up, I see USA is somewhere around 30% of income [1] as housing cost, while NZ is about 17% [2]. Seems to indicate there is room to grow under tight supply conditions.

[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/how-to-save-more-money-2017-...

[2] https://www.stats.govt.nz/information-releases/household-inc...

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by pixelbash on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @04:31PM (#17769484)
About the insulation thing, to be clear, it's just a heat pump and a certain R number in the floor and ceiling (correct me if I'm wrong). Pumps cost <5k to install and insulation isn't that much more if done while building. Double glazing isn't mandatory either.

What I'm trying to say is walking into a house here in winter still doesn't feel like a place in say, Northern Europe. I don't think it's that onerous.

Sources: Partners brother in law is a builder, parents just had heat pumps installed, our landlord just installed underfloor insulation and it's currently 12 degrees C in the house.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by sitharus on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @03:54PM (#17769176)
As another New Zealander with an investment property I thought the government closed the loss-making rental loophole s few years back. You can’t use rental losses to offset personal tax so why would you rent at a loss?
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by jpollock on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @10:40PM (#17771490)
http://taxpolicy.ird.govt.nz/news/2018-03-29-issues-paper-lo...

Not yet, but soon. They did tighten up the rules around businesses that _never_ make a profit a while ago (I seem to remember).

CONSULT YOUR ACCOUNTANT.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by sjg007 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:35PM (#17768533)
Weird.. you can build a house in the upper midwest USA for 200k. That's land + all of the regulations etc... Condos should be cheaper per unit too. But like everywhere there is a construction labor shortage. I would hope that the kids gets into construction, at least as a summer job or something while pursuing education.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:41PM (#17768574)
Finding young unskilled apprentices for construction work is easy, finding experienced skilled journeymen is hard because most of them leave the field during each construction bust.

You just can’t make a career out of construction with the current boom and bust way the cycle is going.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by user5994461 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:53PM (#17768680)
You can absolutely have a career in construction, as I know many people who have.

The challenge is health. It's a very demanding line of work where you have to carry weight, wake up in the early morning and work in the cold. People don't want to work like that. It's very hard on the body and you're broken when you reach your 50's.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by sjg007 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @04:11PM (#17769316)
I think a lot of things can be improved here with technology both in materials and for doing the actual work where the risk is lower so your body isn't completely shot.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by InitialLastName on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @05:04PM (#17769769)
It's almost like that problem would be partially solved if the US had a system where you could get healthcare without needing it to be tied to full-time employment.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by user5994461 on Thursday August 16, 2018 @07:26AM (#17773684)
It's not just an insurance problem. I assume accidents are already covered as part of your construction work.

When you are in your 20's. You fall from a ladder, break some bones, you heal and get back on your feet one year later. When you are in your 50's, you are more fragile and less resilient, same thing happens, you might never be able to work again. It's brutal.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by sjg007 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @04:10PM (#17769309)
Eh I don't really buy it... HVAC techs, plumbers, electricians, earthwork, even carpenters/framers can all find work outside of construction booms. And you can move towards prefab as much as possible as well if you are deeply concerned..
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by Max_aaa on Thursday August 16, 2018 @02:29AM (#17772394)
A 2.4M 2x4 costs almost 10 NZD here. And that is the cheapest lumber.

There are huge markups in the local market on building materials due to a duopoly. It is cheaper to fly to Australia buy NZ made siding there and ship it to NZ than to buy it locally.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by sjg007 on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:23PM (#17776662)
huh... sounds like an opportunity to ship over some containers from China.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by lancewiggs on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:18AM (#17772111)
The land in Auckland is driving the value. It's a lovely climate, great city to live in, stable economy and government and open the water. There simply isn;'t much of that sort of living around.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by itake on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:43PM (#17768044)
So the property is being occupied, which I don't think they have a problem with. The issue is wealthy investors are coming in, buying up property at above market rate, and then letting it sit empty and driving up the price higher since there is less sellers on the market.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by user5994461 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:46PM (#17768063)
Doesn't matter if it's rented or not, it drives the price up either way.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by ben_w on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:58PM (#17768207)
If it’s rented out to a local or sold to a local, the ratio of buildings to locals is the same. Supply or demand (or things outside this context such was wages) has to change for prices to change.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by moorhosj on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:15PM (#17768360)
You assume that the ratio of buildings to locals is the sole input for real estate prices.

If an external rentier enters the market and realizes yield, other rentiers will follow. This increases demand for housing assets, not necessarily housing utility. this is the problem they are trying to solve.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by user5994461 on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @03:06PM (#17768781)
Foreign buyers increase the supply of cash. It drives buy prices up, which in turns drives rent up slightly.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by zzleeper on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:49PM (#17768098)
In many countries, property taxes are local and don't go to schools (which have funding from income taxes i.e. from the state).

So it's not like the foreign investors are beneficial in any way, besides maybe paying their bit of water/electricity/police costs (and if they only pay their share, then why bother accomodating all the volatility to house prices they bring?)

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by Taniwha on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @03:04PM (#17768766)
Yes this is true in NZ - property taxes here ("rates") pay for roads, water, street lighting, that sort of thing. Not schools, police, or other stuff done by central govt.

Also property taxes here are not tied directly to house valuations - there's a fixed component, plus a component that's calculated from your valuation divided by the sum of the valuations of ALL the properties in the city. That means that if everyone's valuations are doubled your taxes don't change, if your house value goes up faster than the average you do pay more, if it goes up more slowly your taxes go down.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by lancewiggs on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:20AM (#17772114)
To add to that - the valuations include both the land and the property, and they are itemised.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by saltcured on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:18PM (#17768385)
Yes, what is the target problem really?

Do you want to ban vacant or mostly vacant housing stock for its constriction of housing supplies? Why only foreign owned? Don't vacant holiday or investment homes of residents have the same impact?

Do you also want to ban renter occupied homes where a landlord is profiting excessively? How do you define excessive? Why only foreign landlords? Don't domestic landlords have the same impact? Don't investment trusts have the same impact, regardless of who owns the shares? Or is there a problem with your tax system, so the foreign-consumed profits are not taxed at the source?

If you dislike speculative investment, shouldn't you really dislike renter occupied homes where the landlord isn't profiting? They might accept a tenant at a partial loss, as long as it costs less than holding the property vacant, but this behavior depends on their speculative expectation that the future value is worth the holding costs. It is not sustainable for rent to be lower than the total holding costs (taxes, maintenance, depreciation, risk).

It is interesting to imagine a strict owner-occupation requirement. Nobody can own a home they don't live in as primary residence. Obviously, that means nobody can own a second home unless you zone some special vacation-home areas. And nobody can become a landlord, owning and operating rental properties. No person and no corporation nor trust. Ignoring the obvious disaster of how to get there from here, how would such an economy work? Does everybody at every income level get access to financing to buy their own home? It's hard to define a similar rule for commercial properties, since corporations can fractionally live in many places and it will be hard to define a minimum occupation density to distinguish real use of a commercial property from token use of a speculative holding. The same problem applies to wealthy home owners---what's the difference between a huge estate/mansion and an apartment building other than resident density?

At the other extreme, what about a strict public-owner requirement? What if every property had to be owned by a trust available on open markets? Everyone could buy into shares of every trust, and everyone would pay rent to some trust owning their residence. Everyone could benefit from real estate investment whether they have enough assets to own 1/100, 1, or 100 homes. Independently, they would decide what kind of housing and cost are best for them. What would happen to rents and property values...?

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by refurb on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:34PM (#17768520)
Why only foreign owned? Don't vacant holiday or investment homes of residents have the same impact?

This happened in BC, Canada. It’s a popular spot for vacation homes for Canadians, this they get slammed with a tax as well.

Govt backed down and created exemptions for large swaths of BC.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by pouetpouet on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:22PM (#17767854)
way less than poeple living there. Unless there is some sort of a unique land value tax
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by VectorLock on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:26PM (#17767887)
Like property tax?
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:35PM (#17767972)
Ya, property taxes should act against such behavior, but many places like Vancouver lack one. Not sure about NZ, but it seems like property taxes are more of an American thing.

Edit: oops, Canada does have a property tax, and New Zealand has something like it. So it’s just Australia (on first residences) and the UK that don’t. Well, China also. I’ll take my downvotes gracefully.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by kareemm on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:57PM (#17768202)
Homeowners do pay property tax in Vancouver:

https://vancouver.ca/home-property-development/property-tax....

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by lostlogin on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @02:18PM (#17768398)
There are property taxes here in New Zealand, known as ‘rates’.

You can look up what they are for a property and get an idea of the property value on local government websites.

https://www.aucklandcouncil.govt.nz/property-rates-valuation...

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by indemnity on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @03:44PM (#17769080)
They are absolutely minimal though, works out to about 0.23% of value (aware that’s not the only component) for us in Auckland.
Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by jly on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @04:13PM (#17769336)
Yeah, this is a relatively important metric for both investing but also affordability. It shows that there is an apples to oranges comparison in housing prices across markets (discounting currency differences).

When calculating the affordability of a home, the total monthly cash flow requirements (housing costs as a percentage of income) are critical. I live in an area where the rates are 10x that of Auckland. A $600k home valuation requires a ~$250 weekly rate commitment vs only about $27 in Auckland - a significant difference. It's still an expensive home by any metric, but considerably more affordable.

From a speculation perspective, an investor in Auckland can sit on a very expensive property with almost no cash flow burden, reducing the need to even rent.

Re:New Zealand Passes Law to Crack Down on Foreign Home Buyers by goodJobWalrus on Wednesday August 15, 2018 @01:40PM (#17768016)
We pay property tax in Ontario.