News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by dsp1234 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:16AM (#17707358)
Note that the beginning of the article quickly mentions the new attack that doesn't require the 4-way handshake. Then the rest of the article describes the 4-way handshake attack.

Here is the source for information on the attack that only requires a single EAPOL frame[0].

"This attack was discovered accidentally while looking for new ways to attack the new WPA3 security standard. WPA3 will be much harder to attack because of its modern key establishment protocol called "Simultaneous Authentication of Equals" (SAE).

The main difference from existing attacks is that in this attack, capture of a full EAPOL 4-way handshake is not required. The new attack is performed on the RSN IE (Robust Security Network Information Element) of a single EAPOL frame.

At this time, we do not know for which vendors or for how many routers this technique will work, but we think it will work against all 802.11i/p/q/r networks with roaming functions enabled (most modern routers).

The main advantages of this attack are as follow: No more regular users required - because the attacker directly communicates with the AP (aka "client-less" attack) No more waiting for a complete 4-way handshake between the regular user and the AP No more eventual retransmissions of EAPOL frames (which can lead to uncrackable results) No more eventual invalid passwords sent by the regular user No more lost EAPOL frames when the regular user or the AP is too far away from the attacker No more fixing of nonce and replaycounter values required (resulting in slightly higher speeds)" [0]

[0] - https://hashcat.net/forum/thread-7717.html

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by sctb on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:11PM (#17707899)
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by alanfranzoni on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:36AM (#17707570)
I'm not totally sure of what "cracking" means in this context. Without the 4-way handshake, what does "cracking" mean? Am I discovering the wifi network password, or am I able to decrypt a client's WPA2-protected connection? That's very different!

In WPA, in contrast with WEP, knowing a network's password does not automatically let you sniff another client's traffic. So, the distinction is quite interesting.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by sp332 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:27PM (#17708059)
Thanks, that was something the article should have more more clear. The attack gets you the wifi password but you still can't eavesdrop on other users.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by craftyguy on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:09PM (#17707877)
tl;dr: they're bruteforcing it. use a long, random string of characters as your passphrase and you'll be resistant.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by chaosite on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:22AM (#17707417)
This seems to be the attack mentioned in the blog: https://hashcat.net/forum/thread-7717.html

Basically it seems like there's a thing called PMKID, which is a HMAC-SHA1 of the PMK and things we know, which you can get just by asking for it.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by cmurf on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:44AM (#17707642)
Is there a new hardware dependency for supporting WPA3? Or could most existing 802.11ac era APs be firmware flashed to support WPA3? (Setting aside the business case where there's probably insufficient economies of scale for paid software upgrades for existing hardware that would enable WPA3, rather than just selling a new product.)
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:25PM (#17708033)
From browsing the DD-WRT forums it seems very likely that new hardware (802.11ax support specifically) will be required. If not in theory, at least in practice.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by criddell on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:03AM (#17707233)
Near the end of the video didn't he supply the password (Ankle123)? If so, what was actually cracked?

I have a reasonably strong password on my wifi (it looks something like "OwEs3PMY7yk6qwR4ic"). Is this crackable with this guy's setup in a couple of days?

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:20AM (#17707393)
No. They use Hashcat to generate a large table of keys based on a dictionary + permutations. So "L4vend3rB1ue" is likely crackable in few days, whereas "kGsunI68$@4g" is not.

Also, they say "with a reasonably priced GPU cracking infrastructure, many systems can be cracked within a few days."

I take this to mean they're using something of the order of magnitude of a couple K80 instances on Google Cloud, which will cost $25 per day. By no means prohibitive if you want to try and crack one specific WiFi, but too expensive for wardriving etc.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by tzs on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:51PM (#17708297)
This reminds me of something I've wondered about with brute force cracking.

Suppose Alice uses a 14 character password, each character chosen at random from the range [U+0021, U+007E] (e.g., the 94 printable ASCII characters above space). There are 4.21x10^27 or 2^91.8 possible passwords for Alice.

Bob, on the other hand, uses a 20 character password, also chosen at random, but Bob used a much smaller character set. He just used the 10 ASCII digits. There are 1x10^20 or 2^66.4 possible passwords for Bob. (Bob would need 28 digits for his password space to be as large as Alice's).

Bob's passwords come from a much smaller set, and so could be brute forced much faster--if the attacker knew that they only had to search that much smaller set. In most cases, though, the attacker will not know that.

But, a lot of people do use reduced character sets, so I'd expect brute force attackers to give some preference for searching those first--but how much? Would they be likely to find Bob's 20 character all numeric password ahead of Alice's 14 character all-94 password?

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by Dylan16807 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:12PM (#17709055)
> But, a lot of people do use reduced character sets, so I'd expect brute force attackers to give some preference for searching those first--but how much?

The correct answer is that it barely matters.

So an Alice password is worth 27.6 digits and if you went in order of entropy you'd try them after you try 27 digit passwords.

Let's say you think it's overwhelmingly likely that a password is Alice-style, maybe 99% likely. This suggests that you devote 1% of your processing power to Bob style. Instead of trying Alice-style passwords after you try 27 digit passwords, you will try them after... 25 digit passwords

Because the difficulty increases exponentially, devoting just a smidge of processing power to each different kind means that your progress goes roughly in order of increasing entropy.

And Bob's password will be cracked first, since "digits" is a very reasonable category to devote some computation to.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by sigi45 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:08PM (#17708441)
Probably. I would try it first with normal letters and than with everything else.

But you should look up how the default password generation algorithm is from the vendor / model you try to crack.

I make my wifipassword way longer by using my phonenumber

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by chess19 on Thursday August 09, 2018 @01:15PM (#17726187)
For maximum safety you should assume your adversary knows which character set your password comes from. Frankly, there are few reasons not to assume this.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by GekkePrutser on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:31PM (#17708114)
You can't use rainbow tables for WPA because the SSID is included in the hash. So the same password will result in a different key for different networks.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by mangix on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:26PM (#17708609)
Ehhh. Hashcat has a mode (2501) that operates assuming the PMK is known.

Rainbow tables are fairly useless though.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by baybal2 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:38PM (#17708183)
Yes, but it makes possible to generate them for most popular SSIDs
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by crtasm on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:40AM (#17714996)
So it follows there's some benefit to picking your own SSID? Nice, I wasn't aware of that.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by SmellyGeekBoy on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:09AM (#17707289)
Sounds like it's still a brute force method, so my guess would be no. The only bit that he's made easier is capturing the encrypted key in the first place.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by fixermark on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:15AM (#17707348)
Yes. "With a reasonably priced GPU cracking infrastructure, many systems can be cracked within a few days."

That's not an "everything's on fire" state of affairs, but it's plenty for a targeted attack against a specific domestic target to be feasible, since most home setups never rotate their password (and certainly aren't rotating it on a 2-day window).

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by criddell on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:18AM (#17707373)
The part that made me ask my question is many systems. What are the characteristics of the systems that cannot be cracked in a matter of days?
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by close04 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:20AM (#17707398)
Increased password complexity?
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by discreditable on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:56AM (#17707186)
WPA2's day is past imho. It's a shame that WPA3 looks like it might have its own problems thanks to closet development.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by fixermark on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:14AM (#17707334)
This story might want a caveat: "If the password doesn't change frequently."

I think most people still don't think of "Key can be brute-forced in a few days of offline processing" as "owned," necessarily.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by close04 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:19AM (#17707384)
"Several days" is orders of magnitude less than the interval between most password changes. The vast majority of users never change their WiFi password unless they get a new router.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by sp332 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:29PM (#17708088)
It's a trade-off. If your data is valuable enough to change the password every day, it might be worth it for an attacker to rent a bunch of computing power and crack it in hours.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by LeifCarrotson on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:04PM (#17708393)
It's a whole lot closer to "owned" than "key can be brute-forced after centuries of online processing".

Previously, I believe, it was thought that you had to test the password against the actual router. An offline attack that lets you try millions of keys per second on as many machines as you want to spin up is pretty close to owned when compared to an online attack that only allows single-digit tests per second.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by danmg on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:08PM (#17707876)
This isn't new. mode 2501 cracking in hashcat has been there for over a year.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by voxadam on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:05AM (#17707255)
It seems like it might be time to configure my mobile devices (e.g. phones and laptops) to use my newly configured Wireguard VPN even when using my own WPA2-PSK (AES) wifi at home.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by snuxoll on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:31PM (#17708113)
Deploying WPA2-Enterprise is also an option, which is what I've done myself at home. There's plenty of affordable ways to do this - white box pfSense (install the FreeRADIUS package) + AP that supports WPA2-Ent, going full Ubiquiti with a UniFi Security Gateway + UniFi AP (you can just run the controller on your machine, a raspberry pi or a $5/mo VPS).

I have a small server rack at home so I've got a significantly more complicated (and expensive) setup that I wouldn't recommend to even the average reader on HN unless they were interested in the whole homelab thing.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by sp332 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:32PM (#17708116)
You can't eavesdrop on other wifi users with this attack. This just gets you the wifi password.

Edit: There is another kind of attack that could extend this though. An attacker sets up an AP with the same SSID, and the same password (using the new attack). Then they kick you off the real network with a deauth attack and hope your device reconnects to theirs.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by Fnoord on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:51PM (#17710016)
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by sp332 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:10PM (#17710233)
I'm not an expert, but wouldn't they have to sniff the four-way handshake for that to work? This new attack specifically doesn't do that.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by voxadam on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:18PM (#17708530)
Am I correct that the attack your describing is what's commonly called an Evil Twin Attack?
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by yjftsjthsd-h on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:37AM (#17707576)
Not trusting the network is especially helpful because routers tend to have security issues at an alarming rate and poor update cycles. Forget WPA2 being crackable; the router itself is in a botnet.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by Qub3d on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:10PM (#17710238)
Is it bad that I want to go make a wardriving setup again?
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by Fnoord on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:59PM (#17710115)
This is about WPA2-PSK (aka WPA2-Personal), not WPA2 (aka WPA2-Enterprise). PSK was already vulnerable to brute force attacks. It always is.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by tunesmith on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:02PM (#17709548)
Any recommendations on what an Airport Extreme user should move on to if they're looking for something similarly easy to set up?
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by givinguflac on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:12PM (#17709641)
I’ve yet to find a router that is as easy to set up and works as well. Asus routers are decent if you spend the time to configure, but there are tons of options. I use Asus with the Merlin open firmware and it’s great. I’m not aware of any router that supports wpa3 yet.

Edit: FWIW, mesh is the new hype, but it still can’t beat wired access points.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by CharlesW on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:11PM (#17709624)
Although Netgear Orbi setups do have a full-featured web UI, you can also just stick to the mobile app for an Airport-like setup and management experience.

I replaced my router and helped a neighbor replace theirs. After a few months of use, I have no complaints.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by Tijdreiziger on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:09PM (#17711759)
Most routers nowadays are plug-and-play. A pre-set SSID and password come printed on the router, so there's no need to configure anything (unless you would like to change settings, of course).
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by as-j on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:12PM (#17709636)
Moved to an Eero on the weekend. Just wanted WiFi that works. Felt like a very Apple unboxing and easy setup. Performance seems good.

But that’s 1 data point.

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by nexact on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:33AM (#17707536)
Not every vendor is including RSN data. "A whole lot easier " is an overstatement imo.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by grendelt on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:43AM (#17707636)
> sparenly

?!

Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by ozfive on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:23AM (#17707421)
Hahaha keep trying. I'm close to a solution to this wifi cracking problem! Taking days or even hours won't be able to touch what I have...
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by yjftsjthsd-h on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:38AM (#17707584)
Would you care to share your approach?
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by jacoblambda on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:40AM (#17707602)
flip the router over and write down the password?
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by Joyfield on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:26PM (#17708608)
Write? What kind of savage are you? Take a picture of it.
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by ozfive on Thursday August 09, 2018 @11:39AM (#17725119)
Good one!
Re:Cracking WPA-2 Just Got a Whole Lot Easier by ozfive on Thursday August 09, 2018 @11:37AM (#17725099)
No, because it is something I could sell to enterprise.