Edit: If anyone is more curious about this, a large amount of the rips in the TLMC were ripped by one uploader (or a group of people using a singular alias) on the Japanese P2P programs Share[0] and Perfect Dark[1].
He was so prolific in the scene that he has his own Baidu wiki page[2] (albeit, it's not as strict as Wikipedia with notability, I still find it impressive).
All of his rips, as far as I know, were affected by this "normalize" setting, so even though he ripped hundreds (thousands?) of albums, a large majority of them probably wouldn't be considered "archive quality".
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Share_(P2P)
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_Dark_(P2P)
[2] https://baike.baidu.com/item/%E5%8F%B0%E9%AD%94%E7%8E%8B
Unfortunately, the majority of rips fall over EAC's normalize threshold, which means the volume is decreased, which ends up truncating some of the bits (assuming the album was using the full range of the 16bit audio).
Edit: I noticed you used the term "fidelity", so you might be talking about being able to perceive the damage to the audio, which is not necessarily what I'm talking about.
The point of EAC (Exact Audio Copy) is to make archival quality copies of audio CDs, this means as close to bit-exact as possible. Modifying the audio in any way would be counterproductive to that purpose, even if it doesn't necessarily affect the actual sound quality.
For this album in particular, the audio CRCs of the other tracks don't match up between TLMC and a fresh rip:
TLMC:
01.wav: 9A5E3226
02.wav: 577A675B
03.wav: 3548C299
04.wav: E5DEC006
05.wav: D33AC4AE
06.wav: 7427AC6F
07.wav: 83A58517
08.wav: 0DCA8419
09.wav: 703BAEAC
My rip: 01.wav: 565F2B5A
02.wav: E916B3A2
03.wav: A595BC09
04.wav: D989F0D6
05.wav: C6A2DD2B
06.wav: C8403284
07.wav: D01D6BC4
08.wav: 8786C1AA
09.wav: 1E3641DDFor comparing .wav files you can also treat them as plain binary data, and use standard diff tools. For example I used `cmp -l` to count differences between rips, and `vbindiff` to view them.
a) reverse one of the channels and them sum them and you'll sum will contain only stereo data
b) reverse and sum (a) with the original track to get only the mono content
However human hearing doesn't just import the signal, the initial processing is done during acquisition itself. Psychoacoustic lossy audio encodings like MP3 rely on this, an MP3 sounds to you very much like the original but a naive audiodiff would find huge differences.
When you've got a .wav file open in a hex editor, it's no longer really about the music itself.
As a fellow ripper of physical CDs in 2018, the point is that a correct rip of CDDA from the CD is the one and only way to be sure you won't ever have to rip that music again.
Any other file, any other delivery/download mechanism, any other format ... you'll be fooling around with that song again sometime. But not if you have the correct, error free rip of the WAV/PCM from the CD.
So it's really not about the sound vs. some other format ...
I've been ripping in AAC 256kbps for 15 years now and have yet to see any reason to revisit any of those CDs. Even if a more efficient encoding mechanism gains mainstream support, I'll just use that for new rips only since storage is cheap enough.
That's exactly the point. Using anything but a lossless codec for ripping music is an unwise decision.
However I store it on a local NAS as well as a an external SSD (in case I need it in a portable way, which rarely happens) - I opted for an expensive SSD because it's very light, small and portable, but a traditional external drive would handle music just fine if price is a major concern.
At the end everyone has different requirements, but since I consider ripping a huge amount of music a major task I wouldn't want to repeat, I'd make sure I do it right from the beginning - and opting for a lossy format doesn't fit into that idea.
I mantain both: a tree of lossless files and an exact copy already encoded as 320kbit mp3 that is automatically mantained (just because i can quickly cram those into a usb thumbdrive and they'll play anywhere -- i can't say the same about flac support).
o/
I'm glad iTunes offers to transcode my lossless collection to lossy AAC on the fly before syncing to the iPhone (yes, some people still do that).
Of course my concern is storage in mobile devices. Yours seems to be flac support? However is that really an issue these days? I use ALAC (due to using iOS devices), but even then I never run into compatibility issues. Any worthwhile software/hardware supports either format - with Apple being the big outlier requiring ALAC.
Part of my original point was that I've been using AAC exclusively for 15 years now, and with all the content encoded in AAC now I don't see support for it disappearing in the next 15 either.
Rephrasing the question: What are people typically using these days when not going for FLAC? Some of my mp3s are definitely from the "HDD space is expensive" age 15+ years ago...
That doesn't necessarily mean it was ripped without errors. I think op was trying to make sure he has an exact copy, not just one that sounds alright.
Sure, op has no absolute guarantee, but the fact that his crc32 matches that of the AccurateRip DB is, apart from his statistical approach, another strong indicator that he actually got it right. The alternative is that either the other user who submitted the crc32 to the database coincidentally ended up with exactly the same read errors, or that it's a hash collision (not entirely unlikely given the size of the checksum).
It's reasonable to assume op got a perfect rip.
> That single AccurateRip entry for this album matched my CRCs for all tracks except track #3 – they had 0x84B9DD1A, vs my result of 0xA595BC09. I suspect that original ripper didn’t realize their disk was bad.
(Btw did you see the addition at the beginning of the article? Funky stuff going on...)
I didn't know this existed but I am grateful for you changing this and now I need to buy a new hard drive.
Were you a fan of Touhou back in its heyday, or is it just one of the many that rouse your curiousity?
It reminds me of traditional Japanese court poetry, where half the esthetic work is done by knowledge of allusions and borrowings and the poet is trying to express a familiar theme in a slightly better way rather than seeking for novelty like most forms of literature.
Or in simple terms: A large collection of cover songs for the soundtracks of a popular Japanese bullet-hell game series.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D%C5%8Djin
TTA usually. There is an Ogg Vorbis torrent about a tenth the size, but I'm not sure it's being kept in sync with the original TLMC.
It used to be the largest torrent in circulation and also the one that broke some client programs due to its huge size.
If anyone is terribly curious what it sounds like, I've put up an OGG copy here: https://www.dropbox.com/s/u88u1xpdmdxbqal/03%20%E5%BC%98%E4%...
Oh well. I'm sure it was a great learning experience anyway. :)