News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by yasp on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:05PM (#17174147)
I am so sick of this perpetual fallacy about labor shortages. If you can't find enough workers it means you need to raise the price you're offering. (But yasp the article cited one particular firm has already increased prices 15% this year.) Doesn't matter. There is a certain price at which the market will clear. If the market isn't clearing it's because the price being offered is too low. Keep trying.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by ams6110 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:24PM (#17174273)
Conversely, maybe there really isn't a shortage, and trucking companies want to get more drivers so that they can pay less. So they push a narrative of being able to make 80 to $100,000, but don't disclose that it's only a tiny fraction of experienced or specially qualified drivers who actually earn that much
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lopmotr on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:54PM (#17174458)
There's never a shortage. Shortage just means somebody wants to pay less than they're having to. Even if half the truck drivers vanished, there still wouldn't be a shortage. The price would simply go up and some people who would have shipped things by truck would produce those things closer to their destination or otherwise not need a truck afterall.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by TheCapn on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:06PM (#17174528)
That's a simplistic view of shortages of labour markets. Just taking trucking as an example, many jurisdictions have safety standards drivers need to meet. If "half the truck drivers vanished" tomorrow we'd have an absolute shortage until labour could be spun up to account for the supply demand.

It's also overly simplistic to believe that trucking companies can infinitely raise wages to support demand. People/businesses only tolerate a certain cap of pricing on goods and to say that ceiling is infinitely high is silly.

If markets were perfectly efficient, sure all your wishes and hopes would be a reality. But we're not efficient, we're flawed humans running these things so the flaws are apparent when you attempt to accommodate.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lopmotr on Monday May 28, 2018 @08:28PM (#17175583)
How are you defining shortage? If half the drivers vanished, then half as much stuff would be shipped by truck. What's the problem with that, other than things would be worse for people? Is there a correct amount of truck driving that should happen? Are we currently at that correct amount? Have we ever been?
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by macintux on Monday May 28, 2018 @10:56PM (#17176144)
By your logic has there ever been a shortage of anything?
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lopmotr on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:50AM (#17203647)
Yea, it's an emotional concept that seems to mean things cost more than somebody was expecting. You could say there's a shortage of anything you like, so it's a meaningless word. There's a shortage of helicopters because lots of people want them but don't want to pay the high price they currently have. There's a shortage of petrol because if it was much cheaper, I'd be running a generator to power my house. I want that cheap petrol but there isn't enough for the price to be so low.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by fpig on Monday May 28, 2018 @08:47PM (#17175639)
The reason why the world doesn't work the way you're suggesting and why shortages do exist is nominal rigidity. And it's much more complicated than "the boss is reluctant to pay the worker more". The client might also be reluctant to pay for the service more, regardless of supply and demand. Consumers might be reluctant to pay a higher price. If the current increase in demand for trucking services is temporary, and they increased wages, they're kind of stuck with the now higher wages as wages are strongly sticky-down (in other words you can't just constantly adjust wages to their market price, up or down, because humans react very negatively to their wages being cut). It is deeply entrenched in the economy and human minds. This is why shortages often only resolve themselves in the long term. Until they resolve themselves, they certainly do exist.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by joshuamorton on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:04PM (#17174518)
This isn't necessarily true. The can be shortages of resources (food, water) independently of price. Labor is just another resource, why cant there be a shortage of it?
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lopmotr on Monday May 28, 2018 @08:37PM (#17175607)
Food prices do go up and down, and on each up, more people on the fringes of survivability die from lack of food, perhaps indirectly through disease. How high do food prices have to go before it would be classified as a shortage? The distinction seems arbitrary.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by joshuamorton on Monday May 28, 2018 @08:42PM (#17175626)
>Food prices do go up and down, and on each up, more people on the fringes of survivability die from lack of food, perhaps indirectly through disease.

This really isn't true. In practice it may be, but that's due to inefficient allocation, not due to a lack of resources. We have enough food to feed the entire human population. A shortage would be if we didn't.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by fjsolwmv on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:45AM (#17176567)
OK. There are often shortages of food allocation. Still shortages.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by winstonewert on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @01:12PM (#17181059)
What does "shortage of food allocation" even mean? Problems with how food is allocated is completely different sort of problem than not having enough food.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by rileymat2 on Monday May 28, 2018 @08:26PM (#17175580)
I agree with your point, but I wonder if there has been a shortage of food or water in the last 30 years that more money could not have solved quickly. It seems these happen in poor/war torn areas.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by joshuamorton on Monday May 28, 2018 @08:36PM (#17175606)
Offhand IDK, I was more thinking in terms of a theoretical resource constrained environment where the population is beyond the carrying capacity. You have a shortage that money cannot solve.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by winstonewert on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @01:20PM (#17181133)
Even there, the situation isn't fundamentally different.

We are constantly in a situation where we do not have enough resources to do everything we'd like to do, we have decide which are the best uses of the resources.

If we don't even have enough resources to keep everyone alive, then we are still in that exact same situation of not having enough resources to do everything we'd like to do. We are going to have to decide how to expend those resources (i.e. which people are going to live)

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by maxxxxx on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:07PM (#17174163)
Our economy has split into areas where in some areas "talent" can get almost infinite amounts of money and in other areas it's simply not conceivable to pay people more. I wonder how free market people explain this. Based on the market theories I have heard it doesn't make sense.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lotsofpulp on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:10PM (#17174178)
It does make sense, you don’t need “infinite” amount of money. Pay a driver $200k a year. Or give them an 8 hour workday, and week off week on schedules so they can see their family.

There’s many solutions, all of them involve incentivizing people to become drivers. If people want their Amazon orders so bad, they’ll end up paying. And if they don’t, then they have to re-prioritize what they want.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by StudentStuff on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:16PM (#17174219)
Part of the problem is with BNSF, UP & the other major long haul rail lines, there is no good aggregator for those looking to ship a few pallets of goods from California to Seattle, and the railroad is happy to set high minimums which make long distance trucking viable. Its ultimately quite silly, I really do think an Uber for Railroad shipping which partnered with the local railroads (that are desperate for revenue & work for cheap) and long haul railroads could effectively shrink the need for long haul trucking.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by HarryHirsch on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:20PM (#17174251)
Uber for railroad shipping? LCL (Less-than-container-load) freight forwarding has been an industry since God-knows-when, and you'd think this includes intermodal. You learn all this when you've done a few international moves.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by shiftpgdn on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:26PM (#17174282)
If you've done an international move surely you saw how horribly the industry is run. It's ripe for "disruption." Most of the pages of companies doing the work look straight out of 2004.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by HarryHirsch on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:32PM (#17174321)
To be honest, I can't complain about the state of the industry. You find someone (through recommendations), they give you a quote, you drop off the goods, and the stuff arrives 6 weeks later. It's miraculous, there must be so much informal knowledge to make it all work.

The disruption is these "moving pods". They are more expensive, but they are well advertised, and one fears that the established small players will be driven out of business.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by toasterlovin on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:01PM (#17174504)
There is a YC company doing this: Flexport.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by HarryHirsch on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @01:33PM (#17181245)
Their website is full of fluff, and you have to sign up for an account. With your average freight forwarder you just pick up the phone for a quote, and if the quote is outside their area of expertise they'll refer you to someone who can perform. What is their niche, exactly?
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by toasterlovin on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @05:20PM (#17183011)
Their "niche" is that you can actually track your shipments on their website, rather than having to harass your dinosaur freight forwarder via phone & email and hope that they deign to get back to you. Oh, and you can also request quotes via their website! Seriously, though, you should give them a shot. They were a game changer for a former employer. And there's a phone number in the website footer.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by analognoise on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:31PM (#17174312)
Railroads are only inexpensive because they demand those minimums to reduce or eliminate their touch labor costs.

If they removed those minimums, the price would go up substantially - your model doesn't include that cost on the train side, it would incur it on you as a shipping aggregator, making your costs uncompetitive.

Just a guess, I haven't done an analysis.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by skookumchuck on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:23PM (#17174264)
Just put the truck on the railroad flatcar.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by toomuchtodo on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:25PM (#17174280)
There is an enormous existing market for this. It's called intermodal transport.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intermodal_freight_transport

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by skookumchuck on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:35PM (#17174343)
Given the interstates are clogged with long haul trucks, it obviously isn't nearly enormous enough.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by toasterlovin on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:06PM (#17174529)
Trucks are much faster than train. Depending on the cost incurred in having goods be unsellable for some period of time, trucks often make sense.

Trains also aren't that much cheaper. I'm not sure why this is, but my hunch is that much of the cost in transportation is pick up from origin and drop off at destination and this essentially has to be done via truck. So, if you're shipping via train, you incur an additional pick up and drop off, since the goods need to go from the trucker's hub to the train, then from the train to the trucker's hub. That probably erases a lot of the savings that you see when you just calculate costs based on the physics of truck vs. train.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by skookumchuck on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:12PM (#17174565)
The reason trucks are cheaper is because the roads are paid for by gas taxes on cars. The weight taxes on trucks do not begin to cover the fatigue damage caused by trucks. Most of the repaving of highways is due to truck damage.

Railroads, on the other hand, pay all their own track maintenance, and even have to pay property taxes on the track. The whole system is tilted against railroads.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by toasterlovin on Monday May 28, 2018 @06:49PM (#17175299)
FWIW, I didn't say that trucks are cheaper. It's been a while since I've priced this stuff out, but, from what I recall, trains are cheaper for going cross country. Your point still stands, though, if it's correct.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by toomuchtodo on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:01PM (#17174503)
Incentives and all that. Have to raise heavy truck highway taxes if you want to push a lot of that freight onto the rail backbone.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by skookumchuck on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:08PM (#17174539)
I'd raise weight taxes, and use the revenue to reduce taxes on freight trains.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lopmotr on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:01PM (#17174500)
Is it the trucks clogging them or everyone else? Maybe if human travelers flew instead of driving, then there would be space for the trucks.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by cimmanom on Monday May 28, 2018 @05:01PM (#17174820)
Or if the humans took rail?
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by chrisseaton on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:32PM (#17174317)
I wouldn't re-train as a truck driver for $200k a year? Would you?

And you can't just say 'there's lots of people for whom $200k would be a lot of money' because there's a lot of people who whom $50k is a lot of money and those jobs aren't filled either.

Short of literally offering a million dollars a year, it's got to be more complicated than how much you offer.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by opencl on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:51PM (#17174439)
$200k is more than 97% of Americans make so I think it would fill the jobs pretty quickly. Getting a CDL only takes a couple of months, that would be way better ROI than most college degrees.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by rgbrenner on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:43PM (#17174388)
If $1m/year is the price, then that's the price.

If there are alternatives available that use less or cheaper labor, then people will use those instead.

There's no cap for any price. And if the alternatives are cheaper, then maybe that type of business doesn't need to exist in the economy.

That's supply and demand.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by vkou on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:36PM (#17174356)
I wouldn't re-train as a truck driver, but my partner, who makes $35,000/year moving heavy things around in a Seattle theater would. She'd step over a lot of bodies to do so.

The $50,000/year jobs that aren't being filled have one of:

1. Require years of non-transferable training.

2. Have insane working hours, that make your real pay closer to minimum wage.

3. In especially shitty working conditions.

4. Are in locations where $50,000/year isn't enough to live on.

5. Destroy your body after a few years on the job.

6. Have better-paying, better-work-condition alternatives that use similar skill-sets.

7. Or, more typically, two or more of the above.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by cimmanom on Monday May 28, 2018 @05:07PM (#17174852)
Truck driving ticks boxes 2, 5, and arguably 3.

That said, if it paid $200k/yr (median or even 75th percentile), the shortage would disappear post haste. The vast majorly of other jobs that pay that much tick boxes 1, 4, or both and are thus logistically out of reach of at least half the population.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by RandomInteger4 on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:18PM (#17174589)
If the training were free and I was guaranteed a job, then I definitely would. I see little downside.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by chrisseaton on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:47PM (#17174757)
> I see little downside.

I think the job has a very high incident of obesity and heart disease, as it's so sedentary, and a high incident of divorce because it's anti-social.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by RandomInteger4 on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @01:08PM (#17189457)
You raise a good point. I hadn't considered the amount of sitting hours required, where you're incentivized not to make stops to stretch your legs due to time to delivery constraints.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by bryanrasmussen on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:35PM (#17174346)
well I wouldn't but I make pretty good money already. but really the main reason I wouldn't retrain as a truck driver is if I retrain for something it's a job I envision lasting another decade at least.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by ryanmarsh on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:36PM (#17174352)
In 1935 Congress passed the Motor Carrier Act of 1935. With it the ICC restricted new entry into the trucking business and approved specific routes. It also required motor carriers to file tariffs with the ICC 30 days in advance, and allowed protest from other common carriers of proposed tariffs, and required that carriers’ rates be reasonable “as to both minimum and maximum.” The underlying rationale of the 1935 Act was that the motor carrier sector was economically unstable and that cut-throat competition might destroy the fledgling industry.

Driving a truck paid well and the carriers got fat.

After a series of deregulation acts beginning in the 70’s there was a race to the bottom on prices. Many carriers went out of business. Driver pay dropped (all though you could still make a good living doing certain types of OTR.

Swings in the economy are felt in transportation.

Until the trucks drive themselves there will forever be too many/few drivers. It’s the nature of a deregulated industry that moves with the economy.

Every swing in a labor market is not a social crisis. Although we can all probably foresee some real social crises’ related to driver labor in the future and not of the “too little” kind.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by maxxxxx on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:22PM (#17174262)
So why is this not happening in trucking or other areas? Whenever salaries go up in an area it's being reported almost like a miracle.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Applejinx on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:44PM (#17174397)
The people getting almost infinite amounts of money are making the rules and setting the terms of the dialogue.

Because to do so is a tactic for maximizing the amount of money they get, that being their self interest.

When you see this sort of 'workers are fussy and childish even though they're treated and paid incredibly well!' business, it's safe to read it as 'reality has come knocking, and the reports of wonderful conditions and pay are greatly exaggerated'. It's like asking what's wrong with millenials that they're not buying enough diamonds.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by dkasper on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:11PM (#17174182)
As you pay truckers more at some point it doesn’t make economic sense to hire them. Some jobs are cost centers others are profit centers is one way of looking at it. Another factor is industries like trucking have very little differentiation so it’s a race to the bottom.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lev99 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:15PM (#17174216)
As you increase driver pay delivery costs increase. If the shortage was real it would mean deliveries are not being made that would have happened at an increase in delivery cost.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by gaius on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:27PM (#17174290)
The goods being in location A rather than location B is the value add.

Logistics is a profit centre, not a cost.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by mi100hael on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:49PM (#17174424)
Of course the actual act of shipping the goods is a profit center. But payroll is a cost center in every industry I'm aware of. You can't just 10x your shipping costs in order to pay your truckers 10x the salary and expect to remain in business.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by ryguytilidie on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:05PM (#17174527)
Why does debate always turn into this? No one suggested much more than a ~1.5xish pay increase yet the response is "you expect them to pay 10x the salary and remain in business??"?

What is the goal of just exaggerating and debating a thing no one says versus just debating what people are actually saying?

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by gaius on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:00PM (#17174497)
The payroll costs are usually included in each “centre”
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by maxerickson on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:13PM (#17174197)
Prices are sticky. Prices at the store, prices for shipping, prices for labor, etc.

So where people don't have much leverage (or are perceived to not have much leverage), they move slowly. Trucking is low leverage (the training is a couple months and a large proportion of people will be able to obtain a CDL). Around here they've moved to offer paid training, which wasn't the case a year or two ago.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by merpnderp on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:15PM (#17174206)
The US and most of the world's free market countries are actually highly regulated markets where supply and demand are strongly influenced by government influence.

As for this particular case, truck driving is a crappy job, with its long term prospects darkened by self driving technology, and equal paying professional jobs in decent supply. If you're motivated enough to be a professional, you can usually find a better career. And there's a fairly hard cap on how much long haul trucker drivers can be paid before rail becomes more economic.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:21PM (#17174254)
Free market people understand these things pretty easily. I do not see why you are finding it hard. One obvious fallacy in your statement is that someone getting paid infinite money for talent. I have not seen any such examples so far beside Pentagon who get paid more and more irrespective of their incompetence.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by maxxxxx on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:24PM (#17174272)
For example CEO salaries have been increasing rapidly for several decades. Are they so much better now than 40 or more years ago?
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by 5DFractalTetris on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:28PM (#17174295)
Their business intelligence practice has gotten so much faster that they're probably planning 100 years out.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Applejinx on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:48PM (#17174422)
To people following the way market whims have affected corporate planning, this is an extremely humorous hypothesis.

No, I don't think that they are.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by jaggederest on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:01PM (#17174499)
It's even more severely the opposite. Instead of planning for a decade, they're planning for the quarterly results call in ~3 months, maximum.

Like selling and leasing back real estate, which often pumps up cash flow for a few quarters and then cripples the company with operational expenditures instead of appreciating as land tends to do.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by 5DFractalTetris on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:57PM (#17174476)
Interesting. I notice I have been downvoted as well. Thanks for the slap on the back, everybody.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Applejinx on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @01:25PM (#17181179)
That part wasn't me, and I'm not in the least mad :)

It's just that the subject is extremely important, though it's seemingly not related to 'truck driver shortage'. Part of the problem with seeking to first justify the way our economics are structured, and then explain the outcomes, is that it ignores externalities that can be important.

You could take the opposite tack and begin from 'wealthy people are inherently evil' and probably be almost as wrong, but then you'd be arguing a deeply anarchic position where leadership is only dominance and subjugation. That ignores things like Elon Musk's elaborate, sci-fi goals which are clearly that of a nerd writ large, and not simply a pointy-hair CEO guy wanting only wealth.

The truth is a lot simpler: value is what you're able to make happen, but compensation is sheer social engineering. CEO pay has absolutely nothing to do with whether they're more useful as a class than truck drivers. I think some of them are more useful than truck drivers, and some are not.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:20PM (#17174600)
CEO salaries are not infinite; they are huge but not infinite. If Tim cook continues to ask for more and more and more eventually he will lose his job.

But CEO salary has nothing to do with the `Talent`. Tim Cook, Sundar Pichai, Satya Nadella all replaced their predecessors pretty well and will be replaced by someone better in future too.

The real reason for high CEO salaries is mostly about risk associated with replacement. Sundar Pichai got paid $100M in years 2015. Which looks high but when you realise there are 20M shares of Google it is merely $5 per share.

If you are a Google shareholder would you risk Google's steady growth for a $5 dividend per year ? Will you waste your time saving $100M or rather focus on empowering Sundar to find next $10B market to disrupt ?

CEO salaries are high and they will soar with time too as corporations become large and government regulations increase. As regulations and size of corporations increase a person friends with Ajit Pai would matter more than a person willing to take a pay cut.

As a free market person I have no problem understanding it. Whether it is desirable, good or bad those are value judgements but there is no magic or hidden conspiracies at play here.

P.S. : I think Sundar is getting paid really pennies. Justin Bieber made $80 Millions in year 2016. He is just a singer (and a bad one at it). Sundar on other hand is spearheading a company that forms the brain of our civilisational progress at the moment, responsible for employing millions across the globe and saving billions for entire humanity.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by petra on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:24PM (#17174616)
Are corporations better managed today, than a few decades ago, when CEO's earned much less ?
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:40PM (#17174714)
Why do you think that there should be any correlation between how better they are managed and CEO salary ? There may be there may not be it is irrelevant.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by maxxxxx on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:49PM (#17174764)
I thought the quality of management is the way productivity of a CEO is managed. So there should be a connection between that and his pay.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Monday May 28, 2018 @06:43PM (#17175284)
No. Pay is always based on what it would cost to replace you. It never depends on what you actually do. (What you are willing to pay for X always depends on what is the cost of replacing X with the alternative).
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by fjsolwmv on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:54AM (#17176604)
How can you write one comment that says both "CEO is not talent, they are replaceable cogs" and "CEO is key to both preserving the current value and creating the future growth of the company"?
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:25PM (#17180603)
CEOs are replaceable but there is a risk in that replacement. The high salaries of CEO mostly reflects that risk. You have not understood my beef with the use of word "infinite".
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by mcguire on Monday May 28, 2018 @09:29PM (#17175790)
Software development.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by yasp on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:08PM (#17174170)
I don't know much about the trucking industry but I imagine that it is competitive enough where employers don't feel like they have much latitude to pass higher wages along to their customers.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lotsofpulp on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:12PM (#17174193)
The only reasons that would be is if other trucking companies are not having driver shortages and can continue to deliver without raising prices, or the the end users of the items they are delivering are not willing to pay for the increase in cost. I doubt both are true.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by jandrewrogers on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:58PM (#17174813)
This mischaracterizes a more complex situation and conflates several things. While simple unwillingness to pay a market clearing price is the cause in some cases, I would assert it is a small minority of cases in practice. Some other important causes of labor shortages:

- Labor intensive, low margin industries typically have long-term financial structures that don't allow for high wage volatility. Most workers also dislike wage volatility, so this arrangement works. However, this means that there is limited ability by the business to address labor shortages by increasing wages.

- There is an actual labor shortage. If the market needs 1,000 neurosurgeons and there are only 800 in the world, no wage level will make that shortage disappear and it may be many years before the market can adapt. This is painfully evident at the high-end of the software engineering market. Paying higher wages doesn't eliminate the shortage, it just moves it around.

- Individual wages are capped by value produced. Companies that can pay the highest wages are those where employees produce the most value. The value produced by employees is finite so at some wage they are effectively unemployable; the market has to clear in the other direction as well.

- Spatiotemporal latency and distribution i.e. the required skills are trainable but do not exist when and where you need them. This is increasingly challenging as businesses are required to adapt on shorter timeframes; human populations change and migrate at relatively slow rates.

- Local monopsony for labor sets an economically optimal clearing price for the buyer. This creates a synthetic "labor shortage" of sorts in company towns and similar; market clearing, but in a skewed market. This is not the situation for the vast majority of Americans.

Most labor markets are some combination of all these, and the first four reasons are common in most American labor markets. None of those real labor shortages can be reasonably addressed simply by "paying more". That isn't how markets work.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by scarface74 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:15PM (#17174210)
That doesn't always work as is the case for farm work once you make immigration harder. How many Americans if given a choice would rather make $40K a year doing nice and comfortable office work than make $120K a year (yes I'm making up a number to make a point) to do back breaking manual labor in the hot sun?

Not quite to that extreme, but I'm giving up money now by choosing not to go into management and stay a senior developer because I don't want to be a manager and not to get a better paying job as a consultant who would have to travel more and be away from my family. My wife took a pay cut when we got married to work at a job she enjoys.

Some jobs are not worth the extra money to a number of people no matter how much money you throw at them.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by mlthoughts2018 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:36PM (#17174347)
I, for one, would enjoy a physically challenging job spending time outdoors, learning about specialized equipment, hueristics for the business, if I felt like I was very well-paid and valued. Most such jobs seem to be marketed to push down salaries above all else, target the work at low-skilled candidates, generally have low-status perceptions in society, and hiring companies seem focused on finding ways to mitigate labor shortage without raising wages.

The quote, “the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent” comes to mind. Companies will not pay competitively. They’ll suffer in any other way, but they won’t pay people.

The same effect happens at many price points. For example, the huge push of hype into data science is often a way to push down wages in machine learning / stats. Jobs go unfilled for months, but the company will not offer competitive pay or benefits. I’ve seen this both as a candidate and as a hiring manager frustrated by HR & leadership teams vetoing rare, qualified candidates because they ask for $30k above the budget, or they want sponsored travel to academic conferences, or they want us to match their existing severance benefits at their current company.

Even when we have indisputable business needs for detailed experience in a domain specialty, they think: can’t you just hire a kid out of school with a cardigan & a macbook for $130K? When we show them a qualified candidate earning $200k, it’s just an unconditional no, without any thought as to why that wage gap is there, and why we have a “talent shortage.”

Just totally clueless yet extremely price sensitive.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by steve_gh on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:25PM (#17180595)
Technical director in a specialist engineering data science consultancy group here. The problem we face is a gap between customer expectation of skills and costs. We have a brilliant high-skilled team (15% post-doc, pretty much everyone else MSc in a STEM subject, loads of experience). Our customers like what we do (we are constantly recruiting), but they don't always realise that our fees are based on competing for talent against hedge funds and high-tech startups. It's a fine balancing act to get the right calibre of people at a price our market will bear.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by mlthoughts2018 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @01:15PM (#17181081)
I am a machine learning team manager, sounds similar to your role, but in a large traditional enterprise company. What I see more of is that big companies expect to be able to dictate wages to candidates completely independently of market compensation or competition for candidates.

One thing is that people up the food chain are usually rewarded for outwardly displaying one-sided emotional buy-in to the company's stated mission, to the point that their jobs largely consist of emotional labor, cheerleading every initiative, restructuring, TED talk, executive announcement, etc., as unequivocally "good", never "bad", and 100% forward-thinking genius.

Surely most of them have internal, private lives where they know this is nonsense, but they cannot let it be seen or even suspected. And as a result, their language must always be based in the presumption that any candidate in the world would be lucky to work for us, and would have to be a fool to choose to work somewhere else, and that if they turned us down for any reason at all, it must always mean their heart was in the wrong place and they were insincere and misguided to have any doubt about working for us.

When you are trying to create job requisitions, slides about growing a team, etc., and this is the sort of attitude you're going to face in the approval meetings, it is wickedly difficult. There's no way you can come right out and say we don't offer competitive salaries, because that would mean somehow "we are bad." And HR, whose job isn't tied to the actual productivity of my team, is more than happy to sycophantically agree with upper management, and try to spin the story that either it just takes time to find the right (read: unwittingly cheap) candidate, or else it's the technical team's fault for not doing a good job with interviews.

Then there will be some lengthy song and dance about hiring third party recruiters (who will tell them the same thing -- candidates who are good enough are not cheap enough), sexy new start-ups in the HR space, like HackerRank nonsense, or management consultants, followed by tenuous re-orgs, restructurings, constantly reworded job ads, tweaking of job titles, creating more and more "road maps" about what roles we see the team growing into, etc.

And after months, or even years, of wasted effort on all that junk overhead, we'll still just be lacking the basic productivity we need to create the basic business outcomes we need. Different managers will have quit or gotten promoted. Different start-ups will have gone out of business or popped into existence. Different consulting companies will offer new over-the-moon promises about finding talent. And it all just repeats.

When it comes to wages in these companies, the amounts it would take to hire a top-end candidate (say, maybe, $350K in total compensation or something) is absolutely trivial to the company's budget. They could pay thousands of people at that wage, even including overhead for benefits, etc.

It really has nothing to do with the wage. It's just about this perception that the company is entitled to get the labor it wants at whatever price it wants. Followed by great ideas being slowly bled to death by never-ending re-orgs, consultant engagements, and ever changing management personnel.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by rgbrenner on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:20PM (#17174246)
Why is 120k the right number? Have you taken some implicit biases of your own, and decided that's the worth of farm work?

The correct price of farm labor is whatever it costs to obtain it. There is no cap. It's whatever it costs to persuade people to move from their comfy office to the farm.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by scarface74 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:34PM (#17174333)
At a certain point, the marginal value of a dollar to anyone isn't worth the work it would take to make that dollar. That value is different for different people based on the opportunity but it does add up in aggregate.

If someone can choose to make $30K a year and adjust thier lifestyle accordingly instead of making $90K a year doing a job that they don't want to do, many people will choose the former.

I would go so far as to say the vast majority of public school teachers make the choice between less pay and being able to do a job that they enjoy as opposed to doing a job that they don't enjoy.

Anecdotally, every person I know that decided to work in the school system (including my mom and my wife) chose to do it because of stability, being off for the summer, and being able to work with kids when they both could have made more money doing something else. I doubt you could offer them 10x the amount of money to be willing to work in the fields.

But more to the point of the article, many people would not take the trade off of the dangers and long hours away from thier families, for any amount of money.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by fjsolwmv on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @10:26AM (#17179407)
Are you sure teachers wouldn't take 10x? That means 1 year of sacrifice in exchange for moving retirement up 10 years -- that's much better stability and time to spend with family and kids.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by scarface74 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @03:18PM (#17182157)
I seriously doubt that my mom would have been willing to work in the fields for any amount of money.

Heck, I wouldn't. Once you have a comfortable lifestyle, the marginal value of a dollar goes down.

After the kids get 4-5 they are in school during the day and you have the same schedule for the holidays and the summer.

My mom not only went back to work part time for the school board, she voluntarily took a pay cut from what they were willing to offer her so she could work more hours helping at risk kids without interfering with her pension.

She could have easily worked at a college, made more money and received her full pension

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by randomdata on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:30PM (#17174302)
As someone who is both a farmer and software developer, if you were going to force me to choose, I'd probably go with the $120k job. Although I see no reason to not do both and collect the $120k and $40k income.

> Some jobs are not worth the extra money to a number of people no matter how much money you throw at them.

Which is fine. As price rises, demand wanes. If strawberry pickers cost more than the consumer is willing to pay for strawberries, we'll stop growing strawberries and they can start eating something that is more efficient to produce (for example, something that is more easily harvested with machines) instead.

I will point out that this is why the formal definition of shortage is not "being able to buy what you want at a price you can afford", even if it is used that way colloquially.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by opencl on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:46PM (#17174410)
Considering that a huge number of Americans already do back breaking labor in the hot sun for $40k a year or less (usually quite significantly less), I think they would love to make $120k a year for farm work.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:14PM (#17174204)
By your logic entire concept of labour shortage is outrageous because any shortage will clear with high enough price. But for any job such as that of Truck drive the market value of that job is only X. Paying more than X would mean you should look for alternatives and get out of that business.

As the truck diver salaries go up cost of everything that relies on transportation also goes up marginally. Suddenly the struggling pistachio farmer will now find it even less economical to continue, Wallmart will have to raise prices of their goods and so on. All eventually leading up to poor people paying even more for their daily consumption items such as diapers and baby food.

The brighter side of this is that the Truck driving as an occupation would be pretty much extinct in next 20 years as self driving trucks, hyperloops, cargo drones etc. will replace them or make them really low skill jobs.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by yasp on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:17PM (#17174224)
Yes. This is how a well functioning economy works.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by platz on Monday May 28, 2018 @05:27PM (#17174945)
exactly - if they truly have a trucking shortage, the prices of all the intermediaries will have to rise, including the end shelf-price.

More short-term, Wallmart will either just discontinue that product or offer it elsewhere due to free movement of capital. We'll get just a couple brands of cereal at the supermarket, instead of 25.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @01:34AM (#17176738)
Yes. That is point I have been making.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by platz on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @08:19AM (#17178423)
But you seem to think the price going up is a bad thing, when in fact it is simply supply and demand, and necessary for markets to function.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:28PM (#17180632)
Not really. OP was arguing that there are no shortages, the companies are not willing offer more. I pointed out that if we were to accept that logic then we might as well stop using the word "shortage" as every shortage is likely to clear up if you pay more.

But the truck driver's worth is determined by market too so whenever someone says there is a shortage they mean shortage at a viable price point.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by toomuchtodo on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:26PM (#17174283)
> All eventually leading up to poor people paying even more for their daily consumption items such as diapers and baby food.

Shareholders make less, consumers don't pay more, because you're still going to rather have your goods get to market versus not being in business.

As many others in this thread have mentioned, there is no shortage. This is a narrative pushed by actors attempting to keep trucking wages low.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by jaggederest on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:03PM (#17174513)
The allocation of increased costs isn't as simple as "shareholders make less" or "consumers pay more". It depends on the number of buyers and sellers in that particular marketplace, with a sliding scale between monopsony and monopoly allocating respectively all the costs to the producer or consumer, combined with the elasticity of supply and demand for the goods and substitutes.

For example, in rental markets, it's been shown that tax increases are almost entirely passed on to tenants.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by furgooswft13 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:35PM (#17174341)
> Truck driving as an occupation would be pretty much extinct in next 20 years as self driving trucks

I doubt it. Once off the highway trucks, given their size and ungainliness, have to perform maneuvers and general rule breaking to get around that I doubt any computer would be able to manage safely in 50 years at the very least.

I've said before that self driving vehicles will be a great boon to truck drivers in the immediate future. It will allow them to relax, relatively, on the most tedious and mind numbing part of the job. Navigating small roads and loading/unloading cargo will still be a human job for awhile to come.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:45PM (#17174737)
I used the term extinct in a sense that bank tellers are pretty much extinct today because % of transactions going through real human tellers is very low. Most people use ATMs and online banking.

You correct to say that a lot of things about truck driving might not get 100% automated in next 20 years but many aspects will reducing the truck driver's salary and skill expectation. For example Wallmart or Amazon could build warehouses where trucks will be loaded and unloaded in 100% automatic fashion. For majority of the interstate driving trucks might simply go with minimal supervision and driver will have to take control only in 10% of total time. All this will make trucking less lucrative and less productive occupation. That is as good as extinction.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by dmortin on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:58AM (#17176617)
Truck drivers will still be needed off the highway, but their salaries will also be reduced if they have to drive, e.g., for only 10-20 percent of the way.

They will only be helpers for the self driving truck, not the main drivers like today.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by CPLX on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:26PM (#17174285)
If the prospect of mass unemployment and the infliction of considerable misery on a large portion of the population is considered "the brighter side" then your argument contains some pretty consequential unstated value judgements.

What, exactly, is the point of commerce in the first place? Is it measured by some abstract efficiency metric or do real life humans figure into your analysis at all? If so, which humans count and which ones don't?

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Karishma1234 on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:28PM (#17174644)
> What, exactly, is the point of commerce in the first place?

Very good question. The point of commerce is that people be able to buy other people's time willingly for a rate they voluntarily negotiate. When you can buy someone else's time you save time for your own self to do something that interests you. Everyone time you fill gas in your car you are buying perhaps 0.5 seconds of a guy who chose to work on a Oil rig in Alaska and 1 second of a government servant in Washington DC working for Energy department.

As long as people have free time there is never a problem of mass unemployment unless government makes it a crime to work on voluntarily negotiated terms.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by Firadeoclus on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @10:31AM (#17179453)
Your definition seems to entirely ignore matter. It's not enough for people to have time on their hands, they also somehow need access to the means of production, the physical goods. And enough of them to actually survive.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by CPLX on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:52PM (#17174787)
> there is never a problem of mass unemployment

Except, of course, there often is.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by mrep on Monday May 28, 2018 @08:49PM (#17175651)
> By your logic entire concept of labour shortage is outrageous because any shortage will clear with high enough price.

Per wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shortage#Causes

In a perfect market (one that matches a simple microeconomic model), an excess of demand will prompt sellers to increase prices until demand at that price matches the available supply, establishing market equilibrium. In economic terminology, a shortage occurs when for some reason (such as government intervention, or decisions by sellers not to raise prices) the price does not rise to reach equilibrium. In this circumstance, buyers want to purchase more at the market price than the quantity of the good or service that is available, and some non-price mechanism (such as "first come, first served" or a lottery) determines which buyers are served. So in a perfect market the only thing that can cause a shortage is price.

So while it can happen, 99% of the time these articles are just some company complaining about the cost of labour which they don't want to pay.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by rayiner on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:33PM (#17174331)
> By your logic entire concept of labour shortage is outrageous

The concept of an anything shortage in an efficient market is outrageous.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by throwaway2048 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:22PM (#17174259)
businesses are not entitled to cheap labour just so they can have cheaper products, sorry.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by shams93 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:29PM (#17174298)
The reason this hasn't happened in decades is every time there are labor gains the fed steps in to thrust us into a recession to destroy any labor gains thus salaries remain frozen in 1979, you salary is still wearing huge sideburns and a leisure suit while a sandwich and a soda from the market are $18. The fed plays a big role in suppressing wage income. Ultimately we create a society that punished hard work and rewards sloth on the part of the rentier class.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by perl4ever on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:42PM (#17174380)
I think a so-called labor shortage can be defined as an inelastic supply under given circumstances. There are always limits to how markets can be idealized - if you offered me $100K, $1M, or $1B to drive a truck across the country tomorrow, it wouldn't make any difference, I still couldn't qualify.

There is likely a gap between the salary a current truck driver will take and the one a potential truck driver will take, because the people who are not already doing it not only need some training but are likely to view it as a dying industry due to publicity about self-driving vehicles. So it seems like there could be substantial inelasticity just above the typical wage.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by randomdata on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:56PM (#17174471)
You might not qualify, but a sufficient amount might attract those who are. I personally know quite a few people who are legally qualified to drive truck, but have jobs that pay more doing something else.

But there are also existing truck drivers from whom you can poach from another company. If that other company cannot afford the new rate that you've offered, they're no longer in the market for a truck driver, and are no longer counted.

It's like of like software developers. At, let's say, $150,000 per year, there are only so many companies who can afford them. A place that can only afford $30,000 per year for a developer isn't in the market for developers in the first place, no matter how much they claim they are. So as price rises, the need for drivers also declines.

Technically speaking, the definition of shortage is a situation where an external mechanism, such as government intervention, prevents price from rising. That does not seem to be the case here.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by antidaily on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:26PM (#17174281)
The margins on this type of business are very low. I had a client who couldn't afford to process more than 20% of the invoices online (even though customers demanded it) because of 1.5% cc processing fee.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by meritt on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:44PM (#17174394)
Labor shortages absolutely exist. If there are 100 jobs requiring a specific skill and only 97 people exist who have that skill, that's a labor shortage. Those companies can compete for those workers all they want, but it doesn't magically create 3 new workers.

Those shortages create opportunities and more people train to fill those gaps but it takes some amount of time before 3 new workers are available.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by stevenwoo on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:13PM (#17174570)
There are some alternatives that do not increase the labor supply - for farmers they might switch to a crop that requires less manual labor or is mechanizable so they do not need as many workers, and demand for that crop might be filled by imports from another country. It seems like something weird is going on with farm labor because we hear about a shortage of workers every couple of years but farm worker pay have not gone up that much ( up to half the average California workers salary).

Here's one example of the guy in Stockton paying about 16000(?) versus the people in Napa paying 40000 for the same crop/work (the grapes in Napa are worth more), and Napa farm workers are commuting from the Central Valley.

http://www.latimes.com/projects/la-fi-farms-immigration/

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lopmotr on Monday May 28, 2018 @04:27PM (#17174628)
In that case, 3 companies will realize they don't actually need those workers afterall, not for the salary they're demanding. They'll find another way to do business without hiring them, or they might even go out of business, which is fine and normal in a well functioning economy.

There's actually no need for truck drivers. People could carry loads on their backs. The reason companies don't hire people for this is because they're much more expensive (ignoring speed/etc.) than truck drivers. So if you're saying there can be labor shortages (in a free market), you could also say there's a severe shortage of human thing-carriers, which is ridiculous.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by meritt on Monday May 28, 2018 @05:07PM (#17174854)
> In that case, 3 companies will realize they don't actually need those workers afterall, not for the salary they're demanding. They'll find another way to do business without hiring them, or they might even go out of business, which is fine and normal in a well functioning economy.

Absolutely that could happen. But it's funny how you refuse to acknowledge that there may be a "labor shortage" and instead you present it as a "abundance of jobs", as if they aren't two sides of the same coin.

Your second point is just ridiculous, I agree.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lopmotr on Thursday May 31, 2018 @06:40PM (#17200960)
It's neither a labor shortage nor an abundance of jobs because there's no correct amount of labor to compare against. All it is is a price for labor which sometimes goes up and sometimes goes down, but there's no correct price at which there's neither a shortage nor an oversupply.

If it's ridiculous to say there's a shortage of thing-carriers, how is the different from saying there's a shortage of truck drivers? What's the difference? If you just dismiss it as ridiculous, then you probably don't know what you're talking about.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by meritt on Thursday May 31, 2018 @06:52PM (#17201028)
Truck drivers require a specific skill and license. There's a finite amount of those people at any point in time. If the number of jobs exceeds the number of workers, then we have an abundance of jobs in relation to the amount of human capital.

It's really not a difficult concept to understand.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by lopmotr on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:42AM (#17203614)
You're missing the point. This has nothing to do with more drivers entering the market to return the numbers to any artificial "correct" number. If more companies wanted truck drivers more desperately, their pay would go up. Same number of drivers but they'd all earn more as employers compete to get what's available. Or if half of them quit, the pay for the remaining half would go up. Less truck driving would be done and fewer companies would need truck drivers (at the price they now demand).
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by nradov on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @11:41AM (#17180144)
What you have described is not a labor shortage.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by meritt on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @11:46AM (#17180190)
Please explain to me what a labor shortage is then, if it's not a shortage of labor.

Should I be using the more economically correct phrase 'scarcity of human capital'?

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by jbob2000 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:14PM (#17174203)
They are increasing compensation, but the job is so shit, and so demanding on time, that it's still not worth it. I'd want to see $500,000 a year before I put long-haul trucking demands on my body.

The industry has labour problems that aren't related to pay. Nobody wants to sit outside a business for 6-8 hours, earning 0 dollars. Solution: Fine deliverees by the minute. Over-policing of truckers. Solution: Lower fines for commercial truckers, thus removing the incentive for police interaction. Long time away from family. Solution: Truckers have a maximum distance they may travel in a day, which includes the return trip.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by ams6110 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:36PM (#17174348)
Yes but there are people who don't have the same point of view as you. There are people who like spending a lot of time by themselves, for which trucking has an appeal. I know people in the trades who say things like "you couldn't pay me enough money to work in an office."
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by mcguire on Monday May 28, 2018 @09:35PM (#17175811)
The people to whom truck driving is attractive are probably already driving trucks.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by rectang on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:31PM (#17174313)
Yes, the "everybody has their price" analysis bothers me as well because it only takes into account monetary compensation. There are lots of other factors which make a job more or less appealing: time away from home, job security, personal risk, physical demands. Maybe try to attract more talent by improving working conditions?