News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by scarface74 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:15PM (#17174210)
That doesn't always work as is the case for farm work once you make immigration harder. How many Americans if given a choice would rather make $40K a year doing nice and comfortable office work than make $120K a year (yes I'm making up a number to make a point) to do back breaking manual labor in the hot sun?

Not quite to that extreme, but I'm giving up money now by choosing not to go into management and stay a senior developer because I don't want to be a manager and not to get a better paying job as a consultant who would have to travel more and be away from my family. My wife took a pay cut when we got married to work at a job she enjoys.

Some jobs are not worth the extra money to a number of people no matter how much money you throw at them.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by mlthoughts2018 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:36PM (#17174347)
I, for one, would enjoy a physically challenging job spending time outdoors, learning about specialized equipment, hueristics for the business, if I felt like I was very well-paid and valued. Most such jobs seem to be marketed to push down salaries above all else, target the work at low-skilled candidates, generally have low-status perceptions in society, and hiring companies seem focused on finding ways to mitigate labor shortage without raising wages.

The quote, “the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent” comes to mind. Companies will not pay competitively. They’ll suffer in any other way, but they won’t pay people.

The same effect happens at many price points. For example, the huge push of hype into data science is often a way to push down wages in machine learning / stats. Jobs go unfilled for months, but the company will not offer competitive pay or benefits. I’ve seen this both as a candidate and as a hiring manager frustrated by HR & leadership teams vetoing rare, qualified candidates because they ask for $30k above the budget, or they want sponsored travel to academic conferences, or they want us to match their existing severance benefits at their current company.

Even when we have indisputable business needs for detailed experience in a domain specialty, they think: can’t you just hire a kid out of school with a cardigan & a macbook for $130K? When we show them a qualified candidate earning $200k, it’s just an unconditional no, without any thought as to why that wage gap is there, and why we have a “talent shortage.”

Just totally clueless yet extremely price sensitive.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by steve_gh on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:25PM (#17180595)
Technical director in a specialist engineering data science consultancy group here. The problem we face is a gap between customer expectation of skills and costs. We have a brilliant high-skilled team (15% post-doc, pretty much everyone else MSc in a STEM subject, loads of experience). Our customers like what we do (we are constantly recruiting), but they don't always realise that our fees are based on competing for talent against hedge funds and high-tech startups. It's a fine balancing act to get the right calibre of people at a price our market will bear.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by mlthoughts2018 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @01:15PM (#17181081)
I am a machine learning team manager, sounds similar to your role, but in a large traditional enterprise company. What I see more of is that big companies expect to be able to dictate wages to candidates completely independently of market compensation or competition for candidates.

One thing is that people up the food chain are usually rewarded for outwardly displaying one-sided emotional buy-in to the company's stated mission, to the point that their jobs largely consist of emotional labor, cheerleading every initiative, restructuring, TED talk, executive announcement, etc., as unequivocally "good", never "bad", and 100% forward-thinking genius.

Surely most of them have internal, private lives where they know this is nonsense, but they cannot let it be seen or even suspected. And as a result, their language must always be based in the presumption that any candidate in the world would be lucky to work for us, and would have to be a fool to choose to work somewhere else, and that if they turned us down for any reason at all, it must always mean their heart was in the wrong place and they were insincere and misguided to have any doubt about working for us.

When you are trying to create job requisitions, slides about growing a team, etc., and this is the sort of attitude you're going to face in the approval meetings, it is wickedly difficult. There's no way you can come right out and say we don't offer competitive salaries, because that would mean somehow "we are bad." And HR, whose job isn't tied to the actual productivity of my team, is more than happy to sycophantically agree with upper management, and try to spin the story that either it just takes time to find the right (read: unwittingly cheap) candidate, or else it's the technical team's fault for not doing a good job with interviews.

Then there will be some lengthy song and dance about hiring third party recruiters (who will tell them the same thing -- candidates who are good enough are not cheap enough), sexy new start-ups in the HR space, like HackerRank nonsense, or management consultants, followed by tenuous re-orgs, restructurings, constantly reworded job ads, tweaking of job titles, creating more and more "road maps" about what roles we see the team growing into, etc.

And after months, or even years, of wasted effort on all that junk overhead, we'll still just be lacking the basic productivity we need to create the basic business outcomes we need. Different managers will have quit or gotten promoted. Different start-ups will have gone out of business or popped into existence. Different consulting companies will offer new over-the-moon promises about finding talent. And it all just repeats.

When it comes to wages in these companies, the amounts it would take to hire a top-end candidate (say, maybe, $350K in total compensation or something) is absolutely trivial to the company's budget. They could pay thousands of people at that wage, even including overhead for benefits, etc.

It really has nothing to do with the wage. It's just about this perception that the company is entitled to get the labor it wants at whatever price it wants. Followed by great ideas being slowly bled to death by never-ending re-orgs, consultant engagements, and ever changing management personnel.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by rgbrenner on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:20PM (#17174246)
Why is 120k the right number? Have you taken some implicit biases of your own, and decided that's the worth of farm work?

The correct price of farm labor is whatever it costs to obtain it. There is no cap. It's whatever it costs to persuade people to move from their comfy office to the farm.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by scarface74 on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:34PM (#17174333)
At a certain point, the marginal value of a dollar to anyone isn't worth the work it would take to make that dollar. That value is different for different people based on the opportunity but it does add up in aggregate.

If someone can choose to make $30K a year and adjust thier lifestyle accordingly instead of making $90K a year doing a job that they don't want to do, many people will choose the former.

I would go so far as to say the vast majority of public school teachers make the choice between less pay and being able to do a job that they enjoy as opposed to doing a job that they don't enjoy.

Anecdotally, every person I know that decided to work in the school system (including my mom and my wife) chose to do it because of stability, being off for the summer, and being able to work with kids when they both could have made more money doing something else. I doubt you could offer them 10x the amount of money to be willing to work in the fields.

But more to the point of the article, many people would not take the trade off of the dangers and long hours away from thier families, for any amount of money.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by fjsolwmv on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @10:26AM (#17179407)
Are you sure teachers wouldn't take 10x? That means 1 year of sacrifice in exchange for moving retirement up 10 years -- that's much better stability and time to spend with family and kids.
Re:America has a truck driver shortage by scarface74 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @03:18PM (#17182157)
I seriously doubt that my mom would have been willing to work in the fields for any amount of money.

Heck, I wouldn't. Once you have a comfortable lifestyle, the marginal value of a dollar goes down.

After the kids get 4-5 they are in school during the day and you have the same schedule for the holidays and the summer.

My mom not only went back to work part time for the school board, she voluntarily took a pay cut from what they were willing to offer her so she could work more hours helping at risk kids without interfering with her pension.

She could have easily worked at a college, made more money and received her full pension

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by randomdata on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:30PM (#17174302)
As someone who is both a farmer and software developer, if you were going to force me to choose, I'd probably go with the $120k job. Although I see no reason to not do both and collect the $120k and $40k income.

> Some jobs are not worth the extra money to a number of people no matter how much money you throw at them.

Which is fine. As price rises, demand wanes. If strawberry pickers cost more than the consumer is willing to pay for strawberries, we'll stop growing strawberries and they can start eating something that is more efficient to produce (for example, something that is more easily harvested with machines) instead.

I will point out that this is why the formal definition of shortage is not "being able to buy what you want at a price you can afford", even if it is used that way colloquially.

Re:America has a truck driver shortage by opencl on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:46PM (#17174410)
Considering that a huge number of Americans already do back breaking labor in the hot sun for $40k a year or less (usually quite significantly less), I think they would love to make $120k a year for farm work.