News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by yardie on Sunday May 20, 2018 @11:01PM (#17115908)
I took the inaugural train this weekend from Miami to Ft. Lauderdale. The distance is 24miles as the crow flies and the journey exactly 30 minutes. So the average speed for this leg of the journey was 48mph.

This same journey would take 45 minutes by car in the express lane. I don't even want to imagine what this would be in the non-express during rush hour.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by sandos on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:09AM (#17116687)
That is a really slow train, almost makes it sound like a tram. How many stops were there?

Trains here in Sweden, albeit for longer distances usually go either 120, 160 or 200 km/h. Thats 74/100/124 miles/h.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by snaily on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:05AM (#17117088)
Just looked up an example to compare: Östertälje-Uppsala C, a large part of a Stockholm commuter train line, is 102 km long, and takes 1:32h for an average speed of 66km/h, or 41mph, below the 45mph quoted in the article.

The acceleration and waiting at stations really hits the average.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:57AM (#17117451)
This is a regional train not commuter. According to the official website there is no stop between Miami and Ft Lauredale: https://gobrightline.com/fort-lauderdale/
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by gsnedders on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:13AM (#17118957)
A better comparison is the Stockholm C – Uppsala C SJ-operated non-stop services, which like the Miami to Ft Lauredale services take exactly 30 minutes.

This is 63 km (39 mi) as the crow flies (66 km by track), so an average speed of 126 km/h (78 mph), substantially quicker than the Miami to Ft Lauredale service.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by tssva on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:44PM (#17127877)
Taking a look at Google maps that is not really comparable either. Much of the area between them appears to be rural with a low population density where as Miami to Ft Lauderdale is high population density the entire route. Train speeds are limited in high density areas for safety.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by gsnedders on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:45AM (#17133297)
> Train speeds are limited in high density areas for safety.

There are plenty of places in Europe where 100mph+ running through urban areas is common. Urban v. rural isn't really a consideration for line speeds here. Heck, most of the mainlines north and west out of London reach their 125mph top speeds while still within Greater London. The question here is more about the presence and type of at-grade crossings, and there's a fair number on lines with 125mph running.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by geezerjay on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:39AM (#17119170)
> The acceleration and waiting at stations really hits the average.

Actually, having to wait about 1 or 2 minutes at each stop is what really drags down the commercial speed. A train only takes a fraction of that time to go from 100km/h to zero.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by geezerjay on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:35AM (#17119139)
> That is a really slow train, almost makes it sound like a tram.

I don't believe that's remotely slow. A commercial speed of 48mph (about 77km/h) is a respectable speed for a conventional intercity and suburban train. Please note that commercial speed is the average speed, and also takes into account the time that a train stays at each stop.

As a comparison, the commercial speed of a tram (light rail, no right-of-way) is around 20km/h (about 12mph) and the average commercial speed of a subway system (medium rail, right-of-way) is about 30km/h (about 17mph). The latter is, obviously, also not slow because it matches the average speed of an automobile circulating in an urban area.

Going nearly 80km/h is respectably fast, and will beat the commercial speed of your typical commute by car.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:57PM (#17120313)
> I don't believe that's remotely slow. A commercial speed of 48mph (about 77km/h) is a respectable speed for a conventional intercity and suburban train.

There's nothing respectable about under 80 for an intercity train which has 0 stops over 40km. In Europe this is an average speed more closely associated with commuter train, or the regional trains with relatively frequent stops (every 5~10km).

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by tzahola on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:05AM (#17117086)
From the article: “The train runs at a top speed of 79 miles per hour on the leg between Miami and Fort Lauderdale ”
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by endless1234 on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:01AM (#17117066)
Top speed vs average speed.. ~80km/h average is pretty normal/good for commuter trains
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:13AM (#17117795)
It's not a commuter train it's intercity. Tri-rail is the existing commuter service, it has 17 stations between Miami and West Palm Beach included (and Mangonia Park beyond WPB). This has 3 stations total: Miami, West Palm Beach and Fort Lauredale.

Silver Service has more stops along the way than Brightline.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by kss238 on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:31AM (#17116950)
It's not even a 40km trip. How fast do you expect the train to get up to?
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:52AM (#17117030)
https://www.google.fr/maps/dir/Dijon+Gare,+Dijon,+France/Bea...

~40km, 18 minutes. That's an average speed of ~130km/h.

There's also a run with 4 station stops inbetween and makes the trip in 28, so that's still an average speed of ~85km/h.

77km/h average on a ~40km non-stop (I'm assuming) run is quite slow.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by yardie on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:31PM (#17120579)
There is a lot of open fields in that route and there are lot of above grade and under grade crossings. No need to slow for traffic.

Brightline covers a few cities with one long strip of a suburb the entire route. Except in length the comparison isn't remotely fair.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @05:11AM (#17124642)
It's a completely fair comparison, Brightline decided not to use grade separation.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by Operyl on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:51AM (#17126270)
Brightline reused existing tracks for the most part. They just upgraded what was needed over the course of several months.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:01AM (#17117462)
> non-stop (I'm assuming)

Confirmed looking at the official site, there is no stop between Miami and Ft Lauredale.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by alex_duf on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:45AM (#17117004)
It's fairly common in Europe to have trains go fast, even on short distances. Some London tube line (Victoria line, metropolitan line) got faster than that train.

Don't get me wrong, definitely a great step in the right direction.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by mhandley on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:46AM (#17117009)
London St Pancras to St Albans (a medium size town north of london) is 25 miles. The train takes 19 minutes.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by bobthepanda on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:48AM (#17117018)
The question is if whether or not saving ten minutes is worth the amount it would cost the company to do the required upgrades. The answer is, at least right now, not yet.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:00AM (#17117064)
It's a brand new regional train yet barely reaches the speed of your average euro commuter train from the 60s (not joking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNCF_Class_Z_5300 has a top speed of 81mph).
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by bobthepanda on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:04AM (#17117082)
We are also talking about rail service where none previously existed, in a sprawled out, auto-dependent metropolitan area. High speed rail was not built in a day.

It's also worth noting that all rail has to be at this point is faster than its competition, which it is. Cars are slower and this is far too short of a distance for airplanes.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by projektfu on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:11AM (#17117285)
http://www.tri-rail.com

The area has had commuter rail for over 20 years. This express service is using previously freight-only lines. What's really going to be impressive is when it connects Orlando.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:13AM (#17117790)
The 3h they're predicting for Miami - Orlando seems less than impressive. Especially as the Orlando station is at the airport.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by hamandcheese on Monday May 21, 2018 @08:52AM (#17117985)
Especially considering you can fly Orlando to Miami, possibly in less total time.

Granted, flying is not a cost effective means to commute, but I don’t think rail service from Orlando to Miami will have too many true commuters on board compared to less frequent travelers.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by ghaff on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:50AM (#17118331)
You're basically talking the equivalent of Boston to New York City although you don't have the same potential for downtown to downtown travel. That's definitely not a daily commute sort of thing. I don't know enough about Florida travel patterns to know how much sense that city pair makes.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:36AM (#17118673)
If you have the market for an HSR (a real one) it's feasible, thought not great and you'd really need better downtown public transport. Assuming direct it'd be a ~1:45 trip, possibly 1:30 on the really modern 350km/h (~220mph) lines, and if you don't have trouble falling asleep you can usually sleep/nap, you can work, and you could have a meal service.

Not cheap though, HSR tickets are not $10 (though it's not that far if you're using a high-frequency subscription thing, especially if you're using it daily).

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by hamandcheese on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:15AM (#17118519)
Personally I’d rather see Orlando to Tampa, but it definitely felt like 80% of the people I went to college with in Orlando were from south Florida.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by bobthepanda on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:45PM (#17120698)
West Palm Beach to Miami is equivalent to Trenton to New York, which is not great but also not wildly unrealistic.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by bobthepanda on Monday May 21, 2018 @12:18PM (#17119466)
Both airports are traffic prone and you have to account the time of getting there and passing through American security theater.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @12:54PM (#17119805)
> you have to account the time of getting there

Only at Miami since the Orlando train station is, again, at the Orlando airport. So the traffic trouble will be the exact same.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by closeparen on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:23PM (#17120512)
Arbitraging TSA rules with rail is only going to work until the first train bomb. At most.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by saosebastiao on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:55AM (#17119283)
The top speed here is regulatory. There is a 79mph speed limit on tracks shared with freight trains. Also we have weight minimums.

Basically most of the reason our trains suck is because our regulatory body sucks.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by rayiner on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:17AM (#17118531)
That's about 75 miles per hour. Acela (our high-speed intercity train) makes the 39 mile Washington to Baltimore trip (with a single stop in-between) at 68 miles per hour. The non-express intercity train makes a two-stop trip at 49 miles per hour. The commuter train is under 40 miles per hour.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by cbm-vic-20 on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:21AM (#17119030)
Acela does the trip between Boston and Providence (43.6 miles by rail) in 33 minutes: that's just about 80mph, which includes one stop along the way. The Northeast Regional does it in 38 minutes- about 69mph on average.

The Acela hits 150mph along some stretches in New England.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by geezerjay on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:49AM (#17119243)
> Acela (our high-speed intercity train) makes the 39 mile Washington to Baltimore trip (with a single stop in-between) at 68 miles per hour.

That's not necessarily a fair comparison, as IIRC Amtrack shares rail tracks with cargo trains. Cargo trains are far slower and occupy tracks for longer stretches of time, while passenger trains require longer stretches of track to be reserved for their passage to ensure higher circulation speeds. Thus, having to share tracks with slower trains limits how the track can be allocated to passenger traffic.

To put it differently, that would be like stating that a bus is slow because in some stretches of road it is forced to wait cargo trucks to pass.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by rayiner on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:01PM (#17119867)
Amtrak owns the Boston-DC segment and does not share with freight rail.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by geezerjay on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:18PM (#17120002)
> Amtrak owns the Boston-DC segment and does not share with freight rail.

Wikipedia says that several companies run freight trains over sections of the NEC, as well as the line is also used by commuter trains.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northeast_Corridor

As a comparison, the TGV connection between Paris and Brussels may be a high-speed track, but train speeds grind to a halt way down to 20km/h when passing through track sections used by commuter and freight trains.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by Operyl on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:49AM (#17126254)
There've been a number of accidents involving the train now, too. People who think they can outrun the train, as far as I'm aware they've all been pedestrians. I wonder if this is the reason they're not going faster yet.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by tonywastaken on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:32PM (#17123524)
The FEC (Florida East Coast railway) tracks that the Brightline runs on have a lot of grade crossings in between Miami and Ft. Lauderdale.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by andrepd on Monday May 21, 2018 @12:26PM (#17119530)
The top speed is nearly irrelevant to the time of the trip. The bulk of the difference is in the length and frequency of the stops.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:58PM (#17120323)
It has no stops between Miami and Ft Lauredale. 0. None. Nada. Zip.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by walshemj on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:00AM (#17118393)
Possibly limited by the max speed allowed by the track limits as some one said that it was using freight tracks.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by CalRobert on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:43AM (#17118726)
Or this, since 79 mph is oddly specific.

"Trains without "an automatic cab signal, automatic train stop or automatic train control system "may not exceed 79 mph."" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rail_speed_limits_in_the_Unite...

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by zaroth on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:48PM (#17122132)
They spent $1.5 billion reusing existing track and still couldn’t get ATC? :-(
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by walshemj on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @08:10AM (#17125317)
Don't think they have this on a national scale in the states
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by cjrp on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:23AM (#17116917)
Don't you have commuter trains?
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by masklinn on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:10AM (#17117109)
This is a regional train not a commuter train. Commuter trains have stations every few miles, this doesn't.

It's a bit subtle, but that folks commute with it doesn't make it a commuter train, I've known folks who commuted via HSR (proper, euro-style).

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by chrisseaton on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:30AM (#17116946)
Yes, but they speed up to between stations and don't run at just 48 mph.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by cjrp on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:32AM (#17116959)
Presumably the average speed of 48mph includes slowing down/accelerating.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by gsnedders on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:15AM (#17118975)
The question then is why it takes so long to accelerate.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by geezerjay on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:52AM (#17119266)
> The question then is why it takes so long to accelerate.

For a number of reasons, including safety, passenger comfort, and managing the trade-off between energy waste and traveling speed. You can picture a passenger bus and how gradually the driver needs to start the ride. You can't just supercharge the engine and expect passengers to grab hold to their seats.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by gsnedders on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:00PM (#17122219)
The relatively new stopping trains here accelerate at up to 1.0m/s^2; using that as a figure (because it's nice and round), and where 79mph ~= 35m/s (to 2 s.f., as are all derived figures below):

It takes 35 seconds to accelerate up to top speed, in which case it has travelled 610m. The distance of the track is 25 miles (or 40km), and assuming it maintains the top speed throughout and deceleration matches acceleration for comfort, then the journey would take 19 minutes.

If we take the lower value of 0.79m/s^2, which is what the newest intercity diesel trains do:

It takes 44 seconds to accelerate up to top speed, in which case it has travelled 780m. The journey would take 20 minutes.

Okay, these are somewhat optimistic assumptions, but the European in me would be surprised if there were that many places where it had to slow significantly, and obviously they don't actually have linear acceleration (we're talking closer to 60s to 60mph in the diesel case in reality, though the additional acceleration to 79mph is likely near the maximum acceleration give the reason for the prolongation is reducing jank).

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by goatlover on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:49AM (#17116812)
Yeah, we don't get to have those kinds of trains here. Maybe 74, and maybe hyperloop one day.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by pc86 on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:54AM (#17117698)
The train travels 79mph, it's just not in a straight line.

Take the straight line distance and using that to computer average speed is disingenuous to say the least.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by ComradeTaco on Sunday May 20, 2018 @11:29PM (#17115962)
It's definitely a good option and it's just a conventional speed intercity service: A true high speed rail line would take about 14 minutes.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by noobermin on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:35AM (#17116360)
As if high speed rail exists in the united states. This is high tech for us here.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by adventured on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:31AM (#17116555)
It's about to. Texas is going to build a bunch of high speed rail over the next 15-20 years, likely linking every major city in the state and then connecting into a few neighbor states. The first line, between Dallas and Houston, will begin construction within the next year. Unlike California, Texas will actually get this done quickly at a sane cost, and it will act as a model for the rest of the US.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Central_Railway

https://communityimpact.com/houston/tomball-magnolia/develop...

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by mnky9800n on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:35AM (#17116564)
This is still too slow. Available in 20 years? I live now, not 20 years from now. True investment would see it being built far quicker.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by desdiv on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:46AM (#17116603)
"The best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago. The second best time is now."

I agree with you that it's too little too late, but at least they're trying.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by moz23 on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:56AM (#17117702)
15-20 years is exactly the same timeframe that most of Europe uses for railway planning. That includes things like HS2 in the UK, the Berlin-Munich high speed rail project, LGV Rhin-Rhone, the new Gotthard tunnel, etc.

The main difference is that this planning is done much further in advance (although at least the UK is well behind in terms of rail capacity construction - the UK and the US have many similarities in terms of government incompetence).

Only place that is faster is China, but they work on a different scale.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by adventured on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:51AM (#17116625)
Hopefully you'll be alive in 20 years too. It's the old adage about the best time to plant a tree. The US has been avoiding high speed rail for decades leaning on excuses about time & cost; it's a form of being crippled by short-term thinking.

Connecting Dallas, Houston, Austin, San Antonio, El Paso, will take at least a decade, more likely closer to 15 years. There is no real scenario where it happens faster.

From El Paso you push to Tucson, Phoenix, Albuquerque.

From Houston you go to New Orleans.

From Dallas you go to Oklahoma City.

Then if other cities are smart at all and pick up some confidence about what can be done, and at a reasonable cost, you then see eg St Louis, Louisville, Cincinnati, Indianapolis, Chicago all link up. And so on.

The model for the US will be regional high speed rail, rather than massive scale coast to coast approaches. Maybe eventually you get high speed interlinking between them.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by goatlover on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:53AM (#17116820)
From OKCity to Wichita to KSCity to Chicago. Connect Texas to Chicago by high speed rail.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by adventured on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:16AM (#17116895)
Charlotte to Atlanta to Jacksonville to Orlando to Tampa to Miami.

Atlanta or Jacksonville to Mobile and on to New Orleans, which gets you to Texas via Houston.

El Paso to Tucson/Phoenix gets you to Vegas. Properly that's an easy hop to Los Angeles (skepticism warranted because it's infrastructure in California), which gets you LA to Texas to Miami.

If they did it right, Texas ends up acting as the obvious central web that you can tie the country together with high speed rail over time.

We could build all of this for $400 billion perhaps, if it's done as it will be in Texas in terms of time & cost (enter the land & zoning nightmares in some parts of the country); $20b per year for 20 years (non inflation adjusted), which we can easily afford.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by projektfu on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:16AM (#17117297)
Why these big switchbacks, like atl-jax-orl and orl-tpa-mia? Kind of out of the way for little benefit. Perhaps Orlando could be a hub, with lines going NE, NW, SW, and SE.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by usrusr on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:50AM (#17117218)
For comparison, Germany is just now finishing rail projects that were triggered by the reunification.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by ghaff on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:52AM (#17118345)
And then there's the new Berlin airport...
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by yardie on Sunday May 20, 2018 @11:51PM (#17116014)
Yes, but this is passing through developed land at this point. I've yet to see a european high speed train hit it's top speed in a populated area. Even TGV doesn't do it's namesake while in Ile-de-France.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by pgeorgi on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:03AM (#17116667)
They're slower in populated areas because the tracks aren't made for high-speed there (eg. too strong curvature, lots of junctions).

The same train takes 12 minutes for the ICE Frankfurt/Cologne to get from Frankfurt central station to Frankfurt Airport (9km linear distance, average 45km/h, 28mph) and then 49 minutes from there to Cologne (150km linear distance, average 183km/h, 113mph).

The latter leg is still pretty close to "populated areas" (just outside various towns along the route), but the track was specifically made for that train (taking required minimum curvature etc into account) and point-to-point connection (fewer junctions).

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by vonmoltke on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:03AM (#17118051)
> The latter leg is still pretty close to "populated areas" (just outside various towns along the route), but the track was specifically made for that train (taking required minimum curvature etc into account) and point-to-point connection (fewer junctions).

How many grade crossings are there on that route? This train, at least through Hallandale/Hollywood, needs to deal with a grade crossing every half mile (800m) or so. Considering the crap that went on during the effort 20 years ago to get FEC to stop using horns at certain times of day convincing people that a train should be allowed to do 100+ mph down that line is a non-starter.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by gsnedders on Monday May 21, 2018 @11:17AM (#17118999)
Basically nowhere in Europe allows grade crossings (of any sort, pedestrian or vehicular) at over 200km/h, and it's a 300km/h line. There aren't any.

That said, I can think of a fair number of places in different places in Europe where there's at-grade crossings in built up areas where trains regularly cross at around 100mph. (OTOH, there's no general requirement for horns/whistles at them.)

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday May 20, 2018 @11:56PM (#17116025)
In China, HSR can hit full speed in urban areas, but they are also on viaducts.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by bobthepanda on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:23AM (#17116307)
China also lacks actual mechanisms ensuring that land seizure serves the public and results in fair compensation.

Some models are better off not being applied.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by jfoutz on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:52AM (#17116419)
I’m not sure if you are asserting eminent domain is a mistake.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by bobthepanda on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:10AM (#17116480)
Of course not all of it is, but at the same time there are limits to how much benefit you can get out of it for the downside. In the West eminent domain's necessity is contestable, and thus it is used very sparingly and only when the benefits are undoubtedly much better than the downside; no modern Western country could get away with evicting 1.5 million people for a sporting event, or appropriating massive amounts of land to build speculative real estate when vacancy rates are in the double digits.

Is the benefit of running at full tilt in cities really worth it? You don't spend a lot of mileage traveling within a city, and cities are generally places where trains slow down and stop anyways. Combined with the very high cost of land appropriation in a city assuming fair market compensation, there's a reason why most places just don't bother with full high speed rail in urban areas.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by thaumasiotes on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:05AM (#17116858)
> In the West eminent domain's necessity is contestable, and thus it is used very sparingly and only when the benefits are undoubtedly much better than the downside

Or for an alternative view, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelo_v._City_of_New_London .

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by twelvechairs on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:59AM (#17117057)
The USA actually has a long history of extensive eminent domain use, although it has cooled more recently. As with most anglosphere countries lately its use has become more highly protested, challenged and politicized, making it a little more haphazard (and much more if those with economic ability to mount a serious legal challenge are involved).

In China its been used more regularly however compensation has been often ridiculously pitiful (although sometimes also quite reasonable and this has as I understand improved more recently). Sometimes we pay poor compensation in the west too though maybe not as bad.

Its also tied to China's communist past where land is for the public good (and typically only leased by individuals) as opposed to the west's 'right to land ownership' (i use inverted commas because its never really been an absolute right, even if people use the phrase).

Best practice in my view (as someone in the industry) is probably somewhere in between. I don't believe in a world of limited resources (as we are in) in indefinite rights of land ownership. I do believe however in fair compensation, which probably should be a considerable premium above an independently assessed market value (if the site was otherwise sold today, accounting for any other anticipated changes to the neighbourhood).

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by bobthepanda on Monday May 21, 2018 @04:51AM (#17117029)
> Opposition to the ruling was widespread, coming from groups such as AARP, the NAACP, the Libertarian Party and the Institute for Justice. Many owners of family farms also disapproved of the ruling, as they saw it as an avenue by which cities could seize their land for private developments. The American Conservative Union condemned the decision.[29]

As a result, many states changed their eminent domain laws. Prior to the Kelo decision, only seven states specifically prohibited the use of eminent domain for economic development except to eliminate blight. Since the decision, forty-four states have amended their eminent domain laws, although some of these changes are cosmetic.[30]

The mechanisms were adjusted accordingly as the public and the politicians they voted in saw fit.

Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by mnky9800n on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:36AM (#17116569)
There is no land ownership in China. So why should there be strong eminent domain laws?
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by joe_the_user on Sunday May 20, 2018 @11:54PM (#17116019)
Compared to Sonoma County Smart Train, in my area, which takes an hour to get from Santa Rosa to San Rafael (Google say 38 miles by freeway so I assume less as the crow flies) in an hour, this seems quite good.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by johannes1234321 on Monday May 21, 2018 @01:08PM (#17119916)
Any issue is that the car brings you close to your final destination. With a train you need connecting service, a working public transport system, like in Japan and many parts of Europe.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by pc86 on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:56AM (#17117701)
I hope it's obviously why you can't use straight line distance to computer average speed for something that doesn't move in a perfectly straight line.
Re:One-Of-a-Kind Private Train Takes on Florida’s Traffic Ni... by dx034 on Monday May 21, 2018 @07:58AM (#17117717)
High-speed trains often move close to straight-line (which is a reason why they're so expensive) and if you compare to planes (for longer distances), they also fly approx straight lines. Theoretical average speed is a valid measurement, in my opinion, also for door-to-door times for flying vs. driving.