News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by jacquesm on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:12PM (#17097477)
Thank you for making a coherent argument. You are missing one point I think: if not for those regulations those companies would love to do business. They are forbidden from doing business, this guy sees the law and runs off without even trying to become compliant. That's a different thing. There is no way that Kinder could be compliant with US law in such a way that they would not be exposed to what - to EU sensibilities - amount to exorbitant damage claims.

Similar arguments apply to the other examples you use, I see your point and there are valid reasons to not enter a certain market because of the legal climate there but the point I am trying to make is that the OP has not raise any valid point at all other than 'I don't want to comply'. And that's fine by me but then don't bother dressing it up in a bunch of made up requirements.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kingofhdds on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:58AM (#17098816)
>this guy sees the law and runs off without even trying to become compliant

This guy quite clearly states that he doesn't have resources to become compliant, while it is too risky to make a mistake here.

There are fans of GDPR on this website, who prefer to ignore the fact that the compliance has its cost, and added to that still unknown risks of practical interpretation of legislation which also have their cost. But these are real life things.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by Angostura on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:24AM (#17099135)
I respect his right to do whatever he would like with his own hobby, but we should be clear that the guy is stating he doesn’t have the resources, based on a series of misunderstandings.

So, for example, he says he is required to appoint a DPO.

The U.K. Information Commissioner has this to say:

>Do we need to appoint a Data Protection Officer?

A> Under the GDPR, you must appoint a DPO if:

> you are a public authority (except for courts acting in their judicial capacity);

> your core activities require large scale, regular and systematic monitoring of individuals (for example, online behaviour tracking);

> * or your core activities consist of large scale processing of special categories of data or data relating to criminal convictions and offences.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by caffeine5150 on Friday May 18, 2018 @10:19AM (#17101650)
You are correct as to a DPO, but if he is, say in the US, and subject to GDPR, he must have an EU Representative, who by all indications would be liable for his violations. That's a significant burden if not a practical impossibility for most in his position. Also, if he's transferring personal data from the EU to the US directly from individuals, his only practical way of making that transfer compliant is likely to be privacy shield certified which is not cost free (although he could maybe rely on consent as a derogation, but relying on that has risk). I can think of many things like this that have, if not a hard cost, then a definite cost in time and resources to comply including keeping up with compliance. Could easily be not worth the effort for a single individual.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kingofhdds on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:02AM (#17099813)
And "large scale" means how many records in DB? How many users? Or records per day?
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by Angostura on Friday May 18, 2018 @07:23AM (#17100499)
Why have you isolated one element from a multiple element sentence:

If

* core activities * require * large scale * regular * systematic

If you tick all those other boxes, but are concerned that your processing may be teetering on the boundary of 'large scale', I would be cautious and assume your liable.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kingofhdds on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:05AM (#17100724)
All repeatable processes are systematic, almost the whole IT goes into the category. And "core" is undefined too.

I agree that it is safer to imply you're liable.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by peteretep on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:41AM (#17100021)
These are excellent questions that you will have to have shown you've considered if you get audited. If there's disagreement with the regulator, you'll come together to resolve it, and then may need to appoint one.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kingofhdds on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:55AM (#17100105)
Well, so it's undefined, at least until practice of legal application establishes. Undefined means risk, and stopping serving EU is a meaningful mitigation, if your profits don't compensate you for all the hassle. Where's "overreaction“ then?
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by pgeorgi on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:23AM (#17099926)
Monal is an XMPP client running on user's iOS devices. Is that person even running an XMPP server for those users?
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by caffeine5150 on Friday May 18, 2018 @10:21AM (#17101663)
A UK privacy attorney I know considered 20k records (individuals) to be large scale. I haven't seen much helpful guidance. The WP29 guidance I've read only gives examples at the very extremes of large and small so not too helpful. Practical guidelines will evolve over time.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by scotty79 on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:49AM (#17100069)
I guess if you have to ask that question you are not a large scale.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kingofhdds on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:57AM (#17100114)
I don't think an argument of such kind would stand in your communication with regulators, or (especially) in courts.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by scotty79 on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:58AM (#17101472)
This is "what will you do if the lightning strikes you" thinking. Only about less probable things.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kingofhdds on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:51PM (#17105239)
I'm not sure I understand your point. Do you mean “they won't catch you"?
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by scotty79 on Friday May 18, 2018 @06:10PM (#17105327)
They won't even manage to precisely decide what actually means 'large' let alone if it applies to you specifically, before you die of old age.

The above statement will apply to everybody or nearly everybody (still not you).

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by e12e on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:27AM (#17100835)
Perhaps more important, dpo is just another hat - if he's ceo,cfo,cto - he can be dpo too?
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by krfsm on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:43AM (#17100953)
There are limitations, namely:

"There must not be a conflict of interest between the duties of the individual as a DPO and her other duties, if any."

Specifically they recommend against also being the data controller. I.e. you shouldn't be responsible both for handling personal data and verifying compliance of said handling.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by johnchristopher on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:32AM (#17101273)
No, because you wouldn't be independent enough. A CFO or a CTO would tell its board things are okay because it isn't in its interest to do otherwise.

That's why some independent DPO jobs are appearing.

But the DPO is a small cog in the machine. Updating the processes is the most time and resource consuming regarding the GDPR.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by aembleton on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:29AM (#17099363)
That's the UK's interpretation of GDPR. What about France or Poland, or any of the other countries?

I suppose it depends where in Europe he would like to visit

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by poizan42 on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:56AM (#17099471)
I'm not seeing any interpretation being done here, but judge for yourself. Here is what the GDPR actually says (Art. 37 Designation of the data protection officer):

> (1) The controller and the processor shall designate a data protection officer in any case where:

> a) the processing is carried out by a public authority or body, except for courts acting in their judicial capacity;

> b) the core activities of the controller or the processor consist of processing operations which, by virtue of their nature, their scope and/or their purposes, require regular and systematic monitoring of data subjects on a large scale; or

> c) the core activities of the controller or the processor consist of processing on a large scale of special categories of data pursuant to Article 9 or personal data relating to criminal convictions and offences referred to in Article 10.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by Angostura on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:45AM (#17099723)
That's the UK's straight-forward unequivocal explanation of the rules. Where there is room for interpretation or uncertainty, the ICO is very good at pointing this out. It doesn't here.

As poisan42 points out - it echoes the words in the actual article, directly.

Bottom line, he doesn't need a DPO.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by raverbashing on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:05AM (#17099509)
There's no "UK Interpretation", this is the whole point of the EU. The rules apply across the block.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by jashmatthews on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:23AM (#17099597)
EU law doesn't work like that. Each country has to pass their own local law to enforce the GDPR. For the UK that was the Data Protection Bill 2017.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by YeGoblynQueenne on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:51AM (#17099749)
From wikipedia:

The GDPR replaces the 1995 Data Protection Directive.[4] Because the GDPR is a regulation, not a directive, it does not require national governments to pass any enabling legislation and is directly binding and applicable.[5]

So, no local laws. It's a regulation.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by jotaen on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:58AM (#17100118)
Only for the sake of correctness/completeness: GDPR does allow member states to adjust certain details to bring them in line with local regulations (see Chapter 9). These are explicit opening clauses though that must not basically weaken or augment GDPR.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by jashmatthews on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:27AM (#17100831)
It's more complex than that. Different countries might pass different laws about interpretation, and both are valid until there's an ECJ decision.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by jashmatthews on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:22AM (#17100810)
It's an EU Regulation, which under EU law the local courts have a duty to enforce. Local courts and laws will be dealing with all the details unless a case is appealed to ECJ.

To say that local courts and laws will have no influence is complete rubbish.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by jashmatthews on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:41AM (#17101342)
I'm not sure why people are downvoting this so hard: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:eMV5_l...
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by number6 on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:23AM (#17099134)
GDPR compliance takes resources. I would say for a small business it takes about 1 or 2 days. Not hard work but tedious. In the end you will have around 5 documents that will show your processes, what you do to keep data save, a plan how you deal with questions from customers and regulators, that you trained your employees and that you choose your subs carefully.

Essentially that's it.

I am no lawyer but I am a CPO.

Pro tip: Speak with the regulators they are on your side.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kingofhdds on Friday May 18, 2018 @06:04PM (#17105305)
I guess you are EU-based, unlike the guy whose text we are debating here.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by number6 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @11:00AM (#17112984)
Yes - I guess having an EU contact is something not easy to come by on the other hand there might soon be a service for it.

I guess an XMPP Server could be considered a communication service an could be subject not to the GDPR but to regulations concerning ISPs and Phone companies.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by wiz21c on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:23AM (#17099338)
Well many of us find it completely normal to spend days on having a good security, setting up HTTPS, encrypting content to protect privacy. I wonder why GDPR seems so different, it's just more of the same, just less technical.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by askmike on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:32AM (#17099652)
Exactly. It will take a while before standards and best practices form, but they will.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by bryanrasmussen on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:44AM (#17099416)
I guess I am a fan of GDPR, certainly compliance to anything has a cost. I personally don't find the costs of GDPR compliance onerous unless you have already built up lots of non compliant systems that now need to be fixed, in which case the free ride is over. Anyway, this guy is pulling out of the EU but if he allows anyone from the EU to use his service from a non-EU location anyway he would be risking non-compliance.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by jiveturkey on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:04AM (#17101096)
no. gdpr applies only to people in the eu. if you are an eu person in canada it does not apply to you.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @05:54AM (#17124799)
you're right, it seems a few people have been making the same mistake about eu citizens that I've made.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by subway on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:26PM (#17097575)
Kinder is an amusing example, since they decided to offer a compliant variant of their product in the US.

https://www.today.com/food/kinder-joy-chocolate-eggs-are-com...

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by Sylos on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:17AM (#17098660)
They did that in a rather smart way, too, by diverging it enough from the original that they could sell it elsewhere as a new thing.

I mean, it never really took off here, very few people prefer it over the original, but better than not being able to sell it outside of the US at all.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by fcbrooklyn on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:33PM (#17097617)
Yes. Rather a step back from the original offering isn't it? If I'm being honest, I couldn't give a damn about the kinder eggs prohibition, as I am not a child, and I do not have children. The Bovril issue is by far my biggest personal concern, although I'd really like to be able to buy raw milk cheese.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by jkaplowitz on Thursday May 17, 2018 @11:38PM (#17098502)
There are states in the US where you can buy raw milk cheese legally. You just can't do it through interstate commerce, but for example it can be done in person at farmer's markets with cash. New York is one such state, I dunno about the other major tech hub states.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by fcbrooklyn on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:17PM (#17097517)
Bovril could easily comply. They would simply have to open a manufacturing facility that did not use UK beef. The French cheese makers could sort of comply, by pasteurizing their milk. Kinder, I admit, has a more difficult problem, and has, in fact attempted to comply, by creating a completely different product with the same name.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by CaptainZapp on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:28AM (#17098948)
"The French cheese makers could sort of comply, by pasteurizing their milk"

And why should the French cripple a delicious and traditional product, which is gladly gobbled up by millions of happy consumers to sell their product in the US?

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by tinus_hn on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:10AM (#17099525)
Because otherwise they can’t sell it there. Their country, their rules. A French cheese maker doesn’t get to dictate the rules abroad. Take it or leave it.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by CaptainZapp on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:54AM (#17099768)
It seems to me that French and other European cheese makers are much more interested in protecting the integrity of their product than opening up the US market for it.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by C4stor on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:37AM (#17100907)
You mean, exactly what we are doing right now, causing all kind of outrage in France ? Funny you should bring that up, because it's a very hot topic currently :-D
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by dogecoinbase on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:28PM (#17097593)
Ah yes, "simply" open a manufacturing facility.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by fcbrooklyn on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:31PM (#17097606)
There will be a cost involved. And presumably there will be some benefits that result. Those are precisely the parameters of OP's decision.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by tokyodude on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:05AM (#17099062)
I'm not following your distinction. The only difference seems to be timing.

Case 1: CompanyA is already doing business in CountryB. CountryB changes regulations. CompanyA pulls out of CountryB because of regulations

Case 2: CountryB has regulations. CompanyA choose not to do business in CountryB because of regulations

am I missing something?

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by Moru on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:03AM (#17099275)
Except EU has always (well, Sweden since 1973) had regulation, if you would gave followed that, you would not have to change much in most cases. Just write some documents and smaller changes.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by llcoolv on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:36PM (#17104319)
But in this case this is not even a business. It is a zero-revenue open-source project. It seems to me that only very well-funded charities are allowed to run web services now.

P.S. I sincerely hope my country gets out of this ASAP.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kerng on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:43PM (#17097667)
Kinder is a great example actually on how a company adjusted their product. Now I believe in all markets (even beyond USA) the product is safer and less dangerous for kids to get injured.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by Sylos on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:27AM (#17098943)
I really don't think, it got safer.

It takes some special talent, even as an adult, to take such a big bite off of a classic Kinder egg that you'd have any chance of accidentally swallowing the plastic capsule or somehow else hurting yourself on it.

And with the new egg, I'd be concerned that my kids swallowed that plastic spoon. Like, that's something they actively have to put into their mouth and it's not as interesting as the toy for them to be motivated to not swallow it.

It's also small enough for them to realistically pull this off.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by qz3 on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:56AM (#17098812)
Is safety a real concern here? I would have never viewed Kinder Eggs as dangerous in any way.

I haven't found a single case of a child getting hurt in Germany. Only news reports about them being unhealthy (big surprise).

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by fcbrooklyn on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:46PM (#17097683)
Actually, I'm pretty sure they still stick the toys inside the eggs everywhere except the US. Perhaps a European can correct me on this assumption.

EDIT: Turns out the US-style kinder eggs are indeed available outside the US.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by mast on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:14PM (#17097835)
In Canada they definitely still put toys in the eggs. http://www.ferrero.ca/our-brands/kinder-surprise/moments-of-...
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kerng on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:55PM (#17098046)
http://fortune.com/2017/05/22/kinder-egg-usa-debut/

Toy is also in US version but different design

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by lstamour on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:08AM (#17098621)
I’m in Canada and can confirm that the toy-in-the-egg version was always sold here. As far as I know, this hasn’t changed. E.g. http://www.canada.com/life/Kinder+Surprises+Banned/2353187/s...
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by Some_Degenerate on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:58PM (#17097740)
I've seen this variety sold in Poland

https://www.candywarehouse.com/assets/item/regular/kinder-jo...

But I'm not sure it's typical.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kerng on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:56PM (#17098054)
Yeah. That's the US version also, not sure how common it is outside US.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by Sylos on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:22AM (#17098673)
They marketed it as a new thing beside the original here in Germany.

Most people seem to prefer the original, though. They lost a lot of charm by going from toy+edible+tinfoil to plastic+toy+plastic+edible+plastic spoon+plastic.

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by dspig on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:19AM (#17099572)
The new one is even more sweet and rich than the eggs (more like a dessert than a snack) and harder to eat for a young child, so not surprising.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by kerng on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:55PM (#17098043)
Looks like this now http://fortune.com/2017/05/22/kinder-egg-usa-debut/

I have seen this outside of US also (pretty sure it was doing a Europe trip)

Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by riffraff on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:15AM (#17098902)
it's just a different product, which shares almost nothing with the original, and is simply sold besides it outside the US.
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by youngtaff on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:58AM (#17100122)
Yup, Kinder Eggs have toys inside in the UK
Re:GDPR: Removing Monal from the EU by Karlozkiller on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:01AM (#17099263)
They're not forbidden to so business, they're forbidden to so business unless they adapt their product or practices. I'd say that is pretty much the same as this case?