News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by 21 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @03:58PM (#17055719)
Can somebody explain why Affordable Rent exists?

Living in San Francisco, or New York, or London is not a human right.

Note: I'm not trolling, I'm a left leaning person which favours basic income and national health insurance, I just don't understand why living in a mega-expensive city should be subventioned by the state. If you can't afford a Ferrari, you buy a Toyota. Why not move to a less expensive place?

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by navytank on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:01PM (#17055741)
You can't fill a city entirely with bankers, tech workers, and other professionals. What about teachers? Police? Those in the restaurant industry?

I don't think anyone is claiming that everyone should have a "human right" to live in SF. But when looking at the city as a systems problem, creating a sustainable system may require these kinds of measures to allow the right mix of people to live in the city.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by Retric on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:00PM (#17055976)
> teachers? Police? Those in the restaurant industry?

If they can't afford to live in the city then you could not fill the jobs without increasing wages. It's a self balancing problem. Further, higher wages increases the costs of restaurants etc which feeds back into pay.

Planned economies don't work because economies are ridiculously complex. Yet people always want to say 'just this once we need subsidies' for say corn production while ignoring the huge negatives associated with such choices.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by boulos on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:04PM (#17055990)
I asked this of Ed Lee directly at an event at work and he hemmed and hawed and said "how can you be against teachers?". At which I reiterated, "Your new affordability test would allow a new college grad software engineer at Google to get below-market rent; why can't we just pay specific people, say teachers and firefighters with families more?". He had no answer.

My conclusion is that most of our policies are driven by a combination of people not thinking through the consequences and people giving handouts to developers. Sometimes those are the same people :).

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by skybrian on Saturday May 12, 2018 @06:57PM (#17056461)
It's expensive and all the money ends up in landlords' bank accounts. Not sure taxpayers are into that?

(If the funding came out of property taxes, then at least the money would be both coming and going to land owners, but Prop 13 prevents that.)

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by Retric on Saturday May 12, 2018 @08:46PM (#17056823)
It's still ends up in federal taxes, and considering social security benefits are based on income it would directly help workers long term.

It would also act as downward pressure on rents as people left the city for better opportunities elsewhere.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by trav4225 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:40PM (#17055905)
What a perfectly rational explanation. Thank you for not instantly appealing to vague notions of social justice.

Dishearteningly, however, people still do this. When people demand affordable rent but do not get it, many still cry "injustice!". This seems to me to be counterproductive as it causes others to wonder what, if anything, such people do not consider to be a human right.

edit: accidentally left out "not" in first paragraph

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by bad_alloc on Saturday May 12, 2018 @06:28PM (#17056351)
> When people demand affordable rent but do not get it, many still cry "injustice!".

Well, it can be interpreted as an injustice. If you have a society that can realistically provide housing and food for everybody, is it not injust to deny handing these things out? The answer depends on what society you're going for. The optimum path is probably neither the extreme of the state providing everybody with everything he needs , nor a dog-eat-dog world in which the idividual gets nothing, no matter his situation.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by trav4225 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @10:37PM (#17057106)
I hear ya. We probably differ on semantics. To me, the modern notion of "justice" seems to be concerned with the answer to the question "What does my fellow man owe me?". The answer to that question is always "nothing". On the other hand, the answer to the question "How ought my fellow man show compassion to me?" is a different question altogether (to me at least). :)
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by azemetre on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:15PM (#17056044)
uhh they are directly appealing to social justice. Class issues are social issues.

I'm curious why you think otherwise.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by trav4225 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @10:42PM (#17057116)
Hmm. I read the comment as addressing the goal of healthy, functioning cities rather than the goal of artificially leveling playing fields.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by Apocryphon on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:04PM (#17055751)
It's sort of like when the subject of human rights gets brought in the discussion of taxation. There are pragmatic concerns being brought up here for social order. Arguing about rights distracts from practical needs to ensure the public good.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by segmondy on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:31PM (#17056112)
Yes you can. If you fill an entire city with bankers and tech workers, then guess what? They will leave when they have no police, teachers or janitors. OR they will start paying those police, teachers & janitors an appropriate amount.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by rm_-rf_slash on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:59PM (#17055970)
That’s a reasonable answer, although I think the better solution for those people would be to pay them more. Increase taxes and prices.

I read the other day on the nytimes that a fire chief in the Bay Area makes $500k. Doesn’t it make more sense to pay people better than to create separate classes of people who either pay real world prices or those who get subsidized.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:00PM (#17055975)
Also, artists et cetera are fun to have around. Look up the history of the Hotel Chelsea, originally sold as luxury long-stay rooms where wealthy folk could mingle with artists staying in subsidised apartments. The model is coming back into favour in New York.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by kofejnik on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:26PM (#17055854)
> measures to allow the right mix of people to live in the city.

So, human engineering, with totally good intentions. Can you define 'right mix of people' in a non-totalitarian way?

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by travmatt on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:39PM (#17055900)
The people who work in that city shouldn’t be forced to commute 3 hours in and out?
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by kofejnik on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:49PM (#17056193)
Nobody's forcing them, if their wages do not justify the commute time, they are totally free to stop commuting. Market pressure will do the rest.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by travmatt on Saturday May 12, 2018 @06:14PM (#17056285)
You’re completely missing the point, the market pressures are broken by restrictive zoning laws which artificially restrict supply.

That’s why you have 6,580 people who are bidding on 95 affordably priced homes.

The fact that you have 70 people applying per home is what we’d call a signal that those homes are in demand, the problem preventing more supply coming on line to meet that demand is the zoning laws, again.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by xref on Saturday May 12, 2018 @07:23PM (#17056534)
> 70 people applying per home is what we’d call a signal that those homes are in demand

uh, well sure I mean there is probably a ton of demand for $100 4Runners too

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by travmatt on Saturday May 12, 2018 @09:43PM (#17056968)
Car companies frequently introduce smaller and more affordable options when they notice strong sales in baseline models - Honda introduced the HRV because people wanted a cheaper CRV. The tone of your comment suggests you disbelieve my remark but then you made an analogy that supports my comment so I’m not really what point your point is?

Unless your idea is that companies shouldn’t take steps to meet demand and instead try to artificially restrict supply?

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by candiodari on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:56AM (#17058139)
That's one business model (e.g. Ferrari, Porsche, Lambourgini, Wedgewood, Breitling, ...), actually increasing supply is another (too many brands to name). I would argue that the brands that increase supply while lowering costs are the ones that do far more good in the world. But if you want to make money, certainly restricting supply can work.

Of course pretending you're one of the restricting supply businesses while in fact increasing supply (ie. Apple) beats both business models by an incredible margin.

And then there is the business model of enforcing your own position by having government goons (rules or actual goons) drive out the competition, which certainly restricts supply (Verizon/AT&T, Suez, Electrabel, Atos Worldline, Total, Shell, Exxon Mobil, Glencore, Gazprom, ING, AXA, BNP Paribas, ... and then there's this tiny little thing called "China")

There's certainly a place for all of these.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by lovich on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:00PM (#17055978)
Can you survive in a city with no one but bankers and tech people? No police, no resturaunts, no firefighters, no cleaners, app because the closest place they can afford is 4+ hours away? Are you going to take turns with your co-workers to clean the bathroom everyday, take out the trash, and clean the floors? Are you able to pull the long hours tech jobs require and still have time to cook food everyday? How would you even get that food if supermarkets can't keep employees around to stock the shelves?

This is all the extreme end of the situation, and we're not there yet, but it's the path we're on in many cities with San Francisco being at the forefront.

You can't have every worker specialize in to a narrow niche and then suddenly remove half of those niches from your society with no replacement and expect it to run smoothly

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by kofejnik on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:42PM (#17056162)
Wow what a nice strawman you have here! All the horrors you've described in so much detail can and will be fixed very nicely by market pressure (if no one is there to clean the bathroom, suddenly janitors will be in high demand and command a nice salary, etc).

Forcing 'the right mix of people' _reeks_ of totalitarian state. Who gets to decide?

Are there going to be income/education quotas? Male vs female? Racial quotes?

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by lovich on Sunday May 13, 2018 @01:36AM (#17057497)
Market pressures aren't fixing it, at least not fast enough to prevent a lot of pain to actual living humans. Yea in the long term it might be fixed, but in the here and now people are hurting. When I was out of college and stuck in retail I had to decide whether I was stealing food or medicine that week or going without, because those jobs don't pay enough to live. I am lucky enough to be talented enough at software to get a job doing it, but you can't expect everyone in the population to have those skills.

Expecting market pressure to take care of everyone is condemning people to die. I agree that the market is more efficient, but that efficiency comes without any sort of humanity. There are people who have no talents that are worth enough in our current economic configuration to earn enough to live at market clearing wages. Should we just let them starve or go homeless because of it?

I also agree that planning a 'right mix' of people does reek of totalitarianism, but the other choice isn't any better.

I don't see how letting the rich choose who gets to live a decent life based on whose most useful to them is any less totalarian when our society is channeling more and more wealth everyday to a small group of people.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by tripletao on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:30AM (#17058077)
(1) The usual argument against below-market housing here isn't "screw the poor". It's "this is an ineffective show at a fix for a problem that the market would resolve if we could build to the higher density that current zoning prohibits".

(2) Even if you have only market-rate housing, that doesn't mean the people who can't afford it end up homeless. You can just give them or their landlords money. In the USA, that's Section 8.

Economists generally like Section 8. It gets a bad reputation, because the apartments tend to be shabby; but that's a question of the amount of the subsidy, not the delivery mechanism. For a given total to spend, I'd rather put two people in a run-down $1.5k apartment each than flip a coin, put one of them in a $3k apartment, and leave the other on the street.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by kofejnik on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @02:34PM (#17076424)
> I'd rather put two people in a run-down $1.5k apartment each than flip a coin, put one of them in a $3k apartment, and leave the other on the street.

Do you want to get USSR? Because one committee plays God and regulates who lives where. Then some other committee, no doubt well-intentioned, will apply the same logic to groceries. And cars. And salaries. And this is how you become USSR.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by tripletao on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @09:53PM (#17079395)
We're discussing this in the context of people who can't afford market-rate apartments. If the government doesn't step in, then some fraction of these people will work harder and strive, and make it on their own. A different fraction will die on the street.

I don't want people dying on the street. I think more permissive zoning laws would solve a lot of our housing affordability crisis, but not all of it. For the rest, I think subsidies for market-rate housing (like Section 8) are the most efficient and transparent solution, and much less USSR-like than what the linked article describes. What do you think?

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by lovich on Sunday May 13, 2018 @02:11PM (#17060141)
Ah, I thought you were just saying the market should sort it all out. Yea giving money to people whoever need housing so they can find the best fit for themselves does seem like a better choice than just having a few winners and the rest get nothing.

The real answer is that more housing needs to be built if demand is this high, but for various reasons that seems politically unfeasible for most US cities

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by soneil on Sunday May 13, 2018 @08:27PM (#17061844)
I don't honestly believe "we'll just end up paying janitors more" actually works out.

You pay teachers more, you pay policemen more, and your taxes go up. You start paying all the waitresses more, the supermarket workers more, the janitors more, your cost of living just goes up.

Wage isn't really an absolute, it's a ratio to the cost of living. So in response to all their food getting more expensive, their taxes going up, etc, you end up paying all your darling tech/finance workers more. Then you're right back where you started. You've solved absolutely nothing, you've just embiggened some numbers.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by ImSkeptical on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:37PM (#17056140)
No, I couldn't live in such a city. If there was nobody to take out the trash we would have to raise more money to increase salaries for garbage men, etc. Some of it, I could live with less of, and some I'd pay more for.

Letting the economy balance itself seems a lot smarter than trying to control it and I think history provides many examples supporting this claim.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by wolco on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:40PM (#17055908)
Enough people with the right skillsets to fill the roles society needs to function.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by jbob2000 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:25PM (#17055851)
Affordable Rent policies block the free market from increasing wages in the city. Instead of paying workers more, we've asked landlords to make up the difference between a living wage and a poverty one.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by setpatchaddress on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:40PM (#17055907)
is this sarcasm? If not, do you have a reference?

The usual argument is that sf needs more housing supply to meet demand, period, let alone affordable housing.

Edit: see zkms, below.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by losteric on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:23PM (#17056087)
I think they're referring to rent controlled apartment... not sure why they think landlords "make up the difference", the landlord simply charges other renters more.

I'm not aware of any studies, but it does seem logical from a system perspective...

The relatively fixed supply of rent-controlled apartments is a random cost-of-living subsidy for low-income workers. Those that "win" can accept lower wages, while the "losers" are forced to compete despite higher cost-of-living (commute or rent). The latter group will get a little more, but not as much as if there was no rent-control. On the employment side, employers may hold jobs open longer hoping for a rent-controlled applicant that will accept lower wages.

Ideally we would have no rent-controlled apartments or enough for everyone that needs it, but anywhere in between is a distorted market that hurts consumers and employees. Eliminating rent control would be my preference, it seems more efficient than subsidizing everyone that needs it (as individuals can choose how to spend their higher wages, whereas rent subsidies always go to rent).

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by DrScump on Sunday May 13, 2018 @04:58AM (#17057987)

  The relatively fixed supply of rent-controlled apartments is a random cost-of-living subsidy for low-income workers
Rent-controlled units are generally not preferentially occupied by low-income workers. They are generally first-come-first-served or are obtained via "connections".
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by zkms on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:25PM (#17055848)
> Can somebody explain why Affordable Rent exists?

Because in large US cities, housing is artificially scarce (and thus pathologically expensive). This artificial scarcity is enforced by zoning laws; which prohibit SROs, rooming houses, and apartments with small floor areas, medium/high-rise apartments, non-family roommates, short-term rentals, buildings above a certain height; whilst requiring stuff like parking, solar panels on the roof, and minimum lot/room/floor areas (that have no justification in genuine safety concerns -- these are all regulations that mandate a certain level of aesthetic/luxury qualities).

The people who have a financial interest in maintaining these zoning laws (which prohibit/delay/obstruct construction of any kind of dense/tall/small/inexpensive housing, of the kind that exist without any problem in actual proper, non-US cities) are single-family homeowners who are making serious money off this artificial scarcity situation.

In this system, subsidised housing (which is generally inaccessible without decade-long waitlists, and meeting extremely narrow criteria (such as having proof of income that's in a narrow range between "low enough to qualify" but also "high enough to be twice the subsidised rent")) has a role as a safety valve to prevent enough coordination that could pose risk to this artificial-scarcity regime. This is not idle theorising -- it worked exactly like that to kill SB827 (a CA state law that would have preempted height limits encoded in local zoning law in areas very close to a subway/train/bus station); where "advocates" for subsidised housing concern-trolled the thing to death with concerns about "displacement".

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by flog on Monday May 14, 2018 @01:40PM (#17067551)
Isn't this every city, everywhere?
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by btian on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:12PM (#17055789)
Because people (in a democracy) decided that it's not in public's interest to have low paid service providers e.g., teachers, cooks, gov workers, to commute many hours a day.

These affordable places are "Toyotas". They're not million dollar apartments with doorman and valet.

It's okay to disagree, and these are not human rights in the sense that it's written into the constitution, or in UN conventions. Not everything governments do are related to human rights.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by tripletao on Saturday May 12, 2018 @07:16PM (#17056517)
Admittedly not a doorman or a valet, but this one's got a "concierge":

https://housing.sfgov.org/listings/a0W0P00000GRYOoUAP

http://thecivicsf.com/

Apartment #205, income-restricted to between $3258 and $3800/month for a single person, $1303/month. The market units are roughly 3x, though the interior finishes are often nicer. I'm guessing around $700k for a similar condo?

It's a kind of genius. If everyone getting screwed by the SF housing market united, then they could vote for land use changes that would solve the problem. Like, if SF abolished all zoning tomorrow, then a lot of terrible things would happen; but do you really doubt that housing prices would go down? We'd have problems, but not the one big central crushing problem that we have now.

Affordable housing policies divide those people, according to stuff like:

faith in government vs. market solutions

personal eligibility vs. ineligibility for the units

preference between a bad apartment vs. a lottery for a great one

That splits the landowners' natural enemies into warring factions, as we see here.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by ng12 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:00PM (#17055735)
I don't think anyone is arguing it's a human right. I think the argument is about displacement. Affordable Housing usually goes to people who have lived in an area for a long time and now can no longer afford it.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by joejerryronnie on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:17PM (#17055821)
Interesting that some people argue affordable housing is good because it allows people to stay in their homes but Prop 13 is bad because it . . . allows people to stay in their homes.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by denverkarma on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:53PM (#17055953)
Prop 13 is just a phenomenal transfer of wealth from the young and working class to the old and wealthy. Don’t kid yourself that it was ever about anything else.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by ng12 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:34PM (#17056130)
What happens if you sell under Prop 13? Does the tax man come calling then?
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by boulos on Sunday May 13, 2018 @04:30AM (#17057904)
The price resets for the new owner.

Under Prop 13, the assessed value is X when you buy it and can only be increased by up to ~2% per year even if your home went up in value by much more. This chains together over long periods of time, so that if you bought a place 20 years ago you are now paying property tax on at most X * 1.02^20. If the new owner paid you 5X for the home, they now pay property tax against that value moving forward.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by ng12 on Sunday May 13, 2018 @04:31PM (#17060894)
It seems to me that the seller should pay a hefty tax on that 5x value. Why should you get rich on appreciation that you didn't pay taxes on? I get the feeling the answer is more about greed and less about helping people stay in their homes.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by joejerryronnie on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:09AM (#17058018)
Do you feel the same way about social security?
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by jdavis703 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:59PM (#17055972)
Ideally the free market would take care of this. But homeowners have been able to hijack the market through rent seeking behaviours that tightly regulate housing. It's very hard to break the market dominance of land owners. Until someone can develop a palletable political solution to do so affordable housing will have to be government mandated or provided.

Further there will always be a segment of the population who can't afford to house themselves (note this is much smaller than those who can't afford housing due to the dysfunctional market). As a society we should be looking out for people who need extra help.

Edit: I'm getting downvoted on this. That's fine, but can someone explain what I said wrong?

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by DrScump on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:07AM (#17058014)

  can someone explain what I said wrong?
For one thing, you are assigning powers to "homeowners" that they do not have. Homeowners don't control zoning or other policy; politicians, and the bureaucrats they appoint, do. They could make noise at a council or planning commission meeting, but so can anyone else.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by jarym on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:03PM (#17055750)
I agree with you but there is still a problem to be solved: a LOT of essential public services are provided by people that have salaries far lower than required for rents in a particular area.

Teachers, nurses, police officers, etc.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by seibelj on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:06PM (#17055760)
Sure, but wouldn’t a city have to increase salaries to allow someone to be a nurse or teacher in an expensive area? Similarly, one can be a nurse or teacher in a lower cost of living place. No one forces you to teach in SF.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by txsh on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:36PM (#17055886)
No. They wouldn’t. They’d just allow the quality of government services to degrade.

Example: every city the United States.

It’s like saying “traffic is good because it forces to government to build more roads.” No, it does not.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by bradknowles on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:14PM (#17055808)
No one forces you to have kids, either.

No kids, no need for teachers or any kind of education system.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by seibelj on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:17PM (#17055823)
Unrelated to my comment? Are there a lack of teachers in SF?
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by jstanley on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:36PM (#17055891)
If those people start being forced to move out, you'll quickly find that salaries will rise to compensate.

Supply and demand is very simple.

Keeping rents artificially cheap is just a backdoor way of keeping salaries artificially low.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by denverkarma on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:51PM (#17055944)
Because the left thinks that the fix for housing shortage caused by governmental regulation starving the market of housing is for the government to intervene further and subsidize the thing they made unobtainable.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by EliRivers on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:07PM (#17056010)
Speaking as someone who routinely votes for the most extreme crazy left-wing loon on the ballot in local elections (disappointing choice this time - only one, the "Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition" party candidate), I'd much rather they did it by forcing the building of a lot more houses, but that seems less palatable to the rich than subsidies.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by falcolas on Saturday May 12, 2018 @07:35PM (#17056583)
How much more are you, as a hypothetical citizen of these cities, willing to pay in taxes to pay for the higher costs of living for your cops, fire fighters, and teachers.

How much more are you willing to pay at the grocery store to hire the checkers and stockers. At a restaurant for the cooks, waiters and waitresses, and cleaning staff? For your taxi, your delivery men, your trash men, your utilities, plumbing, construction, road work, and so forth.

Affordable rent helps to keep your costs, as a hypothetical citizen, low as well.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by cam_l on Saturday May 12, 2018 @11:52PM (#17057289)
Another take on it, rent is like farming. If you pull too much out of the system, the soil gets degraded and the salinity rises, poisoning the crops.

Affordable rent is a way (albeit deeply flawed) of trying to maintain the health of the system. A better way would be to cap profits on property through taxes. Make it too expensive to strip the system of its nutrients.. to continue with the mixed metaphor.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by allengeorge on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:59PM (#17055971)
In Toronto highly-trained cops are leaving because salaries in the exurbs are comparable and afford a higher standard of living (because you’re not forking as much over for housing).

This is a loss for the city because training is expensive. This movement is being repeated across professions.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by pg_bot on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:31PM (#17056115)
This is completely rational behavior, if Toronto wants to keep its police officers they should offer a higher wage.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by falcolas on Saturday May 12, 2018 @07:30PM (#17056558)
Which means they need more money, which means a tax hike. The tax hike is voted upon by the city citizens, and denied.

Instead, the citizens become more likely to complain about the lack of responsiveness of police, and use it to justify their choices to not pay more taxes for those "lazy police."

Cops, teachers, janitors - these are poor candidates for "market forces".

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by pg_bot on Saturday May 12, 2018 @09:01PM (#17056866)
So the citizens move, the city shrinks, housing becomes more affordable and they don't need to raise salaries as the cost of living is lower. It's all an equilibrium, you can't just see one side while ignoring the other. All of those occupations are defined by market forces claiming they aren't is economic ignorance.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by ggm on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:29PM (#17055866)
What kind of society do you want to live in? Do you want walled gardens of luxe, and a ghetto outside for the cleaners?
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by evgen on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:30PM (#17055869)
Living in these places is definitely not a human right. But then again, neither is it necessary for us to allow you to live there either even if you can buy the most palatial home in the city. It cuts both ways.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by crdoconnor on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:10PM (#17055780)
TIL there are people who equate wanting to stay in the city they grew up in as an equivalent level of entitlement to owning a Ferrari.

...and they consider themselves "left leaning"

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by throwaway080383 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:28PM (#17055860)
I want to be a software engineer making FANG $, but live in the tiny Midwestern town I grew up in. It is unethical for society to not provide this for me.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by crdoconnor on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:54AM (#17059196)
Nobody said anything about guaranteeing "FANG" jobs, just a reasonably priced place to live to people who grew up in SF.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by throwaway080383 on Monday May 14, 2018 @04:34PM (#17069203)
Sorry I wasn't totally clear. I currently have a FANG job, but I am forced to live in a high COL locale to maintain it.

Living anywhere near my hometown is simply not an option; I doubt there is a single employed software engineer in a 30 mile radius, and certainly not at the same level of comp.

So, if I want to be a well paid software engineer, I can't live in Iowa. If I want to live in Iowa, I can't be a well paid software engineer. If you want to live in the Bay, don't be a teacher. If you want to be a teacher, don't live in the Bay. If enough folks follow that rationale, Bay Area teachers will get paid more.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by txsh on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:29PM (#17055864)
What if your family lives there?

What if you’re divorced and your children live there?

What if you don’t want to move your children away from their school and friends?

What if jobs in your profession aren’t available elsewhere?

What if you’re receiving medical treatment there that’s not available elsewhere?

What if you’re contractually obligated to be there?

There are a million reasons why someone might not be able to simply move to a new city. Nobody has a right to live in a particular building or neighborhood. But there should be somewhere for them to live within a city no matter what their income is. A city shouldn’t be allowed to ban classes of people.

Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by denverkarma on Saturday May 12, 2018 @04:56PM (#17055963)
It’s the government dictating who can live where and do what via egregious over regulation that bans people from the city. If they’d cut the red tape and let housing be built the economy would normalize toward construction cost over time.
Re:These 95 Apartments Promised Affordable Rent in SF. Then ... by txsh on Saturday May 12, 2018 @07:46PM (#17056626)
Naive, ECON 101 thinking. The free market doesn’t work like this. Read some network theory, son.